Street Photography - what's it all about?

I've never been 100% clear on it. I'm selling it under a sort of fine art / editorial cloak. Basically I'm saying that this is what happened. Model releases are only really needed when you're using the model's image in advertising. I'm not. Its fine art documentary.
 
I think I have been confusing my attempts at street photography as such, with candid portraiture.
Still can't make my mind up.
 
Umm, bit late, sorry.

To me good street photography is like John Coltrane or Ornette Coleman, it's improvisation, interacting with the moment and seeing where it takes you. Most studio portraits are like your average pub rock covers band, churning out the same stuff ad nauseum.
 
Again this is all the divide of fine art photographers and commercial service ones.

People have vastly different tastes.

Personally I love gritty photos, maybe not a lady with fag, but then again i never like the subject to be so pushed in your nose.
 
Fantastic thread, really interesting reading. I've not made it through all the posts yet but wanted to first of all say thanks for sharing Matt Stuart & Motionid's work - really inspirational, just stunning.

I love street photography and think Petemc has hit it on the head with his comments.

Eddie.
 
street is an extension of our love of voyeurism (in the most saintly definition)...if people didn't like to watch people you wouldn't have street photography or coffee shops. There are thousands of coffee shops which mostly sell crap coffee...

I think street photography is photography at its most raw and basic, the problem is as with anything simple, if it's not done well it's crap. Taking a picture of your local tramp is a bit like HDRing your local church...getting a bit old now (excuse the pun)

No surprise that many of the great photographers were/are street or documentary photographers.
 
Good old Wikipedia describes street photography as a "type of documentary photography that features subjects in candid situations within public places".

It constantly amazes me the weird and wonderful things that you see day in day out that need recorded. Pictures of street performers waving at the camera, by contrast, aren't street photography, they're snapshots......
 
I like street photography for its documentary worth and its for this reason that I cannot undertand the many photographs of street performances. Ok, I can see that it may be something different in a normally grey uninteresting street, but they have no link to reality. They nearly all wear costumes and act in a way which gives no indication of the era in which the image was taken. Todays street pics will be tomorrows history lessons. Images that stay in my mind are from the forties and fifties seeing children at play with sticks and hoops, perambulators and bomb sites.

I'd like to be here in fifty years to look back on todays scenes and compare.
 
Images that stay in my mind are from the forties and fifties seeing children at play with sticks and hoops, perambulators and bomb sites.

I'd like to be here in fifty years to look back on todays scenes and compare.


Unfortunately the hysteria that surrounds photographing children nowadays means that future generations won't have such images from our time to look back upon...
 
Deja Vu :D

Sorry to drag it up, just interesting to see this had been discussed not so long ago, and I completely missed it!

DD: Do you get it yet? Or are you still on the fence, so to speak?

Interested in seeing how opinions develop over time.

Gary.
 
DD, I don't get it either... and not because its not what I want to shoot - because I'd not want to take photos of children in studios or weddings either (yes, lovely money for those, but that's not what I do photography for!)

Without getting personal, most of what I have seen posted as SP anyway is just snaps. Just in the same way as I would crit someone's motorsport shots, unless it shows some intent at composition, its just pointing the camera and pressing the button.

I'm sure I'm about to be told that I have totally missed the point and that the randomness of the output is exactly the intent in the first place but....

I think you will find that if you pull out the stuff "considered to be the finest examples of the genre" (and I don't mean from flickr...) that the compositions actually do work - by chance or by design? If you give an infinite number of monkeys an infinite number of typewriters....
 
I'm sure I'm about to be told that I have totally missed the point and that the randomness of the output is exactly the intent in the first place but....

I think you have missed the point as for me Street photography is anything BUT random.
 
I have to say that I also don't "get it".... I don't know why I don't, and (I think) I actually want to "get it". Maybe I just don't understand.....

But then I look at a beautifully constructed Italian motorcycle and think it's heaven sent, and my wife says "it's just a bike..." :shrug:

Steve
 
DD, I don't get it either... and not because its not what I want to shoot - because I'd not want to take photos of children in studios or weddings either (yes, lovely money for those, but that's not what I do photography for!)

Without getting personal, most of what I have seen posted as SP anyway is just snaps. Just in the same way as I would crit someone's motorsport shots, unless it shows some intent at composition, its just pointing the camera and pressing the button.

I'm sure I'm about to be told that I have totally missed the point and that the randomness of the output is exactly the intent in the first place but....

I think you will find that if you pull out the stuff "considered to be the finest examples of the genre" (and I don't mean from flickr...) that the compositions actually do work - by chance or by design? If you give an infinite number of monkeys an infinite number of typewriters....

I'd say you've missed the point by a pretty wide margin and you last paragraph is a bit of an insult to those who have worked hard to develop the skills required to be good at street photography. Allthough I guess you could say the same about all photography, if you let 50 monkeys loose with 1D's at brands hatch you'd eventually get a perfect shot.
 
The way i see this argument, is that Street Photography would be a hobby, whereas the family in a studio will pay bills.

I guess its similar to people using a car to get from A to B, and others who modify and stick bits onto their car.

I cant see much money to be made in street photography as a general rule, but I can understand why it is a hobby for some.
 
The way i see this argument, is that Street Photography would be a hobby, whereas the family in a studio will pay bills.

I guess its similar to people using a car to get from A to B, and others who modify and stick bits onto their car.

I cant see much money to be made in street photography as a general rule, but I can understand why it is a hobby for some.

I think thats a tad short sighted. Professional Photographers will make money through a variety of images, I bet there are some who can easily sell "street shots".

Gary.
 
Deja Vu :D

Sorry to drag it up, just interesting to see this had been discussed not so long ago, and I completely missed it!

DD: Do you get it yet? Or are you still on the fence, so to speak?

Interested in seeing how opinions develop over time.

Gary.



I was wondering who'd rediscovered this thread - might have known !!! :D

Funnily enough, although it's still not really my cup-of-tea - I have developed an appreciation for identifying what I feel is 'good' Street over the multitude of mostly snaps I see purporting to be Street

At Weddings, I always tell any 2nd tog (mostly Dellipher now) to watch for people's interactions developing and to try to capture that - but by paying particular attention to the background so it either compliments or at least doesn't distract

The better Street stuff seems to use this strategy too - often the background makes the shot by telling the story or adding humour; or gives a better Street Portrait by removing the background entirely and thus placing sole emphasis on the subject

I've only tried it once, and even then only a walkabout with my wife - so less than ideal - but I did enjoy doing it and the results weren't too bad

Would I now fancy shooting Street on such as a TP meet - Yes I would

Would I go out & about by myself just to shoot Street - probably not

Is that an ok answer Gary ??? :)

DD
 
I was wondering who'd rediscovered this thread - might have known !!! :D

Funnily enough, although it's still not really my cup-of-tea - I have developed an appreciation for identifying what I feel is 'good' Street over the multitude of mostly snaps I see purporting to be Street

At Weddings, I always tell any 2nd tog (mostly Dellipher now) to watch for people's interactions developing and to try to capture that - but by paying particular attention to the background so it either compliments or at least doesn't distract

The better Street stuff seems to use this strategy too - often the background makes the shot by telling the story or adding humour; or gives a better Street Portrait by removing the background entirely and thus placing sole emphasis on the subject

I've only tried it once, and even then only a walkabout with my wife - so less than ideal - but I did enjoy doing it and the results weren't too bad

Would I now fancy shooting Street on such as a TP meet - Yes I would

Would I go out & about by myself just to shoot Street - probably not

Is that an ok answer Gary ??? :)

DD


Can, Worms, Everywhere :D

Sorry - I did not think bumping the thread would lead to round 2 ;)

Good to see you have found an appreciation for it. I have fallen in love with it, as it allows me to take photos everywhere I go!!

Still, I'm choking to get out and shoot a few landscapes, and looks like I have the time now.

Gary.
 
There was a mention back somewhere about Henri Cartier Bresson making a living from street photography. He did, but from what I can see, there's a world of difference between what he did and the pretty generic "man with fag in hand" street photography you see a billion of on flickr.

I find that much of the recent street photography I've seen, there doesn't seem to be much context. It could be a guy/girl or old man/woman walking down/standing still on the street anywhere at any point in time in the last 15 years. For a documentary photograph I'm not entirely sure this kind of photograph is entirely useful or relative.

I don't want to knock this kind of photography, because some of it is great and very interesting but there's a whole lot of generic street photography that doesn't tell me anything I haven't seen numerous times before. But then I suppose if some of the street photographers were doing anything significantly different or ground breaking, their photos would be hanging in a gallery or featured in a book as opposed to being sat on flickr, much like my photos :)
 
I think thats a tad short sighted. Professional Photographers will make money through a variety of images, I bet there are some who can easily sell "street shots".

Gary.

granted it is a vast generalisation, but it was in response to the "boring, white studio" comment above. Everyone enjoys different styles, and everyone does it for different reasons.

:shrug:
 
Agreed. Thats why the purists use a range finder. Its easier to blend in with that than a 30D + grip + 24-70 + hood. May as well wear a pink flag and quack.

that not just because they are stuck in the past clinging to an outdated expensive camera
 
I'd say you've missed the point by a pretty wide margin and you last paragraph is a bit of an insult to those who have worked hard to develop the skills required to be good at street photography. Allthough I guess you could say the same about all photography, if you let 50 monkeys loose with 1D's at brands hatch you'd eventually get a perfect shot.

So show me ones that do work then...

Trust me, there are enough motorsport shots out there that are dreadful too (and I'd include quite a few of mine in that!)

The point I am trying to make is that zapping someone wandering around town and do a contrasty black n white conversion does not make art in itself.

Its perhaps harder to get that magical context, story, composition, lighting and mood in this form of photography than most others.

So, once again, demonstrate examples of what works and explain why it does, then maybe us non-SP'ers would get it.
 
So show me ones that do work then...

Trust me, there are enough motorsport shots out there that are dreadful too (and I'd include quite a few of mine in that!)

The point I am trying to make is that zapping someone wandering around town and do a contrasty black n white conversion does not make art in itself.

Its perhaps harder to get that magical context, story, composition, lighting and mood in this form of photography than most others.

So, once again, demonstrate examples of what works and explain why it does, then maybe us non-SP'ers would get it.

Just look through this group i'd say this is pretty much cream of the crop and they never let any of the usual cliches in Man smoking,homeless person etc etc.

http://www.flickr.com/groups/onthestreet/

Here are a few I think that work really well that might mean nothing to anyone else.

http://www.flickr.com/photos/shadda/3061892160/sizes/o/in/pool-94761711@N00/
Excellent simply for the surrealness also I think the composition is very good.How long would you be waiting for this moment to happen again?

http://www.flickr.com/photos/maciejdakowicz/3012714064/in/pool-onthestreet
Pretty much for the same reason Lighting is really nice too

http://www.flickr.com/photos/waxypoetic/2489942238/in/pool-onthestreet
Her stare the way she looks almost unhuman,the reflections:love:.
 
Dave,

Street photography works for me as the viewer on two levels, the first level is trying to empathise with the photographers motives, what makes this image a decisive moment, in the eyes of the photographer

The second level is to consider what the image means to you?, What feelings are generated for self when viewing this image?

As a photographer , I am wanting my images to not only tell a story but generate a debate within the viewer , in short I am offering my perception of the world through the image.

As for the lens debate there is a school of thought that to ‘feel it’ you need to be’ near it’,I guess that can be explained why some people want go to a football march for the atmosphere , whist others prefer to watch on TV.

2500340292_3b6de58a54.jpg


The image above, taken on the street of Manchester signifies to me how we are being absorbed by the brand, how individuals are seeing themselves more as part of the consumer race than the human race.

I call this image ‘Full brand absorption’ a term coined by marketing psychologists to signify someone’s total loyalty to a brand.

Hope this explanation helps ..
 
So show me ones that do work then...

Trust me, there are enough motorsport shots out there that are dreadful too (and I'd include quite a few of mine in that!)

The point I am trying to make is that zapping someone wandering around town and do a contrasty black n white conversion does not make art in itself.

Its perhaps harder to get that magical context, story, composition, lighting and mood in this form of photography than most others.

So, once again, demonstrate examples of what works and explain why it does, then maybe us non-SP'ers would get it.

I don't think its anything you will just "GET". You either get it, or you don't. You feel it, or you don't. I don't feel motorsport, or photos of small birds for example. I am indifferent to them. I like the technical merits of those shots, but they leave me cold otherwise.

You don't need to "get" street, as long as there are a few people that do, then all the great photos this forum has seen over the past few days, will continue to inspire.

Gary.
 
Just look through this group i'd say this is pretty much cream of the crop

Would you really? I've had a quick browse and my overriding impression is that they are pretty average examples of Street Photogrpahy. Granted, they're far better than most of the 'snaps of strangers' I've seen posted on forums purporting to be Street Photography, but there are far far finer examples of what makes a good SP shot knocking around.
 
Would you really? I've had a quick browse and my overriding impression is that they are pretty average examples of Street Photogrpahy

Okay you caught me out there :nuts::|

I'd say it is for a place regulary turning out street shots I just tried to use less famous shots/people to get my point across.I could of just linked a magnum profile and be done with it :lol:

Like with everything In photography its very subjective I'd say streetphotography is probally one of the most subjective genres.
 
Street photography works for me as the viewer on two levels, the first level is trying to empathise with the photographers motives, what makes this image a decisive moment, in the eyes of the photographer

The second level is to consider what the image means to you?, What feelings are generated for self when viewing this image?

As a photographer , I am wanting my images to not only tell a story but generate a debate within the viewer , in short I am offering my perception of the world through the image.

Yes! I get that! Good explanation.

Aren't we looking at something close to "proper art" here, in that I look at a cow cut in half and pickled and say "you have cut a cow in half and pickled it... errrm why?" and yet perhaps with the commentary of "this conveys my feelings of the dominance of industrialised agriculture", maybe I do get it as a commentary...


2500340292_3b6de58a54.jpg


That works for me, that is good.

By its very nature though, this sort of shot is a random happening upon, I mean you couldn't walk into an urban environment and just have this happen? Or if you did, it would only be because you had spotted that as an oppurtunity before (much as perhaps say I had worked out a particular corner at a circuit always caused cars to spark etc).
 
So, once again, demonstrate examples of what works and explain why it does, then maybe us non-SP'ers would get it.

No explanation needed for these I feel.

Alan Wilson visits another foum I'm a member of ...
edinburgh9.jpg


Matt Stuart is a reknowned Street Photogrpaher ...

1.jpg


3.jpg


01.jpg


05.jpg


For me, Street Photography can be summed up in one words - juxtaposition.
 
For me, Street Photography can be summed up in one words - juxtaposition.

Ahhhh now we are getting there!

100% see that.

Nice examples too, those are more what I had in mind than "shopping woman with a fag on"
 
By its very nature though, this sort of shot is a random happening upon, I mean you couldn't walk into an urban environment and just have this happen? Or if you did, it would only be because you had spotted that as an oppurtunity before (much as perhaps say I had worked out a particular corner at a circuit always caused cars to spark etc).

Alan Wilsongets the shots he does because he walks mile after mile every day. He knows the streets of Edinburgh like the back of his hand. Street Photogrpahy isn't any more about luck tha any other form. It's about having the eye for it and being able to put yourself in the best position to take advantage of a shot when your eye sees one.
 
No explanation needed for these I feel.

Alan Wilson visits another foum I'm a member of ...

For me, Street Photography can be summed up in one words - juxtaposition.[/QUOTE]

Those are great. There's just so much more to them, the last two in particular.

The only street photography I've indulged in is

[URL="http://www.flickr.com/photos/alastairmoore/2862342917/"][IMG]http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3200/2862342917_30a052e977.jpg[/URL]

and my mate forced me into it :) I don't know whether I like it or not but there you go.

Oh, and this one.



I dunno.. it's kind of fun I suppose but I don't think I'd make a career out of it!
 
to most 99% of the population its a funny picture of a man with a starbucks sign for a head turned B&W to make it more interesting :lol:



2500340292_3b6de58a54.jpg


The image above, taken on the street of Manchester signifies to me how we are being absorbed by the brand, how individuals are seeing themselves more as part of the consumer race than the human race.

I call this image ‘Full brand absorption’ a term coined by marketing psychologists to signify someone’s total loyalty to a brand.

Hope this explanation helps ..
 
yeah they are decetn shots but most of the ones you see are no decent which is I suppose what the OP is on about. street photography is not just taking random pictures in towns and cities then turning them black & white like these two

3314166lgnt4.jpg


3854036lgts6.jpg



No explanation needed for these I feel.

Alan Wilson visits another foum I'm a member of ...
Matt Stuart is a reknowned Street Photogrpaher ...

QUOTE]
 
I really like that one.

Does that make me a bad person?

I really like that one too, the first one is also a nice photo but not amazing.

It doesn't make you a bad person it just makes POAH appear contreversial as usual. See all the comments made in this thread for examples.
 
yeah they are decetn shots but most of the ones you see are no decent which is I suppose what the OP is on about. street photography is not just taking random pictures in towns and cities then turning them black & white like these two

Actually, I'd agree now I understand SP :thumbs:

Juxtaposition is where its at
 
Back
Top