Official Response from 10 Downing street regarding Photography in public places

Messages
160
Name
Mark Wright
Edit My Images
Yes
Just got this email
Thank you for your e-petition.

On 16 February 2009, the Counter-Terrorism Act 2008 (Commencement No.2) Order 2009 brought in to force section 58A of the Terrorism Act 2000 (inserted by section 76 of the CTA 2008), offences relating to information about members of the armed forces etc.

Section 58A makes it an offence to publish, communicate, elicit or attempt to elicit information about any of such persons which is of a kind likely to be useful to a person committing or preparing an act of terrorism. Contrary to some media and public misconception, section 58A does not make it illegal to photograph a police officer, military personnel or member of the intelligence services.

On the 18 August 2009, the Home Office published the following information via its website to clarify photography in relation to section 58A.

Photography and Section 58A of the Terrorism Act 2000

The offence concerns information about persons who are or have been at the front line of counter-terrorism operations, namely the police, the armed forces and members of the security and intelligence agencies.

An officer making an arrest under section 58A must reasonably suspect that the information is of a kind likely to be useful to a person committing or preparing an act of terrorism. An example might be gathering information about the person’s house, car, routes to work and other movements.

Reasonable excuse under section 58A

It is a statutory defence for a person to prove that they had a reasonable excuse for eliciting, publishing or communicating the relevant information. Legitimate journalistic activity (such as covering a demonstration for a newspaper) is likely to constitute such an excuse. Similarly, an innocent tourist or other sight-seer taking a photograph of a police officer is likely to have a reasonable excuse.
 
Yup, got the same email.

Worth printing and sticking in your photo bag methinks.
 
Yup, got the same email.

Worth printing and sticking in your photo bag methinks.

BINGO!! That's what everyone should do.

If you photograph in public places and you get harassment from the officialdom and you don't stick up for yourself it'll happen over and over again. If everyone pulls a copy of that No.10 response out to said harasser, the amount of harassment dished out will soon fall (assuming you're fitting in with the facts stated within the response and can prove it to some degree)
 
Unfortunately it still leaves in the wording
'the information is of a kind likely to be useful...'
which is open to interpretation.

EG
You take a street photo, which includes a litter bin.
Location of the bin on the street is 'likely to be useful' to someone planning to plant a bomb in a litter bin.

You take a photo of the London Eye.
Likely to be useful to someone planning to plant a bomb on it.

etc.

Almost any photo of an urban public place could be considered as potentaily useful - which is where the wording is just to broad. It does not require the office to have suspicion that you may be taking the photo for that purpose, just that it could be useful. The examples imply that you need to be doing so as part of a larger information gatherign excersise, but i'd much rather the actual wording said that as well.
 
Legitimate journalistic activity (such as covering a demonstration for a newspaper) is likely to constitute such an excuse.
Similarly, an innocent tourist or other sight-seer taking a photograph of a police officer is likely to have a reasonable excuse.

Again - "likely" leaves it completely open for them to decide that "likely" doesn't cover you on that occasion.
 
But, equally, removing the word "likely" shuts the door entirely. There are very few laws that are "absolute" offences. Most criminal laws allow for degrees of "reasonable-ness" to some degree or other.

Firstly, I should point out that I don't work in counter-terrorism. I'm an ordinary response officer, the sort that shows up when you dial 999 - not one who spends weeks on end in unmarked vehicles weeing through a hole in the floor and looking at people through very long lenses.

Fictitious Example 1: Animal Rights News decides to distribute names, addresses and photographs of officers in its monthly publication with a view to encouraging activists to target their homes.

Fictitious Example 2: Omar is taking tourist photographs of a particular police officer. He is being paid several thousand pounds for his work by a group under investigation by the security services, and has been told to document his patrol route.

Example 1 would be considered "legitimate" by supporters of the group. I think it is fair to say that the majority of people would say that it isn't. If, however, journalistic activity was a cast-iron rock-solid 100% watertight defence, then the people in this example would be untouchable - despite the fact that their activity is likely to cause harm.

Example 2 is a little more delicate, but the main point I am trying to make is that such an arrest would only occur where there was other corroborative evidence to suggest that such an arrest was necessary; after all, it isn't an offence to photograph a police officer in itself. If the photography law did not exist, then we would have to work with very hazy Conspiracy evidence - during which time Omar could have handed over all his photographs - and it is unlikely that we would be able to do anything at the early planning stage of a plot.

It's difficult to trust the law - I appreciate that - but so far I haven't heard of any arrests being made using it, and the average copper really does have better things to do than arrest a tourist on the half chance that they might be a terrorist.
 
It's not just the law, there are many jobsworths and Little Hitlers who are either ignorant of the rules or laws, or, more than likely dont care and will hassle an innocent Togger "because they can".
The same crap happens to trainspotters at stations too.
 
But, equally, removing the word "likely" shuts the door entirely. There are very few laws that are "absolute" offences. Most criminal laws allow for degrees of "reasonable-ness" to some degree or other.

Firstly, I should point out that I don't work in counter-terrorism. I'm an ordinary response officer, the sort that shows up when you dial 999 - not one who spends weeks on end in unmarked vehicles weeing through a hole in the floor and looking at people through very long lenses.

Fictitious Example 1: Animal Rights News decides to distribute names, addresses and photographs of officers in its monthly publication with a view to encouraging activists to target their homes.

Fictitious Example 2: Omar is taking tourist photographs of a particular police officer. He is being paid several thousand pounds for his work by a group under investigation by the security services, and has been told to document his patrol route.

Example 1 would be considered "legitimate" by supporters of the group. I think it is fair to say that the majority of people would say that it isn't. If, however, journalistic activity was a cast-iron rock-solid 100% watertight defence, then the people in this example would be untouchable - despite the fact that their activity is likely to cause harm.

Example 2 is a little more delicate, but the main point I am trying to make is that such an arrest would only occur where there was other corroborative evidence to suggest that such an arrest was necessary; after all, it isn't an offence to photograph a police officer in itself. If the photography law did not exist, then we would have to work with very hazy Conspiracy evidence - during which time Omar could have handed over all his photographs - and it is unlikely that we would be able to do anything at the early planning stage of a plot.

It's difficult to trust the law - I appreciate that - but so far I haven't heard of any arrests being made using it, and the average copper really does have better things to do than arrest a tourist on the half chance that they might be a terrorist.

Sadly recent problems suggest that many police are using it as a "blanket" stop all photography cop out (excuse the pun)
 
Sadly recent problems suggest that many police are using it as a "blanket" stop all photography cop out (excuse the pun)

I think you are confusing s44 stops (which have been discussed in many other threads, and indeed there is a sticky at the top of this forum) with s58A arrests. No doubt some officers have misinterpreted s58A and stopped people taking pictures, but that is exactly what this sort of clarification is meant to prevent in future. I'm not sure what else we can do. We don't make the laws, so all we can do is try to make it is clear as possible for officers how best to use them.

I believe you'll find far more trouble coming from private security guards and their ilk than the average copper.
 
My interpretation of:
which is of a kind likely to be useful to a person committing or preparing an act of terrorism

Is that it is only likely to be useful to a person committing or preparing an act of terrorism if it is in the possesion of such a person. Equally, a crowbar is a tool likely to be useful to a person committing a breaking and entering offence but a law abiding person having a crowbar in their shed does not fall into that category.

The average photographer is far more likely to have problems with an over-zealous officer mis-using the law than they are to actually fall foul of the law.

Remember that in just about every case you have ever heard about or seen on TV, the police have issued an apology and no charge has been made.

I agree with Mr Plod (above) that we are far more likely to run into jobsworth security guards than we are to have any trouble with police officers.


Steve.
 
It's difficult to trust the law - I appreciate that - but so far I haven't heard of any arrests being made using it, and the average copper really does have better things to do than arrest a tourist on the half chance that they might be a terrorist.

It's good to read the views from the other side of the fence.

I remember, not too long ago, reading an article about somebody taking photographs of a Police officer driving his van the wrong way down a one-way street who then proceeded to enter the local chippy. The police officer spotted the togger and arrested him insisting that he 'assaulted him with the camera'.

The worrying thing is, it's believable and not at all suprising. Although it is a bit sickening to think that these people are the ones whom should be upholding the law and not creating their own. Living in a small town and being the son to a convenience store owner I myself have witnessed the corruption and the attitude of certain officers when it comes to shoplifters etc (I am in noway saying that all police officers are like this).

When I'm out togging and there's children present, I get un-easy and the camera goes away. I know it shouldn't as I'm not a Paedophile but it isn't the point, my life would be ruined if one adult thought I looked suspicious and rang the police. I shouldn't get the same feeling when taking pictures near/around Police officers and the like but I'm afraid I do and I can't help it. It's a little nervewracking when you're just trying to persue a hobby and the Police officers are giving you the eye and you know full well what they are thinking.

I'm one to avoid confrontation completely rather than be confronted and have to defend myself, afterall, I thought that this country stood for 'innocent until proven guilty'? Not 'guilty until proven otherwise'.
 
I think you are confusing s44 stops (which have been discussed in many other threads, and indeed there is a sticky at the top of this forum) with s58A arrests. No doubt some officers have misinterpreted s58A and stopped people taking pictures, but that is exactly what this sort of clarification is meant to prevent in future. I'm not sure what else we can do. We don't make the laws, so all we can do is try to make it is clear as possible for officers how best to use them.

I believe you'll find far more trouble coming from private security guards and their ilk than the average copper.

Ahhh, yes I am getting the two mixed, and I argree at least it's a step in the right direction.
 
Back
Top