Hiya David,
OMG I can't believe I have totally missed your Photo52, I feel terrible. Anyway here I am and going to do a quick catch-up:
Accommodation: Great idea for the theme. Love the colours, although it looks a little soft to me, but that adds to the atmosphere of the playhouse.
New: When I first saw the photo I wasn't quite sure how it related to the theme, but after reading, now understand. I'm not sure about the shadow on the right. A lovely capture of a mother/daughter moment.
Style: Hmmm, I can see where you are going with this, but there are a few things that I would have perhaps done different. The white bottle against the white background makes it all look very bright, almost over-exposed. I find the pink bottle a bit distracting with the barcode and also the light reflection. I would have probably left the straighteners out of the photo. It is a very busy and tight crop.
Open: I like the first photo, it almost looks like it was taken in a dark wax-works meuseum. I like the 2nd photo too with the trees silhouette against the moody sky.
Hard: Wasn't sure how it related till I read your interpretation, then it clicked (it must be because I am typing this at 2am
) I like the skin tone and DOF.
Delicate: Great idea and I think the softness would have added to it.
Clutter: Like the b&w conversion, also like the way you have all the bottles with the labels facing different ways, although the way the bottles are all lined up give it a more organised appearance. Definitely has a dark moody feel to it though.
Chaos: Looks like chaos to me, who has to do the cleaning up?
Didn't see the movement until I read .... I thought it was lighting. Also not sure about the see through door.
Finish: Again wasn't sure what this was about .... but after reading can see what you were trying to achieve. The positioning of the glass in the frame is wrong and all the speckles on the left, what are they? Also the focus looking into the glass is out. I think this one may need some more work.
Trio: Lovely photos, need some work on the composition though and I would have either gone with all colour or all black and white, not a combination.
Knowledge: I like the DOF, I would have perhaps tried to keep the focus down the centre of the book with the OOF to the sides. The vignette effect adds a nice touch to the photo.
Moderation: Wow the background is a bit too bright, I think a different/softer colour would have worked better here. I would have also not included the tall glass as I think the small one speak enough about the moderation and I would have positioned it a little more right of the box.
Empty: Nice idea and the background is a definite improvement to the previous. IMO a bit more space left and lower would work better. Also if you had turned the left shell slightly may have avoided the shadow. There is a tiny spot to the right of the other shell, could be a dust spot.
Object: I think you have done well with this one and the background works well here. Wasn't sure about the shadow at first, but the more I look at it the more I like it. Well done.
Wrong:
indeed, I have seen this sign before and thought how strange. Did you do some selective colouring on this one? I only ask, because it looks like you missed a bit at the top right of the sign. Otherwise a sharp shot.
Paradox: Another photo where without reading what it is about I wouldn't have put it to the theme. Not bad, composition wise, although you have clipped the chaps hat on the left and the image could do with a sharpen. I like the b&w conversion though.
Power: Shouts power to me, both from the pylons and the stacks. Love the moody sky. Not sure about the processing, although it seems to add to the feel of the shot.
Look forward to seeing the tropical shot and the most recent theme.
Wow I can't believe it is now 2.30am ... time for me to hit the pit.
Apologies again for not getting to your project sooner and also if I have repeated what may have already been said/commented - I haven't had chance to read each post for the weeks, just scanned some.
You have some good photos and I can see you are definitely making progress.
Cheers
Dawn