The perfect landscape photo - what will it have...

EdinburghGary

Reply not Report
Messages
19,271
Name
Gary
Edit My Images
Yes
Hi Guys,

I have been asking a lot about the technical side of Landscape Photography, and I still read about it all the time. I have a few photo books now too, to see what the famous photographers do.

What do you consider to be the elements that make the perfect landscape photo? Rather than make my own suggestions, I would prefer to see what you guys all think, I do mean perfect too. Not just OK, or REALLY GOOD. I mean flawless. What will that photo contain, what elements will be mastered, and where would the photographer focus most of his effort?

I do realise there is almost certainly no such thing as a perfectly flawless photo, so this is a "what if", ambigious query...

Keen to hear your thoughts!
 
Light....
Foreground Interest....
Light
Background Interest...
Light
Lead in Lines......
Light
Front to back focus....

And a bit more light....

I would think thats about it... but I do not seem to follow those rules as I can never remember them all,
 
Light....
Foreground Interest....
Light
Background Interest...
Light
Lead in Lines......
Light
Front to back focus....

And a bit more light....

I would think thats about it... but I do not seem to follow those rules as I can never remember them all,

Can you remember your favourite ever landscape photo, either taken by yourself, or someone else?

I'm not sure of mine, I have a few.
 
Light....
Foreground Interest....
Light
Background Interest...
Light
Lead in Lines......
Light
Front to back focus....

And a bit more light....

I would think thats about it... but I do not seem to follow those rules as I can never remember them all,

Pretty much sums it up really, the quality of light has a massive bearing on the final image.

Can you remember your favourite ever landscape photo, either taken by yourself, or someone else?

I'm not sure of mine, I have a few.

Many by Ansel Adams, some by Charlie Waite, the odd one by Eddie Ephrums and a few others.

Not sure this is in the right forum though!
 
For me its Maroon Bells near Aspen by Ansel Adams.

Then again I like most of his stuff.
 
A UFO would add an extra dimension to the photo..or even something like a bright orange flying elephant with an elf on its back would be cool...

But something different to whats already out there would be my vote (other than the ufo and the elephant), maybe a different take on the usual landscape stuff, something unusual in the photo.

:)
 
One mans perfect landscape is another mans carpark Gary. You are developing a yearning for the holy grail of photography
 
No such thing Gary. You could take what you think is the perfect photo and the next day the light could be just a bit better, more interesting clouds, less ripples on the water, etc.

And don't forget the old saying about pleasing all of the people some of the time....

Unless you're looking at this from a commercial viewpoint (in which case the question is a different one anyway) stop worrying about pleasing the viewer and concentrate on what pleases your eye. Feel the shot when you compose, expose and process. Strive to perfect your ability to convey what you felt to the viewer, engage them, open them to new ideas, inspire, and evoke an emotional response.

From what I've seen of your work here you've got a great eye, don't ruin it by trying to paint (photograph) by numbers. Find your own path and see where it takes you :thumbs:

"There are always two people in every photograph, the photographer and the viewer" Ansel Adams (I've probably mis-quoted it slightly but the meaning is clear).
 
For me its Maroon Bells near Aspen by Ansel Adams.

Then again I like most of his stuff.

Yeah, I was going to say anything by Ansel Adams.

His stuff is inspiring for sure, I have not seen a huge amount of his work but what I have seen looks great.

A UFO would add an extra dimension to the photo..or even something like a bright orange flying elephant with an elf on its back would be cool...

But something different to whats already out there would be my vote (other than the ufo and the elephant), maybe a different take on the usual landscape stuff, something unusual in the photo.

:)

Interesting, do you mean off the wall almost? For example, a mix of styles - a disco on a mountain etc :D ?

One mans perfect landscape is another mans carpark Gary. You are developing a yearning for the holy grail of photography

:lol: Just trying to find my way, its tough.

No such thing Gary. You could take what you think is the perfect photo and the next day the light could be just a bit better, more interesting clouds, less ripples on the water, etc.

And don't forget the old saying about pleasing all of the people some of the time....

Unless you're looking at this from a commercial viewpoint (in which case the question is a different one anyway) stop worrying about pleasing the viewer and concentrate on what pleases your eye. Feel the shot when you compose, expose and process. Strive to perfect your ability to convey what you felt to the viewer, engage them, open them to new ideas, inspire, and evoke an emotional response.

From what I've seen of your work here you've got a great eye, don't ruin it by trying to paint (photograph) by numbers. Find your own path and see where it takes you :thumbs:

"There are always two people in every photograph, the photographer and the viewer" Ansel Adams (I've probably mis-quoted it slightly but the meaning is clear).


Cheers mate. The trouble is, I feel I am very rarely satisfied with one of my shots, I have perhaps 2 I adore, 3 or 4 I really like, and the rest don't do it for me. And I can promise hand on heart, I aim to please numero uno with my photos - everyone else is an added bonus :D
 
Hi Guys,

I have been asking a lot about the technical side of Landscape Photography, and I still read about it all the time. I have a few photo books now too, to see what the famous photographers do.

What do you consider to be the elements that make the perfect landscape photo? Rather than make my own suggestions, I would prefer to see what you guys all think, I do mean perfect too. Not just OK, or REALLY GOOD. I mean flawless. What will that photo contain, what elements will be mastered, and where would the photographer focus most of his effort?

I do realise there is almost certainly no such thing as a perfectly flawless photo, so this is a "what if", ambigious query...

Keen to hear your thoughts!


Hi Gary

I'm pretty crap at landscapes, but did read somewhere that the shot should have a definite subject that you can explain to someone in a single sentance as to why you took it and if you can't they won't see it either :D

Not my idea but it kinda makes sense ;)

Steve
 
Cheers mate. The trouble is, I feel I am very rarely satisfied with one of my shots, I have perhaps 2 I adore, 3 or 4 I really like, and the rest don't do it for me. And I can promise hand on heart, I aim to please numero uno with my photos - everyone else is an added bonus :D

So what if you did take the perfect shot? Would you hang up your camera and think what's the point now? It's the journey not the destination that's important. It's the failures and what your learn from them that make the journey interesting.

If it helps I feel exactly the same, I can be pleased with a shot for a day but then I'm looking for the next one. Re-visit old shots from time to time to remind yourself of where you've been and how you got where you are now, it might be a nice surprise.
 
Anything that will have me staring at it for hours

- No slow shutter waterfalls
- No sunsets over mountains
- No waterfalls
- No heavy processing

Probably

- Large format (massive)
- original
- perfect lines
- original

Or perhaps no or all of above!

Many landscapes look so similar anything that catches my eye and really sets itself apart from everything else
 
I think the fundamental aspect of good landscape photography, and by that I mean PLEASING landscapes is simply the lighting.

Good composition comes into it, of course, but the same composition can be lifted by dramatic or sympathetic lighting. Good lighting will not do it on its own, but it is a vital ingredient. Likewise, good lighting can be let down by poor composition - the two go hand in hand.

What I most admire about accomplished landscape practitioners is their ability to make a simple subject interesting. That is usually achieved through isolating most of the scene and getting the viewer to concentrate on just a part of it.

I like Charlie Waites Tuscany shots for instance. A lone tree on rolling hills, that kind of thing - bit it needs good lighting to make it sing.
 
TALENT and TIME...

Of course, you must be professionally and artistically capable, that is TALENT.

However, you also need TIME to be able to visit a site that has the makings of a great photograph on enough occasions in order to shoot it when the weather and lighting is right.

There are times when I have stumbled upon a vista when everything was in place for a great landscape. However, since I remember most of these times (and the times that I missed out for one reason or another), they obviously do not happen frequently.

It is too much to hope for that you will stumble on a vista with light and weather conditions being perfect when you are restricted by the time you have on your holiday. Catching the vista when all facets are in place requires either a great bit of luck or the opportunity and perseverance to revisit the spot many times.

I have found that I am restricted in my photography when I am on holiday with friends and or family. No matter how patient my wife is, she would not be happy spending the major portion of a holiday in order to catch THAT ONE GREAT SHOT. It is not fair to ask her to do that - after all; it is her holiday also.
 
A lot of what has been said above.

For me a stunning landscape (or stunning anything) does that literally - it stuns me, meaning it stops me in my tracks and makes me just, well, look at it.

Oh, and for it to be absolutely perfect it would say copyright Pippy in the corner...!
 
Thanks for all the responses guys. Somethings up with me, I dunno what. My photos are all leaving me flat, and I am absolutely desperate to get out and just take images that I enjoy. My brain seems to be saying "why are you taking these", when I know I can drive a few hours and ***potentially*** get something far more dramatic. Its almost like I want to push myself so hard to try and get that shot, and I need to be honest, I think even if I were presented with the oppertunity to get a magic shot, I would be incapable of taking advantage.

I just dunno. I deleted every single photo from flickr earlier, all of them. I am not upset, or depressed, or unhappy with photography, I am just hungry for more - I want to up my game, go to level 2. I touched on this a few months back, and I felt afterwards I stepped up a little. I now feel ready for the next level, and I feel it will only come from planning, travelling, and thinking about my shots. I feel the days of picking up my camera, and just aimlessly wandering, are gone.

:help:
 
Chin up mate ;) I had a similar feeling once upon a time and decided to try something completely different :lol: Macro, Astro and Solar and soon IR :naughty: OK I'm crap at all of em :D but it makes me think and try harder and to me that's what it's all about :thumbs:
 
I feel the days of picking up my camera, and just aimlessly wandering, are gone.

:help:

Have you thought of buying a medium format outfit and a spotmeter? This will slow you down, and make you think about what you are shooting, why you are shooting it, and how you can achieve the result you want to end up with.

Even with a single lens you will have fun and with only a few exposures available it is important to really think about each exposure.

I have been offered a VGC Mamiya RB67 with a 90 and a 50 for under £400 and am seriously considering it just to have a play and help to increase my interest away from digital.
 
Have you thought of buying a medium format outfit and a spotmeter? This will slow you down, and make you think about what you are shooting, why you are shooting it, and how you can achieve the result you want to end up with.

Even with a single lens you will have fun and with only a few exposures available it is important to really think about each exposure.

I have been offered a VGC Mamiya RB67 with a 90 and a 50 for under £400 and am seriously considering it just to have a play and help to increase my interest away from digital.

Noooooo....last thing EG needs is encouraging to buy more kit :eek::nono:
 
I wonder...

Could I be slightly miffed, that after visiting Skye and Glencoe, and not getting the "light" I wanted, and not getting my killer shot...could it be putting a dampner on shooting back at home? Once I get an itch, I find I always need to scratch it real hard before I can put it behind me, and if I am honest, Skye and Glencoe are still in my head as "current tasks" almost, until I get those shots I feel I can....

I mean its entirely understandable to visit such fantastic scenery, and then come back and be uninspired by what you consider to be much less dynamic and photogenic areas back at home, is it not?

Maybe thats it. Maybe I need to really kick the arse out of the highlands for the next month or two, get some shots that I am real happy with, and then move on...

Anyone else here visited STUNNING scenery, only to be left feeling flat back at home? Its like a withdrawel symptom...
 
Okay, may seem like a stupid question, but do you take most of your landscapes on the hoof, or do you use a tripod? Do you use grad filters?
 
Okay, may seem like a stupid question, but do you take most of your landscapes on the hoof, or do you use a tripod? Do you use grad filters?

Today, I purchased a MASSIVE map of Scotland, its on my wall next to my PC. And I purchased the AA Landscape Photographer of the year awards, volumes 1 and 2, and several books by Colin Baxter, and Colin Prior, both very prominent here in Scotland. I am researching like mad, and hoping to learn a lot. I will master this, give me a year :D


Recently, I have been EXTREMELY well prepared I feel...

1:
I plan my journey to the exact minute.

2:
I check all weather forecasts, sunrise / sunset times, sun directions

3:
I search flickr, and look through books for inspiration

4:
I read a guide or two on landscape photography, just to refresh my memory

5:
I take a very sturdy tripod

6:
I take my remote timer

7:
I use Shutter Delay mode

8:
I try my damned hardest to pick good compisitions, but I really struggle here

9: And now, I literally wait for the light, I chase it too. This is the most important change I am making.

Its all much tougher than I imagined, it really is.
 
Hi Gary

We all look for for the same but sometimes it's just not going to happen if the light is wrong :shrug: or if you cock up the shot with settings or whatever :thinking: All I would say is " If the scene is right" it's up to you :) this was the perfect scene and I cocked it up big time but hey-ho that's the way it goes. Camera set on jpeg and screwed up in PP and overwrote the original :lol:
IMG_0820.jpg
 
Try painting or drawing.

It'll immerse you in the scene while you wait and the results may ultimately be more worthwhile.
 
Do you look for where the other photographers tripod marks are? :lol:

I don't mean to take the Mickey too much, but perhaps you are trying too hard. perhaps you need to feel the shot? That's where the medium format suggestion comes from, it's easier to visualise the shot on a larger screen, 5x4 would be even better, but can take a lot of getting used to.

Seriously, see if you can borrow an RB67 one back and a standard or wide lens with just the WLF and take it out for a walk, if nothing else it will be good exercise.

Whilst you should look at many different images by different photographers, try to see what appeals to you in their shots and what makes you like them or dislike them. Don't try to emulate them exactly but use some of the techniques and tricks that you felt made them good to guide you when composing your own images.

When you have done a few you will hopefully start to develop (pun) a style of your own.
 
if its any consolation i went up week before and didnt get killer shot either lol I did get pretty decent shot of a stag... should have went home then. Maybe your trying tooo hard, trying to force perfect shot. I love Glen Coe even just to wandr about... to my shame never been to Skye but is on my wish list lol

davey
 
Do you look for where the other photographers tripod marks are? :lol:

I don't mean to take the Mickey too much, but perhaps you are trying too hard. perhaps you need to feel the shot? That's where the medium format suggestion comes from, it's easier to visualise the shot on a larger screen, 5x4 would be even better, but can take a lot of getting used to.

Seriously, see if you can borrow an RB67 one back and a standard or wide lens with just the WLF and take it out for a walk, if nothing else it will be good exercise.

Whilst you should look at many different images by different photographers, try to see what appeals to you in their shots and what makes you like them or dislike them. Don't try to emulate them exactly but use some of the techniques and tricks that you felt made them good to guide you when composing your own images.

When you have done a few you will hopefully start to develop (pun) a style of your own.
Not looking to emulate anyone. I'm looking for inspiration, and trying to find common qualities I like. My goal is to have my own style, but having an overall understanding of what works is important, hence the books.
 
Thanks for all the responses guys. Somethings up with me, I dunno what. My photos are all leaving me flat, and I am absolutely desperate to get out and just take images that I enjoy. My brain seems to be saying "why are you taking these", when I know I can drive a few hours and ***potentially*** get something far more dramatic. Its almost like I want to push myself so hard to try and get that shot, and I need to be honest, I think even if I were presented with the oppertunity to get a magic shot, I would be incapable of taking advantage.

I just dunno. I deleted every single photo from flickr earlier, all of them. I am not upset, or depressed, or unhappy with photography, I am just hungry for more - I want to up my game, go to level 2. I touched on this a few months back, and I felt afterwards I stepped up a little. I now feel ready for the next level, and I feel it will only come from planning, travelling, and thinking about my shots. I feel the days of picking up my camera, and just aimlessly wandering, are gone.

:help:

Here's a pint!
 
As already mentioned light is one of THE main important elements...I'd also list good foreground interest, but I've seen great shots without this..I'd also list great scenery, but I've also seen great shots without this too..

ultimately as with all art forms what appeals to one person might not to another, the main thing is it appeals to the person who took the photograph !!

simon
 
Back
Top