Critique Lone tree-Egton Moor

[jpgreenwood]

Not sure if a more bleak look without the foreground interest would have been a better shot. However, it was the wrong time of the day with the sun in the wrong direction, and wrong time of year. This was more of a recce trip.
nyorks_4-2 by jason greenwood, on Flickr

 

[alfbranch]

It needs a crop and more tonal range in the heather IMO like this

Not my shot 2018-05 by Alf Branch, on Flickr

 

[Ladystrange]

Nice Jason, the crop definitely works better I think

 

[Kodiak Qc]

more tonal range in the heather

 

[AgentOrange76]

Yep like the crop much better, Im sure the B&W makes it over the coloured image, fascinates me that by removing the colour can change the image so dramatically. Going to make sure that before I dismiss an image I convert it before ignoring them