Focal length markings on Nikon DX lenses

Messages
247
Name
Barnaby Jaco Skinner
Edit My Images
No
Just checking I understand it right... anything I get wrong please correct me ;)

So if I bought a 17-55mm DX lens for a D7000 and a 17-55mm FX lens for a D700 and compared them next to each other, say one eye in the D7000 and the other eye in the D700, apart from looking like a moron they would not match. To make them match I would need to buy a 25.5-82.5mm FX lens for my D700, then the focal lengths would match and it would be like looking through odd shaped binoculars. This is because the DX sensor is physically smaller than the FX sensor and creates what's known as 'crop factor'.

This 'crop factor', although created by the sensor and not the lens, suggests that all DX lenses on DX bodies do not actually produce the focal length they advertise, instead it's (displayed focal length) X (crop factor)?

This in-turn suggests that the smaller the physical size of the sensor the greater the 'crop factor' when used with the same focal length... which might help to explain how Nikon can squeeze over 800mm out of the new Coolpix lens?

Finally, if I put the 17-55mm DX lens on my 12MP FX body it would truly give me a 17-55mm focal length BUT because the DX lens' rear element hole is smaller than that of an identical-in-focal-length FX lens it would only use half the FX sensor therefore produce a 6MP picture?

Why don't Nikon put the converted focal length on the DX lens rather than the cropped FX equivilent? Seems a little more logical even if not technically correct. :bang:

Thanks for your brain cells, it's been emotional ;)
 
Last edited:
The focal length of a lens is just that, be it dx, fx, mf , half plate, full plate or a sensor the size of a house. The crop factor is just an indication of how much of the possible image is used.
So if you put your fx lens on a dx camera you would get the same image as your dx lens.
 
Just checking I understand it right... anything I get wrong please correct me ;)

So if I bought a 17-55mm DX lens for a D7000 and a 17-55mm FX lens for a D700 and compared them next to each other, say one eye in the D7000 and the other eye in the D700, apart from looking like a moron they would not match. To make them match I would need to buy a 25.5-82.5mm FX lens for my D700, then the focal lengths would match and it would be like looking through odd shaped binoculars. This is because the DX sensor is physically smaller than the FX sensor and creates what's known as 'crop factor'.

This 'crop factor', although created by the sensor and not the lens, suggests that all DX lenses on DX bodies do not actually produce the focal length they advertise, instead it's (displayed focal length) X (crop factor)?

This in-turn suggests that the smaller the physical size of the sensor the greater the 'crop factor' when used with the same focal length... which might help to explain how Nikon can squeeze over 800mm out of the new Coolpix lens?

Finally, if I put the 17-55mm DX lens on my 12MP FX body it would truly give me a 17-55mm focal length BUT because the DX lens' rear element hole is smaller than that of an identical-in-focal-length FX lens it would only use half the FX sensor therefore produce a 6MP picture?

Why don't Nikon put the converted focal length on the DX lens rather than the cropped FX equivilent? Seems a little more logical even if not technically correct. :bang:

Thanks for your brain cells, it's been emotional ;)

To answer the final question first - the focal length of a lens is a physical property of the lens, so thy markings on Dx lenses are correct and stuff logic. At leat the Nikon Dx crop factor is an easy one to do in your head.

Using a Dx lens on a D700 does cause a lot of vignetting - so much so that the actual MP it'll give in Dx mode is closer to 5MP than the 6 you quoted. Leaving the camera in FF mode gives a result like this...
4050193420_526824ab9e.jpg


Can't remember what aperture that was taken at (or the original file on this PC at the moment!).
 
Think of it like this.

Take a full frame camera like the D700 which has a sensor 24x36mm. Then put masking tape around the edges of the sensor, leaving just a small rectangle in the middle 16x24mm. It is now a crop format camera, like the D7000.

The lens has not changed, but the field of view has been cropped by a linear factor of 1.5x, and if you apply that crop factor to the lens focal length it will give you the equivalent focal length in terms of what the sensor records. (Area is reduced by the crop factor squared, ie 1.5x1.5=2.25, so crop format DSLR sensors are less than half the size of full frame, which is where all the extra sharpness and noise benefits come from with full frame.)

A few other things change along the way, but not focal length. That Nikon Coolpix you mention doesn't have an 800mm lens. It is probably around 150mm but multiplied by the crop factor (which is usually about 5x with a compact) you get that as an equivalent focal length in terms of field of view. If you think that this must make a compact's sensor very small, you'd be right!
 
Last edited:
By heck I get mighty confused when folks talk about this subject, so while it's still swirling round my tiny brain can I ask this question. Does the DX sensor sit closer to the rear element of the lens than a FX sensor?:thinking:
 
@Richard - Makes sense. Would it therefore be fairer to say it's the Field Of View (in degrees) that is changed by the crop factor?

edit - @Doog I'm not sure mate but I don't think so, it's just smaller.
 
Last edited:
Doog - I don't think so, although the mirror arrangement would possibly be smaller on a DX body because of the smaller image circle.

If you had an FX body and a DX body you could have a look at the little circle with a score through the middle (usually on the shoulder of the camera), which indicates the 'film' plane, and see if they compare....
 
By heck I get mighty confused when folks talk about this subject, so while it's still swirling round my tiny brain can I ask this question. Does the DX sensor sit closer to the rear element of the lens than a FX sensor?:thinking:

No, I'm pretty sure they are the same distance, the only difference here really is the size of the sensor.

@Richard - Makes sense. Would it therefore be fairer to say it's the Field Of View (in degrees) that is changed by the crop factor?

edit - @Doog I'm not sure mate but I don't think so, it's just smaller.

Since the lens' mm aren't changing I think thats a good way of putting it, the lens sees the whole scene as intended but the sensor is not big enough to record all of it, so it takes the middle section, reducing the fov
 
Last edited:
By heck I get mighty confused when folks talk about this subject, so while it's still swirling round my tiny brain can I ask this question. Does the DX sensor sit closer to the rear element of the lens than a FX sensor?:thinking:

No. In the example above with the masking tape, only the sensor has been changed - it's cropped, and that reduces the field of view it is able to record.

As a result of that, other things might change in order to restore the field of view as required, including the focal length of course (or you could just move the shooting position back). All shorter focal length lenses are generally required to sit closer to the sensor but that is restricted by the mirror so on DSLRs they have to be reconfigured to work around that (known as retro-focus design).

@Richard - Makes sense. Would it therefore be fairer to say it's the Field Of View (in degrees) that is changed by the crop factor?
edit - @Doog I'm not sure mate but I don't think so, it's just smaller.

Yes. It is the field of view as seen and recorded by the sensor that changes, not what comes through the lens.

This is going to sound confusing, but the field of view is not decided by either the lens or the size of the sensor. For that, you need both a lens and a sensor together.

The size of the sensor makes a big difference to lens design, which is why there are benefits with DX and EF-S lenses. They don't need to bother with delivering a big image to fill a full frame sensor, ie they only project a small image circle, and this means they can do other things instead.

For example, the 17-55 2.8 lenses in both Nikon DX and Canon EF-S - it would not be possible to do that and make them work well on full frame. The best that Canon can do for example is the EF 16-35L 2.8, and that is a big and very expensive lump. These benefits with crop format sensors run out quite quickly at longer focal length, which is why nither Nikon nor Canon makes anything like that starting at over about 60mm.
 
Back
Top