Is there such a thing as a universally acclaimed photography book?

Messages
2,170
Edit My Images
Yes
Reading the various postings here

http://www.talkphotography.co.uk/forums/showthread.php?t=111561

concerning the merits of a particular book (I think it was referred to as the "reward to outlay" ratio), I'm bound to ask whether such a thing exists as a photography book which would receive universal acclaim?

And to make it simple let's put this into a number of categories:

  1. Absolute beginner
  2. No longer an absolute beginner
  3. Camera specific
  4. Technique specific
  5. Not necessarily hot off the presses but widely regarded as "a jolly good read"
 
No. There isn't such a thing as a universally acclaimed anything.

Next ........
 
As Stewart says, there is no "Universally acclaimed" source of material.

Now I can help with some of my favourites. But then the reason they are my favourites is because they filled particular gaps in my knowledge at the time. So their use to anyone else will be specific to their requirements.

1. Absolute beginner. The Internet. Don't waste money on a book when it's all right here. Read your camera manual. The bit's you don't understand, look it up.

2. No longer an absolute beginner. Depends what you want to know. Landscape? Portrait, Street, Studio...............

3.Camera specific. Field guides, without a doubt the 5D one is superb.

4.Technique specific. Mark Cleghorn's Wedding Photography. A Manual for anyone who ever wants to shoot a wedding. Please stop posting "how do I shoot a wedding?" threads on here and go and buy this book. :)

5. Not necessarily hot off the presses but widely regarded as "a jolly good read" Joe McNally's The Moment it Clicks because he's a really good bloke, takes brilliant pics and is so generous with his teaching. If anyone deserves the fee for the book, he does.
 
A there is no "Universally acclaimed" source of material.

Well there used to be - the 'Ilford Manual of Photography' was regarded as the bible when I was at college - a while ago mind you - but a lot of what it contains is still relevant - apart from all the stuff on film and b/w processing. Doubt you'll find one easily - might be interesting if you did. I think mine is still on the shelf somewhere.
 
I think you might find that to be pre internet :D

These days there is so much good stuff (and some utter dross) on places like youtube that I don't think you CAN say that there is a single universally acclaimed source any more.
 
I'd say Light Science & Magic has to be pretty well up there. It gives you the Why of lighting. Get to grips with that and you can work out the How in any number of situations. Perhaps a bit dry in places, but well worth sticking with.

Probably ticks boxes 2, 4 (if Lighting can be called a technique), and 5 as a "jolly worthwhile read".
 
Well there used to be - the 'Ilford Manual of Photography' was regarded as the bible when I was at college - a while ago mind you - but a lot of what it contains is still relevant - apart from all the stuff on film and b/w processing. Doubt you'll find one easily -

Looks like there's a few on Amazon - just a case of deciding which year/edition :)
 
I don't think there is one universal book ,and book choice is such a subjective thing in that different people like different styles of writing some things are bound to be left out what some think should be in.Even the manual with camera is not perfect or there would not be more in depth ones produced.

I put the post about Understanding Exposure up to get some feed back about the book and like all things some like it some don't having bought it I find it OK no doubt there is more in depth and more technical books out there.

Having just moved from 35mm slr to an early PhD (push here dummy)digital camera to a DSLR I now have four books.The order in which I tend to read them i.e.the ones i read the most are.

1 The Camera Guide that came with my Nikon D80
2 The Digital SLR Handbook by Michael Freeman
Joint second Understanding Exposure
3 The Digital Photography Handbook by Doug Harman and David Jones


At the moment these books I find give me the information I want to hand. They work for me but not for others.
Then there is the Internet which is a very good source of information but call me old fashioned it still good to have a book to refer to or just to sit down and read.
 
I've got shelves and shelves of photography books, more biased to image content than "how to". Some are works of art in themselves, like the "Ansel Adams at 100" volume but the one that gets read the most and makes me want to pick up a camera and go out again after a days shoot is "The Making of Landscape Photographs" by Charlie Waite.
 
I've got shelves and shelves of photography books, more biased to image content than "how to".

Yayy! It's not just me then :D

I have my own photography section on our bookshelves at home. Well actually it's kind of taking over it's own bookcase and some of the books don't fit on the bookshelves.

I do have a few "How to's" mainly photoshop with Scott Kelby being a regular reference material and a few on various lighting and studio techniques that have proved to be very useful. I can now reverse engineer a lot of photos and work out lighting for myself. Infinitely useful :)

My latest purchases have been the Vanity Fair Portraits book and a lovely Christmas present of Bob Carlos Clarke autobiography.

I can't get enough of quality images :)

My name is Ali and I'm a photo addict.................:naughty:
 
Photojournalism, The Professionals' Approach - Kenneth Kobre
 
Back
Top