The end of stop and search?

Messages
11,513
Name
Stewart
Edit My Images
Yes
Did everybody know that the infamous s44 has been repealed?

The Home Secretary announced it recently. She has made a "remedial" order which replaces sections 44 to 47 of the Terrorism Act 2000 with a "more targeted and proportionate power".

Full details on the Home Office web site here.

Apologies if this is old news but I don't recall seeing it mentioned on here anywhere.
 
Will still happen.
If they don't like the look of you, they'll just use some other "Excuse" and hassle you just the same, especially if your black, working class or forgien looking.
 
Will still happen.
If they don't like the look of you, they'll just use some other "Excuse" and hassle you just the same, especially if your black, working class or forgien looking.

Mmmm, Done nothing wrong? Nothing to worry about!
Working class (whatever that means) carried an ID card most of my life & never had a problem!
Mick
 
No it is not the end of stop and search

Stop and search has been around in one form or another for years, even before all this anti terrorism legislation, and is likely to be around for years to come IMHO
 
No it is not the end of stop and search

Stop and search has been around in one form or another for years, even before all this anti terrorism legislation, and is likely to be around for years to come IMHO
Of course. But the new legislation significantly restricts the ability of police to play the anti-terrorism card, and that's got to be good news for photographers.

From the explanatory notes to the new orders: "An officer exercising the stop and search powers may only do so for the purpose of searching for evidence that the person concerned is a terrorist." (My emphasis.)

That's a pretty high standard of justification.
 
Of course. But the new legislation significantly restricts the ability of police to play the anti-terrorism card, and that's got to be good news for photographers.

From the explanatory notes to the new orders: "An officer exercising the stop and search powers may only do so for the purpose of searching for evidence that the person concerned is a terrorist." (My emphasis.)

That's a pretty high standard of justification.

Not really Stewart, there are plenty of other "cards" the police can play

If they want to stop and search you they will
 
They said on the news the other day that they would increase stop and search in the run up and during the royal wedding.
 
Of course. But the new legislation significantly restricts the ability of police to play the anti-terrorism card, and that's got to be good news for photographers.

From the explanatory notes to the new orders: "An officer exercising the stop and search powers may only do so for the purpose of searching for evidence that the person concerned is a terrorist." (My emphasis.)

That's a pretty high standard of justification.

Imaginary quote from copper "....and we stopped said gentleman cause he was taking photos of a building which we suspect he might be planning to blow up later".

This form of S&S has been ruled out to be replaced by another - Didn't someone on here have small cards that you could print out which detailed photographers right etc?

Might be worth checking (and updating if needed) and redistributing?
 
Crikey, everybody's glass is half empty today, isn't it?

This is a significant improvement to the situation faced by photographers.

Section 44 allowed the police to stop people "for the purposes of searching for articles of a kind which could be used in connection with terrorism, whether or not the constable suspects such articles are present". As we all know, the police have frequently argued that photographs of buildings or individuals could be used in connection with terrorism, and that essentially gave them carte blanch to hassle photographers.

The new orders only allow the police to stop people "for the purpose of searching for evidence that the person concerned is a terrorist." And they have to have reasonable suspicion that you are a terrorist. Simply taking photographs, so matter how much it's getting up the nose of the policeman, is NOT grounds for reasonable suspicion.

Plus, the circumstances under which these powers can be exercised have also been narrowed. Previously, an authorisation to allow stop and search under s44 could be given wherever and whenever a senior police officer decided it was "expedient". Now, the police must reasonably suspect that (a) an act of terrorism is about to take place; and (b) the stop and search powers are necessary in order to prevent it. That's a very high threshold.

You ought to be celebrating this development.
 
Will still happen.
If they don't like the look of you, they'll just use some other "Excuse" and hassle you just the same, especially if your black, working class or forgien looking.

I've been stopped a number of times. I'm white, almost 50 and have been in a suit when stopped. Your class, creed or colour has nothing to do with it.

I agree with Stewart that this is actually good news.

ps: It's usually the uneducated, misinformed or over zealous that actually stop you going about your business. I haven't yet met with one unreasonable (full) police officer who has asked me to stop what I was doing while photographing anywhere.

Steve
 
Crikey, everybody's glass is half empty today, isn't it?

This is a significant improvement to the situation faced by photographers.

Section 44 allowed the police to stop people "for the purposes of searching for articles of a kind which could be used in connection with terrorism, whether or not the constable suspects such articles are present". As we all know, the police have frequently argued that photographs of buildings or individuals could be used in connection with terrorism, and that essentially gave them carte blanch to hassle photographers.

The new orders only allow the police to stop people "for the purpose of searching for evidence that the person concerned is a terrorist." And they have to have reasonable suspicion that you are a terrorist. Simply taking photographs, so matter how much it's getting up the nose of the policeman, is NOT grounds for reasonable suspicion.

Plus, the circumstances under which these powers can be exercised have also been narrowed. Previously, an authorisation to allow stop and search under s44 could be given wherever and whenever a senior police officer decided it was "expedient". Now, the police must reasonably suspect that (a) an act of terrorism is about to take place; and (b) the stop and search powers are necessary in order to prevent it. That's a very high threshold.

You ought to be celebrating this development.

But it also says:

(5) But the power conferred by such an authorisation may be exercised whether or not the constable reasonably suspects that there is such evidence.

So once the area is declared they do not need any other reason before they do a Stop & Search.

As always it depends on how the new powers are used.
Will they declare the whole area inside the M25 as an area where an act of terrorism is about to take place and renew the authorisation automatically, as they did before?

I agree that it should make it better for photographers, however it is a case of wait & see.
 
Back
Top