Gay Man Detained In Airport On Suspicion Of Pedophilia — Because He Had A Camera

Stephen, I don't think the camera is the primary focus here.
I've come across more than a few people who believe that all gay men are paedophiles who happen to prefer little boys to little girls, and that their adult partners are just stop-gaps until a child becomes available.
For someone with that belief, it would be logical to assume that an identifiably gay man with a camera would be using it to take inappropriate photos of children, whereas with anyone else, they would be using it to take holiday snaps. :shake:

Sadly true. The same people often think that other races, particularly if they have a different skin colour, are somehow inferior. I hate bigots.
 
Can you imagine the queues at the border check-in desks if they didn't have stereo types though....jeeesh.

yeah, this is no place to worry about discrimination based on sexuality or colour - it's all about getting those queues down.
 
Stephen, I don't think the camera is the primary focus here.
I've come across more than a few people who believe that all gay men are paedophiles who happen to prefer little boys to little girls, and that their adult partners are just stop-gaps until a child becomes available.
For someone with that belief, it would be logical to assume that an identifiably gay man with a camera would be using it to take inappropriate photos of children, whereas with anyone else, they would be using it to take holiday snaps. :shake:

While I agree to a large degree I am sure that the OP wouldn't have posted the thread if it hadn't had the camera link in it....and I am sure that that element of the story holds more weight to the people on Talk Photography than any other aspect of the story.

Having a few gay friends I just emailed a couple with this story and one replied thus

"I have heard all this sort of thing many times before. These days when we are travelling I don't hold Mxxxxx's (my edit) hand or make any gestures of affection when any authorities are about. It's sad I know but just easier not to rock the boat. As for photo's I have not faced that particular problem but I have never had a camera on show when going through customs so can't comment on that."


Sad indeed - the world is :cuckoo:
 
I have read it ...that is why I am questioning it.

Well if you have read it, please be good enough to say your comment......

".....It is possible that it could have happened but it is also possible that the whole thing is a fabrication to 'highlight' what could happen for 'training' purposes. I can't believe that a chief inspector observer would not report this sort of behaviour if it were true. "

........no longer applies.
 
1 - its blatantly obvious reading through that the border agent was just using excuses, he probably stopped him to meet his quota and then had to find a quick response as to why he did so, though there is an element of homophobia indicated I think the camera was just part of the BS excuse.

2 - you cant avoid stereotyping, one of the things we do as a creature is to group things of a kind or familiar association together, its the way we deal with large quantities of information or numbers of people etc.
Stereotypes are created by this grouping of things or people and often spill over, the classic one is that any single male over 40 living alone is automatically viewed with suspicion, this permeates through all government agencies.
In just the same way the same persists over gay men, the fact that in both cases at some time in the past members from both groups have been convicted of child abuse (paedophilia itself is not a criminal offence, the practise of it, ie child abuse is) has created a "familiar association" that remains prevalent in peoples minds.

3 - as said stereo types or grouping have to be used in such situations, the person is making snap decisions based on a moments contact, thus certain groups would be more likely to be checked.

4 - One critical piece of information is missing from the report, the destination of the couple, it could have been that they where travelling to an area which is known for its sex tourism, this is an activity thats seeing a crack down from all agencies in order to try and reduce the world wide sexual abuse of children.

5 - I hope they don't sue, this whole culture of taking offence and then suing needs to stop now and is particularly prevalent in those that are from some type of minority group.
 
Will need to take a look in Catholic times to see if any travelling priests are getting hassled at airports to see how far that stereotyping goes...
 
did he delete the comments or did a mod?

Not sure Harvey. We quoted most of them so they are still there either way

Edit: it appears he's vanished altogether...Shame, i thought we were bonding ;)

It was a mod :D
(But not me, I was asleep at that time in the morning like all other sane people!!!)

Since Blair and his posts have now disappeared, I've done a final tidy up on the posts responding to him. They didn't make much sense on their own and without any context they weren't making us look very good.
 
Very fishy for my taste. Serious accusations and all details should have given to the director which were not. I work as a field engineer and I travel a lot and have a beard and brown skin. I carry my camera gear with me everywhere and I mean everywhere. Not once my camera equipment raised any questions. Officers were always very polite. I was only stopped once after returning from a trip to Lebanon. They were looking for drugs and I don't blame them.

Either I am very lucky of certain individuals behave suspiciously. Why the 2 men wanted the bag be searched in private? I first thought because they had sex toys but it turned out to camera. This is why it is so fishy.

In also all most cases the reporter of the incident is the one who raise the level of suspicion with rediculous answers to the simplest of questions.

My own observation of course ymmv.
 
Well if you have read it, please be good enough to say your comment......

".....It is possible that it could have happened but it is also possible that the whole thing is a fabrication to 'highlight' what could happen for 'training' purposes. I can't believe that a chief inspector observer would not report this sort of behaviour if it were true. "

........no longer applies.

If you look back through the thread you will notice I made a mistake of using 'it is' rather that 'is it' so no need for a back track from me as I was asking a question.

No one will answer the question of why such a serious event was not reported to the authorities though. This in itself a terrible piece of judgment by the chief inspector.
 
What does being gay or having a camera have to do with being a paedophile? It beggars belief in this day and age that anyone still thinks like this
 
1 - its blatantly obvious reading through that the border agent was just using excuses, he probably stopped him to meet his quota and then had to find a quick response as to why he did so, though there is an element of homophobia indicated I think the camera was just part of the BS excuse.

2 - you cant avoid stereotyping, one of the things we do as a creature is to group things of a kind or familiar association together, its the way we deal with large quantities of information or numbers of people etc.
Stereotypes are created by this grouping of things or people and often spill over, the classic one is that any single male over 40 living alone is automatically viewed with suspicion, this permeates through all government agencies.
In just the same way the same persists over gay men, the fact that in both cases at some time in the past members from both groups have been convicted of child abuse (paedophilia itself is not a criminal offence, the practise of it, ie child abuse is) has created a "familiar association" that remains prevalent in peoples minds.

3 - as said stereo types or grouping have to be used in such situations, the person is making snap decisions based on a moments contact, thus certain groups would be more likely to be checked.

4 - One critical piece of information is missing from the report, the destination of the couple, it could have been that they where travelling to an area which is known for its sex tourism, this is an activity thats seeing a crack down from all agencies in order to try and reduce the world wide sexual abuse of children.

5 - I hope they don't sue, this whole culture of taking offence and then suing needs to stop now and is particularly prevalent in those that are from some type of minority group.

All of the above could only be said by someone who has never been stereotyped and singled out for abuse or discrimination. I would suggest that you live a month or two as a person with brown or black skin, being gay or disabled and then once you have experienced the feelings associated with this type of hateful behavior then comment on it.
 
All of the above could only be said by someone who has never been stereotyped and singled out for abuse or discrimination. I would suggest that you live a month or two as a person with brown or black skin, being gay or disabled and then once you have experienced the feelings associated with this type of hateful behavior then comment on it.

I would suggest you look at Ian's profile...
 
All of the above could only be said by someone who has never been stereotyped and singled out for abuse or discrimination. I would suggest that you live a month or two as a person with brown or black skin, being gay or disabled and then once you have experienced the feelings associated with this type of hateful behavior then comment on it.

Yeah because those are the only sterotypes that exist :bang:

Not that long ago I encountered a sign that said " no dog, no bikers" (admittedly when me and my 35 freinds ignored this prohibition they didnt try to throw us out :lol: )

There are all sorts of negative stereotypes that attach to white men, skin heads, people with hoodies, fat people, thin people, people who like certain sorts of music, people with long hair, people who like certain hobbies - the list is endless.

However at border controls they do have to use profiling - because short of stopping everyone (which some countries do - but the number of people coming into the UK everyday make that a non starter) how else can you target your resources effectively

thats not to say that what happened in the incident described in the OP was in anyway acceptable - but Ian is right in that if you fit the profile for whatever they are trying to stop or catch you are more likely to be stopped.

(oh yeah and btw Ian is disabled - and none of us know anything about his sexuality so it seems that its you thats making the wild generalisations)
 
Last edited:
What does being gay or having a camera have to do with being a paedophile? It beggars belief in this day and age that anyone still thinks like this

+1...

Ridiculous case.

Also interesting to see some people's responses and attitudes on this thread (and I don't mean the trolls...) - homophobic attitudes are alive and well.
 
Then if Ian is disabled I find it hard to believe that he can't find empathy for the people involved in this case.

Not for a minute did I suggest that the minorities I highlighted were the only ones...merely the most commonly oppressed.
 
I can't see where in his post he says he doesnt empathise with them - all he's saying is that a) border security have to use stereotypes to an extent (which is all profiling is at the end of the day) and b) We don't know the whole story because we've only heard one side.

if for example they were returning from Pattaya , two guys with a camera who don't want the bag its in inspected publically returning from one of the principle sex tourism destinations... you can see how that might fit the profile
 
Then if Ian is disabled I find it hard to believe that he can't find empathy for the people involved in this case.

Not for a minute did I suggest that the minorities I highlighted were the only ones...merely the most commonly oppressed.

Are you seriously saying that the minorities are oppressed? ...... People are stopped at security points all the time and whether someone is black, disabled or gay they are still perfectly capable of committing crime! :shrug:
 
Last edited:
Pertinently, one of the issues highlighted in the report is that UKBA don't have the information to determine whether or not they are unfairly targeting particular groups

From the Executive Summary

Equalities considerations were given insufficient attention across immigration and detection functions. Investigation of approaches to race monitoring in detection operations revealed perceived ethnicity was only recorded in search of person forms and this information was not analysed. The Agency had no way of knowing if people of a particular race / ethnicity were targeted for interception more than others or whether particular officers / teams were targeting people from particular groups more than other detection staff. We could not therefore be confident that the Agency was fulfilling its duties in line with the Equality Act 2010. A number of detection staff also informed members of the inspection team that they sometimes delay white passengers if they wish to question a black passenger purely to avoid potential claims of race discrimination. The Ministerial Authorisation allowing closer scrutiny of particular nationals at the border for immigration purposes was not informing frontline practice.

There is, by the way a significant difference between targeted profiling, supported by evidence and backed by policy, and simple stereotyping or plain bigotry.
 
Pertinently, one of the issues highlighted in the report is that UKBA don't have the information to determine whether or not they are unfairly targeting particular groups

From the Executive Summary

A number of detection staff also informed members of the inspection team that they sometimes delay white passengers if they wish to question a black passenger purely to avoid potential claims of race discrimination.

There is, by the way a significant difference between targeted profiling, supported by evidence and backed by policy, and simple stereotyping or plain bigotry.

That must be the best example of PC racial discrimination I've ever seen :lol:
 
I've been searched at an airport, carrying photography kit.

Many millions have been searched without carrying any kit.

This is more to do with the rather naive and insulting comments made by the border officer than the person actually being 'singled out' or persecuted as he will have been just one of thousands who were searched at that location that day.
 
This is more to do with the rather naive and insulting comments made by the border officer than the person actually being 'singled out' or persecuted as he will have been just one of thousands who were searched at that location that day.

and these related to his orientation not to whether he was a photographer as indeed did the reasons for stopping him as they didnt know he had a camera until his luggage was examined.

bottom line therefore the border control officer was a predjudiced homophobic halfwit - but this issue had very little to do with photography.
 
4 - One critical piece of information is missing from the report, the destination of the couple, it could have been that they where travelling to an area which is known for its sex tourism, this is an activity thats seeing a crack down from all agencies in order to try and reduce the world wide sexual abuse of children.

They were entering the U.K. not leaving.
 
They were entering the U.K. not leaving.

in that case they could have been returning fom such an area - i'm not saying that they were , just that ian has a valid point that we don't have the full facts.

However even if they were this isnt about whether it was right to search them - its about the officers bad attitude , not following policy, and making jokes about HIV because of their orientation - that would be out of order even if they were criminals , the officer is still expected to behave in a proffesional manner
 
Last edited:
The title, and many of the comments on this are very misleading.

He was stopped, Ok, possibly for the wrong reasons, and the camera was found during the search, it had nothing what so ever to do with why he was stopped in the first place.

Yes, the BF chappie was wrong, stupid, naive and however else you want to put it, he used the presence of a camera to justify his opinion in retrospect, not as part of his reason to stop.
 
I would suggest you look at Ian's profile...
:lol: thanks Rob

Then if Ian is disabled I find it hard to believe that he can't find empathy for the people involved in this case.

Not for a minute did I suggest that the minorities I highlighted were the only ones...merely the most commonly oppressed.

I don't feel oppressed as a severely disabled person, hounded by a cost cutting government but not oppressed yet, I also have a thick skin and don't subscribe to political correctness, the cult of offence or any of the other BS thats emerged over the last few decades.
As well as that people speak as they find with me, I don't get my knickers in a twist if someone makes a joke about cripples or vegetables, I learned one of the most important life lessons ages ago, learn to laugh at yourself and accept yourself for who and what you are, what others think is unimportant and sometimes downright funny.
I also think people need to go back and learn what real oppression is, its more than name calling or quiet sniggers as you go by, there is no real oppression in this country, there is still a lot of discrimination and the vast majority now is positive discrimination which I personally find just as abhorrent as negative discrimination, equality is every one on equal standing with NO ONE getting preferential or discriminatory treatment.

in that case they could have been returning fom such an area - i'm not saying that they were , just that ian has a valid point that we don't have the full facts.

However even if they were this isnt about whether it was right to search them - its about the officers bad attitude , not following policy, and making jokes about HIV because of their orientation - that would be out of order even if they were criminals , the officer is still expected to behave in a proffesional manner

+1 this is exactly it, the search itself wasn't the problem but the conduct of the border agents whilst conducting and after conducting the search.
 
in that case they could have been returning fom such an area - i'm not saying that they were , just that ian has a valid point that we don't have the full facts.

However even if they were this isnt about whether it was right to search them - its about the officers bad attitude , not following policy, and making jokes about HIV because of their orientation - that would be out of order even if they were criminals , the officer is still expected to behave in a proffesional manner

But the officer did not give the origin of the flight as one of the reasons for stopping the passenger, so it would appear that this is unlikely.
 
But the officer did not give the origin of the flight as one of the reasons for stopping the passenger, so it would appear that this is unlikely.

to be honest you (and I) don't know what the officer did or didnt say verbatim - we've only got a journalists edit of a report writers interpretation of what a senior officer reported the original officer alledgedly said

its not exactly gospel
 
tiler65 said:
Am I bothered? No

Am I surprised? No

Do I think anything will change because of this very old story? No

My biggest problem is that the 'inpsector' won't or can't reveal the names of the perpetrators from this so called 'observation'.

It is possible that it could have happened but it is also possible that the whole thing is a fabrication to 'highlight' what could happen for 'training' purposes. I can't believe that a chief inspector observer would not report this sort of behaviour if it were true.

Any news from the affected passengers?

Questioning the validity of the situation is a defence within itself.
Selfishness is a part of everyone, just some choose to display it more shamelessly.....
 
Although I agree with a part of iancandler's post I firmly disagree with the statement

"You can't help stereotyping"

Each and every one of us should have enough self respecting discipline to not participate in stereotyping, It's our moral obligation..

One can turn a blind eye or except it as normal behavior until it touches you or someone you care about, or it even interrupts your passion or hobby as it has here.

So one can defend the situation by saying its not a true story or even justify it by saying it's normal behavior but at the end or the day what are you really defending.
 
but at the end or the day what are you really defending.

It is called human nature, fact.

We are hunters, it is bred into us to look for weaknesses in others.

Obviously we have evolved where most of us do not 'hunt' any more because we have adapted a culture of 'living' together in reasonable harmony. Apart from many of the conflicts which have religious beginnings where religion was supposed to be the thing that stopped us becoming 'hunters'.

We are what we are, just be rational and except that behaviour goes on. If things change then so be it. Sticks and stones is something I remember vividly from an early age, it appears we seem to have forgotten that in this day and age.
 
Some people look for excuses while others look to improve society. If all anyone ever did was say "it was human nature" and accept everything as it is we would still be living in caves...
 
Some people look for excuses while others look to improve society. If all anyone ever did was say "it was human nature" and accept everything as it is we would still be living in caves...

But you are saying that they are not allowed an opinion...which in my eyes is worse.
 
ernesto said:
Some people look for excuses while others look to improve society. If all anyone ever did was say "it was human nature" and accept everything as it is we would still be living in caves...

Well said, that was my point. Successful societies where not founded on people that except social injustice with the lame excuse of "it is what it is or it's human nature".... we are all untitled to our opinion but thank goodness there will always be people that will stand up and say - that not right!
 
Well said, that was my point. Successful societies where not founded on people that except social injustice with the lame excuse of "it is what it is or it's human nature".... we are all untitled to our opinion but thank goodness there will always be people that will stand up and say - that not right!

Sorry to burst your bubble but where is there a successful society?
 
Back
Top