One of my pictures used without my say.

Messages
411
Name
Darran
Edit My Images
Yes
Hello,

Some of you may know I take photographs at the Belfast Giants Ice Hockey games over here just as a fan from high up in the stands.

Today I was sent a link to The Newcastle Vipers website

http://www.vipershockey.co.uk/latest-headlines/the-circus-is-coming

Now when I saw that I though it looked very familiar so I checked my Flickr photos and hey presto

http://www.flickr.com/photos/darrangilpin/3240193230/sizes/l/

They have used my photo without asking my permission or contacting me in anyway.

This photo is on flyers and poster around Newcastle and being used to promote the up coming game. You can even download a copy of it on their site.

Now for a start since I sit high up and only shoot with an F4L lens the quality isn't that great but still to me it doesn't matter.

Can I do anything about this or is it tough luck since I uploaded onto a site where anyone can view and use download pictures?

Any help is appreciated.
 
As you have reserved all rights then I think they've nary a leg to stand on. I think 1st off you need to send them a letter explaining your dissatisfaction, enclosing an invoice for the use of the picture and the formats you're giving them licence for. As they've already produced the promo material I think there's a good chance they'll pay up...
 
Sorry, I thought I had deleted it from there.

I had posted in there origianally in error. Can Admin delete either this one or the one from The Sports section please.
 
As you have reserved all rights then I think they've nary a leg to stand on. I think 1st off you need to send them a letter explaining your dissatisfaction, enclosing an invoice for the use of the picture and the formats you're giving them licence for. As they've already produced the promo material I think there's a good chance they'll pay up...

I totally agree... Draft a letter and make sure you include a fair price for the advertising licence for all the uses they've already had. The same sort of licence for a shot from Alamy would be around £200-£500 so I'd hit them with something in the middle. :thumbs:
 
The same sort of licence for a shot from Alamy would be around £200-£500 so I'd hit them with something in the middle. :thumbs:
Why?

A fair price would be one you gave them to use the picture with your consent. I'd hit them with an unfair one and negotiate down if and when necessary.
 
This is where I am clueless regarding what I do as different folks seem to having major differing ideas.

Plus the fact the Newcastle Vipers main sponsor is a Solictors firm. :rules:
 
You might find that all rights to the image belong to the league as part of the conditions of entry to the stadium. Whilst you own the copyright they might own the rights.
 
Considering how widespread this picture is being used I'd charge them WAY over the typical £250-£500 fee - stick an extra 0 on the end and that might stop them stealing pictures in future.

Even ask for a commision of ticket sales as you've helped to generate interest
 
You could invoice them obviously, but I think you should think a little out of the box. You could use this opportunity to get yourself some benefits rather than a few quid for the use of the image.

For example, you may be able to wangle yourself better access to the games and therefore enable you to get even better shots. You may end up with a good source of photographic opportunities and may be customers here if you play your cards right.

So think about what you do before you rush at it.
 
I may email The Giants official photographer and see what he states. I know whenever his photos are used on any other sites around the league they have the credit to him on them and vice versa when the Giants get pictures from other league clubs.
 
Don't be intimidated by the sponors being solicitors. If they have used your shot without the relevant permission the should pay the going rate, plus some for you having to chase the payment.
 
Considering how widespread this picture is being used I'd charge them WAY over the typical £250-£500 fee - stick an extra 0 on the end and that might stop them stealing pictures in future.

Even ask for a commision of ticket sales as you've helped to generate interest


Are you having a laugh? They'll just apologise, and take the picture down and may be send him a couple of free tickets at best.
 
You could invoice them obviously, but I think you should think a little out of the box. You could use this opportunity to get yourself some benefits rather than a few quid for the use of the image.

For example, you may be able to wangle yourself better access to the games and therefore enable you to get even better shots. You may end up with a good source of photographic opportunities and may be customers here if you play your cards right.

So think about what you do before you rush at it.


The Belfast Giants GM said no to that last season when I asked regarding a press pass to get down to the plexi in the corners and behind the goals etc.

He is happy for fans to take photos from the stands and that's it as they have their own Official tog on the Giants Bench.

As this is an away game and I am not travelling due to the cost involved it's unlikely that route would work, but I do understand where you are coming from.
 
I may email The Giants official photographer and see what he states. I know whenever his photos are used on any other sites around the league they have the credit to him on them and vice versa when the Giants get pictures from other league clubs.



Don't e-mail him, ring him and arrange to go and see him. Get your personality and enthusiasm for sports photography over to him. Use this as a sort of sales opportunity. Get in there man!
 
There's a very useful site called www.own-it.org which has lots of useful IP information on it. You may have to register but its free.

They even have a free advice service using, I think, trained (but not necessarily qualified ) IP people.

I think in the first instance I would contact the culprits, and tell them that you are taking legal advice.

Give them a while to think it through, during which time you DO take legal advice and go back fully armed.
 
I am not a professional tog though.

I have received information though in the last few minutes from someone who contacted a friend in The Vipers org that the Belfast Giants were asked for the photo and they approved it.

Time to start plastering watermarks over everything in that case.

Looks like I am beat on this one and all I can do is convey my dissapointment to The Giants for not contacting me or asking for approval.

For now..looks like case closed.
 
I am not a professional tog though.

I have received information though in the last few minutes from someone who contacted a friend in The Vipers org that the Belfast Giants were asked for the photo and they approved it.

Time to start plastering watermarks over everything in that case.

Looks like I am beat on this one and all I can do is convey my dissapointment to The Giants for not contacting me or asking for approval.

For now..looks like case closed.

No it's not. It's your copyright and the Giants have no right to give it away unless a condition of entry to the venue means that they grab all copyright of any images. Check into it.

I used to be the Media Manager at the London Knights and we had no such controls over images. The only thing I clamped down on was togs selling photos in the Arena bars after the games as that was taking revenue from our official tog.
 
Cheers for the info.

Back in the days I shot on film I got some cracking shots in the Docklands arena on my trip over there. Really miss the place and no London team.
 
I am not a professional tog though.

I have received information though in the last few minutes from someone who contacted a friend in The Vipers org that the Belfast Giants were asked for the photo and they approved it.

Time to start plastering watermarks over everything in that case.

Looks like I am beat on this one and all I can do is convey my dissapointment to The Giants for not contacting me or asking for approval.

For now..looks like case closed.

It doesn't make any difference if you're a pro or not. It is Breach of Copyright pure and simple. Take advice!
 
Plus the fact the Newcastle Vipers main sponsor is a Solictors firm. :rules:

In my mind, this is even more reason to send an invoice. Admittedly, they have the power and legal ability to fight the case, but having their name associated with illegal activity? For a law firm, that is a big no-no.

Send an invoice as though they were a normal customer, then call them to make an appointment to discuss further work. :D

I have one question though - if they have their own photographer, why wouldn't they use one of his pics? If I was their tog, I'd be pretty peeved...
 
It doesn't make any difference if you're a pro or not. It is Breach of Copyright pure and simple. Take advice!

:plusone:

As stated, unless its a condition of entry, the Giants have no right to allow use of the image as its not their copyrights or licence to allow use of.

Contact someone at the giants and ask if they have something like copyrights grabs for allowing photographic use in the stadium, if they dont, then contact them and ask for compensation for "giving away" your image to someone, and then contact the Vipers about the usage licence that you are selling them.
 
"Q Can I bring cameras into the Arena?
The use of cameras in the Arena varies depending on the event. Professional cameras, audio and visual recording of a show is not permitted and is prohibited at all times.

Cameras are allowed during Ice Hockey games. The use of flash photography is prohibited during play.

With regards to concerts, standard personal cameras are usually permitted unless stated otherwise by the Promoter. Please contact Odyssey Arena on 028 9076 6000 to ask if cameras are permitted at the event you will be attending.

Flash photography is prohibited during 'theatre style' shows."



So is a "professional" camera allowed during a hockey game? As with most venues does professional = SLR?

Either way they broke your copyright, but their response might change significantly depending on the answer to the above questions
 
Well for the last few seasons I have shot with a 20D with security and the G Org happy enough.

I am not the only fan shooting pics, other Canon and Nikon users also have no problem. The Giants play at home tomorrow night so I may see if I can speak to the GM.
 
I am not the only fan shooting pics, other Canon and Nikon users also have no problem. The Giants play at home tomorrow night so I may see if I can speak to the GM.

I think that the Giants would have given permission to use the shot without knowing anything about copyright. Even in the days of the Ice Hockey Superleague most clubs were pretty poorly run.

Oh, and short sponsors mean nothing. The Knights were 'sponsored' by the Evening Standard who committed to include a certain amount of column inches in the paper each week in exchange for shirt sponsorship. We were usually lucky to get two inches of a match report written by one of the lads who laid out the racing pages and who worte it because he was a fan.
 
The 'professional' restriction refers to people making money out of photos they've taken, at the expense of the official photographers. Nothing to do with the type of camera. But these restrictive clauses are very hard to enforce and often have no legal status at all.

Bottom line is, I think, that they have made a simple cock up. Which is not uncommon at all. They owe you, but how you play it from here is surely not just a case of thinking up a high fee and sending them a bill. You could probably do that, if you want a lot of hassle and possibly get your camera taken off you in future.

Ask yourself honestly what you would have said if they had contacted you first about this pic. Maybe you would have been happy for a credit and no fee! Maybe not. Obviously they can't give you a retrospective credit, so some form of 'compensation' package is in order.

Would it not suit both you and them if you got better photo access to games? If you keep it sweet, you could play this situation to both your advantage and theirs. Far better way than upsetting everybody for the sake of a couple of hundred quid, then getting you and you cameras banned.

Try not to get emotional about having been 'ripped off' and wanting some kind of moral payback - it was just a mistake. I think you've actually been quite lucky in getting your picture used so prominently, great compliment, so stick it in your portfolio and try and work it so that it is the first of many - for which you might even get paid a few quid, for doing what you obviously enjoy. Result!
 
I fully agree, if they had of asked me I would have been delighted to offer it to them for my name in the programme, screens etc and maybe if I get to travel to a Vipers game in Newcastle I can ask for the oppurtunity to photograph from the benches etc.

I certaintly don't want to tread on The Giants toes with be being firstly and foremostly a fan before a photographer.

Now to get my hands on one of the posters they have put up in it's full glossy goodness.
 
1st of all you need to no the copyright policy of the Belfast Giants, It might be like football and they might own the copyright for any pictures taken in the ground. The FA own the copyright of any pictures taken in a stadium that is part of any of the football leagues. So you might find even though you took the picture, you didn't have permission and you don't own the copyright.
 
Do you really? They went onto Flickr and nick a photo, ignoring all the caveats about copyright listed on that site. At best they been negligent, at worse they're thieves.

Yes, I do think it's a simple cock-up. Knowingly or not, rightly or wrongly, someone made a stupid mistake. It happens. And given what Darran has already said, not that much of a surprise. Even people on here are confused about copyright. As Darran says: "Trust me the Elite League is an utter farce, on and off the ice."

And Jerry, why should Darran take legal advice? Assuming we know all the facts here, and they don't seem to be in any doubt, no legal bod is going to tell him anything he has not already been told here, for free. He'll just get a bill, which will gobble any fee he might get for the picture, and if he then sends a solicitor's letter he'll get an even bigger fee and cause instant upset with the Elite League.

From your post here and elswhere you seem to be running a personal agenda against people using cheap/free photography in a manner which you have a problem with. The truth is that most photographs today do not have a high intrinsic value, and they are swapped and traded quite casually as not being worth much, and generally disposable. That may be right or wrong in your opinion, but that is the value society has put on it and you can resist it as much as you like, but you'll only get a sore head and won't it change anything.

Much better to go with the flow, get credit where credit is due, make a few pounds, and enjoy your picture taking. Try to turn this thing into an opportunity. Not worth making a fuss and getting upset about.
 
Yes, I do think it's a simple cock-up. Knowingly or not, rightly or wrongly, someone made a stupid mistake. It happens. And given what Darran has already said, not that much of a surprise. Even people on here are confused about copyright. As Darran says: "Trust me the Elite League is an utter farce, on and off the ice."

And Jerry, why should Darran take legal advice? Assuming we know all the facts here, and they don't seem to be in any doubt, no legal bod is going to tell him anything he has not already been told here, for free. He'll just get a bill, which will gobble any fee he might get for the picture, and if he then sends a solicitor's letter he'll get an even bigger fee and cause instant upset with the Elite League.

From your post here and elswhere you seem to be running a personal agenda against people using cheap/free photography in a manner which you have a problem with. The truth is that most photographs today do not have a high intrinsic value, and they are swapped and traded quite casually as not being worth much, and generally disposable. That may be right or wrong in your opinion, but that is the value society has put on it and you can resist it as much as you like, but you'll only get a sore head and won't it change anything.

Much better to go with the flow, get credit where credit is due, make a few pounds, and enjoy your picture taking. Try to turn this thing into an opportunity. Not worth making a fuss and getting upset about.

darran is being given all sorts of advice here, some of which makes sense, some of which doesn't. He posted because his picture had been used illegally, so I suggested he needed legal advice so that he could then make an informed decision for himself about what to do.

If he were try the website link I suggested he could get that advice free of charge - which is why I said "quasi-legal".

I certainly do have a problem with Breach of Copyright, which is what this appears to be.
 
Back
Top