Have you ever held back a photograph for ethical reasons?

Can i ask why people would delete images of injurys. I have a photo of me in a fight at the moment i got a sever cut about my eye. Blood splatter and all its a cracking image. Even tho the fight was stoped due to the cut resulting in a loss to me i still love that image.
 
Reading some of the comments from professionaly employed photographers seems to me to be akin to the "I was only obeying orders" scenario.

What about personal morality and integrity? Is that just sacrificed to 'get the shot'? If you are being paid to shoot does that automatically remove your humanity? Does your duty to your employer override your duty to your fellow man?

I think the OP made the correct decision and behaved like a decent human being.
 
Can i ask why people would delete images of injurys. I have a photo of me in a fight at the moment i got a sever cut about my eye. Blood splatter and all its a cracking image. Even tho the fight was stoped due to the cut resulting in a loss to me i still love that image.

haha different scenario.. I do combat photogrpahy and wait all night hoping for blood hahaha

A 10 yr old kid lying on the floor in agony crying his eyes out is kinda different and really no need... a boxer with blood spewing from above his eye...great! :)
 
He was either a staffer or a freelance on contract- it's all there in the first post if you read it.

Also: plenty of freelancers shooting for local/regional papers in the early 90s?
A few, yes, but certainly not plenty.

Just been back and reread the first post - apart from a hint (maybe) in "my editor", no mention of status of OP.

Most pics in the local rag down here seem still to be shot by freelancers - I think they only have one staffer!

Straycat, thanks for status clarification. Although possibly wrong from an employment point of view, you did right on moral/ethical grounds (IMO).
 
Straycat, thanks for status clarification. Although possibly wrong from an employment point of view, you did right on moral/ethical grounds (IMO).

So the question then is.. what comes first..loyalty to the people who have given you a job.., pay your wage, help you to feed your family... or your own morals ?

For clarity To be honest I dont have a single problem wiht what straycat did/does or anyone else.. its each to his own... just having a debate not finger pointing :)
 
haha different scenario.. I do combat photogrpahy and wait all night hoping for blood hahaha

A 10 yr old kid lying on the floor in agony crying his eyes out is kinda different and really no need... a boxer with blood spewing from above his eye...great! :)

Oh good cos if i look back at my fight photos and i dont see any blood i dont think i have been fighting hard enough ;)
 
So the question then is.. what comes first..loyalty to the people who have given you a job.., pay your wage, help you to feed your family... or your own morals ?

For clarity To be honest I dont have a single problem wiht what straycat did/does or anyone else.. its each to his own... just having a debate not finger pointing :)

I refer the honourable member to post #13.

I'm lucky in that I can afford to make gestures like that. My personal integrity is worth far more to me than employment!
 
Nod said:
Just been back and reread the first post - apart from a hint (maybe) in "my editor", no mention of status of OP.

Most pics in the local rag down here seem still to be shot by freelancers - I think they only have one staffer!

There were far more references than just 'my editor' if you know how papers work. It was pretty clear really.
 
parkmoy said:
Reading some of the comments from professionaly employed photographers seems to me to be akin to the "I was only obeying orders" scenario.

What about personal morality and integrity? Is that just sacrificed to 'get the shot'? If you are being paid to shoot does that automatically remove your humanity? Does your duty to your employer override your duty to your fellow man?

I think the OP made the correct decision and behaved like a decent human being.

It's called being a journalist, which means telling the story without fear or favour.
 
There were far more references than just 'my editor' if you know how papers work. It was pretty clear really.

I've never worked for a paper so can hardly be expected to pick up on industry speak! I'll take your word for it though.
 
i was the only one untrained i had taught myself,they had a different mindset to me.

i had covered riots and things myself before working for them and would not hesitate to use a photo if it would make a differance.

in this case it would have made a witty front cover and got the firemen in trouble over something i saw as a minor infraction.

as i had a good enough photo anyway and my remit was to cover the fire not firemen following health and safety to the letter,i did my job.

if they trawl through my contact sheets and negatives its still there.

often i was up against the head photographer from a sister publication covering the same story.

he was technically better than me but worked to a formulae,when i got a good photo it stood out.
as i was thinking different and i cared not just about the photo but the people it impacted on.

my photo of a dog in a dogs home led to every dog being adopted within a week of it being published and caused a bit of a stir.
i was close to not using it because of the wire across the eye,but i then realised that was what made it so good.

in fact the reporter and i where so moved we nearly adopted the dog ourselves...

DogSanctuary1_zps9d1531e0.jpg
 
Last edited:
Bloody good photo! I took a similar one last year- photographing in rescue centres can be tough.

You've got the wrong username btw!
 
parkmoy said:
Where do journalists leave their consciences?

I sometimes wonder. As a firefighter/tog I come across photographers working for the local rag frequently. Some are great (like the OP) and understand that some things occur at fires that mean we have to ignore health and safety to get the job done. They respect this and go easy on us. Others however don't. Recently we attended a house fire and the photographer was there snapping away. The next days paper had a full page dedicated to the fact a fire engine was parked on double yellow lines.... not until the last line did it mention the fact that three people were rescued from the house. The guy was obviously there to cover the fire but I guess the editor thought they could sell more papers by degrading the fire service
 
I sometimes wonder. As a firefighter/tog I come across photographers working for the local rag frequently. Some are great (like the OP) and understand that some things occur at fires that mean we have to ignore health and safety to get the job done. They respect this and go easy on us. Others however don't. Recently we attended a house fire and the photographer was there snapping away. The next days paper had a full page dedicated to the fact a fire engine was parked on double yellow lines.... not until the last line did it mention the fact that three people were rescued from the house. The guy was obviously there to cover the fire but I guess the editor thought they could sell more papers by degrading the fire service

hardly the photographers fault ???? i dont see how your blaming the photographer for what the editor did..
 
KIPAX said:
hardly the photographers fault ???? i dont see how your blaming the photographer for what the editor did..

He took the photo didn't he? Unless he was specifically told to go there and catch us out then he took it off his own back.
 
He took the photo didn't he? Unless he was specifically told to go there and catch us out then he took it off his own back.

he probabl;y didnt even notice the double yellows.. he is there to take pictures of everyhting..pics go back to the papers and they decide what to use and in what way.. he gets absoloutly no say...

i agree the story was pathetic.. but to blame the photogrpaher is a bit childish to be honest..
 
KIPAX said:
he probabl;y didnt even notice the double yellows.. he is there to take pictures of everyhting..pics go back to the papers and they decide what to use and in what way.. he gets absoloutly no say...

i agree the story was pathetic.. but to blame the photogrpaher is a bit childish to be honest..

Oh he noticed them alright. Nice shot from low down with nice use of leading lines if you get me! Anyway, not here to argue, my point is that this use of pictures can make us wary of how we go about doing our job. We get canned because we ignore health and safety regulations for a couple of seconds in order to rescue someone, we also get canned if we stand by and do nothing because of the same regulations. Same with the police but that's a whole other kettle of fish! :)
 
I'd be interested in reading the full story. You keep mentioning health & safety, yet the photo was of you parked on double yellows. Maybe there was more to this than you are letting on?
 
DemiLion said:
I'd be interested in reading the full story. You keep mentioning health & safety, yet the photo was of you parked on double yellows. Maybe there was more to this than you are letting on?

No not really, I only mention the health and safety thing because I can guarantee you that's what the fireman in the original post was worried about. We get pulled up at work all the time for being pictured in the paper without helmets on or no gloves on, etc.
 
shaylou said:
I guess that is something that one must decide they can live with before excepting the job. I couldn't.

Would you mind expanding on what you are trying to imply?

A word of advice- I'd be very careful how you phrase what you say.
 
DemiLion said:
Would you mind expanding on what you are trying to imply?

A word of advice- I'd be very careful how you phrase what you say.

Excuse me, your reply sounds threatening. Word of advise to you, don't go there. I was not implying anything, I was stating a fact.

For those that didn't understand the simple reply I meant that with every job there are requirements, we all have a choice to except or decline the job if we do not like the requirements of that job. I personally would not put myself in a position where I had no control over what pictures were made public. It's my choice the same as its the choice of others to except a job that requires this.

How in the world you took that is beyond me.

Sounds like someone is a bit on the defensive side...
 
Over the years and in a few jobs, I've worked with firemen, from rookie retained to station officers. One story stands out in particular, an officer attending a nasty RTA saw a bike (motor) helmet lying on the floor (this was in the days before every little detail was scrupulouslt recorded) and gave it a gentle kick. As he did so, he realised that it seemed a bit heavier than he expected and sure enough, the biker's head was still inside. NOT a story anyone would wish to read at the time (as it happens, I knew the biker slightly but didn't hear the tale until years later), especially the family and close friends. Fortunately, the press never got wind and certainl, no photos were taken. Would anyone here have snapped it and published had they been there?
 
How in the world you took that is beyond me.

Sounds like someone is a bit on the defensive side...

Very easily given some of your previous posts and I'm not defensive about my job in the slightest.
 
Over the years and in a few jobs, I've worked with firemen, from rookie retained to station officers. One story stands out in particular, an officer attending a nasty RTA saw a bike (motor) helmet lying on the floor (this was in the days before every little detail was scrupulouslt recorded) and gave it a gentle kick. As he did so, he realised that it seemed a bit heavier than he expected and sure enough, the biker's head was still inside. NOT a story anyone would wish to read at the time (as it happens, I knew the biker slightly but didn't hear the tale until years later), especially the family and close friends. Fortunately, the press never got wind and certainl, no photos were taken. Would anyone here have snapped it and published had they been there?

On the basis that it was a gentle kick; no, absolutely not. It's a fairly human reaction.

If he'd tried converting it into the nearby field, then yes of course I would.
 
he probabl;y didnt even notice the double yellows.. he is there to take pictures of everyhting..pics go back to the papers and they decide what to use and in what way.. he gets absoloutly no say...

i agree the story was pathetic.. but to blame the photogrpaher is a bit childish to be honest..


Yeah, right. He didn't notice the yellow lines and even if he had, he had no idea how the paper would use the picture. Porcine aviation is here:)

I live in N.Ireland and a local photographer, who incidentally took an award winning picture during the 'Troubles', summed it up like this. He said, 'The Nationals come in, don't care who they upset and then leave, I have to live here with my neighbours, there are pictures I won't take.'
 
On the basis that it was a gentle kick; no, absolutely not. It's a fairly human reaction.

If he'd tried converting it into the nearby field, then yes of course I would.

Much more a dribble than a penalty - after all, bash hats are hard and even through capped boots, a hefty kick would hurt! (Apparently, as soon as he realised what he had done, he threw up - an equally human reaction!)
 
...

I live in N.Ireland and a local photographer, who incidentally took an award winning picture during the 'Troubles', summed it up like this. He said, 'The Nationals come in, don't care who they upset and then leave, I have to live here with my neighbours, there are pictures I won't take.'


His words speak absolute volumes don't they.

Professional attitude is all very good and has my respect, but I fear allowing personal ethics and morals to be hidden away under that pro-ethos simply means a photojournalists professional output becomes a charade of news for the sake of profit alone.
This is not photojournalism or investigation, In its basics, its just sales pitch to sell stuff. ...papers are full of this carp right. :gag:
 
Professional attitude is all very good and has my respect, but I fear allowing personal ethics and morals to be hidden away under that pro-ethos simply means a photojournalists professional output becomes a charade of news for the sake of profit alone.
This is not photojournalism or investigation, In its basics, its just sales pitch to sell stuff. ...papers are full of this carp right. :gag:

:thumbs:

Exactly - at least one news photographer on here used to have the tag line " I'm a news photographer not a papparazo," but if you start taking stuff for profit alone without considering ethics , how exactly is that different ?
 
it just shows we all have different ways of dealing with the rights and wrongs.
 
Slightly different note there was an interesting dilemma laid out in the book 'The Bang Bang Club'.

Grey Marinovich had a photo published that featured a man ('sympathetic to the ANC') machete-ing a burning zulu. It went on to win Marinovich a Pulitzer but at the time the Johannesberg police wanted to issue a subpoena to get hold of the negs so they could nick the committer of the crime (as the police representing the then state were anti ANC). The dilemma was this:

A) Give the police the negs and no photographer will get near the action again because it will be assumed that the photographers are working collaboratively with the police

B) Don't give them and risk getting arrested/punished yourself.

I think form memory the paper who printed the shot told the police that Marinovich had left town and taken the negs with him.
 
Last edited:
the answer is A and B

or A,or B

i guess there just is no correct answer its a real dilema.
 
In this country it's simple - the Police have no access to journalistic material without a court order under the terms of PACE.

In SA? Run like buggery!! :lol:
 
In every part of life their are lines in the sand,where you draw thoses lines is up to you.

Photographer is no diffrent :)
 
Slightly different note there was an interesting dilemma laid out in the book 'The Bang Bang Club'.

Grey Marinovich had a photo published that featured a man ('sympathetic to the ANC') machete-ing a burning zulu. It went on to win Marinovich a Pulitzer but at the time the Johannesberg police wanted to issue a subpoena to get hold of the negs so they could nick the committer of the crime (as the police representing the then state were anti ANC). The dilemma was this:

A) Give the police the negs and no photographer will get near the action again because it will be assumed that the photographers are working collaboratively with the police

B) Don't give them and risk getting arrested/punished yourself.

I think form memory the paper who printed the shot told the police that Marinovich had left town and taken the negs with him.

He came to London,and laid low for a while,in some parts of the world, the state has a lot of control over what its people see and what they dont.
:)
 
good job he hadnt come from Israel,mossad would have slotted him,i expect.
 
Back
Top