Haida ND3.0 - 10 Stop Filter

Messages
1,282
Name
Stephen
Edit My Images
Yes
My Haida ND3.0 10 stop filter turned up yesterday so I thought I’d have a play about with it in the house before I use it in anger as I’ve read that they can vary a little bit around the 10 stop mark.

Now bear in mind I’m still on a steep learning curve and haven’t done any long exposure photograph before, I’m aware that there are better quality filters out there than the Haida but I’ve bought it to have a play about with at relatively low cost (£42 for the 77mm).

So I did this inside to try and keep the lighting constant (was a mixture of diffused light through a closed blind and LED ceiling mounded spotlights…which could go some way to explaining some of the blue cast, although I suspect most of it is the filter). I also remembered to cover the view finder as I read somewhere I needed to do this to stop light getting in that way?

The main aim of this for me was to try and give me a better idea of how to calculate exposure times when I use this in the field. I downloaded the iPhone app ‘Long Time’ to help me out a bit with this test.

So here is a photo taken without any filters and is therefore the control shot. All were shot with my D3000 with a Nikon 17-55mm f2.8, all set at f6.3 and ISO 400 (to keep the exposure times sensible). This wasn’t helped by the fact I don’t have a shutter release cable and on bulb mode on the D3000 you need to keep the button pressed, which after a while wasn’t much fun! Don’t know if this is the same on all cameras?

Control shot: 1/15 sec, f6.3, ISO400


2012_07_22-323410-Stop-TEST=1/15 sec by Tunbridge Wells, on Flickr

With ND3.0. I set the time as 60 sec as this should be the correct exposure for a 10 stop filter and got this, which looked a bit dark…


2012_07_22-323510-Stop-TEST-60 sec by Tunbridge Wells, on Flickr

So I tried it at 90 sec. A bit better but still a bit dark?


2012_07_22-323710-Stop-TEST-90 sec by Tunbridge Wells, on Flickr

Again at 105 sec…


2012_07_22-323210-Stop-TEST-105 sec by Tunbridge Wells, on Flickr

And again at 120 sec…


2012_07_22-323610-Stop-TEST-120 sec by Tunbridge Wells, on Flickr

So what do we think? Looks nearer to 11 stops to my un-trained eye?

Any tips or advise would be great before I go out into the field with this.
 
So then to experiment further I tried the same thing with my Haida ND3.0 plus a HOYA Circular polarizing filter. Not sure if I will need to use this or not, is it the done thing?

Any how, as above but first at 180 sec…


2012_07_22-324010-Stop+PL-CIR-180 sec by Tunbridge Wells, on Flickr

Then 240 sec…


2012_07_22-324110-Stop+PL-CIR-240 sec by Tunbridge Wells, on Flickr

And finally 360 sec…


2012_07_22-324210-Stop+PL-CIR-360 sec by Tunbridge Wells, on Flickr

So does this mean I’m somewhere between 12 & 13 stops with this combination?
 
My Haida 10 stopper is closer to 11 stops too....you'll probably find that a CPL will lose you around 2 stops again....so yeah, you'll be close to the 11-12 stops with that combo.
 
Should I be using the CPL with the 10 stop? If I was shooting a waterfall for example there would be no advantage in cutting reflections on the water would there as it would all be milky anyway?
 
Should I be using the CPL with the 10 stop? If I was shooting a waterfall for example there would be no advantage in cutting reflections on the water would there as it would all be milky anyway?

There will probably be reflections and glare on wet rocks, shore, leaves etc so the CPL will help a lot with that.
 
Back
Top