too nice on cc of pictures?

Messages
359
Edit My Images
No
it maybe because I'm a picky b****r with no experience but on looking at pics put up for comments,most are positive when then they are clearly not or a few pointers could be also posted,I know when I post a pic I would want all comments good and bad,maybe I'm missing the point and people are only after a pat on the back?

anyone else feel this?
 
I see quite a lot of constructive suggestions for improvements so I'm not sure everyone just plays nice. Lots of stuff on cropping, blown out shots, focus, colour casts and improvement ideas on composition. Could be that people are inclined more to take the effort and make comments on the ones they really like though, human nature.

At least some people do get some comments, sometimes you get no reply at all :-(
 
snigg said:
it maybe because I'm a picky b****r with no experience but on looking at pics put up for comments,most are positive when then they are clearly not or a few pointers could be also posted,I know when I post a pic I would want all comments good and bad,maybe I'm missing the point and people are only after a pat on the back?

anyone else feel this?

what does it matter really
 
yeah true I have seen those types of comments,guess the ones I see with only "nice shot" stand out more,there has just been a few lately where a see a "bad" point I could make but the rest of the posts have been all positive so feel I best not comment.
 
it maybe because I'm a picky b****r with no experience but on looking at pics put up for comments,most are positive when then they are clearly not or a few pointers could be also posted,I know when I post a pic I would want all comments good and bad,maybe I'm missing the point and people are only after a pat on the back?

anyone else feel this?

Well I have certainly had constructive criticism levelled at my images (tight crops on portraits, not sharp enough, colour casts), and it just helps me to go away and try to improve. Comments though, are like everything in life, you can take them or leave them, try to sort out the good and informative, from the simply negative and unhelpful.
 
yeah true I have seen those types of comments,guess the ones I see with only "nice shot" stand out more,there has just been a few lately where a see a "bad" point I could make but the rest of the posts have been all positive so feel I best not comment.



No you should have commented ..Leading by example works. :thumbs: ...actions not words like.


Let them off the hook a bit will ya... Its also worth considering other aspects of this community. Like members making friends (or simply kissing up because the fancy someone..ewk that so obvious.)
One may have been following someone’s progress and not want to heavily crit but just be supportive of that members efforts.
Or members simply not having the experience to pass full judgment, So they like it, saying so is worthy critique in my book, non-aware egos aside, the words 'nice shot' is more useful and informative than no replies at all I reckon.
 
I agree with Forbiddenbiker, you should have posted how you felt, However, I can understand your reluctance - its very difficult to follow up several 'nice shot' posts with suggestions. :)
 
I agree with Forbiddenbiker, you should have posted how you felt, However, I can understand your reluctance - its very difficult to follow up several 'nice shot' posts with suggestions. :)

Yes that’s true, However if ones friendly and supportive it can be done without upsetting the boat.

Its often well received I find.

Edit: The good news is …analysing such a thread and responding thoughtfully with good critique will empower ones own creativity.. :thumbs:
 
Last edited:
it maybe because I'm a picky b****r with no experience but on looking at pics put up for comments,most are positive when then they are clearly not or a few pointers could be also posted,I know when I post a pic I would want all comments good and bad,maybe I'm missing the point and people are only after a pat on the back?

anyone else feel this?

I've had a fair bit of constructive crit come my way when I've posted in the right section - people have offered ideas and suggestions for alternative cropping, exposure, white balance, cloning bits out etc - all good stuff.

Obviously you also get a lot of comments from people simply saying that they like a particular shot but that's fine unless of course I've posted a complete duffer.
 
Its nice to see some people never change

Its nice to see this old chestnut of CC doing the rounds again! What does it really matter? It someone wants to say nice pic then let them, after all this is a forum on the internet available to all. You can't tell people how to act on it :shrug:
 
it maybe because I'm a picky b****r with no experience but on looking at pics put up for comments,most are positive when then they are clearly not or a few pointers could be also posted,I know when I post a pic I would want all comments good and bad,maybe I'm missing the point and people are only after a pat on the back?

anyone else feel this?

Well - I don't give a great deal of critique, not because I don't feel qulified, but because when I do, it takes me a considerable amount of time. If the person has posted more than a couple of photo's it could well take half an hour or more for a decent critique (I'm a slow typist, and a slower thinker!) I'll therefore only spend that amount of time commenting on something that I either feel really strongly about, or that I think is within my field and I could make a potential improvement for the person. To that end, it's not often I comment on the motorsport/sports/nature sections, but I will happily spend a little time on Landscapes and Photo's from Film.

I'm certainly not someone that just posts "nice capture" comments, and i'm not worried about calling a spade a spade when it needs it, though I do TRY and find some redeeming factor in any shot - even if it's just "well, it's a good location, so i'd suggest a re-shoot sometime when the light's right"...

So -
Should we be trying to give helpful and proper critique.... YES,
Should we be posting "nice shot" comments when it blatantly isn't?.... NO,
Should we all be trying a little harder to give a bit back to the forum?... Absolutely YES.
Should we RTM anyone who spits their dummy out when we've given PROPER CRITIQUE... Again, Absolutely YES
 
Last edited:
Well - I don't give a great deal of critique, not because I don't feel qulified, but because when I do, it takes me a considerable amount of time. If the person has posted more than a couple of photo's it could well take half an hour or more for a decent critique (I'm a slow typist, and a slower thinker!) I'll therefore only spend that amount of time commenting on something that I either feel really strongly about, or that I think is within my field and I could make a potential improvement for the person. To that end, it's not often I comment on the motorsport/sports/nature sections, but I will happily spend a little time on Landscapes and Photo's from Film.

I'm certainly not someone that just posts "nice capture" comments, and i'm not worried about calling a spade a spade when it needs it, though I do TRY and find some redeeming factor in any shot - even if it's just "well, it's a good location, so i'd suggest a re-shoot sometime when the light's right"...

So -
Should we be trying to give helpful and proper critique.... YES,
Should we be posting "nice shot" comments when it blatantly isn't?.... NO,
Should we all be trying a little harder to give a bit back to the forum?... Absolutely YES.
Should we RTM anyone who spits their dummy out when we've given PROPER CRITIQUE... Again, Absolutely YES

I totally agree with all of what you have said but you still can't force people to do it and I think endless discussions like this aren't going to encourage people to change either :shrug:
 
maybe an addition to the swear filter that changes "nice shot" to "I'm too lazy to give proper critique on this image" every now and then :lol:
 
I'm not clear on one thing here, Snigg - are you talking about the general 'photo sharing' posts, or posts marked as requesting 'Critique' :shrug:?

If you are referring to posts where the photographer has requested critiques, then you do have a point (IMO), assuming you are seeing lots of "Good capture :thumbs:"! sort of comments. Personally, I haven't really seen too much of that in those specific threads recently :shrug:.

On the other hand, if you are referring to the general forums where people go to share their photographs and (if they're anything like me ;)) hope to God that somebody says, "That's nice :love:", then I think that you are missing the point somewhat :|. Those forums are not solely for c&c, just for sharing - viewers are free (and encouraged) to say as much or as little as they want to about other people's photos :).
 
I'm not clear on one thing here, Snigg - are you talking about the general 'photo sharing' posts, or posts marked as requesting 'Critique' :shrug:?

If you are referring to posts where the photographer has requested critiques, then you do have a point (IMO), assuming you are seeing lots of "Good capture :thumbs:"! sort of comments. Personally, I haven't really seen too much of that in those specific threads recently :shrug:.

On the other hand, if you are referring to the general forums where people go to share their photographs and (if they're anything like me ;)) hope to God that somebody says, "That's nice :love:", then I think that you are missing the point somewhat :|. Those forums are not solely for c&c, just for sharing - viewers are free (and encouraged) to say as much or as little as they want to about other people's photos :).

I was under the impression that anything posted in the critique forums ws up for critique, but if the "CRITIQUE" flag was also set, then the user was asking for a full no-holds-barred rip it apart (whilst still being constructive and non-abusive of course) going over!
 
I was under the impression that anything posted in the critique forums ws up for critique, but if the "CRITIQUE" flag was also set, then the user was asking for a full no-holds-barred rip it apart (whilst still being constructive and non-abusive of course) going over!

Here's what Uncle Marcel wrote on the subject (most relevant part in red) ;):

Threads with the "Critique" prefix :
For thread starters
If you want critique on your images, use this tag.
Post no more than 6 photos. Select your best. Less than 6 is even better.
Try and explain some thoughts behind the photos (this is not compulsory).
Be prepared to take criticism. If you throw a hissy fit at any polite and constructive criticism offered then you will be shot......revived, and shot again.

Replying
If you see a thread with this tag, please give some thought to your reply.
"Nice shot", "Cracking stuff" and "4 and 5 are my faves", while thoroughly encouraging for the photographer....are merely expressions. Proper thoughts are encouraged with this tag.
At the very least, just say *why* you like the photo, regardless of how 'simple' you think your opinion is.......or you will be shot...or forced to watch DNA test result exclusives from The Jeremy Kyle show, repeatedly.
If you are offering critique, be polite AND constructive. Re-read your post. If it's neither of these, don't post it.
If you're struggling to be polite, don't post.
If you can't be constructive, don't post.
If you can't think of anything positive. See a therapist.


For threads without the "Critique" prefix :
For thread starters
If you don't want *any* critique of your photos, then do not use the critique prefix.
If you just want to share a load of your images from an event, do not use the critique prefix.
If you just want "Nice shot" style comments, do not use the critique prefix.
If you post without the critique prefix, you may add more than the 6 image limit to subsequent posts.
If your photo is an out of focus shot of your cat asleep on the couch, or your puppy licking its own privates, or some random funny photo you found on the internet, then please use the Photos For Pleasure forum.

Replying
Either say something nice and constructive, or click "back".
You may give critique, but it MUST be constructive and helpful.
Don't complain if more than x photos have been posted, just click "back".


(Unquote)

Also, the most used sub-forum is called, "GENERAL PHOTO SHARING" and is described as, "A forum to post and share your photographs for general thoughts, comments and criqitue" :shrug:. Seems like 'soft crit' is quite the done thing there ;).
 
Last edited:
So does that mean we Can't critique anything unless it's got the flag set?

You were dead right in your earlier post :thumbs:

Everything posted in the general sharing forums (fora?) is up for critique :)

If critique is not wanted then whack it in photos for pleasure

The Critique flag simply indicates a desire for more detailed and considered critique.
 
You were dead right in your earlier post :thumbs:

Everything posted in the general sharing forums (fora?) is up for critique :)

If critique is not wanted then whack it in photos for pleasure

The Critique flag simply indicates a desire for more detailed and considered critique.

Thanks - i'd hate to think I was doing something that was slowly annoying the membership one by one...;)
 
So does that mean we Can't critique anything unless it's got the flag set?

No, not at all! As I already said, it's for 'sharing' and 'not solely for c&c'. Some degree of critique is essential, otherwise it becomes a pretty pointless exercise, IMO :shrug:.

I was only trying to point out that it is perfectly acceptable (and even encouraged) for people to leave general, complimentary remarks as replies, without going into detail about what they don't like about the photo(s). The posts with the 'Critique' flag are where it is not appropriate to leave such general, 'light' remarks.

Anyway, these aren't my opinions - it's what's written by the Moderator in charge, or so I understand :shrug:. Here's the thread ...

http://www.talkphotography.co.uk/forums/showthread.php?t=241480
 
I struggle with leaving crit comments as not really experienced enough but will post "GREAT SHOT " if I really think it is & it appeals to me .

I do struggle with some photo's as they appear "soft or oof or blurred " to me yet every other comment is saying " great capture, lovely focus etc etc .
Is it my screen letting me down or am I missing something obvious?
 
I struggle with leaving crit comments as not really experienced enough but will post "GREAT SHOT " if I really think it is & it appeals to me .

I do struggle with some photo's as they appear "soft or oof or blurred " to me yet every other comment is saying " great capture, lovely focus etc etc .
Is it my screen letting me down or am I missing something obvious?

Yes - you're missing the fact that some people haven't noticed that the shot is OOF of soft :lol: Seriously, next time you see this, mention that they look OOF to you... you'll probably find that 10 more people pile in afterwards with "well, I didn't like saying but now you mention it...."
 
discussed millions of times, just get in there and comment.
 
politely
 
Back
Top