Photographer gets £5000 compensation for police assault

TG.

Messages
6,957
Name
Tel
Edit My Images
No
Not sure if this has already been posted if so mods can delete, but here you go "A photographer who was handcuffed, arrested, cautioned and detained for eight hours for trying to take pictures of a road accident has been awarded more than £5,000 after legal help from the NUJ"...full story HERE
 
Nice result :)
 
This is worrying if the police feel they can arrest a tog for "doing his job" No matter what the outcome the coper must have felt he was in the right and the fact he was held for 8 hours means others in authority did too.
 
This is worrying if the police feel they can arrest a tog for "doing his job" No matter what the outcome the coper must have felt he was in the right and the fact he was held for 8 hours means others in authority did too.

Well if they keep doing it a lot of other people will be queing up for 5K as well, maybe if they actually followed the law instead of making it up as they go along they wouldn't have had to fork out the money in the first place.
 
I might have to modify my business plan with potential new income streams like that. :D
 
“It’s a great relief that I've been cleared. I was concerned that I’d have a criminal record and a caution hanging over my head when I knew perfectly well that I hadn’t broken the law.”

This was the biggest concern for him and for anyone who is in the same boat. So im glad hes got it all sorted, having a criminal record could/would of really affected his in the future.
 
This was the biggest concern for him and for anyone who is in the same boat. So im glad hes got it all sorted, having a criminal record could/would of really affected his in the future.

Unless he wanted to become an MP or join the police ;)
 
I wonder what would happen if the tog was a amateur/passerby/tourist who doesn't have the might of the NUJ behind them or have the confidence or money to hire solicitors in such a case. A lot of folk would just accept the caution just to get out of the nick, Wonder when the pigs will start pulling our fingernails out to extract a confession...maybe they already do.
 
I wonder what would happen if the tog was a amateur/passerby/tourist who doesn't have the might of the NUJ behind them or have the confidence or money to hire solicitors in such a case. A lot of folk would just accept the caution just to get out of the nick, Wonder when the pigs will start pulling our fingernails out to extract a confession...maybe they already do.

Lets face it, if you're polite enough to police most are polite back. When people start being idiots and extremely defensive, or just plain rude by calling them PIGS etc then the **** will hit the fan. Yes the policeman shouldn't have demanded his camera etc, but you've also no idea what the photographer did.

Perhaps he was another tog that wanted to get his name known, after all, getting arrested with your camera seems like a way of getting your 5 minutes of fame.

I am in no way stating that anyone was right or wrong as we do not know the details, and a blog post just isn't good enough for me. Your PIGS comment just annoyed me.
 
A slightly fuller account on the web site of his solicitors, Thompsons Solicitors

Despite staying behind the police cordon Andrew was approached by a police sergeant who demanded he handed over the pictures and his camera.

Mr Handley explained he was perfectly within his rights to take photographs and contacted his editor who attempted to speak to the officer.

Instead he was arrested. His hands were cuffed behind his back, he was cautioned, had his finger prints and DNA taken. He was then detained for eight hours at Milton Keynes central police station.

According to another story the charge under which he was arrested was "obstructing an officer in the course of duty", which would be consistent with the story (notably it's not a public order offence).

34 years as a newspaper photographer (14 of which with the MK News) suggests that he isn't a, er, 'young punk' trying to grab some limelight.
 
I wonder what would happen if the tog was a amateur/passerby/tourist who doesn't have the might of the NUJ behind them or have the confidence or money to hire solicitors in such a case. A lot of folk would just accept the caution just to get out of the nick, Wonder when the pigs will start pulling our fingernails out to extract a confession...maybe they already do.

Thats an interesting analogy but I think it could have been brought across in a less offensive ("pigs") manner.

So, to hear what people think:

What would have happened if the photographer was joe average without the backing of the NUJ?
 
Hmm. It seems that the Buckinghamshire Police Authority "apologised for the unlawful arrest". This means that they apologised for their officer(s) committing a criminal offence, so can we expect the perpetrator(s), who are known, to be prosecuted? I doubt it.

The police do have a difficult job at times, but I believe there has to be greater criminal and civil liability at a personal level. Officers are engaged, trained and paid to uphold the law, not to abuse it.

FWIW, the police don't pay compensation in these cases. The money comes from the public purse. Neat.
 
I wonder what would happen if the tog was a amateur/passerby/tourist who doesn't have the might of the NUJ behind them or have the confidence or money to hire solicitors in such a case. A lot of folk would just accept the caution just to get out of the nick, Wonder when the pigs will start pulling our fingernails out to extract a confession...maybe they already do.

Pigs, Bizzies, Woodentops, Rossers,The Filth, - interestingly In my line of work I only hear these references from people usually caught on the wrong side of the law.

Now if I made a derogatory comment about Frank and his fellow citizens from North of the Border :nono:, the phone line to the Police Complaints Authority would be in meltdown !!!!

Some would say because I wear the uniform,that I should accept such offensive comments as part and parcel of my job.
Im all for lively debate and very much in favour of defending photographers rights and freedoms.

I have always accepted criticism,where its merited,and on the subject of photographers rights, I agree that the police have been rightly criticised over the actions of a few misguided,uninformed officers.

But to group them together and refer to them generically as 'Pigs' is a bit below the belt.

As an interesting footnote,the Force I work for have just circulated advice about S44 and the stop/search guidlines for people taking photographs.It points out that 99.9% of photographers are law abiding people, just going about their hobby or business.

Rights and freedoms - message received..................over and out

Regards

david700
 
Now if I made a derogatory comment about Frank and his fellow citizens from North of the Border :nono:, the phone line to the Police Complaints Authority would be in meltdown !!!!

probably because it would be illegal to make any such offensive and discriminatory remark on the basis of nationality under Sections 31 and 32 of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 ;)

But to group them together and refer to them generically as 'Pigs' is a bit below the belt.

This, however, is true. Unnecessarily offensive and does no favours to furthering genuine concerns about police behaviour in this context.
 
Not been on the wrong side of the law but what respect they think they should get with the uniform was lost many years ago.
My job also dealing with the public/drunks/junkies, and sometimes folk who are mentally unstable, many a time when I've required assistance from them from threatened assault to being spat on a 999 call usually results in a half hour wait for them to turn up. In nearly 30 years of doing the job The response times I and colleagues have noted is usually around 30 mins, by the time they come the culprits are long gone, joe public does not want the hassle of being a witness either.

Anything to do with violence they always appear to be delays, I was involved in a hit and run where a female had struck my vehicle. Police were called and the local nick was less than a mile away, they never turned up after waiting 45 mins. Yes they got in touch with me via a phone call to my company and asked me to travel to the other side of the city to give a statement, No chance, I told him where I lived and get in his bloody car and come and see me. Never heard of it again and they had all the details given to them

A long time friend witnessed a young copper being badly assaulted from a bunch of thugs, he jumped in to help the young copper just when his backup arrived, my friend got a tanking from the pigs thinking he was responsible for the attack. There was never any apology or thanks for helping their colleague in trouble.

Sorry if I sound a little peed off with the boys in blue but respect is earned, not given with the uniform. And BTW David your
interestingly In my line of work I only hear these references from people usually caught on the wrong side of the law.
Just shows the assumptions of a typical plod, just for the record mine is clean as a whistle, also CRB checks out fine too, requirement of my job.
 
Frank - Im not going to defend bad service or attempt to explain it away.What I will say is, that in 2 years time when I retire, I will walk away knowing that I have done my best for the last 30 years.I joined the job to serve the public,which, to the best of my ability,I have done. And there are many more like me who have done the same.
I replied because a. I find the term 'pig',used generically to describe police officers as offensive.
b. Im fully supportive of the various photographers rights campaigns about S44 and stop and search/account situations that have arisen. Far to many in my opinion.

I dont know what your occupation is, but I wouldn't for one moment thing of denigrating your occupation by the use of an offensive term.

Maybe, as you say,Im a typical plod,but what do you describe as a typical plod ?
Certainly the many hundreds,if not thousands of people I have had contact with over the years,have viewed me as a typical plod. Not one member of the public or victim though, has ever called me a pig.

Regards

david700
 
I might have to modify my business plan with potential new income streams like that. :D

Sounds like a plan :D

Lets face it, if you're polite enough to police most are polite back.

Not necessarily so, i took a photo of a doorman who assaulted me, and he complained to the plod outside subway sandwich shop where the incident happened, to which i was told by the plod i either delete the photo or get arrested for breach of the peace, at the time i was unsure of the law, and didn't fancy a night in a cell, however if the same thing where to happen now i would be happy to be locked up, and take it further, and have a nice new D3s at the end of it for my trouble :D oh and incidentally the incident happened in Milton Keynes, and it's not the first time i've had hassle with MK plod, as have friends of mine,and from personal experience there a total bunch of unprofessional r soles.
 
Back
Top