Selling images taken on private land

Messages
782
Edit My Images
No
This is sparked by another thread on the forum but I didn't want to hijack it, so...

I understand that if you take photos on private land when you've been instructed not to constitutes trespass and that you can be forcefully removed, and I understand that selling or using photos taken when instructed not to may lead to you being pursued for damages - but what about when you're not told not to take photos? I can't find any information relating to what you can do if you're not issued any terms.

For example:
You attend an event at a race circuit as a spectator and you receive a ticket. One of the terms of entry is that your photography is for your own personal use only. Nice and simple, no selling or giving them to the paper or anything like that.

On another day they have a track day when they don't operate a ticket system so you aren't made to agree to their usual terms or even told what they are. Does the fact they haven't imposed the usual terms mean you're free to sell your photos from that event?
 
I would guess that by entering their premises you are agreeing to any rules they care to apply
 
Can you agree to rules that you aren't shown? If it's on a ticket or on signs then that's fair enough but if the rules are hidden away on their website or not published at all it seems a bit unreasonable to have you automatically agree with them.
 
speaking as a guest on a lotus track day last year, whilst not a ticketed event, I did have to sign my life away to ride around in various cars, one of the conditions was I couldnt use any pics for commercial purposes whatsoever etc etc etc.........

Mind you quite tricky to get a sharp pic when being thrown round Snetterton in an Elise at silly speeds around corners........
 
Can you agree to rules that you aren't shown? If it's on a ticket or on signs then that's fair enough but if the rules are hidden away on their website or not published at all it seems a bit unreasonable to have you automatically agree with them.

That'snot correct.

If it's on the ticket and the ticket directs you to the web site where the T&Cs are located then by entyeriung you are accepting them. They should be easy to find (not normally hidden away).

You need to be careful as you could have someone claim compensation for loss of sales - especially if pro's are there and have the consent.
 
Can you agree to rules that you aren't shown? If it's on a ticket or on signs then that's fair enough but if the rules are hidden away on their website or not published at all it seems a bit unreasonable to have you automatically agree with them.

Not unreasonbable - Would be unreasonabale not to check.

If it's on the ticket and the ticket directs you to the web site where the T&Cs are located then by entering you are accepting them. They should be easy to find (not normally hidden away).

You need to be careful as you could have someone claim compensation for loss of sales - especially if pro's are there and have the consent.
 
If it's on the ticket and the ticket directs you to the web site where the T&Cs are located then by entering you are accepting them. They should be easy to find (not normally hidden away).

You need to be careful as you could have someone claim compensation for loss of sales - especially if pro's are there and have the consent.

I'm talking about when you don't get a ticket at all, just walk in to somewhere through the front entrance without anyone really caring and aren't hindering someone else's ability to sell photos.

If their terms were buried on their website and you never had any reason to see their website it's unreasonable (morally, I don't know if it's unreasonable legally and I imagine you'd have to argue it in court which would be expensive) to have you to agree to them by entering as you've very little chance of knowing they exist and no way of checking them unless you had internet access at the location.
Though I'm thinking of cases where there wouldn't be any terms communicated to you in anyway way whatsoever.

---------------

For clarity this thread about selling photos taken at an Oulton Park track day is what made me wonder.
Everyone's launched into helping the OP sell the photos but no one has mentioned the issue of permission, which I thought was odd considering tracks normally prohibit selling photos taken there. Given the questions the OP is asking and their other threads on the forums I'm assuming they're not a professional and were just there for fun but have ended up with a possible sale so I was wondering if the OP has mistakenly assumed they can sell the photos without permission and that the people replying have mistakenly assumed the OP has permission or whether it's actually alright for them to do so.
 
Last edited:
There could be an argument that you are trespassing just because you were not challenged doesn't mean you should have been there.

One reason why these events are not generally open to "the public" is that it changes the insurance/permit.
 
I'll be honest I don't know the answer but you could try and sell the images and wait to see if anyone comes after you :)
 
Can you agree to rules that you aren't shown? If it's on a ticket or on signs then that's fair enough but if the rules are hidden away on their website or not published at all it seems a bit unreasonable to have you automatically agree with them.

By and large, no. You're not bound by terms and conditions that you didn't know about, and couldn't reasonably be expected to know about. That's why they're normally displayed at entrances etc, and may also appear on tickets. It's to inform, and to make it very difficult to argue that "I didn't know".
 
I'll be honest I don't know the answer but you could try and sell the images and wait to see if anyone comes after you :)

I've sold a number of urbex pictures that were taken without permission. No one's come after me, but no one cares probably, or they haven't been reading the books and mags in which they were published.
 
If it's on the ticket and the ticket directs you to the web site where the T&Cs are located then by entyeriung you are accepting them.

That can't be right surely? not everyone has the internet..the rules would only apply to those with internet access :)
 
There could be an argument that you are trespassing just because you were not challenged doesn't mean you should have been there.

One reason why these events are not generally open to "the public" is that it changes the insurance/permit.

Trackdays are not run under an MSA permit. The organising companies are not MSA registered clubs, so presumably have their own insurance rather than using the MSA's master policy.

We hire various circuits for motorsport events run under MSA permits. At none of them do we impose any restrictions on photography by members of the public that remain in areas that the public have access to. Further, we do not charge the public for entry to the venue, at one circuit it is a condition of the hire that our use is "non-revenue", i.e. that we do not charge the public to enter.

If the circuit wishes to restrict sale of images that is not something they have ever made us aware of when we've hired the place from them.
 
That can't be right surely? not everyone has the internet..the rules would only apply to those with internet access :)

No - Look at the competitions on TV. they all say the same. For the T&Cs refer to the web @ www.whatever.com/whatever

Quite normal as the majority of people have access and all can get access through their local library if required.
 
No - Look at the competitions on TV. they all say the same. For the T&Cs refer to the web @ www.whatever.com/whatever
.

so your saying if its on telly it must be right?

its not... :)

not everyone has access to the internet. thats a fact. you cannot presume they have.. therefore you cannot enforce T&Cs on people who have no access to them... common sense tells us that :)
 
Simple solution to the problem.... ask the landowner if they mind...

Whilst ignorance is bliss, ignorance is no excuse in the eyes of the law.

If you are engaging in business, surely its best to find out if there are any problems.

Hardly worth getting a fiver for a photo when it could land you in hot water. I seem to remember the often cited figure for damages for unauthorised commercial use of sporting images can be monumental - perhaps not for some track day, but maybe... you don't know until you ask.

Lastly, sure there are chancers out there who do sell stuff they aren't supposed to, personally I don't because I like to play fair and don't want to loose my house over something thats quite frankly chicken feed.
 
so your saying if its on telly it must be right?

its not... :)

not everyone has access to the internet. thats a fact. you cannot presume they have.. therefore you cannot enforce T&Cs on people who have no access to them... common sense tells us that :)

Re access - id change that to "not everyone has access to the internet at home". All but the most needy will have acces to libraries where you can access the net for free. Not that that is an issue really.

At an event, the T&Cs will most likely be posted there somewhere - although whether you take the time to read or not is down to the individual.

I think it would be down to what is reasonable at the end of the day. Not saying any particular way is right though as if we're honest I don't think any of us actually know for sure :)
 
onomatopoeia. MUI that any "event" (track days, test days etc) involving cars, motorbikes etc has to apply for an exemption from certain parts oft he R.T.A these are issued by the MSA , ACU AMCA, etc and are referred to as certificates of exemption.

The ones I have seen talk about "are the public being permitted" but makes no referance to weather they are paying or not. I do know for actual MSA events there is a differance in the premium paid if the event is open to public or not.
 
I know what I think ... everybody is speculating.

Best go and see someone with real legal knowledge on these matters.

Or as I said... just bloody ask!
 
There's a time and a place for consulting lawyers, but I've worked with a lot of them and it's often a case of 'maybe, it depends, it's complicated, there's more than one way to look at this'................It's not always a cop out, or an excuse to rack up fees, the law can be a ass and it can be difficult to give a definitive opinion at times. Things can go either way if something gets to court.

I'd definitely get legal advice/representation if I was facing serious criminal charges or civil proceedings, or if I was thinking about initiating proceedings; but probably not for run of the mill stuff. There are often easier and cheaper alternatives.
 
Or... You could just ask the press office for the circuit...for free
 
Those kinds of blanket exclusion terms are usually just hot air with the sole intention of protecting the event holder's own interests, ie in this case probably some local tog/s who have a deal to sell prints on behalf of the circuit. Same with music gigs.

Unless you have read and signed something specifically excluding photography, then all they can do is tell you to stop, throw you out, and ban you from coming again. No laws have been broken.

If you take pictures and use them commercially there are other legal niceties to be aware of, as there always is, but no legal come-back from the circuit owners just for taking them, even if they threaten it. They'll just ban you.
 
KIPAX said:
so your saying if its on telly it must be right?

its not... :)

not everyone has access to the internet. thats a fact. you cannot presume they have.. therefore you cannot enforce T&Cs on people who have no access to them... common sense tells us that :)

Totally disagree. If you don't have access to the Internet, you can't check the T&Cs so you shouldn't go in if that bothers you.

If we follow your argument to it's conclusion, no contract would ever be enforceable if the signatory couldn't read. If that were the case, businesses would be lining up to hire illiterate staff to sign their contracts to give them a get-out if it goes Pete Tong. If I sign a contract in Spanish, it's still enforceable even if I had no idea what it said. The responsibility lies with me to ensure I understand the conditions I agree to.

The protection you DO have is through the Unfair Terms in Consumer Contract Regulations, which state that conditions you weren't aware of aren't enforceable. But that wouldn't cover you CHOOSING not to read them. In any case, it's unlikely that a track day ticket would be covered by the regulations.
 
Llamaman said:
Totally disagree. If you don't have access to the Internet, you can't check the T&Cs so you shouldn't go in if that bothers you.

OFT: Unfair contract terms guidance
Guidance for the Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regulations 1999
September 2008

http://www.oft.gov.uk/shared_oft/reports/unfair_contract_terms/oft311.pdf

Office of Fair Trading said:
9.1 Terms which have the effect of making consumers agree to accept obligations of which they can have no knowledge at the time of contracting are open to serious objection. It is a fundamental requirement of contractual fairness that consumers should always have an opportunity to read and understand terms before becoming bound by them (see Part IV).

9.2 It is not 'hidden terms' themselves that are indicated to be unfair, but any term which binds the consumer to accept or comply with them – or, in legal jargon, 'incorporates' them 'by reference'. However, terms of whose existence and content the consumer has no adequate notice at the time of entering the contract may not be binding under the general law, in any case, especially if they are onerous in character.

9.3 We also object to terms which require consumers to accept that they are bound by the terms of other linked contracts (for example, insurance contracts) or rules or regulations unless they are given an appropriate chance to read them.


OFT: A guide for businesses on distance selling

http://www.oft.gov.uk/shared_oft/business_leaflets/general/oft698.pdf

Office of Fair Trading said:
Written and additional information (Regulation 8)

3.9 Once consumers decide to buy you must provide them in writing with some of the information at paragraph 3.1 and some additional information (Regulation 8)

3.10 If you provide pre-contractual information in a form that does not allow it to be stored or reproduced by the consumer, such as during a phone call or on a website, then you must confirm in writing, or in another durable medium12 available and accessible to the consumer, the information given at paragraph 3.1(i) to (viii).
 
Back
Top