Photography guidance for the police

But why more so now than when the IRA were killing a lot more people (in the UK that is)?
Interesting you should mention that. My Dad and Brother were in Guildford the night of the pub bombings in 1974. On their way to that pub (The Horse and Groom) for a drink, they were knocked over by the blast as the walked towards it (luckily they were unhurt). Ironically the reason they were in Guildford that night was to take photos!
 
But why more so now than when the IRA were killing a lot more people (in the UK that is)?

To be honest i don't know i mean yes the ira did a lot of damage in the uk i was in town the day they blew up warrington and believe me seeing children blown across the street is not something i shall easily forget.
It just sems that with the media mentioning terrorism at every turn these days it somehow seems more real, i mean back in the ira days people seemed to think "oh it will never happen here" at least thats what i thought, it always seemed distant in some way until they attacked my home town.
Now it's as if everyone expects it every day, as i said i don't know why it just seems different.

Anyway getting off topic... sorry.
 
But why more so now than when the IRA were killing a lot more people (in the UK that is)?

Because it suits Governments to keep us under control, and acquiescent, and the best way they can do that is to instill fear.
 
lol...sometimes you lot make me laugh - you make it sound like we live in a South American dictatorship...
 
lol...sometimes you lot make me laugh - you make it sound like we live in a South American dictatorship...

No we don't, but we are force fed terror bull-**** when there really is only conflict related to ownership.

I feel fairly uncomfortable discussing these matters with a military photographer I respect and admire though. Sorry.
 
lol...I'm a Leftie myself, so don't worry - I just refuse to be drawn by all the 'conspiracy' theorists - if you knew how dysfunctional the Govermnent and security services really were, you'd realise that there's no way we could orchestrate half of what is mooted...having said that - the level of institutional incompetence should be the REAL cause for concern...lol
 
lol...I'm a Leftie myself, so don't worry - I just refuse to be drawn by all the 'conspiracy' theorists - if you knew how dysfunctional the Govermnent and security services really were, you'd realise that there's no way we could orchestrate half of what is mooted...having said that - the level of institutional incompetence should be the REAL cause for concern...lol

Well, I consider myself to be quite firm, I don't allow myself to be drawn in by anything.

I question things and base my opinion, my feelings on logistics or as close to as I can possibly get.

Conspiracy theory is such an easy straw to grab at or make accusation of.

You can't deny the repetition of history though, if it worked in the past then why wouldn't it work in the present.
 
Oh I definitely go for cock up over conspiracy most of the time, but you can see from the way the Government tried to get ID cards through by pretending that they would make any difference to terrorists that they do use the threat of terrorism to get people to agree to their proposals.

They've been forced to admit that they won't help against terrorism now, but that was their original argument for introducing them.
 
I still don't get why anyone has a downer on ID cards - everywhere else in Europe has them and so far those Governments have spectacularly failed to use that database for nefarious Big-Brother practices...
If you're not a criminal you have nothing to fear - most of us already have ID cards in the form of Driver's Licence, Credit/Debit cards and club-cards from stores and Supermarkets - the range of information stored on those is staggering...

You all worry too much...
 
You all worry too much...

No, with all due respect, it's not a case of worrying, it's a case of concluding.

I have many significant worries in life and they pretty much revolve around staying afloat, maintaining my business and of course, trying to enjoy as much of life as possible, (I'm getting there).
I am generally a happy chap.
 
I still don't get why anyone has a downer on ID cards - everywhere else in Europe has them and so far those Governments have spectacularly failed to use that database for nefarious Big-Brother practices...
If you're not a criminal you have nothing to fear - most of us already have ID cards in the form of Driver's Licence, Credit/Debit cards and club-cards from stores and Supermarkets - the range of information stored on those is staggering...

You all worry too much...

No country has an ID card like the one proposed for us, so there is nothing to compare it with.
 
but...all the information proposed for the ID card is already available through other means - take travel - you pay for fuel with your card, there's a record - you drive down a road, a fixed-camera on a motorway bridge records your VRN - they know where you go at what time and now with average speed cameras, how fast you're going...
Take a bus - there's a camera on it that records you getting on and off - trains, planes, buses all the same - we are already the most heavily surveilled society on the planet - and you're worried about another card - added to the four or five already in your wallet?
C'mon...

And once again - what is there to fear - what have you done that's so heinous that you need to keep your identity and whereabouts a secret?

If you really think that the Government is going to go all 1984 on us then vote for a different one...
 
but...all the information proposed for the ID card is already available through other means -


If it is all available already then they don't need it in an ID card.

the fact is that the Government doesn't have access to it in the way you describe, or they wouldn't be seeking it now.

They have proved time and time again that they can't be trusted with data, they shouldn't be given the opportunity to go further.

As for the argument that if you have done nothing wrong you have nothing to fear, well tell that to Jean Charles Menezez, or Ian Tomlinson. Oh no, you can't can you?

Tell it to all the Iraqi civilians that have died just because the Government used a lie about a threat to justify their actions.
 
I still don't get why anyone has a downer on ID cards - everywhere else in Europe has them and so far those Governments have spectacularly failed to use that database for nefarious Big-Brother practices...
If you're not a criminal you have nothing to fear - most of us already have ID cards in the form of Driver's Licence, Credit/Debit cards and club-cards from stores and Supermarkets - the range of information stored on those is staggering...

You all worry too much...

If you want to know what I have against the ID cards then I'll show you one of the four bus passes the local council sent my 76-year old father, each time they removed the pic he sent in with the application and put a picture of a woman on his card, even though her file had a link to my father's, saying that they had put his picture on her card as well.....twice.

Which means that despite knowing it was the wrong picture they still issued his card twice knowing that the picture was wrong.

It only got sorted in the end when I phoned them and told them the Daily Mail were preparing a feature on the matter and would they like to comment :suspect:

That's just a bus pass, imagine the balls-up they could manage with 60 million cards with full identification details on them :lol:
 
Still it will be a great way to get a new identity... :lol:
 
hahahahaha lovely - once in Northern Ireland the RMP did a security check on MPH and a young Monkey-Girl got past me with a photo of Mickey-Mouse on her MOD-90...:eek:
I even directed her straight to the Ops Room...oh dearie-me...:gag:
 
An interesting illustration of Government ability to handle information comes from the G20.

The officer now under caution for the manslaughter of Ian Tomlinson left the met on a sickness pension Met after a road rage incident.

He was later employed by the Met as a civilian, got a job with Surrey as a constable, and then transferred back to the Met, where they had no idea they had employed him before and had an outstanding disciplinary against him.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2009/jul/05/query-g20-assault-case-officer
 
Me again, sorry for the 3 in a row.

I've just heard about the 5 deaths in Afghanistan bringing the number to14 in 11 days I think.

I'd like to point out that whatever my views of Politicians I support the Armed Forces wherever they are sent and believe that they should always be given the tools to do the job. (Not saying these latest deaths were because they weren't, Arkady will know more of that)

I also think they should be given support when they return.
 
An interesting illustration of Government ability to handle information comes from the G20.

The officer now under caution for the manslaughter of Ian Tomlinson left the met on a sickness pension Met after a road rage incident.

He was later employed by the Met as a civilian, got a job with Surrey as a constable, and then transferred back to the Met, where they had no idea they had employed him before and had an outstanding disciplinary against him.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2009/jul/05/query-g20-assault-case-officer

See, if we had ID cards that would never of happened :lol:
 
Me again, sorry for the 3 in a row.

I've just heard about the 5 deaths in Afghanistan bringing the number to14 in 11 days I think.

I'd like to point out that whatever my views of Politicians I support the Armed Forces wherever they are sent and believe that they should always be given the tools to do the job. (Not saying these latest deaths were because they weren't, Arkady will know more of that)

I also think they should be given support when they return.

Helicopters...more of them...NOW
The Chinooks we have in theatre are the very same aircraft we used in the Falklands war 27 years ago... I photographed them being reassembled when the Joint Helicopter Force first deployed in January 2006. The oldest aircraft there is 32 years old...older than most of the soldiers now dying for lack of airlift capability...

Most of us don't own a car more than 5 years old for christ's sake...

Never mind new boots, it's bloody mines that are killing us - a comfy insole is no good if you step on a booby-trapped 155mm artillery shell...:bang:

And if we can't get any more in Theatre, there are planty of other NATO countries that can - they might not be able to put boots on the ground, but even the bloody Italians can fly helicopters FFS!!!


Sorry for the rant but one of the guys killed yesterday is from my Regiment.
 
What amazes me is that no one seems to realise that Id cards will be forged, and thus possibly legitimising a terrorist. I.e Mr Bomber shows his fake Id card and no matter how suspicious he may look, he gets in the office block,bank or wherever and bang! Whereas now with no id card he may be questioned and stopped.

Or am I missing something? I am blonde!:help:
 
No matter how much we all disagree about any subject we care to discuss here - it's all good - because we have the freedom to argue our views in a public forum...

Whether you accept it or not, those guys are indirectly dying to preserve those freedoms...Please just remember that. Then it won't be for nothing.
 
No matter how much we all disagree about any subject we care to discuss here - it's all good - because we have the freedom to argue our views in a public forum...

I'm respectfully bowing out here.

I've grown up in an environment that has always had respect and keen interest in the British Military.

Whether you accept it or not, those guys are indirectly dying to preserve those freedoms...Please just remember that. Then it won't be for nothing.

I find this quite an unfair and upsetting statement.

People are losing their lives indeed but it's not for preservation of freedom. US and UK presence in Iraq has nothing to do with justice.

This is my opinion and there is very little that will change it I'm afraid.

I want nothing but our troops out, home and never again to be involved in America's affairs for ownership.
 
People are losing their lives indeed but it's not for preservation of freedom. US and UK presence in Iraq has nothing to do with justice.
.

Tom, I respect your opinions even if I violently disagree with them...:lol:

What happened in Iraq has nothing to do with what is happening in Afghanistan - to confuse the two seperate conflicts does us no good. The recent war in Iraq was a futile war of aggression pureley motivated by greed and profit. The only people to benefit were the Hallibuton stockholders...


The conflict in Afghanistan is something else entirely - and even I'm not sure what that is yet - I used to know at the beginning, but things have changed...we helped rid the country of the Taliban only for the place to act as a focus for all islamic fundamentalism attacking 'Western' democracy...
It could be argued that we either fight them there or fight them closer to home...I don't like fighting in Afghanistan but it's better than fighting them in Ashford...
 
Tom, I respect your opinions even if I violently disagree with them...:lol:

What happened in Iraq has nothing to do with what is happening in Afghanistan - to confuse the two seperate conflicts does us no good. The recent war in Iraq was a futile war of aggression pureley motivated by greed and profit. The only people to benefit were the Hallibuton stockholders...

Doesn't seem like you 'violently' disagree though. After your above post, it seems were at least in the same chapter if not on the same page :).

The conflict in Afghanistan is something else entirely - and even I'm not sure what that is yet - I used to know at the beginning, but things have changed...we helped rid the country of the Taliban only for the place to act as a focus for all islamic fundamentalism attacking 'Western' democracy...
It could be argued that we either fight them there or fight them closer to home...I don't like fighting in Afghanistan but it's better than fighting them in Ashford...

I'm very relieved you can respect my opinion as I respect yours and I'm grateful of your civilized manner in this discussion.
I need you to know that I sincerely appreciate your opinion, views and beliefs.

I'm frankly amazed that someone with a military commitment such as yourself has even mentioned the word 'Halliburton' without being compelled to put 'conspiracy theory' in the same paragraph or sentence.

With regards to Afghanistan, It's interesting, you say that in the beginning you thought you had an idea but now your not so sure.
Anyway, I'm not trying to confuse the issues in Afghanistan with Iraq, I simply don't want anymore of you fine fellows dead and further involvement will result precisely so.

Personally, I have tremendous difficulty in believing that the Taliban would ever get to Ashford, nor have ever been in places such as Ashford, hypothetically speaking of course.

To accept that the war invasion of Iraq was solely for the benefit of banking cartels then why is there difficulty in realizing why 'Western Democracy' has such a bad wrap anyway?
The generation of events to sway the public view, no matter the loss of innocent lives?
It's failings are of monumental proportion and has the blood of millions on it's hands.
Surely you must be able to empathize with the feelings toward the Western world in light of current affairs?

In your opinion, why exactly are the Taliban so interested in harming British people?

To note, I am a very un-religious type, not exactly anti-religious but all the devout following of religions and the conflicts it has generated both in history and presently, perplex me.

After all, all of the pages of any bible or holy script originate from human minds, imagination and were written by human hands.

Humans are, or can be, fantastic story tellers and also incredibly efficient liars.
 
I as 99% of people in the UK support our troop, believing they do an excellent job with the equipment provided. One death or injury to our troops is one too many.

I do however think the war in Afghanistan is the wrong way to deal with the Taliban. They have had some support from the population because they allowed them to grow and sell poppy for Heroin. A much simpler and cheaper solution would be for our government to buy ALL the heroin produced. This would have several benefits.

There would be no reason to support the Taliban

WE (the government) would control the heroin market, which would help in this country's drug problem.

There is a world shortage of medical heroin, we could fill that gap by sell the drug to other country (thus getting some of our money back)

Most importantly our troops would be safe at home.


If we had listened to the Russians 20 years ago we would not need to be in Afghanistan now.
 
What happened in Iraq has nothing to do with what is happening in Afghanistan - to confuse the two seperate conflicts does us no good. The recent war in Iraq was a futile war of aggression pureley motivated by greed and profit. The only people to benefit were the Hallibuton stockholders...


The conflict in Afghanistan is something else entirely - and even I'm not sure what that is yet - I used to know at the beginning, but things have changed...we helped rid the country of the Taliban only for the place to act as a focus for all islamic fundamentalism attacking 'Western' democracy...
It could be argued that we either fight them there or fight them closer to home...I don't like fighting in Afghanistan but it's better than fighting them in Ashford...

I agree wholeheartedly, Iraq and Afghanistan are completely different.

Not only that, but if we hadn't gone on the folly of invading Iraq, seen as the biggest failure in foreign policy since Suez, the position in Afghanistan would be completely different now.
 
The original reason for the invasion of Afghanistan was that al-Qaeda had so fully infiltrated the Taleban that we were forced to remove them from power.
The problem that the Taleban (not al-Qaeda, please note) have with us is that we are a foreign army on what they consider to be their soil.
The fact remains that we are still there as a guest of the democratically-elected government of Afghanistan.
Now the problem with that is that the vast majority of Afghans vehemently distrust central government, so in effect we are there at the invitation of the ruling classes and the intelligentsia...not so much the poppy-farmers in the south who have always done things their own way...

And while the Taleban (in effect the political opposition in Afghanistan) are unlikely to end up in Ashford, there are plenty of their supporters who will - the London Tube bombers were UK citizens remember?
For the most part, the men we actually face in Helmand are not Afghan - they are Pakistanis, Lebanese, Syrian, Saudi - and sadly, people from the UK.

Intellectually I didn't have a problem with removing Saddam from power in Iraq, I just wished everyone had been more honest about it - no WMD-[PLEASE DON'T TRY TO BYPASS THE SWEAR FILTER] - instead we should have been hearing: "We are going to get rid of a bad guy who gasses his own people and to safeguard mineral resources for the rest of the free world.." That's enough of a reason! Better reason than some wars have been fought for...but it wan't the time to do it...

The Bush-Cheney-Rumsfeld cabal has to go down in history as the worst case of nepotistic, self-serving scumbags in recent memory: invading Iraq made no tactical or strategic sense at that time; it also had the effect of diverting resources away from Afghanistan at a time when we could have wrapped the whole thing up in a couple of years...Now we are in the situation where we have to walk to battle as we haven't enough helicopters - they all got trashed in Iraq...

We used to joke about it last year while in Basrah - count up how much money has been wasted in Iraq...billions upon billions of dollars...and for what? The country's in ruins, the infrastructure is stone-age and the people have lost faith in the West for at least a generation...
Knowing what Saddam was like - someone should have offered him a deal: $20 million a year for life and go into exile in a lush paradise of your choosing or we kill you - anyone want to bet how that would have turned out?

Cheaper for a start...
 
The Bush-Cheney-Rumsfeld cabal has to go down in history as the worst case of nepotistic, self-serving scumbags in recent memory: invading Iraq made no tactical or strategic sense at that time;

Yes it did. Bush had promised the American people that he'd get Bin Laden and the others responsible for 9-11. And he failed. So he decided to persuade them that Sadam was the real one they should be targetting. That was easy - they had his home address!

As for WMDs - they did have proof that Sadam owned them at one time. Cheney still had the reciepts!
 
Yes it did. Bush had promised the American people that he'd get Bin Laden and the others responsible for 9-11. And he failed. So he decided to persuade them that Sadam was the real one they should be targetting. That was easy - they had his home address!

As for WMDs - they did have proof that Sadam owned them at one time. Cheney still had the reciepts!

I almost bit...lol
 
I think we have missed a trick with the poppy farmers. The Taleban didn't allow them to grow opium, but there is a world shortage of Morphine I understand, so it would make sense to pay them to produce opium which could then be processed for medical use.

That would make the West much more popular than the Taleban.
 
And while the Taleban (in effect the political opposition in Afghanistan) are unlikely to end up in Ashford, there are plenty of their supporters who will - the London Tube bombers were UK citizens remember?

I remember very well but I remain unsure as to who was to blame for the bombings.

Would you say that fighting the Taleban on 'home' soils prevents the threat of terror attacks, or could it possibly encourage and provoke it?

Let's say overthrowing the Taleban or even their extermination were succesful, is that really the end to the 'war' on terror?

Will bills like The Patriot Act and the Anti Terror Act suddenly become redundant if all terrorists ceased to exist?

Intellectually I didn't have a problem with removing Saddam from power in Iraq, I just wished everyone had been more honest about it...

I agree, they should have said: 'You have valuable mineral resources in your country, around the 10-30 trillion dollars worth, we're a cominageddit!'?

I feel quite strongly, that if those mineral resources didn't exist, the last decade or so would have been very different.

Knowing what Saddam was like - someone should have offered him a deal: $20 million a year for life and go into exile in a lush paradise of your choosing or we kill you - anyone want to bet how that would have turned out?.....

I think it's fairly logical to assume that such a deal was proposed initially but Hussain would have refused the same as Castro did when the eco hitmen came knocking on his door. :shrug:

.....Cheaper for a start...

Agreed, in both life and tax payers money.
 
I think this thread may have strayed a wee bit :suspect:

At the ned of the day we won't win in Afghanistan, no-one has ever beaten them - look at the Russians, they threw wave after wave of soldiers at them and lost. Ofcourse back then the UK and US were bankrolling the mujahideen and traing their fighters,in fact iirc some were brought over here and schooled up in the Highlands by our military....
 
We can't 'beat' the taleban - the best we can hope to do is bludgeon them to the negotiating table from a postion of strength...make them understand that they cannot 'win' by military means - we simply will not slink away - some of them are moderates and we'll eventually have to deal with them anyway...

They're not stupid people and they will come to understand - in the same way the IRA did that talking eventually gets it done in the end...
 
Back
Top