Scanned 35mm trannies - why do they look so awful?

Messages
12,589
Name
Jeremy Moore
Edit My Images
No
I'm using a good quality slide scanner (Nikon Super Coolscan 5000ED) to scan my old 35mm slides at 4000dpi, but when viewed on screen they look dreadful!

However, I think, and hope, that they would produce perfectly good prints.

I've had some scanned commercially on a big flatbed scanner as well, and they printed OK despite looking terrible on screen.

Can anyone explain why this should be?
 
I think you'll have to elaborate on what's terrible about them for anyone to be able to comment.
 
jerry12953 said:
I'm using a good quality slide scanner (Nikon Super Coolscan 5000ED) to scan my old 35mm slides at 4000dpi, but when viewed on screen they look dreadful!

However, I think, and hope, that they would produce perfectly good prints.

I've had some scanned commercially on a big flatbed scanner as well, and they printed OK despite looking terrible on screen.

Can anyone explain why this should be?


Are you looking at them at 100% it amazes me how clean a digital file from a decent camera can be even at ridiculous ISOs, people pixel peep and complain about stuff that would be impossible to achieve on 35 film or slide. Your probably just seeing what film looks like when viewed this closely.
 
Are you looking at them at 100% it amazes me how clean a digital file from a decent camera can be even at ridiculous ISOs, people pixel peep and complain about stuff that would be impossible to achieve on 35 film or slide. Your probably just seeing what film looks like when viewed this closely.

Yes, certainly at 100% they look terrible. I don't know how to describe it - out of focus, noisy, grainy, just dreadful really. You wouldn't tolerate them from a digital camera.

And yet they produce decent enough images when printed, either photographically or litho.

When I made my first (and only) submission to alamy I made the mistake of using scanned trannies and they were rejected as being "soft or lacking definition". I suppose they just blow them up to 100% and make a decision from there, despite the fact that they print fine.
 
I'm using a good quality slide scanner (Nikon Super Coolscan 5000ED) to scan my old 35mm slides at 4000dpi, but when viewed on screen they look dreadful!

However, I think, and hope, that they would produce perfectly good prints.

I've had some scanned commercially on a big flatbed scanner as well, and they printed OK despite looking terrible on screen.

Can anyone explain why this should be?

Same thing happen to me,with my 1st scans,they looked dreadful,i was using an canon,i think i did mine in to much of a hurry :D,havnt had the time to go back and try again,but will give it ago again,when i get more time :)
 
I tried some myself and they look quite dreadful at 2000x3000 - thats with 300/2.8 lens!

Film quality could have an impact - ISO 25 is probably the one giving slightly better resolution, but still miles away from ISO 400 digital.

What sizes were the prints OK? I could get 8x12 ish but I doubt I could push it much further; digital goes to A2 and well beyond even when viewed closely.

Personally, only large format (or MF - pushing it) is worthy shooting film. Digital is miles ahead.
 
I wouldn't bother printing photographically from scanned 35 mm trannies normally but they've been acceptable up to 15 x 10 inches when I've had to.

Commercial (litho) printing though, I've been surprised at how good the quality can be from 35mm Velvia 50 slides even printed quite large. The detail can be fantastic, even though the scans might look terrible!

Maybe it really is just an example of how good the quality is from digital now - and has been for some time.
 
Last edited:
I was having this problem as well, scanning doesn't seem to get the slide right.

If you are using something like Velvia it has a magenta cast which tends to scan red making shadows look icky and requires some work to bring back to normal. I've found adjusting the histogram for each image by changing the black/white/grey levels in the scanning software usually gives you much more leeway when post processing later.

When i do scans of slides now i always project them first so i can see what they really look like, then i scan them to make them look close enough, put them back in the projector and edit the slide scans in Lightroom to match the projection on the wall next to me. Doing this made me realise that the scans weren't that bad, it was just how the film looked but i couldn't tell till i'd seen them projected.
 
I was having this problem as well, scanning doesn't seem to get the slide right.

If you are using something like Velvia it has a magenta cast which tends to scan red making shadows look icky and requires some work to bring back to normal. I've found adjusting the histogram for each image by changing the black/white/grey levels in the scanning software usually gives you much more leeway when post processing later.

When i do scans of slides now i always project them first so i can see what they really look like, then i scan them to make them look close enough, put them back in the projector and edit the slide scans in Lightroom to match the projection on the wall next to me. Doing this made me realise that the scans weren't that bad, it was just how the film looked but i couldn't tell till i'd seen them projected.

My scans have a fairly predictable slight blue cast to them. Do you have a lightbox? If it has a colour corrected tube it might be a better way of assessing the colour balance than a projector.....

It 's funny that you can blow a 35mm slide up pretty huge using a projector and it often looks OK. Maybe you don't examine them so carefully then.
 
It 's funny that you can blow a 35mm slide up pretty huge using a projector and it often looks OK. Maybe you don't examine them so carefully then.

But then you're probably sitting a few metres away from the screen, not peering at it from merely a few inches away. ;)

e2a: put another way, I suspect most people here would think twice (and probably five, six or seven times) about blowing up a photo taken by a 2 megapixel camera to a 50" print and putting it in their living room, but that's exactly what you do with an HD TV.
 
Last edited:
More on scanning and related topics.....

A couple of days ago I took 11 images on a disc to a local printer. Three were digital files, the other eight were (corrected) scans. They all looked fine on my monitor.

On the monitor at the printers (Mac based), the digital images looked fine - and very similar to what I saw on my own monitor. The scans looked quite different.

Any suggestions why this should be?

If it was poor calibration of my monitor, wouldn't they all have looked different?
 
I think our old slides are not actually as good as we remember them Jerry, and while they looked great projected across the room, they didn't in fact stand up that well to closer scrutiny. My very best Kodachromes are barely as good as I got from my 40D everytime with ease, and the 5D2 just blows them away completely effortlessly.

That's the first thing, and the second is that a professionally scanned litho reproduction is a very high quality affair, skilfully separated into three colours, each one custom adjusted, and then a black applied to give some much needed extra punch.

Basically, it's not easy. And even then, you can't get quality out that isn't there in the first place :(

NB I've heard good reports of bulk scans done in India. Never had any myself, but publishing companies get their archives digitised that way. Mostly medium format though, cos 35mm wasn't good enough...
 
Hoppy, I agree with you about the quality of digital and the technical quality of the images you get from a 5D2.

I'm happy to accept that if you look at an image scanned from 35mm at 100%, its going to look awful in comparison. From my recent experience this seems to be the case even with professionally scanned slides.

However, when printed lithographically they can still produce very good results.

Any idea why the scans should have looked so different to the digital files on one monitor, when they all looked fine on another? I can't see any logical reason for that.
 
Last edited:
I spent ages scanning and cleaning up loads of 35mm. Learning how to use the clone tool is useful as you can take out major blemishes. Gone right off film since doing that.

Which scanning software do you use? Vuescan has profiles for different film types so it corrects for some of the colour differences.

It's just best not to pixel peep :)
 
Here's a good video on retouching 35mm scans if it's any help.
http://ow.ly/5qtwj

Thanks, I'll have a look at that.

"I spent ages scanning and cleaning up loads of 35mm. Learning how to use the clone tool is useful as you can take out major blemishes. Gone right off film since doing that.

Which scanning software do you use? Vuescan has profiles for different film types so it corrects for some of the colour differences.

It's just best not to pixel peep"

Indeed, I do agree about the pixel peeping. I'm using the software which came with the scanner, Nikon Scan. It seems to produce good results at normal settings and I take the scans into Lightroom to adjust them. Not they seem to need much adjusting mind you!
 
Last edited:
Back
Top