Minimalism: What's good, what's not?

Messages
1,642
Edit My Images
Yes
Sometimes I see a minimalist photo that makes a really big impact on me and impresses instantly. Sometimes I just think 'well that's a photo of nothing'.

I took this today:


For this I am edging more towards 'this is a photo of nothing'.

This one on the other hand (not mine) I really really like.

I don't quite understand where the distinction is between good and not good.
What do you think makes a shot along these lines good and what makes it fall flat?
Examples welcome.
 
Nowt wrong with that Matt, quite like that.

I took one very similar to the one in your link not so long ago:

3210350985_b95220f6a2.jpg


I guess it's in the eye of the beholder, as I've already had a marmite-esque reaction to mine from friends.
 
The example you posted -

has a sense of power and movement to it. Its also astonishingly phallic (really - I'm not being facetious here) so it has an appeal that shouts power and strength. The fact that its a rocket or a plane or whatever just adds to that. Its macho.

By contrast - and don't take this too hard - your's is a just a pic of a truck on a bridge. Why? It doesn't say anything much to me. Say you'd got the same truck head on, or driving off into the distance, then you would create an image that asks a question - where is he going, where has he been? Create a sense of scale or a story. That's why the example pic works so well - where are they going? Sure, its a simple composition, but it says a lot more.

Hope that helps. Sometimes I'm better at theory than practise.

MV
 
I think this is an excellent question and if it wasnt my bedtime i could go on for ages......

There's a dividing line (fuzzy and moveable, depending on the 'eye of the beholder') between a minimalist image that conveys a mood or focuses the attention on a subject and an image that needs a verbal explanation to do the same. Obviously that is mainly aimed at images designed for third party consumption and becomes somewhat irrelevant when it's a personal piece of art.

Colour alone can be very enjoyable as can a shape and so on, these have there own qualities that require skill and i suppose the next stage is to add something else to the image that emphasises these, next something that also resonates with them and so on. If the image can also convey an emotion or transport the viewer then there is yet another dimension of expression. This counts for any good photography but in my opinion minimalism, if that is what is being experimented with, is the specific intention to communicate something on a more subconcious level.

i'm going to bed now, hope this thread keeps going :thumbs:
 
I love the truck!

It makes me imagine what the rest of the bridge is like! In my head i'm thinking of some next confusing bridge!

I love it!

And the plane one, it makes me think.. Where was this picture taken? It looks like it could be in Hawaii but wait... where's that plane going? Is there anyone important on that plane?

Oooo I love these photo's, possiblilty's are endless!
 
I love the truck!

It makes me imagine what the rest of the bridge is like! In my head i'm thinking of some next confusing bridge!

I love it!

And the plane one, it makes me think.. Where was this picture taken? It looks like it could be in Hawaii but wait... where's that plane going? Is there anyone important on that plane?

Oooo I love these photo's, possiblilty's are endless!

Thats the other important ingredient I guess, the ability as a viewer to think deeper and bring a translation to an image. There are at least 2 skills involved in this, having the knowledge to interpret the 'correct' meaning to an image and also the imagination to say 'that reminds me of........' and 'It makes me think of....' etc. There is a kinda common symbology i.e, as has been mentioned above, phallic images 'its long and straight and so it looks like a willy' and in this sense simple images can be used like a language (especially if you like talking about willys!) but obviously you can also look too far, lots of things are long but they are not all intended to be dangly man wood. Sometimes an explanation will tell you more about the viewer than it does the original image;). Sometimes it's the setting in which something is placed which makes it one thing or another (resists obvious joke about placing phallic object in suitable setting!)

I think minimalism is an exciting language and one that can be used in conjuction with 'normal' photography techniques like the over used 'rule of thirds' (which i could also go on about, but i won't here). I also dont think that it is a simple or easy technique. Take critiques for example, a simple 'i like this picture' or ''thats nice' doesnt really convey any depth of emotion and is merely an acknowledgement, like a friendly :wave:Hello. or LOL

ian
 
Thats the other important ingredient I guess, the ability as a viewer to think deeper and bring a translation to an image. There are at least 2 skills involved in this, having the knowledge to interpret the 'correct' meaning to an image and also the imagination to say 'that reminds me of........' and 'It makes me think of....' etc. There is a kinda common symbology i.e, as has been mentioned above, phallic images 'its long and straight and so it looks like a willy' and in this sense simple images can be used like a language (especially if you like talking about willys!) but obviously you can also look too far, lots of things are long but they are not all intended to be dangly man wood. Sometimes an explanation will tell you more about the viewer than it does the original image;)

I think minimalism is an exciting language and one that can be used in conjuction with 'normal' photography techniques like the over used 'rule of thirds' (which i could also go on about, but i won't here). I also dont think that it is a simple or easy technique. Take critiques for example, a simple 'i like this picture' or ''thats nice' doesnt really convey any depth of emotion and is merely an acknowledgement, like a friendly :wave:Hello. or LOL

ian


^^^^^^

He said willy, tehe.... Sorry for the immaturness.... I'm only young!

But, I understand what you mean.

I suppose it gives the viewer the freedom to view the image as they see it, not like the way it's portraied!

<3
 
Excellent question, with lovely examples. I think minimalist photos can beautiful and powerful, so long as they're captured right, with the right subject matter and extremely careful consideration of composition.

Your truck is ace, and the one of the plane is also extremely powerful, although could do with being a touch further into the frame.
 
Everything is debatable I suppose, but one thing that I have come to realise over the years is that, less is most definitely more. So I too love the minimalist approach - cutting out everything which is superfluous and conveying the core of the matter or subject, simply or deftly. Here's a link to a minimalist photographer David Burdeny. http://www.davidburdeny.com/
 
Everything is debatable I suppose, but one thing that I have come to realise over the years is that, less is most definitely more. So I too love the minimalist approach - cutting out everything which is superfluous and conveying the core of the matter or subject, simply or deftly. Here's a link to a minimalist photographer David Burdeny. http://www.davidburdeny.com/

i like David Burdenys pictures, but im not keen on the plane or the truck one, i guess i dont think deep enough about them:shrug: there just isnt enough in the picture for me, it almost seems like they didnt have a long enough lens to capture what they wanted to
 
Very interesting thread. It&#8217;s hard to sum up what it is that makes one picture like this work and another not. I think its probably two things, both of which have been touched upon above.

Aesthetics - large areas of tone/colour just look nice. Especially when juxtaposed with smaller areas of different tone or complexity.

Meaning - What does the image make you think about. Whether that's where the people on the plane are going, what the rest of the bridge looks like, or something much deeper.

These sort of pictures always remind me of a painting that I like by Francisco Goya:

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/38/Goya_Dog.jpg

Similar sort of thing. And I think I like it for the same reasons.
 
BTW, i think it takes courage to approach a new discipline and go against the grain, especialy amongst people who are content and capable within their own ways of expression. The image of the truck on the bridge could easily convey this. It looks like a toy entering the frame, maybe it's empty but i think it's full of goodies. It could be a long bridge that's it's crossing and the sky makes it feel as if the bridge is high and daunting but the truck looks resolute. The only adjustment i would suggest is making more of the spacing between the supporting legs and how the angle changes their appearance from a single leg under the truck to double legs towards the left, almost as if they are rotating. :thumbs:
 
Thanks for all the input here. It's good to hear a few different perspectives. I guess I still don't quite get this, but I am trying to.

I guess to an extent the image with the plane I like because of the large area of single, soft colour. I also like strong geometry in pictures, so the way the trail lines up so well with the frame is a big big plus. Another plus with this (and other like it) is that they are usually contextless, allowing your mind to assume what it will. The truck photo is contextless in the same way, but having taken it, I know where it is, I know what the landscape was like and for me it will always remind me of that cold afternoon I spent walking near Howden.

Sorry, just thinking out loud. This is great stuff guys. I'd love to hear more thoughts.
 
I find this flickr group quite a good resource to see what people make of minimalist photography.
 
What do you think makes a shot along these lines good and what makes it fall flat?
Context.

Some minimalist shots only work when you know the context behind them; be that a plaque alongside them in a gallery that explains what they are or some form of accompanying text in a magazine, book, etc.

But a lot of minimalist shots simply need to look good. If they are pretty and work as a nice photo that people want to look at, context doesn't really matter as it doesn't need to come into the equation.

Take your photo of the truck. For me and my tastes it doesn't do much. I don't find it particularly pretty and therefore it's not really making me want to stare at it. But in the right context it would work perfectly well as a minimalist study and then become something more than a photo of a truck.

On the other hand, I think Simmotino's photo is really pretty and I'd happily spend a long time staring at that if it was in a gallery or magazine where I could see it in all its glory. For me if doesn't even need to have any context but if it had then that would just add a little more to the shot.
 
I love the minimalist approach, although I'm no expert and I can't necessarily articulate why.

But what I find amusing and perplexing is that some people really don't understand it at all. At Maidenhead Camera Club the other week the competition judge was definitely one of those. This is what he'd have said about your truck on the bridge.

Minimal-1.jpg


Minimal-2.jpg


Minimal-3.jpg
 
Interesting viewpoint glitch. I see what you mean about the need to be pretty but could you elaborate a bit about context? What context do you think would be needed for the truck to work for you? If possible, could you show me an example or two of other photos that you think do and do not need context adding?

And tht made me laugh a fair bit StewartR :D
 
I love the minimalist approach, although I'm no expert and I can't necessarily articulate why.

But what I find amusing and perplexing is that some people really don't understand it at all. At Maidenhead Camera Club the other week the competition judge was definitely one of those. This is what he'd have said about your truck on the bridge.

Minimal-1.jpg


Minimal-2.jpg


Minimal-3.jpg

Thats very funny and a work of art in itself :thumbs:

Evolution rules.
 
The Matt said:
Interesting viewpoint glitch. I see what you mean about the need to be pretty but could you elaborate a bit about context? What context do you think would be needed for the truck to work for you? If possible, could you show me an example or two of other photos that you think do and do not need context adding?
Well that's the tricky thing. It's very difficult to add context when you aren't the person who took the photograph and know what was going through that person's head at the time; what they were thinking, why they took it, what it represents to them, etc.

I guess the easiest explanation I can think up is that of modern art. Some modern art I love because I can look at it and think it's wonderful. Case in point being Damien Hirst's Lullaby Spring which not only looks amazing but shows off the most fantastic craftsmanship, even when you don't know or understand the meaning behind it all.

But where Lullaby Spring has that effect on me instantly, some other pieces require them to be looked at in context.

I can't remember the name of the piece or the artist, but there is a piece bought by one of the major London galleries that had the entire Daily Mail readership spitting out their cornflakes. It's basically a series of marble 'bricks' laid out on the floor. Now, some people might find it nice to look at and some might think it's a load of old rubbish. But if you know the context in which the work is meant to be taken it becomes a very clever piece of work indeed and you might then look at it in a completely different way.

Or you might still think it's a load of old rubbish.
 
first look was a dull truck, second look was more interesting.
Art's meant to pose questions isn't it, and that shot on proper reflection does pose questions, wheres the truck going, whats it carrying ect.
Third look I really like it, would go nicely on a wall as a fairly big print for a conversation piece.
 
first look was a dull truck, second look was more interesting.
Art's meant to pose questions isn't it, and that shot on proper reflection does pose questions, wheres the truck going, whats it carrying ect.
Third look I really like it, would go nicely on a wall as a fairly big print for a conversation piece.
:agree: Although i'm not sure if that would be an official definition, i do think an image that sparks a further depth of imagination than simply portraying a scene as accurately as possible is more worthy of being called art (in the sense of creatively bringing more to an image). Thats not taking anything away from 'normal' photography at all, that is a skill in itself, if anything i'm saying that these are almost 2 seperate entities and i'm sure that if a new catagory were created in the critique section then a) it would be popular, b) people would be even more inspired to see their work from a different perspective and c) the images would speak volumes more than anybodys verbal description on this thread of what we think minimalism is.

Context has been mentioned a couple of times as being very important to expressing images and i think this can be broken down into 3 types.
1) Internal-context within the photograph itself, colours, juxtopositions, shapes, subjects etc etc.
2) External-Verbal descriptions, poems, words, other images by the same artist displayed alongside to assist in the intent of the image.
3) Setting-Images displayed in the same gallery/forum that gets people in a sympathetic frame of mind and makes it easier to get into the genre.

Sorry if i'm going on and on and on and pretending to be all high brow, but new stuff does inspire me.
 
Back
Top