Street Photography - what's it all about?

Messages
9,521
Edit My Images
Yes
Hi all

I'm clearly confused and need some guidance please

And please, I'm not having a 'go' at anyone's photography here but...

I know there's quite a following on TP about 'Street Photography', but I'm sorry to say I just don't get it at all

:shrug::shrug::shrug:

The basic technique seems to be... wonder around a street, ideally with a very wide aperture lens, and snap away at a load of strangers buying shopping, having a fag, strolling along on one's mobile phone, eating crisps/chips/whatever...

Little heed needs to be paid to usual rules of composition, exposure, WB, and camera shake or a degree of OoF seems to be fine - and generally do so where the subject doesn't know you're photographing them - so there's rarely any connection either. Isn't it just snapshot voyeurism???

I, like many I know, like sometimes to sit and watch the world go bye - and I guess we all look/comment/giggle about the vagaries of others' shapes, action & dress sense from time to time, but why photograph it?

So what's the point then? Cos I really can't see why anyone would want to do it as (IMHO) rarely do the results look more than boring 'snaps'

Please enlighten me - I'm clearly missing out here

:help::help::help:

Yours, confused of Barnsley

DD
 
I have only tried it a few times and to get a decent shot that I'm happy with is rare.

I hate taking 'posed' shots of people, much prefer them in thier natural environment with natural expressions.

Rather than just snap away I do think about the shot before hand.

About the only 3 I'm happy with.


DSCN2842-1.jpg


page1-3.jpg


DSCN3237copy.jpg


There is also that added excitement of being escorted of the premises, (happen once to me), or punched in the mouth, (not happened to me yet).
 
i havent twken any street shots as yet .but to me theres a diffrent challenge every where you look in the towns/citys .Being on here an seeing the diffrent shots is a good inspiration to take some as each corner you turn or doorway you pass is diffrent and may not ever be repeated .
 
Its about seeing the interesting or obscure in everyday moments that most people either just plain don't see, or can't see as anything more than 'an everyday thing.' Also its about documenting life, the photographer's life, the feel of life on the streets or wherever it may be at a particular time / location. If it wasn't for street photography then we would have far less idea of what life was like in the past 100 years or so.

Besides, its a damn site more interesting than white backgrounds and making everyone look the same in a studio. ;)
 
Hmm, for a start, I think the usual rules of composition, wb, exposure, etc, DO apply, very much much so, which is half the art to good street photography - its being able to get an asaethetically pleasing shot in those few brief moments whilst at the same time, capturing a 'moment in time', and point of interest. That isn't to say that breaking the rules makes for bad street photography, it can make for some very good shots, in the right circumstances.

For the photographer, capturing that 'perfect' moment without the luxury of setting it up, pre-planning and taking as many shots as you want till you get it right is the challenge. Even getting a landscape in the perfect light will usually allow for a little more time than trying to get that one shot before the person/people moves on and the image is gone. For the viewer, its like any other picture, one man's apple pie is another mans poison, you can like fo dislike the final result, but the appreciation is also in whether you can say yes, thats a good image even if its not my thing.

Well, thats just my opinion anyway. ;)
 
Dear Confused Of Barnsley :lol: (sorry, couldn't help that; sounds like something out of Dear Deirdre! Anyway (ahem)..

Hi DD,
I fully understand what you are saying, and in a sense, you are right about the 'snapshot voyeurism' thing, but there is a bit more to it than that. I consider myself to be a Street Photographer (I'm blummin' rubbish at it mind, but that's another story) and snapping people on the street going about their daily business is something I really enjoy doing. Photography should be varied, right? And there's nothing more varied in the world than people - no two subjects are the same.
That said, for me, 'true' street photography has to have a point of interest and actually 'say' something, or it is just a candid snapshot. Proper street photography is about Timing in my opinion. Catching someone doing something at the exact precise moment is a skill in itself. It's something you have little or no control over, and may never catch the moment again. It really is a challange, and a hard one at that.
I recommend that you check out a 'proper' Street Photographer by the name of Matt Stewart (just google it). Have a look at some of his work to see what I mean. At first glance, some of his images look like just a snapshot, but keep looking... you will be amazed at how he sees the world. A scene that you or I would probably not even notice and would pass by, he's noticed something and captured it.
Here is an example of my own work:

2340747391_0c16711946.jpg


At first glance, you may think it's just a homeless guy going through a bin, but the wording on the shop window above him makes the shot. Get it?
Also, SP doesn't have to be 'on the street'...

2347467667_4118c29c99_o.jpg


Again, first glance tells you it's just a candid shot of an old guy in a pub. But look again, and you'll see he's sitting in the same pose as the girl in the picture above his head!

SP is 'candid snapshots' in a way, but with a twist.
 
Besides, its a damn site more interesting than white backgrounds and making everyone look the same in a studio. ;)

I wondered when the insults would start

:D

I take a boring shot of a child, a fraction of a life moment, and it goes onto someone's wall. A year or so later we repeat it, chronicling that person's life and making a family truly happy & giving them something to enjoy and laugh at perhaps 50 years later when someone else photographs their grandkids

The fag smoker you snap will never see your shot, it won't end up on a wall & 99.99% of the time it sits on your harddrive with no-one viewing it. 10 years from now if you see it again, you'll say/think what? That jacket's in fashion again? Or Top Shop has moved? And that's not boring?

Thanks for your attempt at an explanation - but nope - still don't 'get it'

DD
 
I think Ladylens has pretty much got it bang on from my point of view. Which happens more often than not it should be said.

It's really not my bag at all, I don't really enjoy it and seldom engage in it. All good reasons to go and do some I guess.

I did once have the immense pleasure of printing an exhibition for a very great (what I always called a) grab shot photographer. It was a nightmare as his negs were truly terrible and shots that he spent less than a second of his life considering and executing, took me sometimes weeks to get the perfect print from.

The shots were fabulous though and I very much doubt I could have shot that collection.
 
Thanks for that - Matt Stewart's work is ace - wonderful use of humour. But I can't help thinking he see's potential, then waits for the right sort of people to walk by and make the shot - otherwise he'd be extraordinarily lucky with some of those fab shots

So if that's what you're after, I can see the fun but I still don't see what you'd do with it afterwards

Jokes are inherently ephemeral. Would you really want such on your wall? And if so, for how long? You'd have to change it often to not be boring

His work is completely different to the 'man with a fag' shot so familiar to Street Photography though as it has a clear point; so in most SP am I just not getting the point?

DD
 
I think its just a matter of taste.

I do portraits and i am very pleased when the client is pleased but sometimes I do think the posed portrait with plain background is boring. I would rather take the photos of the children in a park or digging the garden ect.

BUT they are their children and they love them.

Street photography is a whole different ball game and some will not end up on the wall but that moment is frozen in time and will be looked back on in years to come as it will be our history.


and our history is important
 
i take quite a few 'street' photography photos and strange as it may seem very seldom upload & most do stay on hard drive. Ones below probably not best examples i took last weekend. for some reason people do strange thing whn i piont camera at them


2425252550_49c3895089.jpg


2424439405_9c730b9394.jpg


2425252276_7dd55f5fbe.jpg


2425300096_c2bce1056e.jpg
 
just a thought on this topic and what oh just said (what you see today may not be there tomorrow).
 
I wondered when the insults would start

:D

I take a boring shot of a child, a fraction of a life moment, and it goes onto someone's wall. A year or so later we repeat it, chronicling that person's life and making a family truly happy & giving them something to enjoy and laugh at perhaps 50 years later when someone else photographs their grandkids

The fag smoker you snap will never see your shot, it won't end up on a wall & 99.99% of the time it sits on your harddrive with no-one viewing it. 10 years from now if you see it again, you'll say/think what? That jacket's in fashion again? Or Top Shop has moved? And that's not boring?

Thanks for your attempt at an explanation - but nope - still don't 'get it'

DD

You really could put this argument across for anyones photography other than marketed studio portraits. We as (mostly) digital photographers of all subjects, wildlife, still life, landscape, street, artistic photography etc etc. Im sure we all have thousands of shots sat on our hard drive not being shown to anyone.

I do tend to get rather bored with perfectly focused, white balance, sharp, posed etc etc studio or just portrait photos. Street photography produces something real an unrepeatable moment.

You really cannot compare studio photography for the family album and street photography.

One of mine from last weekend:

DSC00565edit3resize.jpg
 
Nice debate,

Personally, I think that the are two things here. One as others have said is the use of ironic text or other things that make a street photo engaging - about seeing. Then there are the simple 200mm snaps that people take that are not true street work but a good effort but not true street photography.
 
I take a boring shot of a child, a fraction of a life moment, and it goes onto someone's wall. A year or so later we repeat it, chronicling that person's life and making a family truly happy & giving them something to enjoy and laugh at perhaps 50 years later when someone else photographs their grandkids

Just before I get into this I'm only generalising and not picking on your work. I'm going for dramatic effect :) The thing I hate about babies in front of white backgrounds is that they're so far removed from life its unreal. 50 years in the future they'll look back and say "Ah remember when we put the baby in front of a big piece of white paper? Good times." Which I think is why I love street photography because its so real. Remember when that thing actually happened? No offence to you as I'm sure your client base is happy.

The fag smoker you snap will never see your shot, it won't end up on a wall & 99.99% of the time it sits on your harddrive with no-one viewing it. 10 years from now if you see it again, you'll say/think what? That jacket's in fashion again? Or Top Shop has moved? And that's not boring?

But why does it matter whether the subject has seen it? Its not studio portraiture. He isn't a client. Its documentary. Maybe no-one will ever see it but the photographer did. They saw it, they were there and they documented it. Do you take photos just to show people or do you take photos to take photos? I'll document whatever I can because I can. I might not show people but I would feel that I let myself down if I didn't take that photo.

I think the thing here is that you're a studio photographer. You manufacture moments. You have complete control over the light and the way people are. Its the complete opposite of street photography. Street photography is about spotting those real moments. Right place, right time. I don't really know what I can say to make you see the light, so to speak. Its not a complex thing really. Its simply capturing life on the street. It drives me because its real and its gone in a split second. You can go back into the studio and get the same pose day after day. You can't capture what happened in real life yesterday ever again.

http://www.in-public.com/
http://flickr.com/photos/motionid/sets/72157594486719792/
Great pdf on street photography but it does contain swearies.
 
Think you hit the nail on the head there Pete.

Street photography is a much needed break from as Pete put it dull 'Manufactured moments'.
 
petemc - you've said it as it is. I see street as photos from a real life movie - the stage is constantly changing - the script, completely random...
 

Probably one of my favorite photographers. Sean manages to capture real life, one off moments so well. His shots are beautiful and intriguing.

Some of my favorite photos taken by MotionID are below, i think they help prove my point...

http://www.flickr.com/photos/motionid/425126512/

http://www.flickr.com/photos/motionid/805508349/

http://www.flickr.com/photos/motionid/421913936/

http://www.flickr.com/photos/motionid/2041147695/
 
Manufactured moments have their place, street is no less valid creatively than studio, studio portrature is all about the subject, isolated on an un-distracting background.
Its not boring, its an art, where every crease/line/shadow is an important detail.
Street is different, street is about telling a story, or capturing a moment that is interesting enough for the viewer think about what they seeing and ask questions.
Technical aspects dont matter, even basic w/b/focus/stuff aren't more important than the content as a whole.
Sometimes they are manufactured in the sense that the shot was "waited for", other times purely accidental and others are just seen.
They can be candid or not, the subject/s can be eyeing the lens or not, close or distant, this doesn't define street.
Street is a story, a moment in time captured, I think if the viewer is not engaged by the photo, it has failed as "street".
 
Manufactured moments have their place, street is no less valid creatively than studio, studio portrature is all about the subject, isolated on an un-distracting background.
Its not boring, its an art, where every crease/line/shadow is an important detail.

I didn't mean that they have no place. I do them myself but there is something synthetic about them. Sure they can be nice but they're not "real".

Technical aspects dont matter, even basic w/b/focus/stuff aren't more important than the content as a whole.

I disagree. Technical does matter or the greatest street images ever taken would be blurry badly processed messes.

“To take photographs means to recognize - simultaneously and within a fraction of a second - both the fact itself and the rigorous organization of visually perceived forms that give it meaning. It is putting one's head, one's eye and one's heart on the same axis.” - Cartier-Bresson

A similar thing to what I say. Photography is about what you see, what you feel and what your camera saw. Get those 3 things right and you'll get a good photo.
 
Little heed needs to be paid to usual rules of composition, exposure, WB, and camera shake or a degree of OoF seems to be fine - and generally do so where the subject doesn't know you're photographing them - so there's rarely any connection either. Isn't it just snapshot voyeurism???

usual rules of composition only count when its possible, you walking maybe sitting see something that tickles your fancy you may only have split second to react. No time to compose perfect shot thats spontaneity of street photography.
 
I didn't mean that they have no place. I do them myself but there is something synthetic about them. Sure they can be nice but they're not "real".

Not real, depends on the processing, I have more of an issue with that than any background.
Definitely, floating in white is a surreal backdrop, but the focus is the portrait, the face/body whatever.
It is manufactured, but, I dunno, everything is I suppose by some measure.


I disagree. Technical does matter or the greatest street images ever taken would be blurry badly processed messes.

To a point, I mean, if you can't make the image out, its no good, but the technical rules and attention to detail of studio portraiture dont really apply to street.

I like this guy Joel Meyerowitz, I watch this video and I still dont know how he does it, I think his best work is actually with Large Format, but his insight/methods of shooting street, really say what street photography is imo.

somebody needs to get Winogrand out of the closet:lol:
 
Fantastic thread.

DD, its simply a case of each to their own. I must admit, studio portraits do nothing for me and I wouldn't have that type of image on a nice canvas hanging on my wall, just not my bag, I find it cheesy. I'm sure you understand I'm not saying it isn't technically easy or anything. Its a bit like asking a guy who is perfectly happy driving round in the nissan primera he's owned for the last 10 reliable years why he doesn't fancy a brand new range rover or lotus elise, its just not his thing is it ?

Maybe its also a bit like why men will NEVER understand women. Just one of those things that maybe one day, one might start to grasp, but quite unlikely.

I've tried street photography several times and never really come away with a shot I like so I can fully respect the work that goes into being a real street photographer.

I've also tried to get nice portraits of friends children for them and none of them have turned out any good either, so can also respect the kind of work you do.

There are many variations on a theme in this world, cars, houses, people, religions, etc etc, also photography.
 
Photography whatever the style is imo a snapshot in time that can never happen again. A piece of history to marvel over in years to come.

I like those stiff formal portraits of the Victorians but equally the street scenes showing life as it was.

Before the camera was invented the painter was the only way to record how someone looked. Understandably most of these paintings are of rich people. But how I wish there were more paintings of Victorian street life. History fascinates me and I expect there will be people like me in the future as well.

The written word is a great source of information but a 'picture paints a thousand words'.
 
Photography whatever the style is imo a snapshot in time that can never happen again.

Thats true of course but its far easier to recreate a lighting setup on a white background and tell a person to smile in a studio than it is to get 10 random people on the street to re-enact their emotional states from yesterday. Getting the cloud formations just right so that light is the same is always tricky ;)
 
Street photography isn't really about taking a technically perfect shot. Basic rules of photography still apply, but street doesn't exactly have a set style, it a very undefined, organic style of shooting. It's not about simply taking snapshots and freezing a moment in time, it's about experiencing these moments and (hopefully) being able get a decent shot out of it. It's about making the ordinary extraordinary, making models out of people everyone walks by everyday. It's about capturing that very decisive moment, whether it's a kind gesture or someone barfing out that night's kebab after a night's heavy drinking. It's the experience of witnessing those moments.
 
It's about capturing that very decisive moment, whether it's a kind gesture or someone barfing out that night's kebab after a night's heavy drinking.

OK, now I think you're going too far! :suspect:

Actually, that would make a great shot :clap:
 
Fascinating read all - thanks

I understand Matt Stewart's 'jokes' as lying in wait for the appropriate street scene to emerge - and his shots are extremely well seen and executed

But I still can't see what history we'll learn from motionid's (here http://www.flickr.com/photos/motionid/sets/72157594486719792/ ) images of wet underpasses and umbrellas shot against OoF lights; nor pictures of women pushing a pram with a fag in hand? If it was purely about history, we'd record the whole scene rather than someone's feet methinks?

I've seen street shots recently of a teenager holding a ball and a woman looking in a shop window - does that tell us anything? Aside from clothes perhaps, haven't teenagers kicked balls for donkey's years and didn't women look in shops when they were first invented? Will they ever stop!

I can see it's a moment in time, as is a water drop, or a cloud formation captured skirting over a mountain - it's just the relevance that still eludes me

Maybe I could have a go with someone and better see it then?

I'm also intrigued by the assertion that it has to be up close and personal, 50mm or less presumably, as a 200mm shot isn't street photography apparently. So if you're that close - do you ask to take someone's photo? Or just shoot it anyway and wait for the 'What the f-ing Hell are you doing?' comments???

DD
 
I've got a book called "24 hours in the life of a city" It was shot in Glasgow in the eighties. The whole project was to give the newspaper togs around Glasgow cameras and film and gave them all 24 hours to shoot the character of the city.
It's one of my favourite books, technically brilliant and a fantastic record of life in a 24 hour snapshot.

That 24 hour slot will never come around again and I do wonder where some of the people in the book ended up. Where are they now? how did their lives turn out?

I think that's my favourite use for street photography, it is a record of not just a place but a time too.
 
i usually use 50mm but ones above i used 28-135mm which is why camera sticks out and more posed for shot even thou they werent posed more an imptomtu act of showing off.

I took a load of down & outs one day with 50mm took shots then asked if ok to use to be nice i offered odd ciggy as inducement lol

I would say take a 70-200mm out or 70-300mm get used to taking people as sort of voyuer at a distance, then when your comfortable use 50mm something like that. i dont think there are any 'rules' on what lens etc you use.
 
Interesting that you mention
a water drop
above as in another thread based upon a 'throwaway' comment by another you tried catching watch /water droplets in a glass and now seem to quite like it.

If your not sure as to the point in something why not go out and try it and then come back and see if you feel any different.

I had never been in a studio until a couple of weeks ago and despite having been there still have loads to learn. I could have come away disappointed and gone back to landscapes etc but having been there I am interested in doing more.

Its like anything even if you dont understand it does it make it uninteresting or not worth giving a try and then fair enough if its still not your buzz move on or stay in the area you enjoy the most the studio. :)
 
Interesting that you mention above as in another thread based upon a 'throwaway' comment by another you tried catching watch /water droplets in a glass and now seem to quite like it.

If your not sure as to the point in something why not go out and try it and then come back and see if you feel any different.

I had never been in a studio until a couple of weeks ago and despite having been there still have loads to learn. I could have come away disappointed and gone back to landscapes etc but having been there I am interested in doing more.

Its like anything even if you dont understand it does it make it uninteresting or not worth giving a try and then fair enough if its still not your buzz move on or stay in the area you enjoy the most the studio. :)



Try it eh Sheepy? Okay, why the Hell not

Barnsley market here I come (when I find out when it is first!)

Anyone free to come along too?

DD
 
I don't think there are any rules per-se on lenses. Although you do get the old school crew who say if it isn't on a Leica with a 50mm prime, then it isn't SP. Personally I use the nifty fifty for the bulk of my street stuff, its un-intrusive, fast and versatile, so makes sense to me. I also shoot quite a lot on the 10-22 as well, I just think with shorter focal lengths you engage the viewer more, and feel more like part of the moment.

You should be in there with the people you're photographing anyway, so shorter lenses just make more sense.
 
Who said it had to be so we can learn from it? Maybe in 30 years time motionid's pictures will be more valued, who knows. Doesn't bother me. They're nice photos of real life. You won't get the "WTF are you doing" comments. The reason why street is meant to be 50mm not 200mm is so you're so much more a part of the scene. 200mm you're detached and removed from the situation. Its easier.
 
Try it eh Sheepy? Okay, why the Hell not

Good man, frankly I am not sure your view will be any different but what do I know but hey gets you out in the fresh air :lol:

Take Del give her something to try in addition to her very nice flowers :nuts:

Sorry cant help you with the market location :shrug: trying to find my own locations in the deep south at the moment!

Kev
 
Looks like we're fixing up for a shoot this Wednesday - I don't have a nifty-fifty (you may have seen my views on those elsewhere on TP!), so I'll try my 20mm f1.8 instead

If it happens, I'll post a few for you all to slag off and tell me where I'm going wrong !!! Should I wear combat trousers and take band-aids for the blood letting?

Cheers

DD
 
Back
Top