Landscapes: The Pro's and Con's of the 4 seasons.

EdinburghGary

Reply not Report
Messages
19,271
Name
Gary
Edit My Images
Yes
Guys,

One season at a time, what do you consider to be the benefits, and drawbacks of shooting landscapes under conditions of said season?

I have had one member question the logic of a highlands trip at the summer solstice, due to the problems of getting good light at that time of year, and I would love to hear your take on this subject. Is Winter best? Why? Do you prefer the Summer? How come? Are you all about those lovely autumnal colours?

Really keen to hear your thoughts. A year ago, I did not appreciate light in the slightest. Now, my first summer with "open eyes" is only a few months away, and I am wanting to plan and prepare myself for hopefully many wonderful landscape opportunities.

Gary.
 
i don't think you'll get a right answer as noone can predict the weather at any time of the year - particularly in the highlands!

look at images and decide what ones YOU like and then arrange your trip for that time of year.

Summer and Autumn months are likely to be more useful as more good days than bad. Spring and winter months are less predictable.

When shooting landscapes you really only have a few short hours each day.... as the sun rises and as the sun sets.

yes you can get nice light at other times but sunset/sunrise are the "Golden" hours for landscapers.
 
Summer Pros, better availability with seasonal places, weather is less of a problem, time in the day to scope places out.
cons - big gap between the good light in the morning and the good light in the evening, lots of waiting around once you have found your location.

Autum - pros, nice colours about, not so much waiting about
cons, higher probability of dull days, rain and a busy time of year for lots of people

winter - pros, not having to get up early for sunrise, sunset is ealier, chance of snow and ice
cons- cold, getting time of work, not much light about

spring- pros, reasonable weather, baby animals, new plants etc, sunrise / sunset not too far apart, most places are open
cons, high chance of rain

spring is my fave time of year :)
 
I wouldn't agree that summer is more useful. Its less. Stupidly long days. Up at 3am for sunrise golden hour and then its a very long wait till 9pm for the next golden hour at sunset. In between you're going to have the sun at the highest and worst position it'll be during the entire year producing more hours of harsh light.
 
i don't think you'll get a right answer as noone can predict the weather at any time of the year - particularly in the highlands!

look at images and decide what ones YIOU like and then arrange your trip for that time of year.

Summer and Autumn months are likely to be more useful as more good days than bad. Spring and winter months are less predictable.

When shooting landscapes you really only have a few short hours each day.... as the sun rises and as the sun sets.

yes you can get nice light at other times but sunset/sunrise are the "Golden" hours for landscapers.


Oh sorry I got the basics, I guess my question should have been wordered slightly differently. I am trying to figure out how the seasons differ in terms of the golden hour. How long might we get (typically), can we should during the day (typically) etc etc.

Just in general, which seasons are more fruitful , presuming good conditions...

Gary.
 
The summer solstice is ideal for shooting in the North of Scotland - if you are willing to do an all nighter. With sunset at 21:30 and twighlight stretching to 23:00, you only have to wait a few hours until the morning twighlight is with you again at about 02:00. In fact it only gets really dark for an hour or so.

Tuesday
23 June 2009 Universal Time

SUN
Begin civil twilight 01:49
Sunrise 03:11
Sun transit 12:22
Sunset 21:33
End civil twilight 22:55
 
The summer solstice is ideal for shooting in the North of Scotland - if you are willing to do an all nighter. With sunset at 21:30 and twighlight stretching to 23:00, you only have to wait a few hours until the morning twighlight is with you again at about 02:00. In fact it only gets really dark for an hour or so.

that is a very good point - and star trails in between ;)
 
The summer solstice is ideal for shooting in the North of Scotland - if you are willing to do an all nighter. With sunset at 21:30 and twighlight stretching to 23:00, you only have to wait a few hours until the morning twighlight is with you again at about 02:00. In fact it only gets really dark for an hour or so.


I must admit to really looking forward to Highlands Tour V2. However, I hope people appreciate the potential difficulties of daytime shooting....it could be a holiday of all nighters, and long days lazing on the beach with lots of booze. How can I sell this idea?

Gary.
 
Summer Pros, better availability with seasonal places, weather is less of a problem, time in the day to scope places out.
cons - big gap between the good light in the morning and the good light in the evening, lots of waiting around once you have found your location.

Autum - pros, nice colours about, not so much waiting about
cons, higher probability of dull days, rain and a busy time of year for lots of people

winter - pros, not having to get up early for sunrise, sunset is ealier, chance of snow and ice
cons- cold, getting time of work, not much light about

spring- pros, reasonable weather, baby animals, new plants etc, sunrise / sunset not too far apart, most places are open
cons, high chance of rain

spring is my fave time of year :)


A good summary, toothie.:clap:

A couple of additonal points, though.

1) Don't restrict yourself to the golden hour.

In my experience, three hours before sunset and three hours after sunrise can still be good. The middle hours of the day are often useless, however, and that is usually 10am - 4pm in mid-summer, or perhaps longer.

2) How do you define autumn?

Again in my experience - which is in Wales largely - autumn starts in early/mid -august. By then the monotonous allover green-ness of mid-summer has largely gone, heather is in flower, early morning valley fog starts to form on suitable days, etc. Best time of year, if you ask me!
 
I must admit to really looking forward to Highlands Tour V2. However, I hope people appreciate the potential difficulties of daytime shooting....it could be a holiday of all nighters, and long days lazing on the beach with lots of booze. How can I sell this idea?

Gary.

Sold
 
In my experience, three hours before sunset and three hours after sunrise can still be good. The middle hours of the day are often useless, however, and that is usually 10am - 4pm in mid-summer, or perhaps longer.

Which makes summer the perfect time for people like me who work regular hours. In summer I can get up stoopidly early, and stay out really late. Love it! Can't wait for the summer!
 
Sold, sold,sold,sold sold.........

But it was anyway :)
 
Winter Pro's
- sunrise at sociable hours
- usually a bit of colour in clouds for longer periods
- low sunlight all day
- chances of dramatic weather conditions
- more chance of snow on the peaks / rivers & streams usually in full flow
- chance to shoot situations where you see lots of frost & ice
- no midges

Winter Cons
- poor/unpredictable weather
- low sunlight all day :) (can sometimes just be too harsh + long shadows cast if you're in a hilly region)
- early sunsets, so if you work 9-5 Mon-Fri you're limited to shooting at the weekends only
- skint at this time of year

=============================

Spring Pro's
- sunrise still at good time, then the clocks go forward which makes the sunrise a bit more bearable
- still a good chance of snowy peaks and rivers/streams being in full flow
- off-peak rates at most B&Bs until end of March
- chances of dramatic weather conditions
- ground vegetation up north is still that lovely golden colour
- no midges

Spring Cons
- can't think of any! I usually get out with the camera most from Feb-Apr

=============================

Summer Pro's
- a short wait between sunset and sunrise the following morning, easy to do an 'all nighter'
- warmer temperatures at sunrise and sunset
- flowers in bloom
- best time for using IR filter :)

Summer Cons
- midge attacks
- rivers/streams can be dried up
- mountains not as inspiring without the snow on the peaks
- harsh light during daylight after the golden hour
- july & august is usually monsoon season in uk :) (except for the annual 1 week heatwave...)

=============================

Autumn Pro's
- trees / foliage beginning to turn
- sunrise / sunset times become more sociable
- midges beginning to die out

Autumn Cons
- can't think of any :D
 
I must admit to really looking forward to Highlands Tour V2. However, I hope people appreciate the potential difficulties of daytime shooting....it could be a holiday of all nighters, and long days lazing on the beach with lots of booze. How can I sell this idea?

Gary.


That's exactly it Gary.

Summer is great if the weather is nice. It means you can toodle about the highlands during the day and choose your location carefully. More time to get between locations and you don't have to do all the driving at night.

Actual quality of light at sunrise and sunset is different too. Cleaner and sharper and less chance of it being clouded over at the crucial moment.

Plus, as you said, it is more of a holiday tyoo as you actually get time to relax and enjoy the place as well.

as for the other seasons......

Spring good for new growth, Bluebells and Daffs etc.

Autumn good for mists and lost of colour in the landscape.

Winter good for snow and dramatic clouds, frosts and staying in bed late. Btw, if that last one si the case, how come we were up at 6:30 every morning in Scotland?
 
Spring:

+ Bluebells, wild garlic, still the possibility of snow on the tops. Gorse - the displays are amazing.

- Weather changeable, storms can build VERY quickly. Often misty on the coast.
Summer:

+ The early morning and late evening light is unbeatable, especially on the west coast. Stunning reflections and colour in lochs and lochans.

- MIDGES. Do not underestimate the problems they can cause. Go prepared and be aware that none of the insect repellants are very effective against them. The best protection is a midge jacket like this: http://www.scottcountry.co.uk/products_detail.asp?productID=1162
Autumn:

+ On good days, the light is lovely and the berries are out on the rowans which, especially in the Northern Highlands, lends a bit of colour. August is a good time for the heather. Slightly later sunrises for a lie in. Possibility of seeing the Aurora Borealis. Seal pups and even otters are possible. I have seen more otters at this time of year than any other. Red Deer rutting in late October.

- Weather unpredictable. Strong gales and even snow in late September and October. Lots of brown almost everywhere in the hills, as the bracken has died off. Again, up north there aren't many deciduous trees, so not much autumn colour.
Winter:

+ Late starts and early finishes. Sunrises to die for. Snow on the hills. Deer at lower levels. Strong water flows in rivers and waterfalls. When the sun shines after a deluge, waterfalls seem to appear everywhere.
- Short daylight hours, sometimes, in bad weather, its dark all day. In adverse weather travelling is difficult and in more remote areas, even dangerous. Blooming cold! :D
 
Summer is the worst as far as I'm concerned, Spring and Autumn are better but Winter is the killer time for scapes for me, it can be crystal sharp clear, or misty as a b****r, any combination of which in the right light is bonza.
The other seasons don't often supply those extremes.
 
Back
Top