New Laptop

gman

gman

Messages
11,303
Name
Graham
Edit My Images
Yes
It's time I retired my laptop, despite my upgrades it's still severely underpowered and I've never liked the screen quality.

But looking for a replacement is fast becoming a nightmare. It doesn't need to be super powerful, but ideally a dedicated graphics card and preferably 16"+ but if the screen is amazing then 15" will be ok. But it would seem that to stay in budget with a good processor and GPU (up to £1,200) the screen quality is usually compromised. To get 100% DCI-P3 it ends up missing a dedicated graphics card, but as Lightroom uses the GPU (and I do some big stitches), I'm not sure I can compromise on that.

A few I've looked at, although I don't know what their screens are like except for the ACER which apparently is a bit crap and washed out:

Acer Nitro (good processor)
Gigabytre A16 (missing numerical keypad but I can compromise with that, good processor)
MSI Cybord 15 (only 15", processor is okish)
ASUS V16 (processor is okish)

Any thoughts or suggestions for something better?
 
gman said:
It's time I retired my laptop, despite my upgrades it's still severely underpowered and I've never liked the screen quality.

But looking for a replacement is fast becoming a nightmare. It doesn't need to be super powerful, but ideally a dedicated graphics card and preferably 16"+ but if the screen is amazing then 15" will be ok. But it would seem that to stay in budget with a good processor and GPU (up to £1,200) the screen quality is usually compromised. To get 100% DCI-P3 it ends up missing a dedicated graphics card, but as Lightroom uses the GPU (and I do some big stitches), I'm not sure I can compromise on that.

A few I've looked at, although I don't know what their screens are like except for the ACER which apparently is a bit crap and washed out:

Acer Nitro (good processor)
Gigabytre A16 (missing numerical keypad but I can compromise with that, good processor)
MSI Cybord 15 (only 15", processor is okish)
ASUS V16 (processor is okish)

Any thoughts or suggestions for something better?
Click to expand...
Perhaps your needs could be met by a custom configuration laptop? Though would that be too far outside your budget?

 
Box Brownie said:
Perhaps your needs could be met by a custom configuration laptop? Though would that be too far outside your budget?

Click to expand...

During lockdown when there were shortages I got a 17" one from PC Specialist and I'm still using it. There's a crack in the case and some of the letters have worn off the keys but it's still going.

I'll get a new one when I can be bothered and it'll be another 17". I like larger screens as I don't have a desktop these days as I hate to see computers set up as I think they dominate the room so I like laptops which can be put away out of sight when not in use.

Would a 17" interest you Graham?
 
Slightly under budget:


A bit over budget:

A bit more over budget:
 
Box Brownie said:
Perhaps your needs could be met by a custom configuration laptop? Though would that be too far outside your budget?

Click to expand...

Aye, I'm guessing a custom one will be very expensive but I might have a look around, you never know! Cheers.

woof woof said:
During lockdown when there were shortages I got a 17" one from PC Specialist and I'm still using it. There's a crack in the case and some of the letters have worn off the keys but it's still going.

I'll get a new one when I can be bothered and it'll be another 17". I like larger screens as I don't have a desktop these days as I hate to see computers set up as I think they dominate the room so I like laptops which can be put away out of sight when not in use.

Would a 17" interest you Graham?
Click to expand...

Anything 16" and upwards, the bigger the screen the better as I find 15" a little small. I forgot about PC Specialist, I've have a look cheers!

ancient_mariner said:
Slightly under budget:


A bit over budget:

A bit more over budget:
Click to expand...

I've never been very keen on Dell as historically I've found them a little restrictive when it comes to upgrading etc, although that was desktops. I never really thought about them for laptops, I think there was an XPS range that was meant to be good. I'll have a look at these links thanks!

EDIT: Ah, Alienware. I know of this and they have a good rep.
 
Last edited:
Those Alienware laptops look perfect, especially with 1 year onsite service seeing as they are refurbs. I think it's now a case of deciding which one... that last one would be pretty future proofed but up goes the budget! lol
 
I've just had a look and they seem cheap for the spec. There's no 17" though but there is a 16". I'm a bit reluctant to settle for a smaller screen though.
 
I quite like that PC Specialist site, it's nice that you can make some custom choices. Prices aren't actually all that bad considering the components and that they are brand new.
 
gman said:
I quite like that PC Specialist site, it's nice that you can make some custom choices. Prices aren't actually all that bad considering the components and that they are brand new.
Click to expand...

When I stopped working in computers I lost all interest and didn't keep up with developments so didn't really know what spec I needed so I called them and they were very helpful.

One thing that worries me is that the letters have worn off some of the keys and I've never seen this before with any other laptop and this doesn't fill me with confidence about the components they choose. I bought mine years ago so hopefully they're buying in better bits now.
 
Last edited:
woof woof said:
When I stopped working in computers I lost all interest and didn't keep up with developments so didn't really know what spec I needed so I called them and they were very helpful.

One thing that worries me is that the letters have worn off some of the keys and I've never seen this before with any other laptop and his doesn't fill me with confidence about the components they choose. I bought mine years ago so hopefully they're buying in better bits now.
Click to expand...

There certainly seems a lot to look through. Their 17" choice seems rather restrictive compared to 16" and 18", but I'll need to spent some time and look through all of their options.

One thing I forgot is that I need 32GB because I often saw my current laptop go well above 16GB of ram when doing big stitches. I think I might have to compromise a little with the graphics card in order to get the screen size and the RAM I need for this budget. A 3xxx series should be fine, I won't really be gaming on it anyway.
 
I've just seen that there's an 18" Alienware, it costs a bit though but I didn't know anyone made an 18".
 
gman said:
I think there was an XPS range that was meant to be good.
Click to expand...

I bought an XPS15 for work from Dell's outlet for the same price as the most basic Macbook from their refurb store in 2014. The battery failed after 3 years, which seems quite common these days, and the keyboard was also replaced under warranty at the same time. I still have it now, and the screen is still fantastic, while the rest of the machine runs quickly enough for casual use and even a bit of photo-processing. If I were to buy another laptop intentionally for work then I'd get an XPS13 or 15 depending on how much travel was required.
 
Cheers all, my brain is a bit frazzeled from looking at so many laptops and specs, so I'm going to revisit this tomorrow when fresh.
 
Check the speeds of any processor you consider, and i7 isn't necessarily faster than an i5.

An off board video card is essential for image processing.

My i7 with a NVidia graphics card (from PC specialists nearly 2 years ago) takes 35 seconds do do a large merge and process, an Apple M4 30 seconds for the same files, and my old laptop 1min 40secs :(
 
Sangoma said:
Check the speeds of any processor you consider, and i7 isn't necessarily faster than an i5.

An off board video card is essential for image processing.

My i7 with a NVidia graphics card (from PC specialists nearly 2 years ago) takes 35 seconds do do a large merge and process, an Apple M4 30 seconds for the same files, and my old laptop 1min 40secs :(
Click to expand...

Aye, I got caught out with that with an i5 in a rushed business computer purchase thinking it should be decent, but turned out to be poor. There's i5's out there that are slower than my old i7 3770k from 2012!

I always use https://www.cpubenchmark.net now to check processors and GPU's. Whilst it's not necessarily the most accurate, it does provide a reasonable guide and comparison.
 
I'm stuck between two laptops. Both the same price with same specs excempt that one has a far superior processor (Intel Core Ultra 7 255HX) but only 16GB of RAM, whereas the other one still has a good processor (Intel Core 7 240H) but it has 32GB of RAM.

To buy 32GB of decent 5600MT/s DDR5 SoDIMM costs around £330, so that's a fair amount extra to sink straight after buying. But unlike the RAM, the processors are soldered directly so there's no option to upgrade them, making me wonder if I should get the better processor.
 
If you can live with the slower processor, take the 32gb RAM. Otherwise upgrade in a couple of years.
 
ancient_mariner said:
If you can live with the slower processor, take the 32gb RAM. Otherwise upgrade in a couple of years.
Click to expand...

I'll have a think about this. I'll be using a wider lens, so will most likely be stitching fewer photos in one session. I might do some tests on the big rig and see how much RAM is used up with smaller stitches. It'll be a similar MP sensor, so individual file sizes hopefully similar as well.
 
ancient_mariner said:
Just came across this with Costco, no idea if the screen is good?

Predator Helios Neo 16 AI 1139.99 from Costco at 16in RTX 5070 gaming laptop - | hotukdeals

www.hotukdeals.com www.hotukdeals.com
Click to expand...

Was just going to mention this one - spec is on the link below - be careful there seems to be lots of variations of this model - some are a 64Gb max and this one apparently is 32Gb - seems to have the screen you want though

 
That's a great find, I forgot about Costco (I loath going there, it's like village of the damned). They all seem to link back to a 16GB version, but with the higher spec GPU and being brand new yet cheaper, I think that might win over the Alienware one.
 
Ended up getting the Acer Predator Helios NEO 16 AI today as suggested and linked above. Cheers for that - an excellent find.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top