Painting my photo to sell - allowed?

Scenario: I wander down to the local harbour and paint the boat that moors up alongside, pack up my easel and go home, photographer arrives and takes photograph of the same scene. Who owns the copyright of each.

Never mind the licensing fees the people who make money out of this sort of thing are the lawyers. Are we about to start seeing new ads on TV, PhotgraphLawyers4U.com :lol:
 
Last edited:
Kerioak said:
Where did the artist get your picture from and do you have any copyright notice on it so that it is easy to contact you? Not that this should make a difference.

As a Wildlife POTY winner it's been fairly wildly published, so access to the photo would have been relatively easy.
 
Scenario: I wander down to the local harbour and paint the boat that moors up alongside, pack up my easel and go home, photographer arrives and takes photograph of the same scene. Who owns the copyright of each.

Never mind the licensing fees the people who make money out of this sort of thing are the lawyers. Are we about to start seeing new ads on TV, PhotgraphLawyers4U.com :lol:

*shrug* it isent a perfect system by any stretch of the imagination (though, itd be discernably different anyways, as the lighting and reletive position of elements would have changed) but any legal system is at best a 'neccecery evil' and its the system that is there, so you either work with it, and make the most of what is there, or you dont, and the people willing to work -with- the system will have a much more sucessful time, given the same opportunities, and youl fall behind.

life doesent really reward idealism, regretably
 
artyman said:
Scenario: I wander down to the local harbour and paint the boat that moors up alongside, pack up my easel and go home, photographer arrives and takes photograph of the same scene. Who owns the copyright of each.

Never mind the licensing fees the people who make money out of this sort of thing are the lawyers. Are we about to start seeing new ads on TV, PhotgraphLawyers4U.com :lol:

Ken, if it were a land/seascape I'd completely agree with you, but as you'd know from your own wildlife work most environmental images are unique in their detail of setting, pose, light etc.

When you factor in the knowledge that this photograph was an international award winner, matters become a bit more clear cut.

As the image is being sold fairly locally to Will, I'd be interested to know if the sales patter associated with the painting referenced the original photograph!
 
Just as a matter of interest is this an oil painting hand painted, or a canvas type thing with an oil painting effect added to look like an oin painting, it seems odd the artist would leave in the wire and things, most artists change a picture slightly so as not to be obvious it's been copied.
 
Thanks for all the replies above, can't reply to all atm but I won't be going straight in all guns blazing!

However, if it comes to it I have that option.

swanseamale47 said:
Just as a matter of interest is this an oil painting hand painted, or a canvas type thing with an oil painting effect added to look like an oin painting, it seems odd the artist would leave in the wire and things, most artists change a picture slightly so as not to be obvious it's been copied.

It's just such a blatant copy there are no changes at all. Strange really.
 
I'm surprised the 'artist' would have left in something as distracting as a wire which makes me wonder whether it isn't a photoshopped print of your original work using some artsy plugin and banged out on to a canvas.

I'd be going down there to see whether it was an actual hand painted copy with a cease and desist letter!
 
It's a very average painting so it'll probably just be left in this case.


I'm surprised the 'artist' would have left in something as distracting as a wire which makes me wonder whether it isn't a photoshopped print of your original work using some artsy plugin and banged out on to a canvas.

I'd be going down there to see whether it was an actual hand painted copy with a cease and desist letter!

Problem is getting there, it's the other side of the country from me.
 
Last edited:
Will
I don't know about any of the legal stuff, but I had a look at your website and you have some cracking wildlife shots there. Don't suppose the squirrel in question has an intriguing look to it has it?

If its the one I'm thinking it is, then I too would be rather upset, its a great capture.

Oh, and well done for all your stuff, at 16 you are doing fine, keep up the good work.


Thank you very much. And yes that's the one!
 
You could ring up the gallery where it is displayed and pretending to be an interested potential purchaser and asking whether it was an actual painting or just a canvas print.... and ask whether the artist has similar work for sale...
 
You could ring up the gallery where it is displayed and pretending to be an interested potential purchaser and asking whether it was an actual painting or just a canvas print.... and ask whether the artist has similar work for sale...

Yeah I'll be doing this, so far I know "Tea room in Hailsham, East Sussex". Bit of a problem...

Anyone in Hailsham?
 
In the first instance, I think you would need to send a cease and desist letter, order them to destroy all unlicensed copies of your photo, and confirm to you in writing that they have done that.

If they fail to do anything about it, then sue them.
 
I wonder if it is a one off or is there other copied work, perhaphs other images from whereever he got your image.
 
Scenario: I wander down to the local harbour and paint the boat that moors up alongside, pack up my easel and go home, photographer arrives and takes photograph of the same scene. Who owns the copyright of each.

You each own copyright to your own work. Completely different situation.
 
Scenario: I wander down to the local harbour and paint the boat that moors up alongside, pack up my easel and go home, photographer arrives and takes photograph of the same scene. Who owns the copyright of each.

Never mind the licensing fees the people who make money out of this sort of thing are the lawyers. Are we about to start seeing new ads on TV, PhotgraphLawyers4U.com :lol:

With respect, as an artist and photographer, I'm amazed that you have to ask that question. No wonder we have problems with copyright. In that situation, the copyright exists separately and compeletely independently in both works.

The painting is here:
https://fbcdn-sphotos-a.akamaihd.ne...0104861004149_566554148_6368971_4768744_n.jpg

It's nothing major, it's selling for £30 or something in a tea room but I still don't know about prints etc.
It's the principal, but tbh I may just leave it this time.

Well it doesn't look anything major does it. Perhaps just a local amateur who sells a few bits and bobs and has innocently made a copy.

However, the copyright breach and is as clear as it gets. It's a fraudulent copy. Paintings like that usually are copies of photos as it's almost impossible to paint them for real, though a prudent artists makes a few changes to disguise the fact.

I would at least ask that you be given the original work in settlement. That's how I settled a similar case a few years ago. I worked for a big publishing company and this sort of thing came up on a regular if infrequent basis.

BTW, that photo of the painting is a technical breach of copyright too - yours! Because the painting is the main and only subject in the image. I know that sounds a bit silly but copyright law often is.
 
BTW, that photo of the painting is a technical breach of copyright too - yours! Because the painting is the main and only subject in the image. I know that sounds a bit silly but copyright law often is.

Thought it might be, off it goes again! ahah.
Anyway - I'm going to just leave it I think, can't be bothered with the hassel.
 
In my limited experience of oil painting you don't put a mat over them, I'd suggest it more lightly an oil painting effect of some sort.
 
It could be water colour, acrylic, gouache or pastels. It's not very good whatever it is.
 
Last edited:
Hey Will I can't say anything about the predicament you are in with this photo and painting but what I would say, is the few dollars you receive from Adsense on your business website worth the lack of professionalism it portrays?
 
If you sold a photo of a building would you expect the architect who designed it to get upset.

FWIW, photographs of buildings are specifically excluded as infringement by Section 62 of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988

CDPA 1988 said:
62 Representation of certain artistic works on public display.

(1) This section applies to—

(a) buildings, and

(b) sculptures, models for buildings and works of artistic craftsmanship, if permanently situated in a public place or in premises open to the public.
​
(2) The copyright in such a work is not infringed by—

(a) making a graphic work representing it,

(b) making a photograph or film of it, or

(c) [making a broadcast of] a visual image of it.
​
(3) Nor is the copyright infringed by the issue to the public of copies, or the [communication to the public], of anything whose making was, by virtue of this section, not an infringement of the copyright.
 
Last edited:
Kerioak said:
I am about 25 minutes away, I know we do have a member who is closer and regularly goes to Hailsham so if you send me the details I can speak to her

Ah thats good thanks. Not sure which cafe it is atm but hopefully I will know tomorrow.

rogermbyrne said:
Hey Will I can't say anything about the predicament you are in with this photo and painting but what I would say, is the few dollars you receive from Adsense on your business website worth the lack of professionalism it portrays?

It's not - and the advert is going with the new website design coming out within the week :)
 
Well looking at the quality of the painting I would get a good print done along with a bit of a blog about it being an original and winning photo of the comp, and ask the Tea room owners if they would care to put it up on their wall for sale for £20 :lol:
 
107 replies, and noone's asked..

What's the squirrel's position on all this? Was this a TFP/CD arrangement?
 
I read the thread last night, and had a thought on it this morning.

I grew up not far from Hailsham, and I remember my grandparents learning to paint. One of the things they were taught was to take a photo of a landscape they wanted to paint (if they did not have enough time complete the painting it in-situ) and then use that to paint from when back home.

It is possible that the artist who made this copy has done so in complete ignorance of the laws on copyright, and simply thought "that's nice, I'll paint it".

While I am in no way condoning copyright violation in this way, it may be worth considering this when making any approach - a polite 'Excuse me, did you realise...' may yield a much more positive result than threats of legal action (which can always be used to escalate, if necessary).
 
I read the thread last night, and had a thought on it this morning.

I grew up not far from Hailsham, and I remember my grandparents learning to paint. One of the things they were taught was to take a photo of a landscape they wanted to paint (if they did not have enough time complete the painting it in-situ) and then use that to paint from when back home.

It is possible that the artist who made this copy has done so in complete ignorance of the laws on copyright, and simply thought "that's nice, I'll paint it".

While I am in no way condoning copyright violation in this way, it may be worth considering this when making any approach - a polite 'Excuse me, did you realise...' may yield a much more positive result than threats of legal action (which can always be used to escalate, if necessary).

If this was a picture that was at home, intended for domestic display only, then I might be inclinded to agree with you; but available for commercial sale in a third party premises? Not a chance!
 
If this was a picture that was at home, intended for domestic display only, then I might be inclinded to agree with you; but available for commercial sale in a third party premises? Not a chance!

If it were in a gallery, I would agree with you that it would be very likely have been done in full knowledge of the copyright implications. However, this is for sale in a 'Tea Room' according to earlier posts - making the chance that the picture is done by a friend of the owner, who thought it looked nice, etc. much higher!
 

And therefore you cannot sue anybody or be sued.

Just out of interest, is it possible that the painting is actually a digital one? there's plenty of software available to make photos look like paintings...
 
I read the thread last night, and had a thought on it this morning.

I grew up not far from Hailsham, and I remember my grandparents learning to paint. One of the things they were taught was to take a photo of a landscape they wanted to paint (if they did not have enough time complete the painting it in-situ) and then use that to paint from when back home.

It is possible that the artist who made this copy has done so in complete ignorance of the laws on copyright, and simply thought "that's nice, I'll paint it".

While I am in no way condoning copyright violation in this way, it may be worth considering this when making any approach - a polite 'Excuse me, did you realise...' may yield a much more positive result than threats of legal action (which can always be used to escalate, if necessary).

Jack vetriano paints only from photographs, but e does go and take his own....
 
Mole hill >>>>>>>>> Mountain!!

I can't believe the views of some of the people in this thread!!

Rob - couldn't agree more.

How is this guy supposed to paint a bloody squirrel anyway? They don't hang around for long. It's not as if he's stealing sales or anything.

There are probably millions of paintings all over the world that have been taken from photographs. They are a completely different media. Treat it as a compliment to the quality of your work and move on.

I'm actually doing my own head in now writing in this thread. :D
 
Back
Top