New lens for D3100

Messages
216
Edit My Images
Yes
I've been toying with the idea of getting an upgrade to the D7000 and/or new lenses for quite some time. With only a small budget of roughly £500 I've decided that I'll start with a new lens then add if I have some spare cash.

My situation is this: I like taking landscapes but only have the opportunity once every week or fortnight (or during holiday). I have a little one on the way (less than 3 weeks!) so I can imagine that I will have even less time for landscapes. I want to take some great shots of my newborn that I can be proud of. I currently have a Nikon D3100 with the kit 18-55mm, 55-300mm and 35mm f1.8 along with a Yonguno 560 and Rf-603 triggers.

My lens options are:
1. Ultra-wide angle Sigma 10-20
2. Wide angle Sigma 17-50 2.8
3. Mid-range zoom Sigma 28-70 2.8

My first option is deciding what type of lens do I want?
- An ultra-wide would be great - this would complete the ultra-wide angle of focal lengths to supplement my kit lens. However, I'm worried that I wouldn't use it often enough.
- A kit lens upgrade might be sensible. I would like to have the low-light ability at the 50mm range instead of the aperture reaching f5.6 on the kit. However, the kit lens is good and wondering is it worth paying around £500 to gain two stops of light with the f2.8?
- A mid-range zoom might be a worthwhile purchase to taking portraiture and candid shots. However, is it necessary since I have all the focal lengths covered?

Just wanting some advice from fellow photographers as it's quite a big decision to make for me - the lens itself is going to be worth about the same as my whole kit combined!
 
2 stops of light will make a world of difference to exposure options. I would go for the kit upgrade - 17-50 f/2.8 but be sure to test the actual copy you'll be buying; Sigma QC has been known to vary.
 
I've been toying with the idea of getting an upgrade to the D7000 and/or new lenses for quite some time. With only a small budget of roughly £500 I've decided that I'll start with a new lens then add if I have some spare cash.

My situation is this: I like taking landscapes but only have the opportunity once every week or fortnight (or during holiday). I have a little one on the way (less than 3 weeks!) so I can imagine that I will have even less time for landscapes. I want to take some great shots of my newborn that I can be proud of. I currently have a Nikon D3100 with the kit 18-55mm, 55-300mm and 35mm f1.8 along with a Yonguno 560 and Rf-603 triggers.

My lens options are:
1. Ultra-wide angle Sigma 10-20
2. Wide angle Sigma 17-50 2.8
3. Mid-range zoom Sigma 28-70 2.8

My first option is deciding what type of lens do I want?
- An ultra-wide would be great - this would complete the ultra-wide angle of focal lengths to supplement my kit lens. However, I'm worried that I wouldn't use it often enough.
- A kit lens upgrade might be sensible. I would like to have the low-light ability at the 50mm range instead of the aperture reaching f5.6 on the kit. However, the kit lens is good and wondering is it worth paying around £500 to gain two stops of light with the f2.8?
- A mid-range zoom might be a worthwhile purchase to taking portraiture and candid shots. However, is it necessary since I have all the focal lengths covered?

Just wanting some advice from fellow photographers as it's quite a big decision to make for me - the lens itself is going to be worth about the same as my whole kit combined!

For £500 or not much more you should be able to pick up a used Nikon 17-55mm f/2.8. Much better choice than any of those Sigma's.
 
I agree, get the Nikkor 17-55mm f2.8.

It's a pro lens for DX Nikon's.
Metal body, weather sealing and big.
Sharp throughout.

£500-600 approx is the going rate second hand.

Riz :)
 
If you buy wisely, you could get a sigma 10-20 and a tamron 17-50 for £500.

I bought my sigma from eBay for £220 in October and its mint. I use it a lot more than I thought I would
 
If you buy wisely, you could get a sigma 10-20 and a tamron 17-50 for £500.

I bought my sigma from eBay for £220 in October and its mint. I use it a lot more than I thought I would

I was just about to message the same thing. These are the 2 lenses i own and happy enough with them.
 
In similar situation with mid range zoom but with around £200 budget. In mix is tamron 28-75 f2.8 which is been offered at £180. 17/18@wide would be nice and probably is more ideal for my use. Any opinions between them? Or all are similar in optics and IQ. BTW one of them will replace both 18-105 and 35mm.

Sorry for hijacking. Thanks
 
In similar situation with mid range zoom but with around £200 budget. In mix is tamron 28-75 f2.8 which is been offered at £180. 17/18@wide would be nice and probably is more ideal for my use. Any opinions between them? Or all are similar in optics and IQ. BTW one of them will replace both 18-105 and 35mm.

Sorry for hijacking. Thanks

Not a good option for a crop camera
 
Back
Top