Photographing a factory production line - your comments noted and final pics chosen

Messages
6,141
Name
Nigel
Edit My Images
Yes
My boss has asked me to take some photos of a couple of basic production lines at our factory with a view to having some 3ftx2ft prints put on the wall in the entrance to the factory.

Instead of the usual normal "static" shots of boxes being hand filled and run through a case packer and stcked onto pallets, I have an idea of introducing some movement into the shots..... something a bit different.

I would like to somehow show the boxes as "ghostly blurs" moving on the conveyor belt using a slow shutter speed. The case packer would remain sharp as this doesnt move.

I would like to see if this effect is also possible with people on the lines aswell and have them as "ghosts" moving around the equipment.

I guess that finding the shutter speed that will produce this effect will probably be a matter of trial and error combined with finding the right aperture, but are there other settings or other factors that I need to try in order to get this look?

Thanks in advance for your help

Final pics now chosen by the boss to capture the essence of the copacking operation.

C&C very welcome

1. Hand packing
3328027979_d8e0e238db_o.jpg


2. Pallet stacking
3328864070_a72dbb6d52_o.jpg


3. Merchandising Unit stacking
3328029175_ef7545a822_o.jpg
 
So long as you have a slow shutter speed...I'd say around half a second to a second would be good, without over doing it :)

16_JU7F3364.jpg


This was shot at 0.8 sec, f11, ISO 50...just to give you an idea! Indoors you will have less light occuring so a higher ISO would need to be used, perhaps around 400.
 
If the people are moving and the machinery is moving, the end result might be a bit too abstract for your boss's requirements. One variation that might be fun would be to have the people as moving "ghosts" but the machinery stationary. If you don't have the authority to switch off the machinery to take the shot, you could create the effect by combining two or more shots (stationary machinery with fast shutter, moving people with slow shutter) in Photoshop. Of course you'd need a tripod to ensure the shots lined up properly.
 
Thanks guys, like both these ideas, especially the one about stopping the line and having the people moving to create ghost figures. :thinking:

I'm going to try both although I suspect that the skill involved in using the flash and getting the right exposure and getting the trail effect is probably beyond my capabilities as an almost noobie

Roll on 1.30pm when I can give it a crack
 
Try looking here for inspiration!
 
if you have the strobes just play :D i find playing with more light sources just makes it funner
but remember to put a gel on the strobe to make it the same colour as the building lights
 
First image is the best. Fantastic in my opinion. Not sure on the rest because they don't seem to be showing anything, but this one shows people hard at work. I like it.
 
agree with the above, first one looks great. good composition and excellent motion blur. maybe rear curtain can be used to stop freeze the people, but not sure how it would have worked in this situation :)
 
#1 is fantastic. The other 3 don't do alot for me.
I think the winning formula here is to keep the product sharp and capture the movement around it (like #1 does), rather than have the product in blur.
Maybe concentrate on points in the production line where the product is stationary but the workers are not.
 
That first shot is fantastic! :clap: :clap: If you could have somehow done a pano with the same effect that would have looked absolutely awesome on an office wall. I have a production background, and can honestly say, having seen lots of 'work' type shots, your first is the best I have seen. In fact I will go as far as to say I thought it was an example shot of some major advertising campaign when I first got a glimpse of it before completely reading your first post!

Well done :clap:

Though I think the guy stood static in the last shot should be worried, if his boss sees that he won't be impressed :lol:
 
thanks for the positive feedback guys. No1 stood out for me too and very happy with it as a first attempt. It's a keeper, so only 3 more to get with the same quality.

As I need to depict the activities of the whole production department, what I will try this week is to incorporate a human element around the other activities shown in the other shots and using the same technique as in the first shot.

hopefully that should then provive a good theme for the series of shots
 
1 & 4 look good enough for the wall, the motion blur doesn't work on the other two and the trolley and cardboard box make 3 look like an untidy work area.
 
1 & 4 look good enough for the wall, the motion blur doesn't work on the other two and the trolley and cardboard box make 3 look like an untidy work area.

I agree. The camera never lies is so true when it comes to stuff like this. We will have to have a thorough tidy up and I will have to pay as much attention to what's showing in the background as well as the main subject of the shot
 
The first shot is your strongest one.

I'm afraid to say the other 3 just dont do it for me.

I have done a quite a few commercial jobs like this and asked a friend who has been a product photographer on many high profile ad campaigns for advise before I did the work and was told always have the product in prime position in the shot, and always have the perspective corrected for the product. So in your first shot I would correct the perspective on the boxes, as it is that the company makes and sells, and if they are going to be 3x3 ft in a area prospective / current customers will walk through they need to be right.

I would take a whole host concentrated on the product with the factory as a background, then also take some of the factory processes, there are some very intresting shots be had on production lines.

Keep the images coming as you take them.

Mark
 
Really like the first shot. They should buy it from you :) Get your name up with it!
 
The first shot is your strongest one.

I'm afraid to say the other 3 just dont do it for me.

I have done a quite a few commercial jobs like this and asked a friend who has been a product photographer on many high profile ad campaigns for advise before I did the work and was told always have the product in prime position in the shot, and always have the perspective corrected for the product. So in your first shot I would correct the perspective on the boxes, as it is that the company makes and sells, and if they are going to be 3x3 ft in a area prospective / current customers will walk through they need to be right.

I would take a whole host concentrated on the product with the factory as a background, then also take some of the factory processes, there are some very intresting shots be had on production lines.

Keep the images coming as you take them.

Mark

I think you are right about the last three shots. The more I look at them the more I dont like them.

I have a question though regarding a technical aspect mentioned in your post and it's one that comes from my ignorance. In the context of what I am trying to convey with this set of pictures, what is meant by having a correct perspective on the boxes and how do I go about correcting it?

thanks for your help
 
I think you are right about the last three shots. The more I look at them the more I dont like them.

I have a question though regarding a technical aspect mentioned in your post and it's one that comes from my ignorance. In the context of what I am trying to convey with this set of pictures, what is meant by having a correct perspective on the boxes and how do I go about correcting it?

thanks for your help


By correct perspective I mean, if you look at the product boxes the sides arnt square with the top and bottom of the box they slope in to the top, this is called converging verticals, a box like the one in the image has all adjoining sides at 90 degress to each other, in the imaage they look as if they are not 90 degrees, its a sympton of lens and film plane in relation to the object photographed, there is a lot wrote about it on the internet, you can correct this in photoshop very easily.

Here is an example of converging verticals and how to fix them.

http://www.better-photographs.com/converging-verticals.html

I hope you understand my explanation (i'm not very good at explaining things), but the example above should help you out.

Mark
 
By correct perspective I mean, if you look at the product boxes the sides arnt square with the top and bottom of the box they slope in to the top, this is called converging verticals, a box like the one in the image has all adjoining sides at 90 degress to each other, in the imaage they look as if they are not 90 degrees, its a sympton of lens and film plane in relation to the object photographed, there is a lot wrote about it on the internet, you can correct this in photoshop very easily.

Here is an example of converging verticals and how to fix them.

http://www.better-photographs.com/converging-verticals.html

I hope you understand my explanation (i'm not very good at explaining things), but the example above should help you out.

Mark

Thanks Mark. Now I understand. Thats the beauty(?) of the Canon 10-22mm I guess. I havent had a go at straightening verticals in Photoshop before, so now's my chance!
 
As said, 1 looks great. In such a situation I'd be tempted to sit my camera on a box of the product on the conveyor (or some similar setup), facing down the track and use a remote shutter release to freeze everything on the conveyor, but blur what is around it ;)
 
Number 1's great, but to be honest, 1 2 and 3 are, 4 not so much. I think a slower shutter speed would work better to give more of an outline to the forklift. But still a cool set.
 
Back
Top