The rule of thirds - what's that all about then?

Messages
68
Edit My Images
Yes
I have often seen critique mentioning that the subject in question would have been better on the 'thirds' now I can see in a lot of cases that it does in fact improve certain pictures.

What I don't quite understand is why it is often said when the picture is just of a certain thing and the rest of the picture is of no real consequence, macros perhaps, flowers and possibly insects also come to mind.

Would it not be (usually) better to have that kind of picture with the main interest slap bang in the middle?
 
Depends what you're taking a picture of, if all you want is the main subject why have anything else in frame at all? On the other hand if you want to show the subject in context or part of the overall image would make a good focal point then the rule of thirds comes into it's own. The rule of thirds has been around for centuries, many famous painters used it because an image looks more natural to the human eye/brain when there is a focal point on one or more of the thirds junctions.
 
There's very little one can add to that excellent article by CT.

Placing the subject(s) on the intersection of thirds tend to make for a very harmonious image.

Sometimes, though, you might want to make a real statement, in which case placing the main subject right in the centre can be effective.

Other subject matter which may benefit from breaking this rule includes the boundary between a landscape and a perfect reflection of it on the surface of a lake.:)

..... Discuss?
 
Would it not be (usually) better to have that kind of picture with the main interest slap bang in the middle?

Heres my (graphic designer) opinion on why the ROT is (mostly) better than a "straight in the middle" shot.

Symmetry is an important aspect in composition and design, but contrast is equally important (probably more IMO). By contrast I don't mean the standard photographic contrast term, I mean contrast as in difference in the way things are laid out in an image. "Placement contrast" if you will.

If our eye has to search for a moment to the main subject location (which is mostly the case with ROT) rather than automatically finding it straight in the middle, it makes for a more pleasing/interesting image. I believe this "searching" is the part of looking at an image which is enjoyed most by the brain. ie. first impression.

But why a rule of thirds and not fourths or fifths? my guess is because its the first uneven number (above one of course) which in turn makes the eye work harder to find the subject than an image divided into easy-to-find halves or quarters.

I hope some of that made sense :thinking:
 
Back
Top