I got GAS and I want a new Landscape lens

ndwgolf

ndwgolf

Messages
4,770
Name
Neil Williams
Edit My Images
No
What is the very very very BEST lens for landscape to screw onto a Nikon D800e????..........looked at the Zeiss 55mm 1.4 but the focal length is to narrow :(
 
Don't you already have a 12-24/2.8? Could have sworn you said that was in your kit bag in the past, I don't see you'd need anything more than that, it has a filter thread right?

Edit: no it doesn't take filters it seems, so I guess maybe I'd go for a 16-35/2.8 I'm sure Nikon has that in its range
 
Last edited:
I think you have the zoom trinity (14-24-70-200) so have a play at landscapes and see which length you like most then get a prime to suit.
 
You're getting well into the realm of diminishing returns here now. It's highly unlikely anyone would be able to tell a shot taken with your 14-24 from one taken with a 21mm Zeiss in a blind test, no matter how hard they tried if you take the shot carefully.
 
viewfromthenorth said:
^this

As David implied, if you've already got the 14-24 then spending as much again on a lens that probably isn't any better is a bit pointless.

But if you've got the urge to spend some money, don't let us put you off!!
Click to expand...

Yup.

I'd say that if you simply must have a new toy, and there's nothing wrong with that if you have the money, you could go for something different like a prime. Maybe the Sigma 35mm f1.4 Art? At narrow apertures there might be no improvement in real world images but it is by many accounts a nice lens.

I read that Sigma may be bringing out a very nice 24mm Art in the future so maybe wait and see?
 
viewfromthenorth said:
^this

A comparison on ePHOTOzine between the two had the Nikon edging it, subjective though.

http://www.ephotozine.com/article/c...-2-8-lenses-are-put-to-the-test--review-11118

As David implied, if you've already got the 14-24 then spending as much again on a lens that probably isn't any better is a bit pointless.

But if you've got the urge to spend some money, don't let us put you off!!
Click to expand...

Maybe I should just invest in the Lee 150 filter system for the 14/24 and be done with it and save myself 1000 quid:).......its just so so big
 
viewfromthenorth said:
^this

A comparison on ePHOTOzine between the two had the Nikon edging it, subjective though.

http://www.ephotozine.com/article/c...-2-8-lenses-are-put-to-the-test--review-11118

As David implied, if you've already got the 14-24 then spending as much again on a lens that probably isn't any better is a bit pointless.

But if you've got the urge to spend some money, don't let us put you off!!
Click to expand...
Thanks for sharing the review Andy............kind of strange not using a Nikon body for the test but like I said above it might be wise to just invest in a filter system for the 14/24. Got anothe 5 days before I get off the rig so time to ponder on the best options
 
I also thought it odd to use a Canon, but I believe it's not uncommon as there is no equivalent in the canon line up.
I guess if you're after something smaller than the 14-24, then the Zeiss does make a lot of sense if you don't mind the manual focus. Otherwise there's the Nikon 24mm which is a bit longer and also rather expensive.
 
viewfromthenorth said:
I also thought it odd to use a Canon, but I believe it's not uncommon as there is no equivalent in the canon line up.
I guess if you're after something smaller than the 14-24, then the Zeiss does make a lot of sense if you don't mind the manual focus. Otherwise there's the Nikon 24mm which is a bit longer and also rather expensive.
Click to expand...
I have the 24mm already and love that lens but like you say its a wee bitty long for Scottish Highlands coastal shots. Not sure if the Zeiss 21mm will work on my Leica M........need to check that out
 
The Zeiss 15mm f/2.8, Zeiss 21mm or Zeiss 25mm f/2 are the three I'd pick from if you absolutely have to buy a lens. The Zeiss Otus can be used if you stitch it but stopping it down is killing a lot of what makes it special. If I were you get good filters for the 14-24 they can be as important as the lens.
 
ndwgolf said:
What is the very very very BEST lens for landscape to screw onto a Nikon D800e????..........looked at the Zeiss 55mm 1.4 but the focal length is to narrow :(
Click to expand...

Probably a tilt-shift is the ultimate landscape lens, eg 24mm PC Nikkor for depth-of-field control, perspective correction, and distortion-free stitched panoramas. Best on a tripod. Extremely sharp, and knowing your affection for quality gear, I think you'd love playing with one of these ;)

Not used the Nikon, but the Canon 24mm T&S gives something like a 12mm lens field-of-view with stitched panoramas.
 
HoppyUK said:
Probably a tilt-shift is the ultimate landscape lens, eg 24mm PC Nikkor for depth-of-field control, perspective correction, and distortion-free stitched panoramas.
Click to expand...

Good call Richard - another vote for a TS lens.
But beware ...... this may open the 'Quality' door to Large Format image making
 
I've got the Nikon 24 PC-E and the axis needs changed for landscape. You can risk it and do it yourself or send it to a Nikon repair centre and it costs about £70. It's a lens that requires careful use and has a steep learning curve. The Zeiss 21 is my trusty landscape lens although a 14-24 vs 21 Zeiss and you would be hard pressed to tell the difference if both were stopped down.
 
HoppyUK said:
Probably a tilt-shift is the ultimate landscape lens, eg 24mm PC Nikkor for depth-of-field control, perspective correction, and distortion-free stitched panoramas. Best on a tripod. Extremely sharp, and knowing your affection for quality gear, I think you'd love playing with one of these ;)

Not used the Nikon, but the Canon 24mm T&S gives something like a 12mm lens field-of-view with stitched panoramas.
Click to expand...
Just told my dealer to get me one................now comes the youtue and google learning curve
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top