Night Photography... whats the best approach!

Messages
1,764
Edit My Images
Yes
Hi

Myself and stantheman where having a discussion in the gallery section but really not the best place to do it as we would appreciate more peoples views!

When shooting night lndscapes such as this...
3273351310_6dc4b4c72d.jpg


... They never turn out as sharp as I've seen other photos.

Im using a tripod... and I generally set my camera to buld... set about f11 and shoot at will... I think the pic abouve was about a 20sec exposure.

I've only also recently discovered I should have the IS turned off on my 28-135mm IS, and I think the IS was on when I took this.

However... In other shots i've taken with a non IS lens I lways am never happy with the results. My tripod is OK... It's a velbon Sherpa 600... I do intend on upgrading... but that asside... we both wondered for shots like this what should you set the camera at... I've heard 2 schools of thought... one to set f5.6 or lower as DOF does not really matter when there is little forground interest at night... then simply shoot... the shorter shutter speed reduces the chance of camera and tripod shake... that makes sens but is it the best option...

I want tack sharp night shots and as you see from my next two images they are not perfect... maybe im being over critical?

Peoples views would be greatly appreciated?

2. Cape Town Waterfront... Just not as sharp as i'd like. Sigma 15-30mm, EOSd5. I think about f8... but not sure!

3272753177_2b079d8d72.jpg


3. Toronto Skyline... again with the sigma non IS.

3272336981_6439e4d27d.jpg


4. NYC from Manhatten Bridge... Probably the 28-135mm IS

3273326448_b3225b69a2.jpg
 
Links are broken, got an extra http:// in them!
 
wont let me eddit for some reason... I've never been able to edit posts on here... always logs me out or says i dont have permission... even though i log in!

pics again anyway...

1.
3273351310_6dc4b4c72d.jpg


2.
3272753177_2b079d8d72.jpg


3.
3272336981_6439e4d27d.jpg


4.
3273326448_b3225b69a2.jpg
 
There seems to be a lot of noise in them, what ISO are you using?

A I should add... I've just thought... these 4 where taken using my EOS3 on slide film... the noise could be a result of the scanning to be honest... half the reason why I went digital as the one place you now want images is a computer and although I loved slide film the scanning was a pain...

im always sure my slides where a little sharper... and my scanner was not fab but ok....

But still... im not so much after peoples coments on these photos as your approach to night photography in terms of buld and f no?

M
 
And maybe the self timer and mirror lockup ? I normally use the 2 second timer and mirror lockup with the remote release.
 
And maybe the self timer and mirror lockup ? I normally use the 2 second timer and mirror lockup with the remote release.

works every time for me, fire the mirror allow tripod and camera to stabalise then fire the shutter, should cut most vibration out of picture. iso of 100 or lowest possible IMHO
 
I use a cable release... just the standard one for the EOS5d...

I have used the 2s self timer too when forgot my cable...

Im unsure about this mirror lock up thing... is that a custom function?

Maybe its simply my tripod is not good enough... I have a velbon sherpa 600.

But what is peoples apature thoughts, wide, closed or somewhere in the middle...

Do people use their lightmeters... or just put it on bulb and do a series of exposures in different lengths.

Mark
 
Mark, for my nighttime images, predominantly astro photography, I use the cable release, 2 second self timer and mirror lockup. There should be an option in the camera menus to enable mirror lockup. This flips the mirror up and out of the way, either on the first press of the shutter ready for a second, or in the case of self timer on the shutter press. By using all three, the remote minimises any vibration I might impart as I don't touch the camera, the mirror flips out of the way and everything then settles for 2 seconds before the exposure begins. I don't normally use my lightmeter, except for the one nighttime non astro shot I've taken, when I did.
 
Possibly they are ok... and its to do with the scanning!

But still no one has really addressed the one question i'd love to know! What is your apature strategy when taking bulb exposures... wide apature and short exposure , somewhere in between or narrow appature and long exposure?

Ive looked in books and it never seems to say either... HELP please!!!

M
 
f/22 and long exposure. Guess the focussing via the distance of the subject.

If I'm shooting digital, I use live view to manually focus (using the on screen zoom) and also to test the exposure. Film is far too expensive to not get the exposure perfect first time.
 
f/22 and long exposure. Guess the focussing via the distance of the subject.

If I'm shooting digital, I use live view to manually focus (using the on screen zoom) and also to test the exposure. Film is far too expensive to not get the exposure perfect first time.

But surely this gives more time with the shutter open and that means more time for the camera to shake on the tripod with wind etc... and the oposite method would render a clearer shot....

Generally f22 will not produce as sharp results as f11 anyway.... unless you actually need the DOF... which in most cases you rarely do!

M
 
oops...only now seen this thread mark :bonk:.okay folks...mark passed comments on some nightime shots i had taken last sunday in london..

http://www.talkphotography.co.uk/forums/showthread.php?t=113774

basically,mark commented that they don't look tack sharp...and through a discussion of sorts,this thread was born.i used ISO100 and a remote release,but not the 2 sec timer/mirror lockup.

could this have been the cause..?

how do the images look to you folk with regards to sharpness......
 
Anyone... what's your apature thoughts...

Seems a real reluctance for people to come forward with their views... maybe its me but just starting to think this is a bit of an area where there is no 'correct' way to go about it?

M
 
Anyone... what's your apature thoughts...

Seems a real reluctance for people to come forward with their views... maybe its me but just starting to think this is a bit of an area where there is no 'correct' way to go about it?

M

you may be right mark..although nightime photography isn't a subject i see often on here,or anywhere else.aperture wise,i would assume the same guidelines as per daytime photography would stand...depending on the DOF you require.i'm gonna give it another go very soon,using the 2 sec timer inc mirror lock up,and see if the results are better.
 
I'll ask again though... what do people think...

wide apature short exposure or small apature longer exposure... what is best?

M
 
I've always used small apature and long exposure for night shots
But I think it's personal preference really :s
 
But surely this gives more time with the shutter open and that means more time for the camera to shake on the tripod with wind etc... and the oposite method would render a clearer shot....

Generally f22 will not produce as sharp results as f11 anyway.... unless you actually need the DOF... which in most cases you rarely do!

M

You asked my aperture strategy, and I told it to you.
It seems you know what you're doing and I don't really understand why you're asking those questions. Those photos all seem spot on and I think you know it!

You've answered your own question already in this thread!
 
You asked my aperture strategy, and I told it to you.
It seems you know what you're doing and I don't really understand why you're asking those questions. Those photos all seem spot on and I think you know it!

You've answered your own question already in this thread!

Hi

I realised you had answered... I just wanted other peoples thoughts... that was all... I am still surprised only a few people have offered an opinion but hey ho thats ok... I think i'll stick to f8...

Those shots are not perfect in my mind... certainly not when seen at full size... I was asking those questions as I ask any question on here... to broaden my knowledge through others experiance... and Yes I answered my own question in the thread...but not sure if my own answer is the correct opinion... hence my question in the first place!

Im not quite sure why you apear to have got upset with my post... but whatever it is I have done... I appologise as it was not my intention...

M

P.S If anyone does have any other opinions please shout out!
 
Tripod, f/8 to f/11, however long it takes to be correctly exposed, mirror locked up and cable release used, ISO as low as it goes (although that'll probably change with the D700) unless it's too cold to hang around!
 
Tripod, f/8 to f/11, however long it takes to be correctly exposed, mirror locked up and cable release used, ISO as low as it goes (although that'll probably change with the D700) unless it's too cold to hang around!

I'll give the mirror lock up a go if I have it... off to find the manual!

M
 
With regards to what aperture, doesnt it also depend on what effect you want to get out of the lights, starburst or no starburst, so I think its always down to personal preference and desired outcome.
 
With regards to what aperture, doesnt it also depend on what effect you want to get out of the lights, starburst or no starburst, so I think its always down to personal preference and desired outcome.

aperture controls depth of field,and how much DOF is determined by the distance from lens to subject generally.you may want all of you nightime shot in focus,or not...you will get the starburst effect if you shoot lights at night whatever the exposure time,wether it's 5 secs or 30 secs...
 
I know aperture controls DOF! From my experience you dont get the starburst effect with a wide open aperture.
 
I know aperture controls DOF! From my experience you dont get the starburst effect with a wide open aperture.

surely that would depend on you focus/where the lights would be..or have i got this wrong :thinking:.i would say though steve...for general night shooting,i wouldn't use an aperture of F/2.8,but thats not to say one couldn't to get a desired effect...
 
I've noticed that the higher the aperture the bigger the starburst effect gets.

Hmmm, I need to go and experiment, are you free one evening this week for a spot of togging somewhere?
 
I've noticed that the higher the aperture the bigger the starburst effect gets.

Hmmm, I need to go and experiment, are you free one evening this week for a spot of togging somewhere?

i can only do wednesday this week steve...in college on monday eve,karate tues and thurs...and wales-france game on friday :woot:.how does wednesday sound to you?
 
Sounds Good, I'll PM you so we dont Hijack this thread :Thumbs:

We'll report back with our findings :D
 
I would not get to het up on DOF for these sort of big landscape night shots... most shots will all be in focus if you shoot at f8... unless you actually have something very close in the foreground and need the DOF you wont need anything past f8 or f11 max.

I think i'll go experiment sometime too...

Honestly guys thanks for the compliments on my shots... but if you seen them full size you would see what i mean...

go on to my flickr and look at them there... they are not tack sharp enough for me!

M
 
Back
Top