The Independent - Breach of Copyright

Messages
813
Edit My Images
Yes
Quite an interesting read below the photo of email being sent between the photographer and The Independent's Editorial Director for Digital..

Click me!

On the 5 – 6 January 2010 they used the Flickr API to search for and display images of snow scenes in the UK – amongst those images displayed was one of mine which is clearly marked on Flickr as “all rights reserved”. They did not seek my permission for the use of my image. I am assuming they used the API without applying a filter on the licence type, this also means that other UK photographers may have had their copyrighted work used without permission; might be worth checking if you had any refers from the Independent on those days.

Below, is a summary of the messages that have been exchanged between myself and Jimmy Leach the Editorial Director for Digital at The Independent; I found their initial reply both surprising and alarming.
 
On the face of it, it seems like a mistake by the Independent. They thought the images from Flickr were copyright-free (I assume) and simply used an image they liked, judging by the response they sent to the photographer.

Since the terms of Flickr are quite clear and legally laid out, I expect they will reach a monetary agreement with the photographer. It would be considerably cheaper than reaching a legal settlement!
 
On the face of it, it seems like a mistake by the Independent. They thought the images from Flickr were copyright-free (I assume) and simply used an image they liked, judging by the response they sent to the photographer.

Since the terms of Flickr are quite clear and legally laid out, I expect they will reach a monetary agreement with the photographer. It would be considerably cheaper than reaching a legal settlement!

:agree: But there is no way a newspaper should make a mistake like this! .. Having said that I do believe that Flickr make it too easy for this sort of thing to happen :thinking:
 
Agreed, it's a silly mistake. I suppose it depends who downloaded the image, whether or not it went through the usual picture channels, and whether or not the Independent's usual procedures were followed. I would expect a Picture Editor for a major national newspaper to know that Flickr is not always a free site, and to check license conditions.

They don't have a leg to stand on, legally, so I expect a quick settlement and resolution with the photographer.
 
Anyone involved with a national newspaper would know that you can't just use a photograph for free. Glad they got caught and hope they get what they deserve.
 
If nothing else in your cv you can list having "worked for the Independent as a freelance." ;)
 
This is the reason you will not see any of my pictures anywhere on the interweb.....every one gets paid for!

The Indy knew EXACTLY what it was doing - so do all the small businesses that rip pictures off for their websites, knowing full well the photographer is hardly ever going to trace it.

There are web crawler type programs you can get which will discover picture uses for you....I have the names of a couple, but not in my head because I don't need them.

How many ripped off pictures do you think there are in the Far East, India, South America......................would you ever find out? The picture tracing software will search the entire interweb and ntify you of each place it finds one of your pictures. I am not sure if you have to insert the picture or just your details for it to work - be a bit laboursome if it was the actual picture in each instance.

Small graphic designers are forever lifting work off the web - I have watched them do it and then got an earful for pointing out the wrongs. If you don't want yourpictures lifted and used for free, you have to keep them to yourself and show them directly to each and every client.
 
This is the reason you will not see any of my pictures anywhere on the interweb.....every one gets paid for!

The Indy knew EXACTLY what it was doing - so do all the small businesses that rip pictures off for their websites, knowing full well the photographer is hardly ever going to trace it.

There are web crawler type programs you can get which will discover picture uses for you....I have the names of a couple, but not in my head because I don't need them.

How many ripped off pictures do you think there are in the Far East, India, South America......................would you ever find out? The picture tracing software will search the entire interweb and ntify you of each place it finds one of your pictures. I am not sure if you have to insert the picture or just your details for it to work - be a bit laboursome if it was the actual picture in each instance.

Small graphic designers are forever lifting work off the web - I have watched them do it and then got an earful for pointing out the wrongs. If you don't want yourpictures lifted and used for free, you have to keep them to yourself and show them directly to each and every client.

How very true. I once, quite by chance, found some of my pictures on a Singapore based web forum. They had at least atributed the pictures to me! I agree that the very nature of psoting images on the Internet exposes them to abuse, but at least they are only low res which obviously resticts how they can be used.
 
Far worse than the fact that they used the images in the first place, is the attitude that the (presumably picture editor) at the independent's end has taken! Surely copyright issues and licensing are one of the first things that they teach in photo ed school :/
 
Far worse than the fact that they used the images in the first place, is the attitude that the (presumably picture editor) at the independent's end has taken! Surely copyright issues and licensing are one of the first things that they teach in photo ed school :/

And the second thing they teach is how to get round them and avoid payment!
 
Thanks for posting this OP

The biggest issue is not that the paper used a copyright image without the necessary permissions but that its editorial representative comes across as lacking basic copyright awareness in the subsequent email exchange.

Edit: Ahem, I seem to have spent so much time reading the flickr page that the posts immediately before mine weren't there when I posted but now are timed more than 30 mins ago...
 
Flickr is fine - You just have to remember to set the 'permissions' correctly - in mine only 'Friends and Family' can download images...
And none of my actual Friends and Family have been added as such, so only the people I want to can actually download the images.
Others can 'Right-Click>Save As' the display image, but the resolution is worthless for any meaningful purpose...

To the original subject, I would be astonished if those responsible for downloading the images were unaware of the copyright issues - I'd bet they were just hoping that either no-one would notice, or be bothered, or be so happy their image was used that they wouldn't think to question the issue...
 
Sorry for the double thread, somehow missed this thread completely! :bonk:
 
Out of curiosity, from a quick scan through the OPs link, it appeared as the the independent had used the Flick API to display images some of which were copyright.

How is this different from hotlinking images (aside from the API agreement) ?

This in turn leads to - how is this different from an image appearing in a google search result ?

I do feel that the ease that the internet links content together is a legal minefield - I do hope that the photographer gets the credit he deserves.
 
One of the reasons I don't use Flickr
 
Others can 'Right-Click>Save As' the display image, but the resolution is worthless for any meaningful purpose...

I got 8 pence per pixel. Small image, but the compensation wasn't worthless to me!
 
I have to say my invoice woudl have been considerably more than £100.

I can't believe the amount of people on Flickr who say he should be happy with nothing or that he is totally in the wrong. What a joke.

This is the problem people are not aware of their rights and are happy to let themselves be shafted over and over again. Unless people stand up this will only get worse. Good on him for standing up for his rights.
 
Flickr is fine - You just have to remember to set the 'permissions' correctly - in mine only 'Friends and Family' can download images...
And none of my actual Friends and Family have been added as such, so only the people I want to can actually download the images.
Others can 'Right-Click>Save As' the display image, but the resolution is worthless for any meaningful purpose...

Sadly this isn't the case.

There is a plugin/hack for firefox that allows anyone to access the full resolution image that you uploaded.

Combine this with another plugin/hack that allows you to download an entire photostream, set or album and your work is pretty vulnerable.

I've used both legitimately to bulk download my own work to a separate computer but they can just as easily be used for downloading photography that the uploader thinks is nice and safe.
 
its simple then, you set all galleries of work your bothered about to "private" and only allow people YOU trust to view them.
 
All of this just validates my own stance on my flickr pics, which is to put a huge copyright symbol in the centre of my pics, at something like 35% transparency. This is in addition to max 800 pixels longest edge, 72dpi, and full exif data regarding ownership and (non)reproduction.

Occasionally I get a derogatory comment about ruining the photo, but that's the point - ruining it enough to dissuade stealing, but not beyond an appreciation threshold. If someone wants the higher unblemished quality then they get to approach me for it.

Simples!
 
its simple then, you set all galleries of work your bothered about to "private" and only allow people YOU trust to view them.

As far as I'm aware these plugin's are also able to access private files as they view the code in your profile, rather than the graphic interface that we see as users.
 
I don't mind people using my photographs to be honest, as long as they were for personal use and not for self-gain.

Use as a wallpaper for their computer? Fine.
Print off and display on their wall at home? Fine.
Publish in a national paper? No thanks.
Print it off and pass it off as their own work? Gtfo.

Obviously if people wanted to use my images I'd rather they followed the link through my watermark and went to my website to contact me about purchasing a print, but why pay when you can get it for nothing.
 
I have to say my invoice woudl have been considerably more than £100.

I can't believe the amount of people on Flickr who say he should be happy with nothing or that he is totally in the wrong. What a joke.

This is the problem people are not aware of their rights and are happy to let themselves be shafted over and over again. Unless people stand up this will only get worse. Good on him for standing up for his rights.

:thumbs:

I was surprised the invoice was for just £100....
 
I don't mind people using my photographs to be honest, as long as they were for personal use and not for self-gain.

Use as a wallpaper for their computer? Fine.
Print off and display on their wall at home? Fine.
Publish in a national paper? No thanks.
Print it off and pass it off as their own work? Gtfo.

Obviously if people wanted to use my images I'd rather they followed the link through my watermark and went to my website to contact me about purchasing a print, but why pay when you can get it for nothing.

Have you seen the price that exhibition prints can sell for, mate?

Why deprive your self of a source of income and at the same time devalue the worth of all photographs (taken by everybody) by giving yours away?
 
The point is what would happen if they had used Lebovitz's work without permission, or David Bailey, Chase Jarvis, (insert any pro tog here) Just someone else put it out there for the public to see, does not mean that anyone can use it, but as said they rarely get caught.

I don't know what the solution is apart from huge fines for those caught abusing this. But as papers have big legal departments, this is unlikely to happen.

It shouldn't stop anyone displaying their work on Flickr, or making it available to the public. It is just a problem that needs to be dealt with. The easiest way would be flickr to stop right click saving, or downloading of files (not perfect but a start). Whether that will ever happen I think it another discussion entirely.
 
Have you seen the price that exhibition prints can sell for, mate?

Why deprive your self of a source of income and at the same time devalue the worth of all photographs (taken by everybody) by giving yours away?

That old story again.

I'm afraid photography isn't what it used to be. Anyone can buy a digital SLR, and a lot of amateur's photographs are actually quite good.

If media corporations such as the BBC and The Independent can get a mediocre photograph that suits a story for free off of an amateur, I seriously doubt they'd want to get a top quality photograph for a premium figure off of a freelance (unless for a top story, like a press conference with an important political figure).

I'll tell you why I'm 'depriving myself of a source of income' by giving my photographs away for free - I've been taking photographs for nearly 3 years now, and the photographs I take for the pleasure of myself and for the viewing pleasure of friends and family do not sell. Unless I can get them exhibited, in a fairly popular gallery, where people wouldn't mind paying for prints, then they won't be seen by the sort of target market I would need for my photographs - the people who actively look to purchase art work that isn't displayed by the millions in the likes of Ikea or Tesco.

The photographs that do sell? The ones I'm commissioned to take. And people won't steal those. Why would someone want a photograph of someone else's family/kitchen/pet?

My point is = I don't think I could consider my photographs as a source of income because I don't (and couldn't afford to) advertise to the sorts of people who would buy my photographs. What isn't acceptable, however, is people: a) making money from my work, b) passing my work off as their own.

As I've said before, I love that people like my photographs enough to want to display them as their desktop/on their wall, and that is payment enough for me.

I am a little hurt that you consider this a devaluation to every other photographer's images.
 
Cool, can I borrow your car. Got any nice canon lenses I can use? ;)

I get the joke mate, but it's not really my point :p

Unless you're an artist yourself, you don't much think about the welfare of the artist.

Music 'piracy' is an example of that.

I would never, ever 'steal' a photograph, but I have asked permission from photographers to portray their work in certain circumstances. I have asked people if they would mind me presenting their work in a presentation (not as mine, but as a credited example of genres of photography), and I've also recently asked photographer Dan Porrett (flickr: http://www.flickr.com/photos/dan-porrett/) if he would mind if I used his image "Sun, Earth and Moon" as my computer wallpaper.
 
Back
Top