Do you think the general public are aware of dslr limitations

Messages
1,102
Name
Carl
Edit My Images
No
I'm wondering if the general public think a dslr camera can do anything, in any light, as it's a supposed professional camera. Have you come across anyone who thinks cameras like ours could do anything, perfectly? For example friends getting asked to photograph weddings, mainly because they think any serious looking camera will take the kind of photos they dream of.

Another example which makes me wonder what the general public think....low light sports photos such as this regularly on the BBC Sport website

_47485698_carew466pa.jpg


Do you think the average person would even notice the noise in the photo or question why it's there?

Just a random post, a bit curious of what the average person thinks a dslr can do!
 
From what I can tell, most folk can't tell the difference between an SLR and a bridge camera - I mean, you wouldn't expect them to. The fact that the lens protrudes from the front, and it has a grip for your hand seems to subsconciously make people think 'professional camera'. Heck, it wasn't all that long ago that I referred to SLRs as 'big cameras' or 'proper cameras'.

As for the noise in that above image... most normals wouldn't see it. I noticed it straight away, but then again I hate noise. Hate it.
 
Before I got my dslr I thought exactly as you described as above.

The noise I would never have noticed as I would have looked at the players but not the noise.

I know what you mean aboutr people thinking that you own a dslr that you can shoot what ever, I have a friend of my mam said to me the other day after looking at 3 pics I took of birds that they look really good and i should be doing weddings soon ha ha ha!!!

I said i will newver be good enough for that as this is a hobby not a profession, but with it being a hobby it HAS made mne more aware of what a good pic should look like.

spike
 
I think the 'average' person as such is interested in capturing the moment, and are less concerned with the technical details of the image.

People will assume a bigger better camera can take better images, and I think that's a fair assumption! :)
 
Yes, but then why should they be aware of the technical limitations of camera equipment?
Most of the general public have no idea what a decent picture actually is, just look at Facebook if you don't believe me. ;)
 
I took some production photos for a web series the other day. I lost count of the "ooh, what a great camera" comments people made when they saw the pictures. People tend to think that DSLRs do all the work these days.
 
I doubt the average person even thinks about it. I've handed my camera to otherwise quite intelligent people and the first thing was to hold it at arms length and look at the display on the back instead of the viewfinder. The second was to ask how it zoomed (it had a prime lens fitted at the time).

There's not necessarily anything wrong with that, it's just a fact of life that camera have changed. Maybe we haven't?
 
I took a picture of an older traveler and his wife last year on holiday at Beamish, he asked me to post them to him when I got them printed. I asked if he had a computer and was he online, he said yes and gave me his email address. I processed them and sent several pictures embedded in an email. He came back to me and was over the moon with the pics and said they were the best ones he had ever seen of him and his wife and did I have a 'special camera' to take such lovely pictures!!
I just said yes!!
 
I think you're right, they don't have a clue, and frankly I really wasn't aware either before I started. I think now I'm more aware of how crap I am now than I was!!!! if that makes sense!

The phrase "all the gear, no idea comes to mind"!!!! Yes I think the average joe will think if he gets a really expensive DSLR, he'll get shots like the pro's....WRONG!!!

My view now, is that photography is an art, and some very fortunate people are born with the artistic streak, others can learn it, but some just will never have a clue!!

I'm still trying!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
The thing is there is now a whole generation that have grown up with compact digital cameras, the 'old school' photographers who shot 35mm with a selection of lenses are now the grizzled 'enthusiast DSLR users. You only have to look at the average wedding party and it is awash with compacts, which probably is about all that most of them will ever need or use. It follows therefore that anyone wielding a 'big camera' is an expert.
 
MY dslr can't do anything at all, not even take a photograph, it NEEDS an operator before it will do a single darn thing.
 
Yes, but then why should they be aware of the technical limitations of camera equipment?
Most of the general public have no idea what a decent picture actually is, just look at Facebook if you don't believe me. ;)

Disagree here.

When I shot specifically for a Sunday sport newspaper, market research told the people who funded the thing that 50% of people read the copy, the other 50% looked at the images. To me that still rings true to this day. :thumbs:
 
I'm wondering if the general public think a dslr camera can do anything, in any light, as it's a supposed professional camera. Have you come across anyone who thinks cameras like ours could do anything, perfectly? For example friends getting asked to photograph weddings, mainly because they think any serious looking camera will take the kind of photos they dream of.

Another example which makes me wonder what the general public think....low light sports photos such as this regularly on the BBC Sport website

_47485698_carew466pa.jpg


Do you think the average person would even notice the noise in the photo or question why it's there?

Just a random post, a bit curious of what the average person thinks a dslr can do!

I would say that yes they are. I note you have a series 1 camera again, but note that they are, along with 50/60/ 7D very much 'general public' cameras. Refer to the I hate focus on imaging thread that occurred on here last week as a case in point. :)
 
Disagree here.

When I shot specifically for a Sunday sport newspaper, market research told the people who funded the thing that 50% of people read the copy, the other 50% looked at the images. To me that still rings true to this day. :thumbs:

You may well be correct, but I do get the impression that there's a general "dumbing down" of expectations in a photo nowadays. Probably as a result of camera phones and youtube and so on. I'm sure that most of us on here appreciate a well focussed, sharp image (even if we ignore the content). I'm just not convinced that most of the public do, or even care.
 
You may well be correct, but I do get the impression that there's a general "dumbing down" of expectations in a photo nowadays. Probably as a result of camera phones and youtube and so on. I'm sure that most of us on here appreciate a well focussed, sharp image (even if we ignore the content). I'm just not convinced that most of the public do, or even care.

but that's why we're toggers and they're not.

I'm sure a lot of people on here care that their car goes in the morning and that's it. Whereas people on the automotive forums won't just care that their car goes, but that it has a nice sound system, a fancy steering wheel... etc. swings and roundabouts, different interests, etc...
 
You may well be correct, but I do get the impression that there's a general "dumbing down" of expectations in a photo nowadays. Probably as a result of camera phones and youtube and so on. I'm sure that most of us on here appreciate a well focussed, sharp image (even if we ignore the content). I'm just not convinced that most of the public do, or even care.

Sure thing - but its not stand alone to photos. My friends all talk about F1, the cars, the races and so on. For me, its a bunch of motors all looking the same going around in circles. Cars, guitars, bikes. You name it, you can apply it. :thumbs:
 
Sure thing - but its not stand alone to photos. My friends all talk about F1, the cars, the races and so on. For me, its a bunch of motors all looking the same going around in circles. Cars, guitars, bikes. You name it, you can apply it. :thumbs:

True that. Mystified how anyone can even raise this as a question to be honest. To an 'outsider' any sufficiently complex/skillful subject is simply a black box..that the majority of people simply couldn't give a flying one about.
 
I'm wondering if the general public think a dslr camera can do anything, in any light, as it's a supposed professional camera. Have you come across anyone who thinks cameras like ours could do anything, perfectly? For example friends getting asked to photograph weddings, mainly because they think any serious looking camera will take the kind of photos they dream of.

Another example which makes me wonder what the general public think....low light sports photos such as this regularly on the BBC Sport website

_47485698_carew466pa.jpg


Do you think the average person would even notice the noise in the photo or question why it's there?

Just a random post, a bit curious of what the average person thinks a dslr can do!

sorry to be a party pooper but Premier league images,even if you've pulled it from the BBC website :nono:
 
No - the average person hasn't a clue until you educate them as to what's achievable.
I'm doing a shoot for a website next week and was shown examples of 'good' images on rival companies' websites as examples of what the client was after.
They were dreadful. I mean truly appalling.
I've now shown the client examples of my non-military work and to say she was impressed would be putting it lightly.

My stuff isn't that great by my own standards, but it's a hell of a lot better than what I was shown.

The client was really only interested that the images be 'nice and clear'...
 
A stranger, curious about my 5D, started asking me about it - how many megapixels etc. I told him twelve. He then told me he'd just bought a better camera than mine - some compact with 14 MPs. I didn't say a word.
 
I think the Photoshop skills of the kids today make cameras kind of obsolete. I mean kids can shoot with a Canon sd1200 and still get amazing photos. Just check flickr. And yes sharpness is awesome and underrated. I hate those sepia artsy stuff that are blurry as hail. Check <a href="http://www.camera.co.uk">best digital camera review</a>
 
_47485698_carew466pa.jpg


Do you think the average person would even notice the noise in the photo or question why it's there?
Of course not.

1. Not everyone is so shallow as to be obsessed with 'noise' in every picture they look at.
2. That picture is intended to illustrate a story and the 'noise' does not affect it in any way.
3.'Noise', in the days before digital, used to be called grain and was a fact of life when pushing Tri-X or HP-5 to get low light pictures.
 
I'm sure that most of us on here appreciate a well focussed, sharp image (even if we ignore the content). I'm just not convinced that most of the public do, or even care.

Funnily enough Bill, I can also appreciate a selectively focussed image (even if it's all out of focus) There are some Bob Carlos Clarke images that are deliberately out of focus and blurred because they are meant to be. Well focussed and sharp are not the only arbiters of what constitutes a good image for me. :)
 
Disagree here.

When I shot specifically for a Sunday sport newspaper, market research told the people who funded the thing that 50% of people read the copy, the other 50% looked at the images. To me that still rings true to this day. :thumbs:


Was that "a Sunday sport newspaper" or "the Sunday Sport newspaper"? :naughty:

If it's the latter I'd doubt as much as 50% of the readership can actually read....:D
 
Most don't know but more importantly, don't care about what makes a good photo. As has been mentioned, the photo in the OP is there to display the moment not the technical ability of the photographer (and his camera).

Also as MisterE has said, I've lost count on the number of times I've had to explain that megapixels don't mean a thing unless you're printing big pictures or cropping which most people will never do because they only care about the moment, not the aesthetics.
 
A stranger, curious about my 5D, started asking me about it - how many megapixels etc. I told him twelve. He then told me he'd just bought a better camera than mine - some compact with 14 MPs. I didn't say a word.

Plus, if he's bought a Nikon Coolpix, he was right...:D
 
I'm going to throw this in revese. That picture looks pretty good to me, it's the action and the players that are important and since we don't know the lighting conditions under which it was taken, we cannot pass judgement on the noise.

I feel that too many photographers are obsessed with the technicalities, rather than the image - they can't see the wood for the trees.

I find that there are competitiond judges like that too - I remember when digital was beginning to creep in, one judge at a competition I was viewing stuck his nose right up against an A3 print and said "Ha, I can see pixelation". Now, an A3 photo should be viewed from several feet away, at which point the "pixelation" was less evident than the grain in many of the other film-based images.

The football picture was not there for a competition, it was probably there to illustrate a point and while I consider football to be more boring than watching paint dry, I reckon the photographer has done a pretty good job.
 
I'm going to throw this in revese. That picture looks pretty good to me, it's the action and the players that are important and since we don't know the lighting conditions under which it was taken, we cannot pass judgement on the noise.

I feel that too many photographers are obsessed with the technicalities, rather than the image - they can't see the wood for the trees.

I find that there are competitiond judges like that too - I remember when digital was beginning to creep in, one judge at a competition I was viewing stuck his nose right up against an A3 print and said "Ha, I can see pixelation". Now, an A3 photo should be viewed from several feet away, at which point the "pixelation" was less evident than the grain in many of the other film-based images.

The football picture was not there for a competition, it was probably there to illustrate a point and while I consider football to be more boring than watching paint dry, I reckon the photographer has done a pretty good job.

Here Here!
 
A stranger, curious about my 5D, started asking me about it - how many megapixels etc. I told him twelve. He then told me he'd just bought a better camera than mine - some compact with 14 MPs. I didn't say a word.

I've been asked that a few times and for a while I used the cameras res. (8.2 in my case). I was often told how 'my compact is better than that'. :thinking:

But the last time I was asked when I was showing sombody a print and my response was 3.8 megapixels (8x10 @240ppi) :p He looked at me funny and moved on. :D

The another annoying comment is 'Wow, you have a really good camera!', Erm, thanks?! What about ME!!!???!! :bonk::bonk:
 
I'm quite surprised how all DSLRs seem to be lumped together as if there is hardly any difference between an entry level and a 21meg professional camera. My first DSLR,a Nikon D60 is hardly any better in quality than my bridge camera.
 
I've been asked that a few times and for a while I used the cameras res. (8.2 in my case). I was often told how 'my compact is better than that'. :thinking:

But the last time I was asked when I was showing sombody a print and my response was 3.8 megapixels (8x10 @240ppi) :p He looked at me funny and moved on. :D

The another annoying comment is 'Wow, you have a really good camera!', Erm, thanks?! What about ME!!!???!! :bonk::bonk:

I heard a story on these forums about a guy who had guests over and they looked at his photos and one of the comments was "Wow, you must have an expensive camera!"

Next week, he's at the house of the woman who made that comment. As he was leaving he says, "Dinner was great, you must have an expensive oven!"
 
I think the "wow you've got a really good camera" comments really sum up this thread, as it's exactly the same attitude that's being expressed about the final photo - "wow that's technically excellent/poor".

There are many aspects to an image, personal taste not being an insignificant one of them.

A photo might not be the most technically accomplished, but that doesn't mean it's a bad photo.

Noise, angle, focus etc - it entirely depends on the image.

In essence, this thread is asking only for confirmation of opinion - not objective comment, and terms like "the general public" and phrases such as "do you think they notice/realise" strike me as condescending and patronising. It's like when talking to music snobs about pop music, or fashionistas that make flat, bored comments like "Oh wow how retro" in order to belittle those who they deem as unworthy or uneducated.
 
Back
Top