Fill-in flash & shallow depth of field ie wide aperture – possible ?

Messages
1,443
Edit My Images
Yes
Guys,

I’m hoping to make the most of the better light with my D90 and get some nice shallow depth of field pics of my children with the 50mm F1.8 lens....shooting at F2.2 However if I try to use fill-in flash with the lens wide open I get blown out over exposed results.

What’s the easiest way to stop this ? – should I drop the exposure comp down a few notches or reduce the amount of flash ? – I don’t have the facility to bounce the sb-400 flash outdoors

Tia,
Mike.
 
If you use the same aperture and shutter speed without flash do you also get over exposure?

I suspect your flash sync is limiting your shutter speed...
 
Suggest you switch the flash to manual mode and adjust the power to get the right exposure. Should be pretty easy to do - just try it and see. The beauty of digital - it doesn't cost anything to try stuff out (apart from the lenses, new bodies, extra flashes, remote triggers....)
 
Shooting in A mode so allowing the camera to set shutter speed. With fill-in flash it shot at 1/200 and was over exposed using a test aperture of F3.2. Using the same aperture without flash the camera set shutter speed to 1/320 and gave a spot on result looking at the histogram. Just realised I had matrix metering on which might have contributed, find spot metering is normally better for portraits.
 
Change your flash gun to high-speed sync. (Not knowing anything about Nikon flashguns, I'm assume the sb-400 has this). This will allow you to shoot at faster shutter-speeds and provide just a bit of fill with the flash.

If you leave the flash set normally, the camera will probably revert back to the sync speed if you're shooting in anything other than manual.
 
I'm not sure you can set high speed sync on the D90. You can't on the D80. Have a look in the shooting menus for 'flash sync speed' and if its possible there will be settings that use auto fp. Use one of these to set it.

Hugh
 
I haven't got an sb-400 so not 100%, but not on the sb-800 or sb-900.

Cheers

Hugh
 
Shooting in A mode so allowing the camera to set shutter speed. With fill-in flash it shot at 1/200 and was over exposed using a test aperture of F3.2. Using the same aperture without flash the camera set shutter speed to 1/320 and gave a spot on result looking at the histogram. Just realised I had matrix metering on which might have contributed, find spot metering is normally better for portraits.

More likely your camera will not sync with the flash above 1/200 - or if it can then there is a setting somewhere preventing this.
 
The Sb-400 has zero control on it so can only work from the camera settings. I'll see if I can get flash sync above 1/200
 
More likely your camera will not sync with the flash above 1/200 - or if it can then there is a setting somewhere preventing this.

I think you could have the answer here - I believe the D40 is better in this respect and might be able to do 1/320.

I'll google and confirm
 
Typically my D40 does far better in this area !!

The D40 has a higher 1/500 flash sync, useful for daytime fill-flash. This compares to the typical 1/200 sync speed of other entry level and even some semi-pro DSLR cameras

Just can AF the 50mm on the D40....

Any ways to work around this problem on the D90 ?....set exposure comp lower ?
 
The problem as I understand it is that the photograph is over-exposed indicating that the shutter speed is too slow. The simplest solution is to de-power the flash manually. If the flash has no buttons, there should be a flash exposure compensation on the camera to enable you to do this.

Comparisons with other camera sync speeds aren't helpful for the poor chap.
 
The limiting factor here is not the camera, it is the flashgun.
The SB-400 does not have a high speed sync option and therefore it will not be possible to go over the 1/200 limit.

The way I see it adjusting the flash power output will not overrule the fact that even without flash the shot is at least 2/3 of a stop over exposed.

Choices are either a flashgun that does support high speed sync or experiment with a 1 or two stop ND filter - although I'm not sure how that would affect the flash peformance.
 
It's possible to drop the flash output on the D90 so i'm going to try that method 1st see how I go. (flash button + commander dial)
 
I don’t have the facility to bounce the sb-400 flash outdoors

Tia,
Mike.

You could try one of these, to allow you to bounce the SB-400 outdoors (click on pic for more details)



or simply make something similar with a bit of white card and an elastic band :nuts:
 
You can set the D90 to high speed sync and this will work with my sb600 but not the sb400 as far as I am aware.

You can reduce the ISO to 100 which will help by one stop, then nd filters and flash compensation from there........
 
A Sto-fen diffuser will also cut the flash output (yes, one's available for the SB-400). Stuff with tissue paper for greater effect.
 
Guys - do these difusers take much strength out of the flash ?

AJESSCA215116637.jpg
 
Guys - posted this thread on dpreview and starting to understand what's going on i think ( this might help oher like me who might not have grasped how fill-in flash works)



The fact that flash is enabled is telling the camera to max out at 1/200th s/speed. For a bright day at F2.8 and ISO 200 this is way too slow. I could put black tape over the flash and the image would still be over exposed as effectively it's a 1/200th pic with no flash....still going to be over exposed.

So this is one area the D40 excels the D90 unless you use a high end flash where you can override the problem by setting faster sync on the flash itself.

Even bouncing the flash with a flash board is still no use here as stated it'll still be a 1/200th pic with a too wide open aperture.

Am I correct in what i've learnt here ?
 
You are correct in what you have learned, it is pretty much what I've been saying
(Albeit somewhat in brief due to posting furtively at work :lol:)
 
Aye, you'll need f/8 at 1/200 with 200ISO for an overcast day, and that'll need an ND8 on the lens so you can open up three stops to f/2.8.

The SB-400 has a guide number of about 30m at 200ISO so the range will be about 3.75m at f/8 (you want fill, so can extend the range, but Ken Rockwell says the GN is about a stop lower so it's swings and roundabouts).

Hopefully the camera's exp comp will control the flash?
 
The rule of thumb with fill flash is to get your exposure right with the main light. In your case, this is ambient daylight (but it could be another flash).

Then set the flash so that if it was the only light, it would underexpose by two stops.

The fill flash will make the overall exposure a bit brighter than just the ambient light. With film, its dynamic range will easily handle this but with digital, you may need to reduce the exposure a bit.

To get to grips with how fill flash works, it's best to experiment a lot with everything in manual mode.

Use shutter speed to control ambient as it has no effect on the flash and use the aperture to control the flash.

As has been stated already, if you are using the lens nearly wide open in good light then your ambient light is going to over-expose at flash friendly shutter speeds so you may want to try some neutral density filters.

Some medium format film cameras get round this problem by having in the lens leaf shutters which can synchronise with the flash at all speeds (usually up to 1/500, sometimes 1/1000).

They were used by almost all wedding and portrait photographers until those strange non-film cameras arrived!



Steve.
 
One more option if you have good light and the children are not moving around too much:

Don't bother with the flash, use a reflector instead and shoot in aperture priority.



Steve.
 
Just one final question - in Manual mode would i be able to overide the flash sync of 1/200 ? ie if i set shutter speed to 1/1000 and aperture to F2.8 would the camera still fire at 1/200th as it knew i was using flash or will manual mode actually overrule this ?
 
Meant to add thanks Richard the sane you were on the right track all along just needed it saying in more wdetail for the penny to drop.....i think this is an area of photogtaphy quite a few people struggle with.
 
I don't think you've grasped the thread Suvv - have a read of the last few posts.....bounce, difuser, even black tape on the flash ain't going to help here.....i was thinking along the same lines until the penny dropped
 
Sorry Mikey, I should have made it clear that I was not trying to solve your original problem, which you have sorted out already.
I was just pointing out that it is easy, and cheap, to use a bounce card with the SB400 - very useful for portrait format indoor shots as well. :D
 
Just one final question - in Manual mode would i be able to overide the flash sync of 1/200 ? ie if i set shutter speed to 1/1000 and aperture to F2.8 would the camera still fire at 1/200th as it knew i was using flash or will manual mode actually overrule this ?

One for you to answer yourself, surely ;)

With my Pentax cameras, Manual or Shutter Priority are the modes to use for high speed sync. Aperture Priority will drop the shutter speed (in dark conditions) according to the focal length used.

The manual for my Fuji (Nikon in another guise) states that f/4.8 is the max aperture to use at 200ISO. With a non-dedicated flash on that camera, M and S modes are used like Pentax, but A mode meters for the ambient light.
 
Just one final question - in Manual mode would i be able to overide the flash sync of 1/200 ? ie if i set shutter speed to 1/1000 and aperture to F2.8 would the camera still fire at 1/200th as it knew i was using flash or will manual mode actually overrule this ?


No,if you have a flash on the hotshoe you will be unable to physically adjust the shutter speed past the camera's max sync speed, unless the flash supports Auto FP, which I would doubt the SB-400 does.
 
Just one final question - in Manual mode would i be able to overide the flash sync of 1/200 ? ie if i set shutter speed to 1/1000 and aperture to F2.8 would the camera still fire at 1/200th as it knew i was using flash or will manual mode actually overrule this ?

If you are in maual mode the shutter will fire at the speed you set it to.

If you set a shutter speed higher than your sync speed then you will get an area of image which is not illuminated by the flash. The faster the shutter, the larger the non-illuminated area.

A focal plane shutter has two curtains. When you press the shutter release, the first curtain starts to open. After a time determined by the shutter speed selected, the second curtain will start to close. At high speeds the second curtain will start to close before the first has fully opened so effectively, a slit of exposure moves across the film or sensor. At slow speeds the first curtain opens completely then the second curtain closes.

The fastest speed for which the shutter is fully open i.e. when the second curtain starts to move as soon as the first curtain is fully open is the sync speed.

The flash duration is much quicker than the shutter speed and the flash must fire at or below the sync speed otherwise the film or sensor will be masked by one of the curtains.



Steve.
 
If I've read this right, my guess is that you've got two problems. ISO200 is too high, although I think you can override this to ISO100 on the D90 which will give you one extra stop in the right direction. The other problem is x-sync at a shortest speed of 1/200sec, which is common to most DSLRs.

Check out the workings of a focal plane type shutter to understand why you can't sync flash at any shorter speeds. High-speed sync is only possible with some top end flash guns that strobe the flash very rapidly, effectively increasing the flash exposure duration, which allows you to set a shorter x-sync speed. If this sounds double-Dutch, it will make sense when you get to grips with the workings of a focal plane shutter (which all DSLRs have).

You might try it with ISO100, which might be okay if the sun isn't too bright. Stopping down to f/4 will also help, if the depth of field is still shallow enough for you but that's not what you bought the fifty-fifty for! In which case a three stops (x8) neutral density filter is the only other answer.

I would shoot on auto exposure, as sorting out fill-flash on manual is a tricky business. Not sure how Nikons work, but usually the aperture priority mode with flash will attempt to set the correct shutter speed for an ambient light exposure (up to 1/200sec or longer) and the flash will sort itself out for correct exposure at the f/number selected.

My Canon gets this about right most times, but you can adjust the ambient exposure in the normal way with exposure compensation on the camera, and there should be a facility to adjust the flash output in the same way (probably on the gun, maybe on the camera?). In this way, you still have full control of both ambient and flash, and the relationship between the two so you get just the balance you want.

The problem you have is trying to do this in bright sun, at a very low f/number, and at ISO200, with flash sync at a shortest speed of 1/200sec. Quite an unusual set of circumstances, but an ND filter will fix it.

Edit: crossed post with Steve, who has explained the problem with focal plane shutters and flash :)
 
I would shoot on auto exposure, as sorting out fill-flash on manual is a tricky business.

Obviously it's a personal preference, but I don't agree with this.

I use all settings at manual and as I only use film, I don't have the option of previewing the image or hystogram on the LCD.

As the original poster is using digital, he can do any amount of experimenting and view the results instantly. The only way to fully understand what is happening is to experiment manually though I do understand that modern TTL flash metering systems can produce very good results.

It depends on priorities really. Do you want to fully understand what is happening and learn how to control it or let the camera work out the details for a hassle free good exposure?

I think in this case though, I would go for the option of a reflector as I suggested earlier.


Steve.
 
Obviously it's a personal preference, but I don't agree with this.

I use all settings at manual and as I only use film, I don't have the option of previewing the image or hystogram on the LCD.

As the original poster is using digital, he can do any amount of experimenting and view the results instantly. The only way to fully understand what is happening is to experiment manually though I do understand that modern TTL flash metering systems can produce very good results.

It depends on priorities really. Do you want to fully understand what is happening and learn how to control it or let the camera work out the details for a hassle free good exposure?

I think in this case though, I would go for the option of a reflector as I suggested earlier.


Steve.

I don't disagree with that at all. Learning is different.

The first fill-flash pic I took was with my dad's Rolliecord TLR and a flash cube. After 20 minutes fiddling with an exposure meter and flash guide numbers, I eventually dared to take the pic. It turned out fantastic, and I've been a big fan of fill flash ever since. At least I didn't have any focal plane x-sync problems with that old Rollei :)

One of the joys of modern kit is the way in which they make loads of otherwise complex calculations effortlessly. For fill flash with my Canon 40D, I just slect the f/number on Av, switch on the flash and shoot. Most of the time the exposure is good, but sometimes the flash is too hot so I just dial in -1 compensation on the flash and I'm ready to go.

But I agree, it is important to know what the camera is doing as the whole scenario is pretty complicated with fill-flash, especially when you throw in the focal-plane shutter issues. I find this kind of thing quite interesting, and I enjoy the 'craft' side of photography.
 
Back
Top