Post your worst street photography clichés

Messages
986
Name
Nick
Edit My Images
No
For example,

Shots of generic old people going shopping
Hundreds of shots of the backs of people's heads
Shots with no inkling of composition whatsoever

:bang:
 
For example,

Shots of generic old people going shopping
Hundreds of shots of the backs of people's heads
Shots with no inkling of composition whatsoever

:bang:

why do you want to see them though :shrug: and why have you not posted one to start it off?
 
Last edited:
I dont take shots which I find annoying :| but perhaps I'm missing the point of your post ;)
 
I think I've worded the original post badly...I just meant write down what types of street photography shots annoy you the most :)
 
1) Anything shot over 50mm (or over 35mm on crop)
2) Colour shots converted to BW
3) Shots that have been cropped to non standard shapes (ie not 3:2 or 4:3)
4) Selective Colour :eek:
5) Fake grain/texture added
6) Shots of beggars/homeless
 
1) Anything shot over 50mm (or over 35mm on crop)
2) Colour shots converted to BW
3) Shots that have been cropped to non standard shapes (ie not 3:2 or 4:3)
4) Selective Colour :eek:
5) Fake grain/texture added
6) Shots of beggars/homeless

Sorry to pick on your list, I agree with it mostly just have a couple questions, on point 2, you don't shoot b&w digitally then? As even if you shoot jpeg, the camera is capturing in colour and processing to b&w.

And on point 5, I'd like you to define "fake".

When i shoot street digitally I shoot RAW and convert to BW in Silver Efex, I have some presets that I use and they pretty much all add a bit of grain. I do this because while I like the convenience of digital I'm really not keen on that clean look.

I expect this would be what you define as "fake"?

Now, when I shoot film I shoot Tri-X which I could develop to be clean as a whistle, I've seen Tri-X pushed to iso3200 and devved such that it had less grain than a Nikon D3 produces at that iso. But I don't, I chose a developer which does give some grain. I have made a choice to process my image (ok, 36 images at a time) in a way that adds grain (or I suppose I could rephrase that to brings out the grain in the film) because I like the look of it.

Would you define that as "fake"?


The OP mentions "Shots of generic old people going shopping". I notice this a lot, the photograph of a very normal looking person going about their business in a very normal looking way, there seems to have been no reason to photograph that particular person, they aren't wonderfully photogenic, they aren't doing anything unusual and the setting is nothing out of the ordinary either. I just don't get why the photographer took that image.

However, I imagine that were I to look at a similar photograph taken in the 50s, 60s or 70s or indeed to look again at this photograph in a few decades time then my opinion might be different.
 
Shots with no scantily clad women.
 
1) Anything shot over 50mm (or over 35mm on crop)
2) Colour shots converted to BW
3) Shots that have been cropped to non standard shapes (ie not 3:2 or 4:3)
4) Selective Colour :eek:
5) Fake grain/texture added
6) Shots of beggars/homeless

:shrug:
 
boliston said:
1) Anything shot over 50mm (or over 35mm on crop)
2) Colour shots converted to BW
3) Shots that have been cropped to non standard shapes (ie not 3:2 or 4:3)
4) Selective Colour :eek:
5) Fake grain/texture added
6) Shots of beggars/homeless

Points 1, 2 and 3, I really don't see the issue with!

Does it matter what focal length you use? Or do you only like the "in your face" style?
 
1) Anything shot over 50mm (or over 35mm on crop)

Fan of Bruce Gilden by any chance?


6) Shots of beggars/homeless

Well that rules out any worthwhile work with the big issue, shelter, centrepoint or any travel shots from India etc...

Imagine if Dorothea Lange felt that way? Her photos first appeared in the San Francisco News on March 10, 1936, as part of a story demanding relief for the starving pea pickers. The feature was a success: relief was organized, and there is no record of death by starvation.
http://www.loc.gov/rr/print/list/128_migm.html

Photos can be a powerful force for good and it can be argued that all aspects of human life is worth recording. For homeless people or those begging, sometimes it's just one small poor decision or circumstance change that puts them in that position. There but for the grace of god...etc
 
Last edited:
1) Anything shot over 50mm (or over 35mm on crop)
2) Colour shots converted to BW
3) Shots that have been cropped to non standard shapes (ie not 3:2 or 4:3)
4) Selective Colour :eek:
5) Fake grain/texture added
6) Shots of beggars/homeless

And there's me getting just about everything wrong!

1) Shot at 300mm
2) Converted to BW (though in my defence, I shoot pretty much everything in RAW, so shooting in BW is not an option. Are you saying I must stop shooting RAW if I want to do *real* `street` photography?
3) Shot cropped from much bigger original (see inset)
4) NOT GUILTY! (phew!!)
5) Vignette added
6) Didn't ask him for his Beggar's Licence, but he doesn't look like the CEO of the Bank of Vancouver.

dfa96aae.jpg


Anyway, what is this with rules for photography? Football has rules. Cricket has Laws.

Photography has opinions
 
Photos can be a powerful force for good and it can be argued that all aspects of human life is worth recording. For homeless people or those begging, sometimes it's just one small poor decision or circumstance change that puts them in that position. There but for the grace of god...etc

I don't think the majority of photographers, and I'm not talking about those documenting the issue for charities etc or producing extensive bodies of work on the subject, are taking such pictures as a "powerful force for good" they are doing so because these people are an (unfortunately) easy source of subject matter.

One incident I recall which illustrated this was Flickr group outing with about 40 or so photographers present, someone spotted a young homeless boy sitting in a doorway and suddenly half the group rushed over and started taking his picture. At one point they were all crowded round him like some paparazzi scrum, barking instructions to him and snapping away.

In what way does that do the homeless person any good? I don't think they even gave him the price of a cup of tea for his time and I'm sure the act of being surrounded by well dressed, well-fed photographers, all sporting expensive camera equipment won't have done much for his self-esteem.

What did I do? I took a picture of the photographers taking their pictures......
 
People with bags, using phones and generally doing boring things. Anyone sitting on a bench with similar body language. People walking about a identikit town centre.

Just look in the street photography thread. Most of it is cliche. In 50 years time when everything has changed enough more of it will seem interesting because it is different to what we see when we wander around town rather than being exactly the same.

Unless it is something that is not generally seen all the time then it is just plain dull.
 
I don't think the majority of photographers, and I'm not talking about those documenting the issue for charities etc or producing extensive bodies of work on the subject, are taking such pictures as a "powerful force for good" they are doing so because these people are an (unfortunately) easy source of subject matter.

One incident I recall which illustrated this was Flickr group outing with about 40 or so photographers present, someone spotted a young homeless boy sitting in a doorway and suddenly half the group rushed over and started taking his picture. At one point they were all crowded round him like some paparazzi scrum, barking instructions to him and snapping away.

In what way does that do the homeless person any good? I don't think they even gave him the price of a cup of tea for his time and I'm sure the act of being surrounded by well dressed, well-fed photographers, all sporting expensive camera equipment won't have done much for his self-esteem.

What did I do? I took a picture of the photographers taking their pictures......

God that sound really bad,i think that why i perfer to work alone.
Someone once said.
The pack show no fear,also no sense responsiblity :(
 
what ding76 said, Black and white EVERYTHING. whyyyyyyyyyyy

And just as good a question, why not?

There are just as many photographers choosing to work in black and white in lots of other genres, just look at the nude and glamour section.

At least the street photographers aren't converting to b&w to hide the fact they are crap at sorting white balance.

There's always going to be exceptions to the rules and sometimes it's nice when you see this ie the shot above taken with a 300mm lens, Philip Lorca D'Corcia's (sp) long lens work but when the majority of long lens street photography tends to be covert shots of pretty girls it's easy to see why people object.
 
what ding76 said, Black and white EVERYTHING. whyyyyyyyyyyy

I shoot almost exclusively BW because I like to shoot shadows and textures and shapes. I can't even think in colour anymore.
 
I shot a fair bit of colour during the summer but definitely prefer black and white.

I like to shoot a mixture of film and digital and shooting colour film = sending it out for dev and scan, shooting b&w film = dev and print at home with control over every step of the process.
 
....

Well that rules out any worthwhile work with the big issue, shelter, centrepoint or any travel shots from India etc...

Imagine if Dorothea Lange felt that way? ...

The photos in the article are what I would describe as "street portrait" rather than "street photography".

The two genres have similarities but I have absolutely no inclination to "interact" with people in my photos which is why I do not do street portraits.
 
Shots of boring people doing boring things, with boring poses and boring facial expressions, shot at long focal lengths.

Not that you can't get an interesting shot with a long lens, but a major part of the interest in street photography is context, and you usually lose that at long focal lengths.
 
Well that rules out any worthwhile work with the big issue, shelter, centrepoint or any travel shots from India etc...

Imagine if Dorothea Lange felt that way? Her photos first appeared in the San Francisco News on March 10, 1936, as part of a story demanding relief for the starving pea pickers. The feature was a success: relief was organized, and there is no record of death by starvation.
http://www.loc.gov/rr/print/list/128_migm.html

Photos can be a powerful force for good and it can be argued that all aspects of human life is worth recording. For homeless people or those begging, sometimes it's just one small poor decision or circumstance change that puts them in that position. There but for the grace of god...etc

I think the OP was talking about street photography which I would take to be just popping out in the street photographing at random. Lange to me was a documentary photographer, she photographed for a purpose and created a large body of work, as do charity projects.

Taking a photo of a homeless person in the street does nothing to help them in my opinion. Talking to a homeless person on the other hand, finding out what factors put them in that situation then lifting the camera is what makes powerful photography. Taking photos to make just a nice B&W portrait, applying a nice sharpen mask, dodge and burn to make them look even more like a victim then sticking it up on flickr is the sort of cliche the OP was talking about.

All in my opinion of course :)
 
Last edited:
Football matches, they're all the same :thumbsdown:
 
Homeless people reading the paper.. in black and white :bang:
 
How do we even know they're homeless?

They might just be badly dressed and a little dirty.
 
Homeless Beggars and Big Issue Sellers?

On more money than me and I work seven days a week.
 
Interesting answers here.

Photography is subjective and cliche is an overused word IMO.

I never look at a photograph and think cliche, or broken the rules - only whether or not I like it.

The reason is a different thing entirely:thumbs: Personal opinion.
 
Vic said:
I think the OP was talking about street photography which I would take to be just popping out in the street photographing at random. Lange to me was a documentary photographer, she photographed for a purpose and created a large body of work, as do charity projects.

Taking a photo of a homeless person in the street does nothing to help them in my opinion. Talking to a homeless person on the other hand, finding out what factors put them in that situation then lifting the camera is what makes powerful photography. Taking photos to make just a nice B&W portrait, applying a nice sharpen mask, dodge and burn to make them look even more like a victim then sticking it up on flickr is the sort of cliche the OP was talking about.

All in my opinion of course :)

Perhaps so vic but I was responding to the list, the last of which stated beggars/homeless.
Taking a picture does nothing, but what you do with it does. An image can be a powerful argument.
 
Back
Top