Post your worst street photography clichés

Perhaps so vic but I was responding to the list, the last of which stated beggars/homeless.
Taking a picture does nothing, but what you do with it does. An image can be a powerful argument.

I'm not sure that the average street photograph of a homeless person has much potential to do any good.

The average crap homeless person shots we are talking about, shot with a long lens, containing little or no context, with no involvement in the subjects life or personality, often processed to emphasise how grubby and disheveled the subject is do little other than give the viewer a spectacle to stare at with no chance of being caught looking.

As Vic says, street portraiture and documentary are something completely different, those types of images can explain something about that persons life, they can show their personality and their humanity. They can make us realise that these people are just that, people.
 
I'm not sure that the average street photograph of a homeless person has much potential to do any good.

The average crap homeless person shots we are talking about, shot with a long lens, containing little or no context, with no involvement in the subjects life or personality, often processed to emphasise how grubby and disheveled the subject is do little other than give the viewer a spectacle to stare at with no chance of being caught looking.

As Vic says, street portraiture and documentary are something completely different, those types of images can explain something about that persons life, they can show their personality and their humanity. They can make us realise that these people are just that, people.

But when does Street photography become documentary. Surely all street photography is documenting that moment at that location? Does it only become documentary over a period of time. Take Vivian Maier as an example.
http://vivianmaier.blogspot.com/

I see a lot of photography as documentary, whether it be recording your children growing up, recording places and people etc. Even sport, whilst it's own gendre, by definition is documenting the moment that player scored, that driver went around the track etc.

There's a lot where I live that I realised has changed and no-one really has many photos of how it was. The local historical society has recently put out requests for images but despite the multitude of cameras people have, there's few images of things that have now been lost forever.

Perhaps now, with the young generation out of work, unemployment rising, money tight etc, that street photography could be used as a barometer of wealth compared to earlier/later times. Who knows, but to just dismiss it as unworthy I think misses the point.

Wow, never really thought about that so much. Thanks for the interesting discussion.
 
As someone who doesn't shoot nor even get what "street" is supposed to be... balance this blast on others attempts at "street" and show me what isn't "cliche".
 
I shoot almost exclusively BW because I like to shoot shadows and textures and shapes. I can't even think in colour anymore.

Because those things don't exist in the 'color' world! ;)

I agree with Desantnik - it's easy to highlight what is bad about genres (although I'm not even sure what genre we're actually talking about), but we also need to see the best of that genre.
 
Sticks head above parapet.
Sometimes things just work better in B&W. The colour version of this looks rubbish. Removing the colour emphasised the family in shaow
97506278.jpg


but it was a nice juxtaposition of a local alcoholic against the family. Printed large you can see the crushed cans of stellar scattered around him.
 
Zack Arias' her Kitty Kitty series on his site has some good stuff on it.

www.zackarias.com

Sticks head above parapet.
Sometimes things just work better in B&W... local alcoholic against the family. Printed large you can see the crushed cans of stellar scattered around him.

Hmmm don't both those two things you guys mentioned/posted fall into all the "cliches" everyone has mentioned in this thread so far? :thumbs:
 
As someone who doesn't shoot nor even get what "street" is supposed to be... balance this blast on others attempts at "street" and show me what isn't "cliche".

If you want to see some good street photography then have a look at some of the galleries on iN-PUBLiC.

Some really good galleries are:
http://www.in-public.com/NickTurpin/gallery/67
http://www.in-public.com/DavidSolomons/gallery/89
http://www.in-public.com/MattStuart/gallery/55
http://www.in-public.com/NilsJorgensen/gallery/61
http://www.in-public.com/PaulRussell/gallery/93
 
Which street photographers cover footy matches?

I did during the late 60's early 70's, most Saturdays during the season. Not by choice I hasten to add. And yes, it was done in mono, printed in my darkroom and dropped off to the editors desk Saturday night ready for Monday publication.
 
I did during the late 60's early 70's, most Saturdays during the season. Not by choice I hasten to add. And yes, it was done in mono, printed in my darkroom and dropped off to the editors desk Saturday night ready for Monday publication.

Street ≠press/sports.

Street photographers I'm liking right now, Daido Moriyama, Shomei Tomatsu, Trent Park, Christophe Agou.
 
Boliston - some good work in those links. As an aside, it's funny how portfolios can be subjective; a couple of those photographers have very interesting work that is let down by work that would fit into this thread quite nicely (thanks to cliches) and work that is actually quite boring IMO.

I really like stuff like this, this and this because they make me think or make you laugh because they're well-spotted....

...But stuff like this, this and this I don't get.
 
Last edited:
Boliston - some good work in those links. As an aside, it's funny how portfolios can be subjective; a couple of those photographers have very interesting work that is let down by work that would fit into this thread quite nicely (thanks to cliches) and work that is actually quite boring IMO.

Agreed but I notice that the specific portfolios he linked to were all colour. I had a look at some of the others and found some far better work (IMHO of course) but a lot (but not all) were in B&W. It would be a shame to dismiss them purely for this reason.

Photography is so subjective that it never ceases to amaze me when people are almost annoyed by a style they just happen not to like. I do the vast majority of my street stuff in B&W because the early B&W stuff is what inspired me in the first place.
 
Fabs - wasn't even thinking in terms of colour or mono but now you've pointed it out, i wonder how impacting those images would be if they were mono?

For me, street stuff was always hard. I always wanted to be an Elliot Erwitt or Martin Parr but I haven't got that wry, comic twist in how I spot stuff. Then I did my major project on my BA Hons course and I had to interview total strangers and take their photographs. But it was straight stuff, just street portraiture. Some shots worked great and some are just embarrassingly bad when I look at them now. The thing for me at the time was B&W devving and printing was easier and cheaper so that's how I shot. I didn't choose B&W for any other reason.

These days, those of us who shoot digital are pretty much forced to shoot in colour, especially with raw capture, so there is a definite decision being made when colour images are being converted to mono.

Okay, back in the film days you'd choose a specific film for a purpose - Kodachrome for saturation, Neopan for grain, Velvia for landscapery (etc, etc) - but I personally, shooting B&W was the default setting for me because of the cost issue. This was all despite the fact what i saw through the viewfinder was in colour.....I don't know if that was the case for established pros but it certainly was for all the students I knew.
 
Last edited:
It's one of the reasons I often set my camera to B&W. I shoot raw so I still get the colour image to convert later but I can get the feel of what I've shot whilst I'm out and about.

Of course I have the advantage of being able to change my mind at the processing stage which I wouldn't have had with film but I see that as a positive even though it's extremely rare that I would change my mind.
 
A major reason for shooting in, or converting to, B+W is that street scenes often contain a melange of colour in which the subject can become lost, or distracting blasts of bright colour in the background that mess up the shot.
 
A major reason for shooting in, or converting to, B+W is that street scenes often contain a melange of colour in which the subject can become lost, or distracting blasts of bright colour in the background that mess up the shot.

Yes, very much this. Meant to add this to my earlier post. Street scenes can be very cluttered and B&W can help to isolate the subject(s)
 
A major reason for shooting in, or converting to, B+W is that street scenes often contain a melange of colour in which the subject can become lost, or distracting blasts of bright colour in the background that mess up the shot.

Agreed, although some would argue that it is the challenge. Look at someone like Marin Parr as someone who met that challenge....:)
 
Agreed, although some would argue that it is the challenge. Look at someone like Marin Parr as someone who met that challenge....:)

I wouldn't class Parr as a street photographer. Although I would agree that colour is a challenge, and suggest that it can also be a benefit. I do feel that to soot primarily in B+W is anachronismtic in this day and age.
 
... it's easy to highlight what is bad about genres ...
I'd argue that it's easy to highlight what each of us dislike about genres rather than what's necessarily bad. One man's out-of-focus badly composed reject is another man's art. :shrug:

As long as the shooter is happy with the shot and doesn't try to claim that it's the only way the subject could be represented, I don't have a problem with any of it.
 
I'd argue that it's easy to highlight what each of us dislike about genres rather than what's necessarily bad. One man's out-of-focus badly composed reject is another man's art. :shrug:

As long as the shooter is happy with the shot and doesn't try to claim that it's the only way the subject could be represented, I don't have a problem with any of it.

Actually, I think this sums my thoughts up nicely. As I said earlier, photography is subjective, there isn't necessarily a right or wrong.
 
I can`t see the point in street photography, it bores me and really does nothing for me. But I guess the street type photographers feel the same about nature and country sports stuff, each to their own...........:)
 
I refer to think of it as a choice. :D

A misguided choice. :p

I shot my first roll of HP5 in almost 30 years a few months back and found I was seeing different pictures to what I was seeing shooting digitally (even if the camera was set to display B+W). I can't explain that.
 
I'd argue that it's easy to highlight what each of us dislike about genres rather than what's necessarily bad. One man's out-of-focus badly composed reject is another man's art. :shrug:

As long as the shooter is happy with the shot and doesn't try to claim that it's the only way the subject could be represented, I don't have a problem with any of it.

Totally. My workmanlike grammar should come with some sort of translation as to what `i really mean!! :lol:

I should have said: "it's easy to highlight we we see as bad...."
 
A misguided choice. :p

I shot my first roll of HP5 in almost 30 years a few months back and found I was seeing different pictures to what I was seeing shooting digitally (even if the camera was set to display B+W). I can't explain that.

:lol: No, just a personal one.

I shoot purely for me, I love B&W photography, always have done. I'm happy with my choice. :)
 
I wouldn't class Parr as a street photographer. Although I would agree that colour is a challenge, and suggest that it can also be a benefit. I do feel that to soot primarily in B+W is anachronismtic in this day and age.

Fair point, although much of what he produces can be transferred over to the street - it's that opportunistic, voyeueristic style. That shot of the postcard in front of the pyramids could quite easily have been Big Ben instead, if you get my drift. :)
 
Actually, I think this sums my thoughts up nicely. As I said earlier, photography is subjective, there isn't necessarily a right or wrong.
Exactly. Beauty in the eye of the beer holder and all that ;)

Whenever these types of discussions come up, it reminds me of the time I popped round to visit a friend of mine who's a very talented fine artist. At the time (some years ago), he was studying art at college and I walked in to find him stabbing a paste brush on a sheet that can only be described as a beige mess.

"What on earth is that?" I asked.

"I'm painting the smell of bread", he replied, "it's coursework".

"Erm, ok", I said, "and that mess is the smell of bread, is it?"

"Doesn't matter", he said, "as long as I can come up with the right description to keep the lecturer happy when I submit it, it'll do. Most modern art is the same load of ball cocks."*







* Well, he didn't say "ball cocks" but you know what I mean. Family forum, etc.
 
Last edited:
I can`t see the point in street photography, it bores me and really does nothing for me. But I guess the street type photographers feel the same about nature and country sports stuff, each to their own...........:)

I am mainly interested in Street Photography but I am also a fan of walking in the country so I normally take my camera.
large.jpg
 
Boliston - some good work in those links. As an aside, it's funny how portfolios can be subjective; a couple of those photographers have very interesting work that is let down by work that would fit into this thread quite nicely (thanks to cliches) and work that is actually quite boring IMO.

I really like stuff like this, this and this because they make me think or make you laugh because they're well-spotted....

...But stuff like this, this and this I don't get.

While I like most of Stuart's work I will agree that the 2 examples are possibly not his best. However I have yet to see a shot by Solomons that I have not liked. The shot here has a lot going on at once but quite a few of his shots are like this.
 
:lol: No, just a personal one.

I shoot purely for me, I love B&W photography, always have done. I'm happy with my choice. :)

That's all that matters. :thumbs:

I could easily stick to B+W and one lens, but digital has liberated me in terms of using colour (which I never could use successfully with film) and therefore subject matter.

Fair point, although much of what he produces can be transferred over to the street - it's that opportunistic, voyeueristic style. That shot of the postcard in front of the pyramids could quite easily have been Big Ben instead, if you get my drift. :)

The difference for me is that there almost always seems to be some form of social criticism/commentary to Parr's work, whereas street photography (at its best) is more concerned with pure picture making (eg Parke's interest in light and shadow).
 
I wouldn't class Parr as a street photographer. Although I would agree that colour is a challenge, and suggest that it can also be a benefit. I do feel that to soot primarily in B+W is anachronismtic in this day and age.

His work was just in a new book called New Street Photographty,and he also written about it in the same book :)
 
Back
Top