Jeremy Clarkson on having his picture taken (again!)

Sorry I still dont think it's acceptable. There is no reason not to help a fellow human being if you are in a position to do so. If it means sacrificing a photograph that defines a moment then so be it. Nothing is worth more than preventing sufferring.

The GOOD/GREAT press photographers and photojournalists will be able to get a shot (any shot) in the first instance, even if it's a bit blurred or not quite composed right. I think you're assuming that we're all going to get our lights, reflectors and a tripod?! :thinking:

You get a shot, then you help, then when you can, you get more shots. 7th July was an interesting one...there were so many police and security personnel running around that the photographers couldn't help even if they wanted to. You were pegged back behind the inner cordon.

Likewise, the G20 protests last year. The security and police prescence was such that you were heavily restricted with where you were "allowed" to be. You try and help, you'd have been smacked with a flick-stick too.

Now, that's different from Farage/UKIP. As we've shown here...it was clear he was OK, the photographer got a shot, helped him, and then got more shots when more qualified help arrived.

All of which probably happened inside 10-20 seconds.

We press togs can generally get a shot pretty quick. Then you do what you can.

Nick Ut is a prime example.
 
Didn't we cover all this with the thread about the motorbike crashing into a Land Rover about a month or so ago?

In the event of an 'incident' - RTA, train-crash, plane-crash, football stadium riot etc.
A photographer's job is to record the event. End of.

If you are the only person arriving at a scene and it is safe to do so, see if you can render assistance. Once other help arrives, record the event.

If there are others already at the scene, record the event; unless you have specialist medical or technical qualifications which make you better-suited to rendering assistance than those already doing so, in which case, render such assistance as is required or appropriate, then record the event.

If the emergency service are already in full attendance, record the event.

In all cases, no matter what level of assistance you choose to give, it is the photographer's responsibility to record the event.

If you think otherwise, you are not a photographer: you are just someone who owns a camera.
 
Why?

Were they all medically trained and able to understand/know what to do with someone who's in the wreckage of a car?

They were getting in the way of the medics.
 
They were getting in the way of the medics.

Ah, okay.

I have to say it's not something I've read particularly much about. I'd defend their right to take pictures (and everyone else to be appalled by their complete flucknuttery) but hadn't realised they obstructed medical help.

Oh, and Arkady's post is spot on.

And jamesb84 has brought back 7/7 to my mind again. It is a lasting regret of mine that I didn't have a camera with me that day. It would really have helped me to have some personal shots to put what happened into context.
 
Last year in my town there was a local factory fire, and of course I went down there with my camera. This factory was right in the middle of some houses, and whilst I was compeled to take some pictures of the fire taking place, I was also aware that next door were peoples homes. So, putting camera away, I helped the residents to evacuate their homes, and instead of taking pictures, I helped 3 huge labrador dogs to safety, still got some pictures of the fire, and got my pictures in the local newspaper!
I was the only " onlooker" to offer any assistance!
 
this is what I wanted to say but couldn't be arsed typing it on my iPhone.

Didn't we cover all this with the thread about the motorbike crashing into a Land Rover about a month or so ago?

In the event of an 'incident' - RTA, train-crash, plane-crash, football stadium riot etc.
A photographer's job is to record the event. End of.

If you are the only person arriving at a scene and it is safe to do so, see if you can render assistance. Once other help arrives, record the event.

If there are others already at the scene, record the event; unless you have specialist medical or technical qualifications which make you better-suited to rendering assistance than those already doing so, in which case, render such assistance as is required or appropriate, then record the event.

If the emergency service are already in full attendance, record the event.

In all cases, no matter what level of assistance you choose to give, it is the photographer's responsibility to record the event.

If you think otherwise, you are not a photographer: you are just someone who owns a camera.
 
"If you think otherwise, you are not a photographer: you are just someone who owns a camera."

Can you modify that please - perhaps it needs to read 'you are not a PRESS photographer'. As it is your statement is extremely insulting and rather narrow minded. Perhaps 'get the pic and then help' is a press photographers job in which case I would rather not have that job thanks. But to say anyone who doesn't think that way is not a photographer is somewhat illogical.
 
My 2p... My instinct would be to snap 1 shot to document the scene on auto in RAW so I take as little time as possible to get the shot. Then do everything I can to help. I am better at taking a good photograph that may well be useful eventually, than first aid. I would never just take shots without making sure I've done everything I can to help first
 
"If you think otherwise, you are not a photographer: you are just someone who owns a camera."

Can you modify that please - perhaps it needs to read 'you are not a PRESS photographer'. As it is your statement is extremely insulting and rather narrow minded. Perhaps 'get the pic and then help' is a press photographers job in which case I would rather not have that job thanks. But to say anyone who doesn't think that way is not a photographer is somewhat illogical.

No...

It's not illogical nor incorrect, nor is it narrow-minded.
Real photographers - of any subject - should instictively turn to their cameras first.
Your first concern should be recording the event for posterity, no matter what it is or how trivial it may seem at the time.

My comment stands - if you don't like it...well that's just too bad.
While you're nursing your delicate sensibilities, the rest of us are getting the images that matter.
 
I accept you have your point of view and we will just have to agree to differ. Since I am paid for taking quality photographs for clients I will need to think of another title for myself as I don't meet your specifications for what a professional photographer should be.

I appreciate you feel the need to get a shot no matter what - I just hope for the sake of your concience that nobody dies while you take it so there is nobody to help after you've snapped
 
I'm completely in agreement with Andy on this. I once had occasion to Photograph Princess Dianna:

Dianna3.jpg


When she left the venue, I followed her onto the street and was appalled at what I saw. What can only be described as a scrum of press photographers who, fortunately, hadn't been let into the venue. I actually witnessed two of them coming to blows. Another was kicking the one in front to try to get him out of the way. I was disgusted at their behaviour.
 
Thankyou Coaster - I'm glad it's not just me.
 
So we're comparing paps to documentary photographers now? By this idiotic logic we might as well all be labelled blood thirsty paps simply because we carry a camera.
 
So we're comparing paps to documentary photographers now? By this idiotic logic we might as well all be labelled blood thirsty paps simply because we carry a camera.

Shouldn't that read:

By this idiotic logic we might as well all be labelled blood thirsty, paedophile, terrorist paps simply because we carry a camera....
;)
 
Back
Top