Limits of high ISO for sports photography ?

Messages
58
Name
Jon
Edit My Images
Yes
Looking for some guidance please, am taking lots of photos of my other half show jumping, which at this time of year is indoor, with not the greatest of lighting.

In order to get a sharp shot of the horses in mid air need to keep the shutter speed up at 1/320 to 1/400 min, but am really struggling with the exposure.

have pushed the ISO on my 40d up as far as it goes, (3200 in extened mode) and end up with noisy pictures - this is using my 24-105 f4 L lens.

Am I really just at the limit of my camera's sensor ? or there something else I should try to improve this ?

anyone suggest a good noise reduction pluggin for Aperture to help ?
 
I also shoot a lot of indoor show jumping. Fortunately I am able to be in the arena as I'm often the official photog. However I now use my 50mm 1.4 ISO 1600 @ a250th. Get good enough results to make a few sales. Like you I found that the benefits of the zoom were eclipsed by the limitations of very often poor light. Tried using my 70-200 2.8 but handicapped by it being too long. I've also changed from 40D to 7D as some venuesare even darker. Recently I was shooting with the 50mm at ISO 4000 f1.4 @ 200th to get anything at all. Very noisy but better than nothing !
 
Indoor arenas was one of the reasons I got my D3 as some of the venues are so dark, I usually use the 70-200mm f/2.8 at anything up to ISO8000. You might want to invest in some faster glass but remember your dof will be much smaller.
 
As Trevor has said, you can go down the route of faster glass, but even that will mean high ISO settings to some extent, just probably slightly less than your current needs. If you want to try that out, why not hire an appropriate lens from somewhere like LensesforHire for a few days to try it out and see what results you get before splashing out on what will inherently be expensive.

As for noise reduction, not sure abot Aperture plugins, but certainly programs like Noise Ninja, Noiseware and various others all get good reviews as free standing or CS plugins. However, always remember that noise reduction also means detail reduction, so it should be applied with care. Again, try them out, mos have free trials or are actually free if you use them free standing.
 
depends on the camera, and the target media for printing

Some camera's are MUCH better than others, and a 400x400px web image is a totally different to a full page spread in a magazine
 
I also shoot a lot of indoor show jumping. Fortunately I am able to be in the arena as I'm often the official photog. However I now use my 50mm 1.4 ISO 1600 @ a250th. Get good enough results to make a few sales. Like you I found that the benefits of the zoom were eclipsed by the limitations of very often poor light. Tried using my 70-200 2.8 but handicapped by it being too long. I've also changed from 40D to 7D as some venuesare even darker. Recently I was shooting with the 50mm at ISO 4000 f1.4 @ 200th to get anything at all. Very noisy but better than nothing !

The shots you took at ISO 4000 were they with the 7D? How noisy are they?
I have a 70-200 f/2.8 IS but have been thinking to get a prime, trying to decide between the 85L f/1.8, the 135L f/2.0 (a second hand one going for £600 in excellent condition) but have been thinking of the 50mm f/1.4 too. I am more likely to use it for portraits at the moment but certainly would be looking to expand what I am shooting so even indoor sports would be one of them.
I wonder how the 50mm f/1.4 would perform to cover a wide variety of situations such as these
 
Yes shots at ISO 4000 were taken with the 7D. I'd rate them as VERY noisy. But as I mentioned I have to get something, still able to sell a few of them on site to the competitors. The 50mm is a recent addition and I LOVE IT. Considered the 85 but it's too long for horses when I'm in the Arena
 
Yes shots at ISO 4000 were taken with the 7D. I'd rate them as VERY noisy. But as I mentioned I have to get something, still able to sell a few of them on site to the competitors. The 50mm is a recent addition and I LOVE IT. Considered the 85 but it's too long for horses when I'm in the Arena

Thanks Trevor, appreciate your response
 
Indoor arenas was one of the reasons I got my D3 as some of the venues are so dark, I usually use the 70-200mm f/2.8 at anything up to ISO8000. You might want to invest in some faster glass but remember your dof will be much smaller.

Quoted for truth.

This is where the D3/D700 shines and no mistake.

And thats not a stupid "Canon vs Nikon" comment, its just the truth.
 
I wouldn't want to shoot indoors in that light with f4 glass tbh
for cheapness you can get a 50-150 sigma f2.8 which will do what you want
for extra reach there is the 70-200 alternate
1/250 should be good enough for a moving horse surely?

p.s noise ninja and noiseware...not sure about plugins
 
Looking for some guidance please, am taking lots of photos of my other half show jumping, which at this time of year is indoor, with not the greatest of lighting.

In order to get a sharp shot of the horses in mid air need to keep the shutter speed up at 1/320 to 1/400 min, but am really struggling with the exposure.

have pushed the ISO on my 40d up as far as it goes, (3200 in extened mode) and end up with noisy pictures - this is using my 24-105 f4 L lens.

Am I really just at the limit of my camera's sensor ? or there something else I should try to improve this ?

anyone suggest a good noise reduction pluggin for Aperture to help ?

You need to gather more light. The options for that are longer shutter speeds, lower f/numbers, flash, and bigger format (larger light gathering area).

Apart from that, it's amplifying the signal by raising ISO to get the exposure you need, and using noise reduction software.

There are inevitable trade-offs to all of these things but for low light shooting you are not best placed, relatively, with a 40D. In the Canon range, the 7D is usefully better (one stop or more) and the 5DII is much better (two or three stops, very roughly) thanks to its larger format.
 
Again not wanting to start a war, i have seem this live and this is where the Nikon D700/D3 blows the equal canon away.

Noise does not start till way up in the scale.
 
Again not wanting to start a war, i have seem this live and this is where the Nikon D700/D3 blows the equal canon away.

Noise does not start till way up in the scale.

Yeah, I think Nikon still has it though the 5DII is getting close. It's very good, but the D3/D700 are just fantastic (as they should be with that feeble pixel count ;) :D ).

However, the OP is using Canon.
 
nikon for this, and against the 5Dii which is excellent, the Nikon will have a better AF system.
however...yes, OP has canon..a 40D, so f2.8 glass is the way forward
 
Looking for some guidance please, am taking lots of photos of my other half show jumping, which at this time of year is indoor, with not the greatest of lighting.

In order to get a sharp shot of the horses in mid air need to keep the shutter speed up at 1/320 to 1/400 min, but am really struggling with the exposure.

have pushed the ISO on my 40d up as far as it goes, (3200 in extened mode) and end up with noisy pictures - this is using my 24-105 f4 L lens.

Am I really just at the limit of my camera's sensor ? or there something else I should try to improve this ?

anyone suggest a good noise reduction pluggin for Aperture to help ?


You are indeed exceeding the limits of your camera sensor by some margin, new glass would be nice but I really don't think that will resolve your issues. You need an ISO monster to give you lots of latitude for exposure. As your target is not really fast moving and is not really going to demand the best of AF systems I would suggest is the 5Dmk 11.


You could change to the D3 etc which would eat those ISO's for breakfast, but as someone else has pointed out the 5D Mk11 is pretty good also.


Hope this helps
 
I'm having similar issues photographing indoor hockey matches in poor lighting with no flash. Using the 24-105L F4 i was struglling to get 160 shutter speed even with the ISO ramped right up (3200 i think). Using the F2.8 L IS USM i was getting over 200 shutter speed at ISO 1600 and the pics look much better. Faster glass is definately the way to go!! :)
 
Back
Top