Pro's and Con's of shooting in RAW

Most of the advantages of Raw have been already covered but to me its worth it just to be able to adjust the whitebalance afterwards.
There are no disadvantages that I can think of its just one extra step to convert a Raw.
I'm also still learning the PP process so in a years time I will probaly want to go back and redo shots for example I've just discovered that DPP has a curves function ! :D
Pete
 
I always find it amusing when I see threads like this, some people seem to take such polar opposites and that the way they do it is 'right'. :lol:

There are misconceptions coming from both sides imho.

If you shoot RAW then there is a lot of post processing needed.

Well, as with any image, it may need some processing to some degree, but then it may not. :shrug:

People say that all RAW images need to be edited, but do they? I can see where a batch edit may be needed to correct a problem, the wrong White Balance used for example, but generally you work on the images that need it, as with a Jpeg.

If you think that all your images are potential keepers then well done to you. :thumbs: I certainly only need to 'process' a small percentage of the images I take, and if it is a number of images that are very similar, then normally there are one or two which stand out as being 'the' potential image.

RAW files take up space.

Yes they do on a RAW v Jpeg file basis, but do you need to keep all the RAW files take? I don't need to, but I do because as someone said earlier, conversion technology advances, but I know that 85-95% of what I keep are rubbish that no technology can make into a usable image, but I keep them for the memories in some cases, and to remind me not to make the same mistakes again. Hopefully. :lol:

If I was doing photography as a business I would be a lot more streamlined and ruthless with my images, keeping what needs to be kept, but I'm not a professional so it doesn't matter what I do as long as I'm enjoying what I'm doing.


Jpegs are not the best quality available.

Maybe not, but what is your final aim for your images? If it is for the net or a 6x4 7v5 print, then as long as you don't need to make major changes to an image, then Jpegs will be fine.

There are a number of Jpeg settings that can be customised in camera and I wonder whether many people take advantage of them. :shrug: If minimal editing is the aim, then these preset and customisable picture styles would seem to be a good idea.


These type of threads are good for people who are unsure of the differences between RAW and Jpeg and hopefully help people to make an informed decision of what is best for them. At least know what your options are, and try all the options to see if you a missing out on anything.

But always remember, it doesn't have to be either/or, it can be both. And you get all the possible benefits post capture by taking both, apart from the using up more Memory Card and HD space. But as I said earlier, you don't need to keep everything you shoot unless you want to. ;) :lol:
 
Well it's funny you should mention that. My PC was having trouble with the Zoombrowser software, but literally 10 minutes ago I've just found Faststone which seems to be a lot faster - lends itself to choosing the pics for batch processing a bit easier I guess.

HmmMmMmm.. got me thinking now! ;)

I use ‘Bridge’ I find it fast and you have all the exif; you can enter like copyright details and tag them so you can do fast search on the tag names.
Say you take a photo of a red poppy, you can tag it under:- flower, red, poppy, place you took it, natural history and lots of other things you might like to tag it with.
 
I didn't stick with digital for long enough to try it but I would think that if you knew what you wanted and learnt how to use all of the functions properly, you could tweak the settings to produce in-camera JPG files the way you wanted them in much the same way as I will choose a film for its characteristics.

This would be more than adequate for most people, especially if normal size prints and/or web presentation was what you wanted.

On the other hand, the type of person who would be able to do this level of menu customisation would probably be the type of person who would like to post process RAW files!


Steve.
 
if i had raw i would try it...but with so many jpegs taken over the years..i dont think i could keep the raw originals
but it would be nice to see if they are really better for 6x4 prints and show and tell on forums
not really my league i think
 
Whilst we are on the subject, how do you usually edit your RAW files ? In the RAW editor or just 'open file' and edit with normal PS controls and what are the usual tweaks ?

I usually 'Open File' straight into PS and use the normal controls, bit of curves and a sharpen (most of the time, but there are exceptions)
 
raw wins, give me more options after the fact than jpeg which i think is massively important

also though it is possible to edit jpegs, every save reduces file size and detail levels. To edit properly lossless files ARE important
 
Whilst we are on the subject, how do you usually edit your RAW files ? In the RAW editor or just 'open file' and edit with normal PS controls and what are the usual tweaks ?

I usually 'Open File' straight into PS and use the normal controls, bit of curves and a sharpen (most of the time, but there are exceptions)

For me it is mostly Lightroom with occasional trips to Photoshop for some tricky edits. Or if I want to squeeze absolute most from the raw files (in terms of best possible quality for demosaicing), I do very occasionally use RawMagick.
 
raw wins, give me more options after the fact than jpeg which i think is massively important

also though it is possible to edit jpegs, every save reduces file size and detail levels. To edit properly lossless files ARE important

Have you used Lightroom? Edits are saved as metadata and as such, are completely reversible and lossless (in the context of the lossy JPG compression). You would have to be a bit dim to continually resave a lossy compression. As you correctly say, eventually it would end up as pure noise (like photocopying a photocopy).

If you care to print or export to web, a saved JPG is created, but the original file is unmolested.

Just my quick take on the debate: JPG for high volume (1000s of shots from holidays/festivals, 100s of shots from gigs). Raw for that one long exposure you've trekked half a mile in the middle of nowhere to get to. Horses for courses. I'd hate to manage all that raw data when it comes to high volumes (whatever people say, it slows you down and means you're constantly buying hard drives). Compression was invented for a reason.

I know wedding pros who use JPGs for this reason. They get it right in camera, sorting white balance out on site, where you can actually see what it should be, exposing properly, then moving on.
 
Whilst we are on the subject, how do you usually edit your RAW files ? In the RAW editor or just 'open file' and edit with normal PS controls and what are the usual tweaks ?

I usually 'Open File' straight into PS and use the normal controls, bit of curves and a sharpen (most of the time, but there are exceptions)

You have to use a RAW converter with Photoshop you will open it in ACR first and I guess lightroom has this as well.
 
You've had a bit of a transformation :p

I know what you're getting at but there's a lot I don't agree with in there :p Before I say anything else I'll say I use both RAW and jpeg.

The first bit doesn't seem to make sense. The camera manufacturers include jpeg options for people who need them. To use your analogy not using jpeg is a bit like buying a 5 speed sportscar and not using 1st or 5th. You're not using the tools the manufacturer has provided at the appropriate times.

The space argument is still valid. Yes, space is cheaper, but files are larger. If you're doing big shoots it doesn't take long to fill a 1Tb drive. I've got about 4TB of storage in my PC just now and am about to archive and replace two 1TB drives.

As far as processing is concerned I think there is a case for RAW, but it does depend on the type of photography you're doing. For me, there's hardly any processing, if it's a bad photo in terms of exposure, it's binned, I've got plenty more to choose from (events).

The last comment really did make me laugh though. Presumably we'll be seeing all the newspaper and sports agency togs chucking their D3 and MkIII's because they're not shooting RAW :lol:

As a general point I don't mind if people want to use RAW all the time, it's got it's place, as has Jpeg and it's there choice. What does grip my **** is the attitude that because someone doesn't use RAW all the time somehow they don't care about their photography. Frankly that's rubbish. Jpegs are capable of providing extremely high quality in print or on the web. Arguably it may not be "best" but how often has anyone looked at an image on here or in print and thought, "Wow, that must have been shot in RAW".

Well funnily enough you've missed the point - :bang:

I said shoot jpeg to go pretty much straight to print - what do you think I do with my studio shots if not pretty much just that??? As explained in the other thread you linked to. Such images need no WB adjustment, nor exposure adjustment, nor exposure rescuing, nor anything else you can think of where a raw file may be useful

And then you go and miss the same point again:bang::bang: re press & sports togs - who of course have no time for any PP and all goes straight to print

In landscape work, architectural work, weddings, pretty much everything that does not go straight to print raw is best - and I know one top Judo sports tog who shoots both - one for PRINT quickly for his mag deadlines & newspapers, while the same images are also saved as raw for books, prints, posters etc. later

But you are entirely correct that you can't look at any image, ever probably, and know for certain whether it was from a jpeg or raw file; and true too that some suggest raw as the only way for the same stupid 'snob' value that shooting in manual supposedly has :shake:

However - raw rules :D

DD
 
Whilst we are on the subject, how do you usually edit your RAW files ? In the RAW editor or just 'open file' and edit with normal PS controls and what are the usual tweaks ?

I usually 'Open File' straight into PS and use the normal controls, bit of curves and a sharpen (most of the time, but there are exceptions)

ACR with Presets - hardly anything goes to Photoshop except for finishing for print etc. same as a jpeg :D

Dump the crap and you don't have space issues either - most are just not ruthless enough - wimps :razz:

It's been a crap day, I'm more than pee-d off so watch it one-n-all :bat::bat::bat:

:lol:

DD
 
Have you used Lightroom? Edits are saved as metadata and as such, are completely reversible and lossless (in the context of the lossy JPG compression). You would have to be a bit dim to continually resave a lossy compression. As you correctly say, eventually it would end up as pure noise (like photocopying a photocopy).

If you care to print or export to web, a saved JPG is created, but the original file is unmolested.

Just my quick take on the debate: JPG for high volume (1000s of shots from holidays/festivals, 100s of shots from gigs). Raw for that one long exposure you've trekked half a mile in the middle of nowhere to get to. Horses for courses. I'd hate to manage all that raw data when it comes to high volumes (whatever people say, it slows you down and means you're constantly buying hard drives). Compression was invented for a reason.

I know wedding pros who use JPGs for this reason. They get it right in camera, sorting white balance out on site, where you can actually see what it should be, exposing properly, then moving on.

I use LR to manage and edit my RAWs never knew it worked the same way for jpegs
 
The way I learnt it was that RAW is capable of basically taking all of the information collected by the cameras sensor and saving it for future use. This allows you to alter an image in post production with far more flexibility (read less loss of data or image quality).

This is why I always shoot in RAW.
 
ACR with Presets - hardly anything goes to Photoshop except for finishing for print etc. same as a jpeg :D

Dump the crap and you don't have space issues either - most are just not ruthless enough - wimps :razz:

It's been a crap day, I'm more than pee-d off so watch it one-n-all :bat::bat::bat:

:lol:

DD

You have to use a RAW converter with Photoshop you will open it in ACR first and I guess lightroom has this as well.

I guess ACR is like my Camera RAW 4 (the panasonic program that came with the camera) Are there any benefits to tweaking in these programs that are dedicted to RAW or can i do the same in PS ? (I did actually change the white balance today in there for the first time before opening into PS, woo hoo !) All the tweaks seem to be do-able in PS and as i usually finish up cropping and stuff it made more sense to do it all in PS.
 
Well funnily enough you've missed the point - :bang:

I said shoot jpeg to go pretty much straight to print - what do you think I do with my studio shots if not pretty much just that??? As explained in the other thread you linked to. Such images need no WB adjustment, nor exposure adjustment, nor exposure rescuing, nor anything else you can think of where a raw file may be useful

So you've sold your DSLR then, I think that's what you recommended? ;)
 
The way I learnt it was that RAW is capable of basically taking all of the information collected by the cameras sensor and saving it for future use.

Exactly. RAW is the data as it appears on the sensor. In order to turn it into an image, you need to interpolate the RGB data into full image data and do some other tweaks such as sharpening and contrast adjustment, etc.

You can either do it once in the camera and live with that version or do it on the computer and experiment with various options.


Steve.
 
Exactly. RAW is the data as it appears on the sensor. In order to turn it into an image, you need to interpolate the RGB data into full image data and do some other tweaks such as sharpening and contrast adjustment, etc.

You can either do it once in the camera and live with that version or do it on the computer and experiment with various options.


Steve.

and the computer is always better as it has more processing power and allows finer control
 
dalex before i write in response to your reply to my post is there any point or are you pretty much stuck in your opinions?

can't really be bothered if it's going to be futile if you see what i mean?

the jist being i disagree with most of what you've written from what i can tell
 
dalex before i write in response to your reply to my post is there any point or are you pretty much stuck in your opinions?

can't really be bothered if it's going to be futile if you see what i mean?

the jist being i disagree with most of what you've written from what i can tell

Fair enough, I guess we are not going to agree. I am not stuck btw, not more than you do in yours anyway ;)
 
and the computer is always better as it has more processing power and allows finer control
Really!!

My ZX81 struggles to process an image quicker than I used to get them from Boots, and it takes 128 piggybacked Rampacks to be able to load an image, that's assuming the dog doesn't knock the table :D
 
Some interesting points raised here. Perhaps once you've all sorted this topic out you can tell me whether a spanner is better than a screwdriver.

The other point about all the extra information in the RAW file is that you can't actually keep it anyway. You're monitor can't display it and you can't print it out onto paper. You have to bin it at some point.

What the more sage amongst us here have been saying is that we always need to look at the job in hand and choose the best tool available. There is no one size fits all. :)
 
Really!!

My ZX81 struggles to process an image quicker than I used to get them from Boots, and it takes 128 piggybacked Rampacks to be able to load an image, that's assuming the dog doesn't knock the table :D

its bad that I had planned out a shouty response, then noticed the smiley then googled zx81 hehehehe lol

and odds are the camera has a juicier processor, though you get more control on the zx if you don't mind staying up all night :D
 
Some interesting points raised here. Perhaps once you've all sorted this topic out you can tell me whether a spanner is better than a screwdriver.

The other point about all the extra information in the RAW file is that you can't actually keep it anyway. You're monitor can't display it and you can't print it out onto paper. You have to bin it at some point.

What the more sage amongst us here have been saying is that we always need to look at the job in hand and choose the best tool available. There is no one size fits all. :)

I can tell you a bolt is better than a screw :D

But I'd rather make my JPEGS in a time and manner of my choosing not how the camera decides, if I wanted to give away control I'd use a PnS or just my phone
 
Really!!

My ZX81 struggles to process an image quicker than I used to get them from Boots, and it takes 128 piggybacked Rampacks to be able to load an image, that's assuming the dog doesn't knock the table :D

The ZX81 was much better than the ZX80 and 1K RAM was such a dream... and the audio cassette saving of files meant you had endless storage really!
 
TBH its a situation thing, if it was an important event and you only had a 1GB memory card then shoot jpeg but if you have more memory then go RAW because it depends heavily on memory. also if it is a once in a lifetime thing then go raw so you dont fail.
 
The other point about all the extra information in the RAW file is that you can't actually keep it anyway. Your monitor can't display it and you can't print it out onto paper.

A slight correction if I may. There are high dynamic range displays even at this time - they are just astonishingly expensive. As with all the technology with time it will find its way to common users like we are. For now, most of a good quality LCDs out there are already capable of displaying 10 bits per channel which is 4 times larger than JPEG is capable of anyway. And as for printers, there are a few already that do allow 16bit per channel printing - Canon PIXMA Pro9500 Mark II for example.

And you can always keep the RAW information - end product is not always JPEG. Could be 16bit TIFF or PSD (where nothing is lost) and good printing houses do accept TIFFs as well (did this just half a year ago and sent my 16 bit B/W photo to print on large canvas as 16bit TIFF).
 
I guess ACR is like my Camera RAW 4 (the panasonic program that came with the camera) Are there any benefits to tweaking in these programs that are dedicted to RAW or can i do the same in PS ? (I did actually change the white balance today in there for the first time before opening into PS, woo hoo !) All the tweaks seem to be do-able in PS and as i usually finish up cropping and stuff it made more sense to do it all in PS.

PS will not open a RAW file it has to go through ACR or some other raw converter
I convert to 16bit TIFF when going into PS
Remember a JPG is 8bit and has 256 levels of information
RAW file most are 14bit which is 16,384 levels
Or some are 12 bit and they have 4,096
So do you want to start with 256 levels from black to white or 16,384?
And one last point is the top level i.e. top 1/5th has 50% of this data so under expose and miss this top stop and with a jpg you will only have 128 levels where as with a 14bit RAW you have 4096 left.
Now which do you want to shoot in?:shrug:
 
PS will not open a RAW file it has to go through ACR or some other raw converter
I convert to 16bit TIFF when going into PS
Remember a JPG is 8bit and has 256 levels of information
RAW file most are 14bit which is 16,384 levels
Or some are 12 bit and they have 4,096
So do you want to start with 256 levels from black to white or 16,384?
And one last point is the top level i.e. top 1/5th has 50% of this data so under expose and miss this top stop and with a jpg you will only have 128 levels where as with a 14bit RAW you have 4096 left.
Now which do you want to shoot in?:shrug:

Well i think i must be missing something then. When i open a RAW file the default program is my 'panasonic camera RAW' which opens with PS, as sort of a top layer. I can then choose to tweak the file in the RAW editor or open it with PS. If i choose to open with PS it shows as having a RAW file extension whilst opened (i cant save it as a RAW though, i can only save a RAW in the original editor) although thats not an issue because when i want to save the original file it has already been tweaked (and then i save it as a .tiff and keep the original, unaltered RAW)
 
Well i think i must be missing something then. When i open a RAW file the default program is my 'panasonic camera RAW' which opens with PS, as sort of a top layer. I can then choose to tweak the file in the RAW editor or open it with PS. If i choose to open with PS it shows as having a RAW file extension whilst opened (i cant save it as a RAW though, i can only save a RAW in the original editor) although thats not an issue because when i want to save the original file it has already been tweaked (and then i save it as a .tiff and keep the original, unaltered RAW)

You arte opening the image with Panasonic Camera Raw and convertibng it, then opening it in PS. What Chaz is saying is that you can't open the file directly in PS without a raw converter, which is what PCR is.
 
PS will not open a RAW file it has to go through ACR or some other raw converter
I convert to 16bit TIFF when going into PS
Remember a JPG is 8bit and has 256 levels of information
RAW file most are 14bit which is 16,384 levels
Or some are 12 bit and they have 4,096
So do you want to start with 256 levels from black to white or 16,384?
And one last point is the top level i.e. top 1/5th has 50% of this data so under expose and miss this top stop and with a jpg you will only have 128 levels where as with a 14bit RAW you have 4096 left.
Now which do you want to shoot in?:shrug:

some of the time Jpeg, some of the time RAW.
 
My camera allows me to shoot in both formats at the same time. :clap:

But default for me is raw, this allows me to get the best out of my images due to my dubious camera technique.

Nikon Capture NX2 is my friend.

Sums it up nicely:thumbs:
 
You arte opening the image with Panasonic Camera Raw and convertibng it, then opening it in PS. What Chaz is saying is that you can't open the file directly in PS without a raw converter, which is what PCR is.

Yeah, I know. What I don’t understand is if I don’t tweak the images in PCR first and load them straight into PS (all be it via PCR) is PS just as effective or does PCR have a better way of dealing with the RAW file first.
 
I can tell you a bolt is better than a screw :D

And who among us has not had to abandon one for the other?

Especially if a husband/boyfriend/father/mother has turned up at an inopportune moment?
 
And who among us has not had to abandon one for the other?

Especially if a husband/boyfriend/father/mother has turned up at an inopportune moment?

lol I love that game though I like being in someones back garden before getting dressed less :p

must think before posting innuendo :bang:
 
Back
Top