Facebook: All Your Stuff is Ours, Even if You Quit

Backups are exactly that, for use in emergency situations. I seriously doubt they'd trawl their backups for images to use.

It's not a lot to expect that when you delete an image from your account that it should be deleted from the service that hosted it.

But I don't know how Facebook works. It'll be interesting to see more info on this though before putting forward my informed opinion :razz:

That's what I thought.
 
As has already been pointed out, their Ts and Cs are there just to save them the almighty headache of deleting every photo you've ever posted there when you quit.

Rubbish.

It's not that difficult or that much of a headache. They don't have a load of students getting paid tuppence ha'penny an hour sitting there deleting individual files.
 
Is all this really a problem anyway?

If your that pleased with a pic you have taken, and you feel its got money making potential so you need to make sure you keep all the rights and copyrights, would you really plonk it on Facebook?!

I am thinking no.....

:shrug:
 
Face book, whats wrong with using the flipping phone.

Yep have to agree to an extent, to be honest i just don't get it, ive heard people at work talk about all the friends they have on facebook, they've never met them for Christs sake, they could be some of the biggest thieves, perverts, and god know what else for all they know, i find it hard having the time catching up with proper friends from the real world without all this virtual crap, what a load of [PLEASE DON'T TRY TO BYPASS THE SWEAR FILTER] it all is :bang:
 
What I really want to know if why anyone thinks fb would want the pictures in the first place based on the blurry camera phone dross my friends put on there :lol:

Don't newspapers buy images from them of newsworthy people who they can't photo for one reason or another?
 
Yep have to agree to an extent, to be honest i just don't get it, ive heard people at work talk about all the friends they have on facebook, they've never met them for Christs sake, they could be some of the biggest thieves, perverts, and god know what else for all they know, i find it hard having the time catching up with proper friends from the real world without all this virtual crap, what a load of [PLEASE DON'T TRY TO BYPASS THE SWEAR FILTER] it all is :bang:

That is what I don't like about social networking sites...the fact people have to 'brag' about friends they've never actually met! But perhaps that is just a reflection on society today...multi billion dollar deals are done on the phone, or with video conferencing...as an example!

I personally only have friends I know personally on my list...all 336 of them ;) Granted, most don't play a part in my life...but they did at one point or another, so it is good to have them there as a contact none the less :)
 
Rubbish.

It's not that difficult or that much of a headache. They don't have a load of students getting paid tuppence ha'penny an hour sitting there deleting individual files.
I'm sorry. I didn't realise you designed the whole of facebook's infrastructure and backup system.
 
Face book, whats wrong with using the flipping phone.


Agreed, but my social life is centred around people/family I meet in real life.
My mobile phone has recently been topped up with £20 quid. The last topup was May 2008 with the same amount. :razz:

For some reason I manage to get through life without having a phone hanging from my ear 24/7. :bonk:
 
storm/teacup tbh. If someone puts one of my photos on facebook(IE, if i dont do it) then the piccy will be removed. Facebook have removed content that didnt belong to the thieving get who posted it before so i have no worries about that. If you post a photo on FB you are fair game to their T&Cs. Dont like it? Dont sign up.
 
Yep, from FB this morning ....
Over the past few days, we have received a lot of feedback about the new terms we posted two weeks ago. Because of this response, we have decided to return to our previous Terms of Use while we resolve the issues that people have raised.

If you want to share your thoughts on what should be in the new terms, check out our group Facebook Bill of Rights and Responsibilities.
 
Is it the same with Myspace?? I'm asking because somebody posted my photo in his profile (it's linking back to my flickr account). I have never been member any of those - myspace, facebook, etc
 
If you post a photo on FB you are fair game to their T&Cs. Dont like it? Dont sign up.

They changed the T&C. ;) People had already signed up...

They obviously recognise they did something wrong because they've reverted the T&C's to what it was previously. Just goes to show if you don't let people play with your intellectual property you do have some sort of control.
 
So how do we stand now, in terms of who has the copywrite to pics we upload? sorry for the obvious question, i got a bit lost :thinking:
 
But two weeks ago, their T&C's grabbed the rights to any photos you uploaded (like BBC et al). So we 'photographers' are still at a losing standpoint.
 
the BBC t&c are very poor for competitions and the like, and anyone who emails us wanting to advertise comps or other things wont get through the door with any rights grabs. Facebook is different, if you have some very high class stuff, you are not going to stick it on their in high quality anyway..are you? and if someone posts something of yours, its a copyright breach anyway, regardless of T&Cs, if YOU post something there then thats a different matter. I agree that they should have put up the T&C when it was changed, but if they reserve the right to changed whenever then its up to them.

Not feeling very charitable today, can you tell?
 
This is obscene. I removed myself from facebook about a year ago fortunately I never uploaded anything.
 
Terms of Use Update
Close

Over the past few days, we have received a lot of feedback about the new terms we posted two weeks ago. Because of this response, we have decided to return to our previous Terms of Use while we resolve the issues that people have raised. For more information, visit the Facebook Blog.

If you want to share your thoughts on what should be in the new terms, check out our group Facebook Bill of Rights and Responsibilities.
 
Luckily though, this has raised the issue, and they know that rights grabbing, including pictures, is naughty.

That isn't what these new changes are about. The new changes are about the way they STILL keep the rights once you leave facebook.

But like I say, theyre looking at it, so maybe it will turn to better than it was before all this kicked off.

I would have liked to have uploaded my 365's to there, but I refused to because of their rights grabbing.
 
Is it the same with Myspace?? I'm asking because somebody posted my photo in his profile (it's linking back to my flickr account). I have never been member any of those - myspace, facebook, etc

Anybody? :help: Should I worry about somebody using one of my photos on MySpace?
 
The worse thing in those T&C's was the fact that if you weren't a memmber and someone else who was a memnber uploaded one of your photos they were still claiming the grab.
 
Well here's the latest extract from the Facebook group :

Thanks for taking the time to share your thoughts with us.

Here are responses to some of the things you've written below:

1. You own your information. Facebook does not. This includes your photos and all other content.

2. Facebook doesn't claim rights to any of your photos or other content. We need a license in order to help you share information with your friends, but we don't claim to own your information.

3. We won't use the information you share on Facebook for anything you haven't asked us to. We realize our current terms are too broad here and they make it seem like we might share information in ways you don't want, but this isn't what we're doing.

4. We will not share your information with anyone if you deactivate your account. If you've already sent a friend a message, they'll still have that message. However, when you deactivate your account, all of your photos and other content are removed.

5. We apologize for the confusion around these issues. We never intended to claim ownership over people's content even though that's what it seems like to many people. This was a mistake and we apologize for the confusion.

I think that's actually quite a clear enough clarification for me.
Before they implemented these changes two weeks ago they grabbed the rights to your photos anyway...seems theyve gone better than they were two weeks ago?

I must admit trawling through the different pages and discussions on it all, it's hard to follow where they're at...two weeks ago..or better?

As that's been posted on the official Facebook Bill of Rights and Responsibilities, I'm less concerned (although I haven't delved into the T&C's to check the exact wording).
 
Back
Top