Pro Landscape Tog Uses 35mm And Non L Zoom

Fair play to the guy if he's still using what is deemed in this day and age old fashioned equipment and processes. He's doing what he likes doing, obviously has success from doing so and probably make a fair bit of wedge from it - what's wrong with that?

Gingerjon, yep, beef is better than pork. But lamb is better than beef......
 
Look, I guess I can get "medium-format" quality now from a 35mm-sized system.

Good for you.

I want grain the size of golf balls and harsh, fuzzy monochrome.


You'd still have got them in the paper.

Probably.

They do print any old rubbish.:p

But I thought you said that it doesn't depend .. ??

Statements about photography - the process, skills, etc

A photograph is not the same as 'photography'.

I'm not, on this occasion, arguing that there's no such thing as objective truth.
 
Statements about photography - the process, skills, etc

A photograph is not the same as 'photography'.

I'm not, on this occasion, arguing that there's no such thing as objective truth.

So a statement about a photograph, or the method invoked to produce a photograph, is not a statement on photography?
 
I'm not quite sure where this is going...

Surely some things are objectively "better" or "worse" - like medium format vs 35mm quality, or noise at 100 ASA vs 3200ASA?

Whereas others, like the content of an image, are not?

There is such an emphasis on the former in photography, and not enough, arguably, on the latter.

Which brings us back to OP, and some people on here like Dave Newbould's images, and others think they're - well - bog standard?
 
So, if statements about photographs or the way photographs are made aren't statements on photography, what the hell is?

I didn't say all statements.

But the statement: f-stop this, shutter speed that and here's the photo is specifically about the photograph and the technical values that went into its creation.

Photography - to me by the way because, like I said, it's subjective - is about what images mean.

So ... the statement, "I took this photo at 1/125 at f/8 ISO 400 using a 50mm lens attached to my trusty Nikon D90" is an objective document of the mechanics - it's no more a statement on photography than "now you press return" is a statement on information technology - whereas "This photograph is of higher quality than this photograph for whatever reason" is a subjective statement on photography.
 
Yes you did ...

Now you're misquoting me - though probably not deliberately.

The 'all statements' bit above refers to your comment:
"So, if statements about photographs or the way photographs are made aren't statements on photography, what the hell is?"

I should probably have been clearer about that. But I am replying here as an alternative to looking at spreadsheets.

But anyway, just to clarify so we can all agree to disagree and go home:
- film is better than digital
- all statements on photography are subjective
- mechanical/technical statements are not 'photography'
- everything I write has the invisible preface "In my opinion for the types of photography I do and writing with relevance to my life only ..." - as does everyone else's comments as well of course but not everybody seems to realise it

Job done.
 
Now you're misquoting me - though probably not deliberately.

I can't see how I'm misquoting you, especially as you reaffirmed your point in a following post.

Your invisible preface is all well and good, but you'd be far better served not making sweeping generalised statements in the first place, particularly when they're wrong, such as "as does everyone else's comments as well of course but not everybody seems to realise it". Some comments are facts some are opinions, that's why it's helpful not to express opinion as fact.
 
I think I may see a distinction between 'photography' and 'photograph(s)' that isn't shared. :thinking:

Well I see photographs as an integral part of photography therefore any discussion or statement on a photograph is by it's very nature a discussion or statement on photography.
 
Well I see photographs as an integral part of photography therefore any discussion or statement on a photograph is by it's very nature a discussion or statement on photography.

I see photographs as concrete and photography as more abstract.

I don't think we're ever going to agree.

But I suspect most people will follow your line of thought.
 
Strange, no one has said apples and oranges yet, no need to thank me all at once. After skimming through this thread it seems no one mentioned the enjoyment of shooting. This to me is far more important than any one camera system, lens or format.
 
After skimming through this thread it seems no one mentioned the enjoyment of shooting. This to me is far more important than any one camera system, lens or format.

Maybe because the post was originally talking about the results rather than the process of shooting.
 
....aaaaaaand relax everyone........

Who would have thought some bloke with an ancient 35mm camera would have caused so much kerfuffle.....
 
ok my take on this is ..... old guy still uses film cos he don,t know or understand a computer, he loves his photography he takes some very nice pics.:thumbs: which it,s obvious people buy, so will everyone please stop knocking a guy for doing what he loves. the (comment) he is supposed to have made probably came from an over zealous pap interviewing him for the local rag :razz: so let him have his time as a pro in his own way. i,m sure if he read this he,d be saying WTF!!!!!!! (YOU WOULD,NT BELIEVE MOST OF THE PEOPLE ON HERE ARE FELLOW TOGS LOL)
 
I always reckon people can use what they want,if they are happy with the results,whats it matter...............:shrug:
 
Surely a good landscape pic is 50% achieved by being in the right place at the right time with the right view and light, and 50% by getting the composition right?

It's not like motorsport or wildlife where you need expensive lenses and bodies with fast AF and huge apertures to get the best results.

can,t believe you said that the guy gets up"at 2 o,clock in the morning to make sure he,s in the right place at the right time" a little bit of dedication required to do that :nono:
 
Back
Top