I'm a Photographer ... not a Terrorist – Media Event - New Scotland Yard

I was there. Travelled down from Manchester over night, slept in the car for a few hours and then got the tube into London. Im in Goldenlights's first photo, wearing a cap directly under the 'NSY' sign.

Was a good turnout really and the police were fair with us all and found it quite amusing I think. Posing for photos etc. Ive heard that a lot of officers think the law is pretty stupid as well and singles out journalists trying to work, trying to bring news to the public. Im sure many photographers and videographers will be harassed and threatened under this new law. But as I understand, it is only illegal to take photographs of public servants IF they can prove that you are then going to use them, in one way or another, to help terrorism. How they will prove that a journalist is going to use them with terrorist intent, I dont know.

Is there a photo thread going yet for everyones photos of the day? Ill post mine up later.
 
RE Moz's post, I'm sure half the police officers out there won't even look twice if they see they could be in the frame of someones shot. Even if they do I'm sure they're not going to arrest them.
I think this is one of them laws that will slowly get forgotten over time. Or at least I hope it is.
 
second last paragraph -




I thought the onus was on the prosecution to prove guilt. Rather than the accused to prove innocence. :shrug: What the hell is going on in this once great country?

If indeed that is exactly what the home office said. Could be a BBC interpretation. Not sure that the home office would issue a statement that someone had to prove their innocence.
 
If indeed that is exactly what the home office said. Could be a BBC interpretation. Not sure that the home office would issue a statement that someone had to prove their innocence.

Erm - speeding offences. I know from personal experience you have to try very hard to prove you weren't...
 
If indeed that is exactly what the home office said. Could be a BBC interpretation. Not sure that the home office would issue a statement that someone had to prove their innocence.

Not sure they wouldn't! You've obviously got more faith in the general competence and specific understanding of the law of the Home Office than me!

Regarding the specific section of the 2008 Counter Terrorism Act that became law on Monday, the wording is so vague that, if accussed of violating it, you'd have a pretty hard job defending yourself. Frankly, I'm appalled that it has passed scrutiny to become law and leaves me with very little faith in the competence of our politicians.
 
Frankly, I'm appalled that it has passed scrutiny to become law and leaves me with very little faith in the competence of our politicians.

Its not alone there. In recent years there have been all sorts of rubbish stuff written into our laws.

I'm not advocating any other bunch of cretins when I say that this government has been characterised by creating legislation built from tabloid headlines. I've never seen bunch idiots make such a ham fisted attempt at being popularist before.

C'mon you muppets, we elected you because foolishly we believed you when you said you knew how to run a country!

And you know the worst thing? The morons likely to be elected next time around are just as stupid!

Somebody save us from this insanity!
 
If indeed that is exactly what the home office said. Could be a BBC interpretation. Not sure that the home office would issue a statement that someone had to prove their innocence.

Oh I think they would.

I'm hoping the first time someone gets arrested under this new law there will be a huge amount of media attention on it, and public opposition to the law remaining.
 
Oh I think they would.

Oh really? Sounds like it would be governmental suicide to me! Are they really THAT stupid? Or did a BBC reporter just interpret that way. It was more likely stated that the person being questioned (Note, I haven't used the words hassled or arrested) may have to explain why they are taking said photographs.
 
You could have answered my entire post rather than just cherry picking that one bit. :nono:

Fine then :p

Oh really? Sounds like it would be governmental suicide to me! Are they really THAT stupid? Or did a BBC reporter just interpret that way. It was more likely stated that the person being questioned (Note, I haven't used the words hassled or arrested) may have to explain why they are taking said photographs.

I don't think it would be governmental suicide. Most people are not observant enough to pick out a small detail like that, or see anything wrong with it. Plus, I think you're underestimating what the Government can get away with. It took an illegal war to get Blair out, and now he's the envoy of the Quartet on the Middle East and earns over £7m a year. Hurray for justice.
 
Fine then :p



I don't think it would be governmental suicide. Most people are not observant enough to pick out a small detail like that, or see anything wrong with it. Plus, I think you're underestimating what the Government can get away with. It took an illegal war to get Blair out, and now he's the envoy of the Quartet on the Middle East and earns over £7m a year. Hurray for justice.

What on earth has that got to do with what the govenment/BBC reporter stated in this case, apart from giving you the opportunity for an anti government rants? :shrug:
 
What on earth has that got to do with what the govenment/BBC reporter stated in this case, apart from giving you the opportunity for an anti government rants? :shrug:

I was making a point about the fact that it wouldn't be governmental suicide, as you said. If Blair got away with that, I think the Home Office could issue a statement saying photographers had to prove their innocence with barely anybody noticing, let alone being outraged.

However, it could also have been a misinterpretation or a slanted report by a BBC reporter. I think I share your distrust of the media, even if we disagree on a lot of other issues! ;)
 
I was making a point about the fact that it wouldn't be governmental suicide, as you said. If Blair got away with that, I think the Home Office could issue a statement saying photographers had to prove their innocence with barely anybody noticing, let alone being outraged.

However, it could also have been a misinterpretation or a slanted report by a BBC reporter. I think I share your distrust of the media, even if we disagree on a lot of other issues! ;)

To be fair Ewan, I don't think people are that stupid and I'm pretty sure the government would deliberately make a statement to that effect.
 
I thought the onus was on the prosecution to prove guilt. Rather than the accused to prove innocence. :shrug: What the hell is going on in this once great country?

Have a look at "Offensive Weapons", Same rules apply there. If everyone had the right to carry a weapon then we all could do it and the Police would need to prove why they had it, which would be impossible, hence in that case its guilty until proven innocent.
Same applies for cameras i guess, got to try and canvas everyone and stop it instead of letting everyone off and the few wrong-uns get through the net.

Im generalising, but as long as people are caught doing terrorist activity then i dont care about bein stopped. I very much doubt you will get arrested for taking pics, just asked nicely to stop and if you are a **** about it, then theres a different story.

My advice is "get over it" you are not special and you wont get arrested for taking pics.
just use your common sense and dont think everyone is out to get you. You wont get a 10 for a picture of a Policeman outside Scotland Yard anyway. I think like that, and my life is alot better because of it.

Its not worth getting so upset about, its just a photo, and it will all blow over until the media descend on another crazy (;)) story and hype it up to get Daily Mail readers uncomfortable.
 
Back
Top