Post your worst street photography clichés

Ed - you're right about parr's intention of giving social commentary and I think that is something I don't see enough of in street photography.

Forget the editorial stuff about riots, protesters and whatnot, a Lot of street stuff seems to ask the viewer to take what they see on face value and accept that what has been shot as important by virtue of the fact it was photographed. It's a bit like fine art but that's another story..... :)
 
...a Lot of street stuff seems to ask the viewer to take what they see on face value and accept that what has been shot as important by virtue of the fact it was photographed.

But that is the very nature of photography, that the act of photographing something gives it significance.

In the distant past only that which was important was photographed, therefore that which is photographed must now be important. That is the tautological implication historically inherent in the medium.
 
But that is the very nature of photography, that the act of photographing something gives it significance.

In the distant past only that which was important was photographed, therefore that which is photographed must now be important. That is the tautological implication historically inherent in the medium.

You've lost me on that last sentence.... you're far too educated!! :lol:

Maybe I'm just failing to move with the times but I just can't buy into this photography for photography's sake with the reason for the shot bolted on afterwards. I can't agree with photographing something making it important as a blanket philosophy. I can see how some flukes, chance captures can be massively powerful in the same way that staged, conceptual work can also have impact. But I just can't buy into the fact that if you take a photograph of the high street on a saturday it now has a significance. Team it up with a story about high street shopping and it fits a role and a purpose but on its own it's still just a moment that was captured, nothing more, nothing less. :)

I suppose I'm one of these people who likes to be presented with a photograph; i.e. I like to have a bit of back story or concept to accompany the shot, or to be able to understand the questions the shot it expecting me to ask. Maybe that a short-sighted approach but it ultimately dictates the kind of work that I gravitate to....
 
Last edited:
You've lost me on that last sentence.... you're far too educated!! :lol:

Not really. I just know some big words and am not scared to use them - even if they're not always the right words! :D

I'm not suggesting that the photos you see as having no significance have any. Most do not, but the act of photographing always implies significance.

The kind of shot I think you are referring to are the ones that have no sense of structure, composition, content, gesture, place or anything else that makes photographs work. I see a lot of it too, and I think it comes from a lack of understanding of what street photography is. It is not merely photographing on the street.

I think where we differ in our views of what photographs should be is that, professionally, you take photographs for a purpose - as illustration (as would be my definition). Therefore you expect all photographs should have a role outside of simply being.

Whereas I take (and look at) photographs as pictures for their own sake (most of the time) - although that in itself isn't simple. For me a photograph has to work as a stand alone image first and foremost. A moment captured can be enough.
 
Ed, that's s really good point.

I suppose I've become so used to taking illustrative images, that the sense of explanation (or the need to explain) had passed over to my personal work, hence why much of the personal stuff on my Flickr is based around a idea of what I'm thinking. I'm not an impulsive photographer by any means, where I see street as being opportunistic in many senses - nothing is for certain on the street.

I was just stood outside having a smoke, thinking about how nice it is be thinking about photography and debating it with others. There's a lot of technical talk on TP but not enough talk about the theories and the reasons about why we take photos.
 
Last edited:
Their was a story,that when Magum was first set up HCB asked Robert Cappa,what to called himself as he was a street photographer,Cappa said you cant call yourself that,you will never get any work,call yourself a photojoumlism :)
 
There's a lot of technical talk on TP but not enough talk about the theories and the reasons about why we take photos.

:thumbs:

For the most part, the technical stuff bores me rigid. I know enough to get by at what I like doing. I'm far more interested in trying to understand why photographs work and how people go about making them, intellectually.

That said I am enjoying your blog.
 
I was just stood outside having a smoke, thinking about how nice it is be thinking about photography and debating it with others. There's a lot of technical talk on TP but not enough talk about the theories and the reasons about why we take photos.

Ahhh but thats the same dicey territory as proper critique... we've talked on here about "safe" and "combustible" topics many times and although this subject you've raised isn't normally on the highly flammable list, it probably should be.

Anyway I think it would be a fairly brief firefight discussion anyhow. I'll put some of the answers together for you:

* Its just something I like doing
* I was just there with my camera and pressed the button
* Someone was paying me and I'll do pretty much anything for money
* I like cars/birds/norks
* Why do I need a reason?

And I suspect the last on that list will pretty much be the bulk of the answers if people are brave enough to admit it in the face of someone looking for deep and meaningful insight into their picture.
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't class Parr as a street photographer. Although I would agree that colour is a challenge, and suggest that it can also be a benefit. I do feel that to soot primarily in B+W is anachronismtic in this day and age.

I think I know what you are trying to say but would you offer a definition of that word please. The only close on in my dictionary is anachronistic, an inconsistancy in time, so are you trying to say an inconsistancy in colour?
 
A quote

"To collect photographs is to collect the world...
Photographs are perhaps the most mysterious of all the objects that make up and thicken the environment we recognise as modern.
Photographs really are experience captured and the camera is the ideal arm of conciousness in its acquisitive mood"
 
I think I know what you are trying to say but would you offer a definition of that word please. The only close on in my dictionary is anachronistic, an inconsistancy in time, so are you trying to say an inconsistancy in colour?

Anachronistic is what he quite clearly meant and that means "an error assigning a thing to an earlier or later age than it belongs to: anything out of keeping with chronology" (Chambers English Dictionary).

He's basically saying that B&W gives the sense of "old fashioned" and not something to be applied to modern day scenes. Mearly aping "classic" street photography by using the same B&W as they did (aka "had no other choice") doesn't make your work equivalent.

Thats what Ed means, although I'm not saying that I agree with it fully ;-)
 
I think I know what you are trying to say but would you offer a definition of that word please. The only close on in my dictionary is anachronistic, an inconsistancy in time, so are you trying to say an inconsistancy in colour?

It's a typo... It should have been 'anachronistic'.

In that in the modern world using black and white exclusively goes against the grain. That doesn't make it wrong, nor does it make it right, but it does run the risk of it being done for self-consciously 'arty' reasons. As if it monochrome gives the photographs more artistic credibility compared to colour.
 
Back
Top