Is it possible to get a perfect DoF with a reversed lens?

Messages
1,296
Edit My Images
No
I love taking close up shots, but i've noticed with my lens reversed it's not always possible to get the subject in focus properly, or if I ever want the whole image to be sharp and in focus it seems to blur!

I understand that it's impossible to set up f stops when the lens is reversed simply because the option isn't available but is there another way to get something like this...

Full focus

i4mj2p.jpg


Instead of this

4hv345.jpg
 
A whole 54 minutes and the thread was all the way down to 5th, can see the need for a bump ;)

Affraid I have no idea of the answer but I would speculate that if you can't "set up f stops" you cannot manipulate DoF - but I may be totally misunderstanding what you mean
 
You can adjust the aperture for this. Set the aperture you want to use, hold down the DOF preview button, and whilst holding it down, remove the lens. The aperture will remains stopped down to whatever F stop you had set. I've done it the once, after a suggestion of how to achieve it on here. I'm not sure if there's a risk to the electronics with this or not.
 
You can adjust the aperture for this. Set the aperture you want to use, hold down the DOF preview button, and whilst holding it down, remove the lens. The aperture will remains stopped down to whatever F stop you had set. I've done it the once, after a suggestion of how to achieve it on here. I'm not sure if there's a risk to the electronics with this or not.

OH WOW thanks alot, that was real helpful, I will try this and see what the outcome is.
 
Can someone help a thicky (that's me btw) to understand what exactly is meant by 'reverse lens'? *has visions on incorrectly mounted lens duck taped to body of camera*
 
Its a kit lens reversed using a special ring which one side has a mount for your camera and then the other is the thread same as on the lens. You literally screw the lens on back to front. Linky to adapter
It then enables you to do mega close macro shots.
 
That's basically about it... The lens is attached/held to the body of the camera backwards, so the lens mount is pointed away from the camera and the objective into the camera.
 
Wow. Never heard of those. Interesting stuff.

Thanks (sorry to hijack slightly xSitara)
 
Wow. Never heard of those. Interesting stuff.

Thanks (sorry to hijack slightly xSitara)

Why are you apologising? It's perfectly fine... I personally think it's ok to add questions and interest in threads, what's wrong with that?

:love: I love when people share thoughts and ideas in my threads makes me feel good lol!
 
Couple of things

1: anyone got a spare reversing ring they no longer want as i would like to give this a go
2: How do we do that linky thing :thinking:

xsitara did it work have you any samples please:thumbs:

Dave
 
Couple of things

1: anyone got a spare reversing ring they no longer want as i would like to give this a go
2: How do we do that linky thing :thinking:

xsitara did it work have you any samples please:thumbs:

Dave

I have my flickr and deviantart in my sig, I'll post pictures in this thread shortly also :D
 
I've used CombineZP for focus stacking in the past with great success.
 
Next job is to reverse mount a 50 onto the front of a zoom.
Eliminates those no app ring lens problems too.
 
Interesting thread, what are the downsides to reversing the lens?

There must be some or people would not buy a macro lens.

I may be wrong or just talking rubbish :p
 
working distance, no metering or af, dodgy 50's with no app ring :)
 
Next job is to reverse mount a 50 onto the front of a zoom.
Eliminates those no app ring lens problems too.
I'm confused, care to tell me more :shake:
Interesting thread, what are the downsides to reversing the lens?

There must be some or people would not buy a macro lens.

I may be wrong or just talking rubbish :p
Seriously, I couldn't afford a macro at this point in my life so i decided to try and reverse lens and it worked great :) Obviously you're not in control of aperture though :(
 
Sure, there's a small, but excellent, program called combineZP

Here's a sample of about 10 images all focus stacked that I shot at Christmas


almonds50pcnt.jpg


It's a very easy tool to use (even easier now that it's GUI).
 
xSitara™;1416657 said:
OH WOW thanks so much for posting this LJR! I will look into getting this sorted :)
Np. The tool is small and, best of all, free. Looking forward to see what you do with it.
 
xSitara™;1416644 said:
Seriously, I couldn't afford a macro at this point in my life so i decided to try and reverse lens and it worked great :) Obviously you're not in control of aperture though :(


Im in the same boat, I may have to give this a go.

Does it matter which one I go for, the ones on ebay seem to all be from Asia?
 
super thread, I've learned something new today.

Just been out in the garden holding my lens back to front and got some good results !

Must get me a reversing ring now !
 
xSitara™;1416767 said:
I ordered mine from Asia! You do mean reverse ring right?
Yeah I mean the reverse ring.

Think ill try one out, £6 quid aint too bad.
It liike like all plastic, is yours like that?
 
xSitara,

This is a very nice thread, but I am wondering .. why can you not adjust the aperture? Or are you using a lens without an aperture ring?



jgs001,

You can adjust the aperture for this. Set the aperture you want to use, hold down the DOF preview button, and whilst holding it down, remove the lens. The aperture will remains stopped down to whatever F stop you had set. I've done it the once, after a suggestion of how to achieve it on here. I'm not sure if there's a risk to the electronics with this or not.

Now that's a very simple and excelletn solution :thumbs:



DpM,

Interesting thread, what are the downsides to reversing the lens?

There must be some or people would not buy a macro lens.

I may be wrong or just talking rubbish :p

This question comes up a lot for this and for why use an extension tube?

True, a macro lens is a lot cheaper, simpler to put on and take off, and a lot easier to use .. but it is also a lot more expensive.

Nikon's own reversing ring is less than £40 .. couple that with a nifty fifty (50mm f/1.8 at about £100) and you can get some pretty magnifications.

Just as you would with a nifty fifty attached to extension tubes.

It's just that's not as easy to set-up, use, and get pictures this way as it is with a "straight forward" macro lens.
 
Cheers Wail, it sounds like a good solution to trying macro without inversting massive amounts of money, esp at the mo with the price hikes.
 
xSitara,

This is a very nice thread, but I am wondering .. why can you not adjust the aperture? Or are you using a lens without an aperture ring?
Hi :)

Because the lens isn't 'attached' and is the other way it's not possible to use aperture. I don't know why to be honest, I thought I was doing something wrong but I wasn't lol!
52mm if you mean the front of my kit lens.
Ah ok, search for a 52mm reverse ring :)
 
Interesting read. What I do for a quick macro jog, is put the 35-105mm on the camera, use it at around 100mm, and then take my nifty 50, and put it infront of the on camera lens but reversed (filters touching). The 50 is manually set to infinity, and the on camera lens set to closest focusing distance. I manage to get more than lifesize shots this way, though it's fiddly to use, holding a lens infront of the camera.
 
xSitara™;1417104 said:
Hi :)
Ah ok, search for a 52mm reverse ring :)

Cheers that brings up a few cheaper option and also a UK seller :thumbs:
 
Interesting read. What I do for a quick macro jog, is put the 35-105mm on the camera, use it at around 100mm, and then take my nifty 50, and put it infront of the on camera lens but reversed (filters touching). The 50 is manually set to infinity, and the on camera lens set to closest focusing distance. I manage to get more than lifesize shots this way, though it's fiddly to use, holding a lens infront of the camera.
Oh wow, sounds quite cool actually, at the moment i'm quite happy with the results i'm getting by reversing my lens although i've never got full focus on a photo if you know what I mean.

I just wanted to find out if it's possible to get a full photo in focus and no blur I guess it's possible and if it does work I don't think i'll purchase a macro lens Lol!
Cheers that brings up a few cheaper option and also a UK seller :thumbs:
Awesome, let me know how it goes :)
 
Interesting read. What I do for a quick macro jog, is put the 35-105mm on the camera, use it at around 100mm, and then take my nifty 50, and put it infront of the on camera lens but reversed (filters touching). The 50 is manually set to infinity, and the on camera lens set to closest focusing distance. I manage to get more than lifesize shots this way, though it's fiddly to use, holding a lens infront of the camera.


If you would like a sturdier method of doing this (stacking a reversed lens onto a right-way-round one, get 2 Cokin mounting rings (one for each filter size) and join them together. Insulating tape is easy and sticks well, gaffer tape does the same job (duct tape does it even better). You can even glue or weld them together for a permanent job.

ISTR seeing a Canon accessory that fitted onto the bayonet end of a reversed lens so allowed aperture control without the DoF trick. Maybe a Canonite can help. I've also seen some amazing results from the MPE 65mm Canon lens.
 
If you would like a sturdier method of doing this (stacking a reversed lens onto a right-way-round one, get 2 Cokin mounting rings (one for each filter size) and join them together. Insulating tape is easy and sticks well, gaffer tape does the same job (duct tape does it even better). You can even glue or weld them together for a permanent job.

Hmmm, interesting...

(goes to fiddle with his cokin filter set)
 
Back
Top