It's the photographer, not the kit...or is it?

Raymond Lin

I am Groot
Messages
10,564
Name
Raymond
Edit My Images
No
The old saying goes that you don't compliment a chef that he has nice pans for his fine cooking like you don't compliment a photographer that he has a nice camera.

However........after looking at the lens archive for the 135L on PoTN. That lens make ordinary shots look like it can be found in a magazine. So, i started to think.....on one hand, good/usually more expensive (less than 2.8) lenses provides me with the ability to take shots that otherwise i wouldn't been able to compare to a slower lens. I mean I can still have the same shot in my mind, regardless of the gear i am holding in my hand, but the more expensive/better gear let me get those shots and turn them into reality.

So...how much is it down to the gear? How much is the photographer?

I guess its a bit like Formula 1 eh?
 
same as faith and works
love and marriage
horse and carriage
chicken and egg?

good equipment removes the 'idea' that one needs a good camera
results tell whether the user really 'needs' the equipment if they cant produce the goods the camera can
one must learn basics but not be frustrated in accessing them
 
having a p&s, I find I get frustrated when my pics aren't crisp - that REALLY is an issue for me, as out of 500 shots, not one really in perfect focus?

(and it's a really good p&s - Nikon P5100)

so, my answer would be ( and I like to think this! ) that it MAY be the camera..... on the other hand, I do have a liking for red wine!:lol::lol::lol::lol:
 
Good equipment allows a good photographer to show what he is capable of.

good equipment shows up the flaws in a bad photographer.
 
having a p&s, I find I get frustrated when my pics aren't crisp - that REALLY is an issue for me, as out of 500 shots, not one really in perfect focus?

i think you may be seeing a difference in apparent focus...focus is focus etc
your lens will give sharp results
put your p+s on a tripod and check it out
this really sounds like you are blaming the equipment...how can they sell them if the shots are not sharp...
big slr shots look sharper... because at larger magnifications...they apparently are!!
 
I find the only thing that changes as I spend money on more and better gear is
my photo's can be enlarged bigger, some of my best shot have been taken on cheap equipment.
 
An old chestnut:

Some people take terrible photographs because they don't know what they are doing. They might have an entry level DSLR with a kit lens or if they may have a Pro DSLR with pro quality glass. Often we asume people are 'better' photographers because of what they have in their kit bag. Whilst most good pro photographers will have pro kit it's amazing how many shocking photographers have the kit simply because they want it and can afford it.

On the flip side you have people who really know what they're doing - they understand exposure, composition, depth of field etc etc and are able to produce great images with whichever equipment they have. For these people I would say equipment can make a huge difference as some equipment simply doesn't allow you to produce certain images.
 
david bailey
olympus trip...

was that true
 
:lol: I make no mistake - I am definitely in the 'learner' category :)

That doesn't get away from the disappointment I have when I am pleased with the composition of the shot, but the focus is not there - and I'm sure I'm not the only one that feels (with a p&s) that it cannot be the user ALL the time :shrug:

Admittedly, there is always 'human element' when something you see looks perfect and the excitement makes you punch the button - which I most certainly do :bonk: but when you're careful, try many different exposures & settings, and STILL don't get something crisp, you find you start to question why - even with a tripod :|
 
:lol: I make no mistake - I am definitely in the 'learner' category :)

That doesn't get away from the disappointment I have when I am pleased with the composition of the shot, but the focus is not there - and I'm sure I'm not the only one that feels (with a p&s) that it cannot be the user ALL the time :shrug:

Admittedly, there is always 'human element' when something you see looks perfect and the excitement makes you punch the button - which I most certainly do :bonk: but when you're careful, try many different exposures & settings, and STILL don't get something crisp, you find you start to question why - even with a tripod :|

do you use spot focussing (the little [ ] in the viewfinder)...it was invented for the point and shoot
i use it all the time...hell if i didnt i would be moaning as well:)
 
You are right Raymond! You need the ability to see the shot in the first place but if the equipment does not allow you to take it then that is the weak link. If you have all the kit in the world and still can't take anything better than a mobile phone pic then you can guess where the weak link is!

There are things you can do with better equipment that CAN make a big difference. I got my hands on the Canon 70-200mm f2.8IS recently and have been testing it before using it in anger at a wedding. I'm used to shooting on 70-200s having had the Canon f4 (sharp as a tack) and the Sigma 70-200 f2.8 which has served me exceptionally well and I have no complaints at all about the work I have done with it.

I usually try to keep the Sigma at about 1/60 due to subject movement and I read a review on the Canon 2.8 that said that at 1/15 you can have a keeper rate of 60%! So I've been testing it and unbelievably I CAN shoot down to 1/15 sec albeit I don't want the dogs jumping about. If they are still I can shoot to that level and they blow up a treat.

So yes, there are times where the kit brings home the bacon. The 85mm f1.8 is another that I personally rate in the category of being something a bit special :)
 
yes - and I've set the metering to be in this bit, have the camera on 'A' priority, and normally take several changing the light/dark and the F number.

and many many positive thoughts! :thumbs: :lol:
 
I recently bought a 300D from someone on here, and a Tamron 50-200 for about £60 from someone else as a cheap very light kit for someone to use if they came out with me as the 1D series and f/2.8 lenses are too heavy (and valuable) for me to hand around to friends for fun use!!

I took it out so I knew where the basic controls were and I admit I am hardly the worlds greatest photographer, but on a reasonably lit day the results were fine. If the pictures were needed at big sizes then the quality difference would probably have been seen but even with me using it, for everyday pictures for website or smaller (A4 or less) prints no doubt bigger if someone good used it, its a very nice cheap purchase.

Yes someone better than me would most likely get better shots with it than I can get with the 1D series ones simply because they are better than me, but I certainly know that Harvey_nikon is right when he says good equipment shows up the flaws in a bad photographer :( and having the flaws shown up so obviously is a very good way to learn :lol:
 
You are right Raymond! You need the ability to see the shot in the first place but if the equipment does not allow you to take it then that is the weak link. If you have all the kit in the world and still can't take anything better than a mobile phone pic then you can guess where the weak link is!

There are things you can do with better equipment that CAN make a big difference. I got my hands on the Canon 70-200mm f2.8IS recently and have been testing it before using it in anger at a wedding. I'm used to shooting on 70-200s having had the Canon f4 (sharp as a tack) and the Sigma 70-200 f2.8 which has served me exceptionally well and I have no complaints at all about the work I have done with it.

I usually try to keep the Sigma at about 1/60 due to subject movement and I read a review on the Canon 2.8 that said that at 1/15 you can have a keeper rate of 60%! So I've been testing it and unbelievably I CAN shoot down to 1/15 sec albeit I don't want the dogs jumping about. If they are still I can shoot to that level and they blow up a treat.

So yes, there are times where the kit brings home the bacon. The 85mm f1.8 is another that I personally rate in the category of being something a bit special :)

Exactly !

Take for example, a shot of a coffee cup.

Take one shot at F/5.6 on a kit lens and another at F/1.2 from a 50L, same focal length, and the 50L will come out with a more "pleasing" image. I guess i am saying that, in a way, money can buy you a better image?
 
:lol: I make no mistake - I am definitely in the 'learner' category :)

That doesn't get away from the disappointment I have when I am pleased with the composition of the shot, but the focus is not there - and I'm sure I'm not the only one that feels (with a p&s) that it cannot be the user ALL the time :shrug:

Admittedly, there is always 'human element' when something you see looks perfect and the excitement makes you punch the button - which I most certainly do :bonk: but when you're careful, try many different exposures & settings, and STILL don't get something crisp, you find you start to question why - even with a tripod :|

HopefulM
..there may be some confusion on my part as to what you are trying to have in focus...in the middle of the viewfinding part is a [ ]...that is where the sensor will focus...if this isnt over the part you want in focus...then it wont be
not all of your photo can be in focus...even with small apertures...it may seem in focus but there is only one discrete area which is in focus focus...that is where the [ ] is.. apart from manual focussing which is a bore when one has poor eyesight!!
i use the little [ ] to get the area i want to be sharp in focus by softly pressing down on the shutter till the motors get the lens in focus
re compose my shot to what i want...the focussed point wont always be in the middle
the press the shutter down to make the exposure

does that seem what you are doing...

i have mickey's original digital at 4Mega mouses....and i am happy with my sharpness...most times...
 
I think if you get out with like minded people you raise you game too, more so than spending loads of cash. The gear helps but isn't the answer. Better glass is great if you can afford it but I am of the stable - try to get the best you can out of the gear you have and nothing is more pleasing than getting a killer shot from amateur equipment. I like to think I have produced some cracking stuff from cheap gear in the past and will hope to continue to do so in the future.
 
yep, that's exactly what I'm doing :thumbs: the 'half' pressing of the button till the [ ] goes blue to say it's in focus (and for that matter, comes into focus on the screen or the green light above the eye piece comes on), then fully depressing the button (and holding still ;) ) till I hear the click finish :D

when using a tripod, I even manage to 'roll' my finger over the button :thumbs:

here's what I mean - using a tripod and rolling my button finger..... ;)

still not quite in focus :shrug: I know the probability is likely user error, but I canno believe that no section of these pics is really is crisp clear focus :thinking:

here you go, do your worst :thumbs::lol:;)

animoslilly0801JPG.jpg



animoslilly080.jpg



animoslilly081.jpg
 
yep, that's exactly what I'm doing :thumbs: the 'half' pressing of the button till the [ ] goes blue to say it's in focus (and for that matter, comes into focus on the screen or the green light above the eye piece comes on), then fully depressing the button (and holding still ;) ) till I hear the click finish :D

when using a tripod, I even manage to 'roll' my finger over the button :thumbs:

here's what I mean - using a tripod and rolling my button finger..... ;)

still not quite in focus :shrug: I know the probability is likely user error, but I canno believe that no section of these pics is really is crisp clear focus :thinking:

here you go, do your worst :thumbs::lol:;)

animoslilly0801JPG.jpg



animoslilly080.jpg



animoslilly081.jpg



tell me does mine seem ok...could be the screen on your pc/laptop
i cant get mine 100% big gun focus but i just look at the prints at the end of the day and they are ok

are you resharpening..or sharpening after resizing

i do think your shots are pretty sharp...do you wear glasses...no joke..i do and use close reading ones to check my pics
 
Exactly !

Take for example, a shot of a coffee cup.

Take one shot at F/5.6 on a kit lens and another at F/1.2 from a 50L, same focal length, and the 50L will come out with a more "pleasing" image. I guess i am saying that, in a way, money can buy you a better image?

Imagine an out of focus and poorly lit dirty cup of coffee taken at f1.2 and and simple and clean, well illuminated cup taken with the kit lens (and the resolution is not that important for the cup!). Now if you do the latter one with f/1.2 then the real difference will show up.
Another example would be shooting football at night with 400D and Sigma 70-300 f/5.6 - it is hopeless. Give 300/2.8 and the pro will deliver, the beginner will miss the 'moment'

So I guess both the kit and the person behind are important.
 
Imagine an out of focus and poorly lit dirty cup of coffee taken at f1.2 and and simple and clean, well illuminated cup taken with the kit lens (and the resolution is not that important for the cup!). Now if you do the latter one with f/1.2 then the real difference will show up.

Now you are adding variables and totally missed my point when you start saying one will be taken "out of focus" (of course it'll look crap out of focus!!!)....All things being equal...the L will give a more pleasing result....that was the point i am getting at.
 
just a quicky...do you use the menu to set macro etc...
if you dont reset it for not macro...then the lens elements are in the wrong place

your shots could be low on Mp what setting have you set for your pics..use the highest
if hand held you could be witnessing camera shake at that distance



this is probably the sharpest i can get using macro and a tripod with f8 as aperture...
its taken on highest setting but being resized...and then resharpened as a jpeg might not be anywhere as good as the big guns
dont go comparing just do the best you can
 
So I guess both the kit and the person behind are important.

Absolutely agree. I guess part of the question though is a bit chicken and egg!

Which comes first, does a good photographer emerge cocoon like reaching for a fast prime or does the fast prime (by sheer luck of course) land in your lap and you go off to learn how to get the best out of it?

I personally think it's a little bit of both and there is a lot of leapfrogging that goes on. You get your hands on something half decent and your technique improves to the stage that you want something even better. Kit/improvement/kit = empty bank account. :gag:
 
Absolutely agree. I guess part of the question though is a bit chicken and egg!

Which comes first, does a good photographer emerge cocoon like reaching for a fast prime or does the fast prime (by sheer luck of course) land in your lap and you go off to learn how to get the best out of it?

I personally think it's a little bit of both and there is a lot of leapfrogging that goes on. You get your hands on something half decent and your technique improves to the stage that you want something even better. Kit/improvement/kit = empty bank account. :gag:

how many of the greats would testify what got them into photography

"my dads old etc etc"
 
How about this thread...

http://www.talkphotography.co.uk/forums/showthread.php?t=160036

And I'll quote myself from that because because I think I managed to sum up my feelings on this subject quite nicely back then:

no matter what skill you have you can't make your lens aperture wider, your focal length longer, your glass have lower dispersion, your frame rate increase, force the AF to lock on accurately and faster or use an old jedi mind trick to reduce shutter lag...

All of those things will hinder you in action photograhy...

If *none* of those things (or any other technical performance aspect) are important in whatever area of photography you choose to practice in, then yes, the photographer and not the machinery is what will yield results.

:D
 
You can see on this site alone how much crap there is taken by people who've invested heavily in kit - all the gear and no idea.

You can also see some good photographers who have limited kit and their shots sing regardless.

Then you have the people who have bad kit and can't take a good photo either.

Then you have the guys with great kit and a great eye for a great photo.

I'd like to put myself in the latter but I think I'm in the second grouping :D
 
Equipment is the technical side of the beast. It governs the objective side of the equation. Things either are or arent sharp, the depth of field is or isnt shallow, the resolution will only allow you to print so big etc.

The photographer is the subjective side. It governs the artistic interpretation of the scene in front it. Chooses which aperture to use etc.

Neither of these are finite and there is a small amount of interplay between them that is the Photographers technical ability, or mastery of their equipment.

Going back Mr Lin's original statement that X lens makes ordinary photos look like ones from a magazine. Yes it does on a technical level, but on an artistic level it will only allow ordinary shots to echo that technical aspect that caused the emotional response in yourself in the first place.

Professional photographers that shoot for magazines say, use similar kit. Thus, the optical performance of that lens (colour, contrast, depth of field, bokeh, detail rendering) will become common place in the media and people will start to make an association that the look that the lens produces equates with good quality photography.
 
A typical example of when it's the kit that counts.

Whilst I tend to concentrate on landscape photography, where we stay up at Loch Sunart allows me to photograph birds, seals, otters etc from the shore. My 300mm lens is fairly cheap and cheerful and if I'm shooting at the full 300mm I don't have the luxury of a massive aperture. As a result I have to slow down the shutter speed which will often result in motion blur or increase the ISO which results in noise.

An expensive 'fast' long lens would allow me to 'get' that shot without needing more skill on my part.

A more expensive body would produce less noise at higher ISO - again without any more skill on my part.
 
I disagree, for the past year I have stopped shooting landscapes with digital but instead used medium format. This was a steep learning curve but because I had to take each shot slowly and think about it my images have massively improved (imho)

Yesterday I used my Dads wide angle on my 40D where I would normally use my Mamiya or my telephoto. I was surprised to how well they turned out, even though they were soft at 100% (old cheap lens) the exposure was spot on and I have 10 images that I am really happy with (see flickr if interested) If I had been at the same place 2 years ago I doubt the images I got would be as good.

Before going film, I bought a 17-40 what many consider to be a pro landscape lens but my images where still cr*p. Buying expensive lens's doesn't work (for me)
 
Now you are adding variables and totally missed my point when you start saying one will be taken "out of focus" (of course it'll look crap out of focus!!!)....All things being equal...the L will give a more pleasing result....that was the point i am getting at.

Well of course! But all things being equal means the photographer being the same as well and leaves us nothing whatsoever to discuss :cuckoo:
 
Absolutely agree. I guess part of the question though is a bit chicken and egg!

Which comes first, does a good photographer emerge cocoon like reaching for a fast prime or does the fast prime (by sheer luck of course) land in your lap and you go off to learn how to get the best out of it?

I personally think it's a little bit of both and there is a lot of leapfrogging that goes on. You get your hands on something half decent and your technique improves to the stage that you want something even better. Kit/improvement/kit = empty bank account. :gag:


The best advice I ever had:
Improve your ability to exceed the level of your current kit. Then buy more kit to exceed your ability. Repeat.
 
I've really enjoyed reading through this thread and having contributed still find myself 'split' when it comes to the original question ..... It's the photographer, not the kit...or is it?

Whilst I adhere to the view that it's the person behind the lens that ultimately determines the quality of the shot I do feel that given a particular task I'm sure (and I'm talking about me) I could return with far better images if I was given a body and lens to the value of £5000 than a body and lens costing £500.

.
 
its both, you can have top spec equipment but you need to know what your doing to get the results, otherwise you just have a £10K Point & Shoot :nono:
 
I've really enjoyed reading this too :), as imho (and I'm just a beginner) you can have the most technically perfect shot, but without the artistic input of the photographer that pic might be the dullest in the world.

I definitley think it's the eye and ability of the tog that makes the shot.:thumbs:
 
The best advice I ever had:
Improve your ability to exceed the level of your current kit. Then buy more kit to exceed your ability. Repeat.

Wise words ;)
 
If you are a good photographer you can identify why you are not getting the shots you want and where the gear is failing you.
If you are a bad photographer the gear is always failing you.

... If you are a gear head, you always have to get more gear, regardless...:D
 
The best advice I ever had:
Improve your ability to exceed the level of your current kit. Then buy more kit to exceed your ability. Repeat.

that is how I look at things now. i've reached the limits of what I feel are importantto my shooting style with my 400d and see that as a good thing. also, my 50mm f/1.8 has also helped mesee bad shots and learn to correct them.

great thread this! i'm on the fence with the question though as I can see everyone's point of view.
 
Back
Top