Goverment looks to warn public on airbrushing

AliB

Suspended / Banned
Messages
7,762
Edit My Images
No
From today's Guardian

http://www.guardian.co.uk/lifeandstyle/2010/jul/25/fashion-industry-airbrushing-clampdown

Goverment equality minister is talking with the fashion industry about the possible introduction of some kind of "flag" to the public that an image has been airbrushed or altered.

I'm all for a little bit of spot removal but I have to say that I am very much with her when it comes to carving off the inches. I was in Debenhams recently and their manequins have a waistline of about 12 inches so the clothes are hanging on something that does not even represent a normal human frame (Not one that is over about 10 years old anyway!) so there is much work to be done.

I do wonder where lines should be drawn (or not drawn as the case may be) though. How much is too much? That's going to be the interesting question and I do feel that it's easy to criticise and much harder to set limits. A few lines to make someone appear younger? Longer legs? Longer eyelashes? shifted boobs? Bum lifts? Longer heels on shoes? Tucked up bingo wings?
All things I have done at a clients request too!

And I also wonder if it's something that could work internationally and where differing cultures would draw the lines.........

Glad something is at least being discussed though.
 
Hi Ali

How did you do longer heels on shoes without deforming the feet?

There was a TV programme or section recently which covered "ambiguous" to put it politely, images shown with make up items . I would prefer to see a mascara ad. with the mascara put on bare eyelashes so you can really see the effect, not added to a eyelash wig which looks thick enough to sweep the floor with !
 
Perhaps the discussion is more valuable than any 'flag'. As you say, how much is too much? We all sympathise with the spot removal but when is a transient spot a freckle...what about colour adjustments to an image? Would that be acceptable? Or not? This is a potential mine field. Education that an image may not represent actuality and that variation is what enables the biological strength of the species...Maybe those who want to be stick thin and orange skinned wouldn't "get it"?

Now there are so many questions buzzing around in my head I can't decide where I stand...on the fence :$
 
While I do agree that the media do portray a image of beauty that is unatainable for the majority of people and in most cases totally fake I dont see what good a small warning on a photograph saying "This has been airbrushed" is going to do. Most people, teenagers included, know that the images in the glossy mags have been airbrushed and still it makes no difference, its what people want to look like.

Culture and peoples perceptions of whats "hot" needs to change, the top models and a lot are still starving themselves to look the way eveyone thinks they are supposed to look. The redtops and other celebity mags need to stop perving on celbrities and shouting as loud as they can when someone puts on half a stone or when they seem to skinny, this all fuels the idea that everyone has to be perfect.
 
Digitial editing is cheaper than cosmetic surgery for personal use and if it makes someone feel good about themselves then I am all for it.

What I do object to is digitial editing which gives the impression that a product will do more than it actually will, for instance mascara as previously mentioned - wrinkle removal (appearance) treatments - the photos they show with these generally indicate it must have been applied by a particularly adept plasterer !
 
David Cameron is heard to be passionately against any airbrushing, so this makes sense as a policy.

david-cameron-880207022.jpg
 
I thought the government were supposed to be looking at ways to save money not waste it
 
Depends on how you view that though Keith. Do you make publicists put a warning on images at very little cost to the taxpayer or do you burden the NHS with the results of treating eating disorders?
 
The advert that really used to get my goat was the one for some miracle anti-ageing cream (Olay?) or similar promoted by Nadine Baggot, the queen of botox...
 
Depends on how you view that though Keith. Do you make publicists put a warning on images at very little cost to the taxpayer or do you burden the NHS with the results of treating eating disorders?

What I was saying Ali is that people know images are airbrushed, putting a sticker on them wont make people look at them differently. What has to change is the way, culturally, we portray beauty that has to change. This must happen across the board in the media, in the modelling/fashion industy, in music/films, its a big job.

On another note it isn't the skinny people that seems to be in the headlines atm its the overweight.
 
Forgive me lord for what I am about to say:

I think air brushing is brilliant,, if you saw the size of some models its the only way you can get them to fit in frame :-p

OK,, totally horrific joking aside, there are many fair points.

But my 2p,,,, chatting to some one I know recently who knows some one who got caught up in one of them modeling scams (pay for port, on books yada yada).
Who got offered air brushing for free and acepted it as the norm and a great way of making an image perfect :o(
And this is no small lass,,, shape best describes as christmas pudding on legs.

So on the flip side of the eating disorder, the other side is the delusion of many that airbrushing is acceptable to make people look perfect.

And I really find that annoying, because it creates the oposite,,, as they have a delusional image of how good they look they then have no coonciousness of their actually physical health and image,,,
 
Do people still 'airbrush' pictures? I doubt an 'airbrush' has been used on an image used in advertising for a decade.

But extreme body morphing enhancing aside, as TinaC suggests, where does it start? Even a monochrome newspaper image is 'altered' isn't it?

Politicians really like making up pointless legislation. If people didn't want to see thin girls advertising stuff you can be sure that the advertisers would have spotted it, so to try to create some artificial limit as to what is 'acceptable' to Ms Fetherstone is never going to be successful as there will always be someone who will try (probably successfully) to circumnavigate it. And what penalty would be applied to them? Nothing.
 
i do think there is a problem when it comes to airbrushing in the fashion industry and that its used too much, in fact i was watching an ugly betty episode the other day and the model didn't like the way she had the liquify filter used on her and wanted to be shown as her normal self not to mention the magazine then cacked themselves when the original unedited prints we about to be published.
 
Depends on how you view that though Keith. Do you make publicists put a warning on images at very little cost to the taxpayer or do you burden the NHS with the results of treating eating disorders?

A few air brushed images are so not the cause of eating disorders, it goes a lot deeper that that, and stopping the airbrushing of images etc. is not going to suddenly stop, or even reduce dramatically, the number of people with eating disorders.

This is just my personal opinion based on having suffered with anorexia myself in my late 20's early 30's

And before anyone comes along and says bull, men don't cant get anorexia yada yada here is a picture of me when I was 30, just before I got taken into hospital because of my anorexia - Just to give a little more perspective the t-shirt I am wearing is a size small and I weighed 6st 4lb

Untitled-1.jpg
 
I'm for truth in advertising, so IMO, airbrushing, fake lashes etc are a bit of a no-no but as long as there's a visible (NOT tiny print, lost in the page gutter) notice to the effect that PS (or similar) and falsies have been used, I guess I'll have to settle for that.

For portraits etc (as long as they're not aimed at dating sites), do whatever's needed to make the subject presentable!
 
I understand that men do suffer from eating disorders too Keith and I hope you are well on your way to a happy, healthy lifestyle.

I also understand just how many youngsters are throwing up in toilets on a regular basis just because they think they need to be skinny to be attractive.

You are right, eating disorders come in many forms and affect many people and yes obesity is just as much a problem, as is the lack of education on food and nutrition and the lack of excercise many of us suffer from.

I still think that setting unrealistic targets for our youngsters is something worthy of proper investigation so I welcome the discussions on all of these topics.
 
I hate being told what to do, and maybe there are better ways of spending money, but I really dislike heavily airbrushed work and glad to see this discussed.

I take the odd spot off and thats about it, but aside from contrast, saturation, exposure, crop and WB change and the like... I probably only edit 1% of images. I hate looking at images knowing they are fake and would much rather see 'normal' people featured.

I actually find most models quite ugly, and generally see girls far more pretty out and about, spots and the odd wobble and all!
 
Hi Ali

How did you do longer heels on shoes without deforming the feet?

Warp tool on the heel Christine. Was shot from behind and elongating the legs and also the heel on the shoe were what was asked for. It was actually part of a training day we were doing and I can now move boobs back to before gravity was discovered too. When you realise just what is going on in some of these images it really is a bit of an eye opener. Some of the more subtle stuff can be amazing.
 
Warp tool on the heel Christine. Was shot from behind and elongating the legs and also the heel on the shoe were what was asked for. It was actually part of a training day we were doing and I can now move boobs back to before gravity was discovered too. When you realise just what is going on in some of these images it really is a bit of an eye opener. Some of the more subtle stuff can be amazing.


Thanks Ali - am now off to search through my images to see if I can find a rear view with heels to practice on
 
Thanks Ali - am now off to search through my images to see if I can find a rear view with heels to practice on

Liquify/forward warp tool and don't make the brush small, keep it at the default size and place the crosshair on the tip of the heel and just pull it a little.
 
.................
You are right, eating disorders come in many forms and affect many people and yes obesity is just as much a problem, as is the lack of education on food and nutrition and the lack of excercise many of us suffer from.............

$0.02 worth
there is no lack of education/knowledge about a correct diet/healthy lifestyle
- it's available to all from many souces

what is lacking is guidance from adults/parents

sorry this is a pet HATE of mine :shake:
every day I pick up overweight children whose overweight parents load into the taxi an assortment of prepared/prepackaged synthetic food which would make a dietitian weep...! ......parents are failing and the children suffer

PS a vast number of distances from home to supermarket are less than 1mile - still the family call a taxi
 
Back
Top