Painting my photo to sell - allowed?

Messages
2,004
Name
Will
Edit My Images
No
Somebody has painted an exact replica of one of my award winning red squirrel photographs and put it for sale. This is the second occurrence.

What are the laws on this. are they allowed to paint and sell without permission or what? Also - if there are any restrictions, any links to the laws would be appreciated thanks.
 
Last edited:
There was a thread on this recently. It is illegal to copy an image like this - you would need to prove that it's exact but I guesss you could. I'll see if I can locate the thread. It was entitled Forth Road Bridge.
 
WillNicholls said:
Some buildings require a license to photograph to sell or for public display, such as the Eiffel tower.

I've heard this painting exact replicas isn't allowed but I may be wrong?

The Eiffel Tower doesn't require permission.

The lighting display does however, as it is classed as an original work.
 
Strictly from a personal perspective I don't think something like this would annoy me many things do annoy me but in this case I also think that the artist could argue that their artistic skills were required for the piece to be created, in a similar vain if you were to take a photo of a famous vista you had seen painted in the past could not the artist of the original painting argue you had copied them, or to look at it another way I go and take x picture a little while later you are in the same location and take the same image could I get annoyed at you for copying me and then send you a bill???

Matt
MWHCVT
 
uk copywrite law doesent have a right of adaption for 'artistic works'

meaning, if someone has created a copy of the image, in any capacity, without demonstrating 'suitable creative input' it counts as under the original copywrite

so, if hes selling an identical picture, just painted, the same law applies as if he was selling your photograph

slightely more difficult to prove, mind, but as far as im aware, yes, hes breaching copywrite (so long as it IS exact)
 
Strictly from a personal perspective I don't think something like this would annoy me many things do annoy me but in this case I also think that the artist could argue that their artistic skills were required for the piece to be created, in a similar vain if you were to take a photo of a famous vista you had seen painted in the past could not the artist of the original painting argue you had copied them, or to look at it another way I go and take x picture a little while later you are in the same location and take the same image could I get annoyed at you for copying me and then send you a bill???

Matt
MWHCVT

if you copy an original painting, it counts as a breach as copywrite. including copywrited works in photographs are only non-sueable if its ruled incidental

and you can send anyone you like a bill, no legal obligation to pay it unless mandated by the courts though - and youd need to prove your work was created before his, anyway :P so if you tried, he probably turn around and counter sue and (legally) be in the right :P
 
in that can you can follow the normal legal channels - but if negotions with the man (remember, if you get a cut, hes actually made you money, so it could work out well for you) fail, consult a lawyer, and inform them before actually getting one to take it straight to the courts - i might know what im talking about, but dont start the habit of taking legal advice from strangers on the internet - no ones infallible, but at least with a lawyer its a malpractise issue if you lose out because of them

best of luck
 
personally id be after a retroactive liscensing fee - thats quite literally what theyd need to do what there doing legally - and if they play it nice with that, well, youve just had an inadvertant customer, so you win

and even if you do chose to seek no compensation, and do ask them to cease, there is a chance they just wont, so if you want it to stop sueing might be your only option

the law only works if you get it involved, afterall

though to be honest, its your picture, you should be doing whatever you want to do about it personally
 
I won't be suing or anything, just asking them to cease it's sales. Or should I be doing something else?

If you feel strongly enough to do the research into the laws which this might break then why do you not feel strongly enough to pursue compensation?

If it were the case that the painter could counter-sue you, the "Gonna stop doing that but I'm not bothered enough to sue you" attitude might make you look like an easy target.

Any chance of seeing the 2 images?
 
I can post the images. However - will I be in a worse position if I post a photo of the painting?

And my reasons are: it's a hassle. I'm 16, and personally I can't afford to go to court. My parents don't see the full situation and think I should just take it as a compliment...

I think asking for a license fee would be good. Could I not also make them sign a contract declaring the cease of production of this and future images?
 
depends - id have to look it up, and might take a fair bit of time - can you post a link to the site he is advertising it on? that circumvents any copywrite issues you might be incurring posting it here

asking for a liscencse fee is probably the best option, but dont let on you wont go to court or hel laugh you away. might even be better to say you are looking into legal action, not a lie, either (not that there is any law about lying)

how old do you look? if you meet him in person to collect and you look sixteen its more likely to not work - at your age i looked like an adult, and i knew a lot of other people that did - so that might not be a problem

and you could get him to sign a contract, but unless the contract has a specific fee included, there is no point, because making someone promise to obey the law doesent increase the penalty if they then dont - so its a bit pointless really
 
It's not online, I don't know yet I need to find the name out. A relative sent me a photo of the painting and I am waiting for this information.

If I asked for a contract to be signed agreeing to damages of say £100 (standard licensing fee probably?) and prohibiting further action then is that better? They are less likely to break a contract that exists than some copyright law when I can't track what they do.

As I'm 16, I can legally sign contracts so my age wouldn't be a problem I don't think. The image is so well known now that I don't see any difficulties.
 
I don't know yet. I am going to ring up and ask this information tomorrow probably.

Do you know how much he is selling for? In fact do you know if he is selling the image?

You may be making a mountain out of a molehill. Just relax until you have the full facts on the matter and then work from there.
 
I can post the images. However - will I be in a worse position if I post a photo of the painting?

And my reasons are: it's a hassle. I'm 16, and personally I can't afford to go to court. My parents don't see the full situation and think I should just take it as a compliment...

I think asking for a license fee would be good. Could I not also make them sign a contract declaring the cease of production of this and future images?

If the painting is online just post a link.

Lets put it this way, if I was the painter (who has already copied your image - twice - and made money from this activity) and you approached me asking me to stop selling a painting which you think you could prove was a copy of one of your photos and you gave me the slightest hint that you were a teenager, couldn't afford to take me to court etc I'd be immediately checking out my options for countersuing and i'd have £ signs where my eyes were. If you then had the audacity to ask me for a license fee - but still don't have the time or money to take me to court - I may think it rude to not take you for every penny you have.
 
It's not online, I don't know yet I need to find the name out. A relative sent me a photo of the painting and I am waiting for this information.

If I asked for a contract to be signed agreeing to damages of say £100 (standard licensing fee probably?) and prohibiting further action then is that better? They are less likely to break a contract that exists than some copyright law when I can't track what they do.

As I'm 16, I can legally sign contracts so my age wouldn't be a problem I don't think. The image is so well known now that I don't see any difficulties.

How do you imagine it going when you tell the artist that you know he has painted your photo because your relative has photographed his painting?
 
fixedimage said:
If the painting is online just post a link.

Lets put it this way, if I was the painter (who has already copied your image - twice - and made money from this activity) and you approached me asking me to stop selling a painting which you think you could prove was a copy of one of your photos and you gave me the slightest hint that you were a teenager, couldn't afford to take me to court etc I'd be immediately checking out my options for countersuing and i'd have £ signs where my eyes were. If you then had the audacity to ask me for a license fee - but still don't have the time or money to take me to court - I may think it rude to not take you for every penny you have.

How can you counter sue when it is so obviously my image that you would literally have to be a blind man to not realise the fact?
 
if you can - go down there and either find a phone number or confront directly.

dont do anything to let on to your age or that you cant sue - and just remember, even if its blindingly obvious to you, its still possible that a court wont find it so - they are only human, and i know people who have been shafted in the system before

if you cant take him to court you cant -make- him pay, so its very much a negotiation issue

and i still wouldent acknowledge that someone sent you the picture, involuntary or no, people tend to fight when the law gets involved, and you dont want whatever reletive taken to court
 
How do you imagine it going when you tell the artist that you know he has painted your photo because your relative has photographed his painting?

There's absolutely nothing wrong with that, especially if it has been taken as a photograph of record. Selling it commercially however would be an entirely different matter.
 
If I asked for a contract to be signed agreeing to damages of say £100 (standard licensing fee probably?) and prohibiting further action then is that better? They are less likely to break a contract that exists than some copyright law when I can't track what they do.

thats a loaded question, technically there is no standard liscencing - you arent a professional, but write up a liscensing contract giving him say five years of saleable use, and demand a couple of hundred and a cut of profits if its high volume sales - if its one picture, charge say thirty to fourty percent of what hes selling it for

you will have to negotiate, and you will have to basically take what you given because of your situation - however dont appear too eager or hel realise and suddenly change his mind
 
Yeah I see. But now this thread is here I can't deny it.

you didnt name names so its not provable - joys of the system, could be another image in another gallery

do keep us posted though, im interested in how it turns out
 
yeah, that sounds perfectly fine

the agency sounds ideal, and it gives you a starting board

if you dont want ot liscense the image out, then damages and prohitibiting further use is probably your best bet - but also the worst from their perspective, so they are less likely to just go with it

and you do realise i mean a non exclusive contract, right?
 
How can you counter sue when it is so obviously my image that you would literally have to be a blind man to not realise the fact?

It can be as obvious as you like but I'd imagine that until you have a way to legally prove the painting is a copy of your image and not just a painting of a scene that bears an uncanny likeness then there will be lawyers out there who would be happy to take a young adult like yourself to court and tear you to shreds.
 
Or I could say the fee be in damages and the contract prohibit further use?

There is no way I will license this image out. Anyway - I have an agency and they have always said they can get involved with things if needed.

I'd definitely get your agency involved.
They will likely have an entire department of people who know this type of law inside out and they will have the time/money to take it to court on your behalf.
 
fixedimage said:
It can be as obvious as you like but I'd imagine that until you have a way to legally prove the painting is a copy of your image and not just a painting of a scene that bears an uncanny likeness then there will be lawyers out there who would be happy to take a young adult like yourself to court and tear you to shreds.

And how can you legally prove it? All the details are there, from the unique blown over ears to the wire wrapped round the post. All the creases in it's fur are correct too.
 
Back
Top