- Messages
- 9,943
- Edit My Images
- Yes
Or you could just use a real camera....
Agree with you
A phone camera may be handy to take snaps but surely its not the same as a DSLR?
Or you could just use a real camera....
Agree with you
A phone camera may be handy to take snaps but surely its not the same as a DSLR?
No one would ever say it's the same as a DSLR. But it's as much a real camera as my D7000. Like I said before there really is a snooty inherent snobbism here regarding camera phones. A Nikon Lumia 900 is a camera and a mobile phone, as is a Samsung Galaxy Nexus as is an iPhone 4S.
To say it's only handy to take snaps is both ill informed and insulting to those that use an iPhone 4S to express themselves through their photography.
The skill is in what the mind perceives and how it's executed. What you take the image with is secondary.
I am not snobbish, just believe that if you are taking the time and trouble to go out and take photographs why not use the best gear available?
I do get the thing with being able to take pictures at any time with a camera phone in your pocket its very handy
as wayne said will have to agree to differ![]()
I am not snobbish, just believe that if you are taking the time and trouble to go out and take photographs why not use the best gear available?
May we enquire which of the digital Hasselblads you use when you are in the studio?
Which large format view camera you use for shooting landscapes?
You'll have a D4 or a 1DX and a couple of those big 600mm lenses for shooting sports too yeah?
I'm surprised you can reach the keyboard from up there on your big pile of the best camera gear available.
Andyvalver said:I own an iPhone 4s and it's one of the best looking phones on the market. So I would not buy a horrid fake camera case to put on it. It's almost like the people who put Ferrari body kits on Toyota mr2's lol
It's almost like the people who put Ferrari body kits on Toyota mr2's lol

No one would ever say it's the same as a DSLR. But it's as much a real camera as my D7000. Like I said before there really is a snooty inherent snobbism here regarding camera phones. A Nikon Lumia 900 is a camera and a mobile phone, as is a Samsung Galaxy Nexus as is an iPhone 4S.
To say it's only handy to take snaps is both ill informed and insulting to those that use an iPhone 4S to express themselves through their photography.
The skill is in what the mind perceives and how it's executed. What you take the image with is secondary.
I wish I hadn't postedMay we enquire which of the digital Hasselblads you use when you are in the studio?
Which large format view camera you use for shooting landscapes?
You'll have a D4 or a 1DX and a couple of those big 600mm lenses for shooting sports too yeah?
I'm surprised you can reach the keyboard from up there on your big pile of the best camera gear available.
I wish I hadn't posteddon't understand the attack just trying to add to the discussion
I never meant that I had top of the range gear I use a 550 d it says so in my sig
Will leave this thread now
What is a "real camera"? I have always presumed any box with film or a sensor capable of taking a photograph would be a real camera (as opposed to a fantasy camera or imaginary camera).
A phone camera may be handy to take snaps but surely its not the same as a DSLR?
My comment was intended as an attack, I just presumed that would practice as you preach.
Why should a photographer go out with the best gear available though? Especially when - as is the case with most but not all iPhoneography - they are going out to do personal photography, not to make images to fulfill a commercial brief where we might assume there would be an expectation or requirement of image quality.
Ricardodaforce said:Interesting. As I mentioned earlier, Getty's latest request from me is a photo taken on my mobile phone. They wouldn't request it if it didn't didn't have commercial potention (in their eyes). Did it meet their image quality requirements? Yes it did.
Interesting. As I mentioned earlier, Getty's latest request from me is a photo taken on my mobile phone. They wouldn't request it if it didn't didn't have commercial potention (in their eyes). Did it meet their image quality requirements? Yes it did.
Thanks Paul
That was what I meant , using the best gear that I have
I do mainly zoo and wildlife photography so a camera phone is not that useful
I did get great shots of cheetah cubs at Chester zoo with my phone tho when they came right up to the glass it was too close for my zoom lens to focus !
thanks Yv![]()
But does this turn of luck with getty make you think, "yeah iphone photography is awesome! Im going to jam my phone in a case that looks like an old camera"
I'm not interested in buying that thing. I just object to this "mobile phones are not cameras" mantra. Anything that takes photos is a camera.
Ricardodaforce said:I'm not interested in buying that thing. I just object to this "mobile phones are not cameras" mantra. Anything that takes photos is a camera.
It might be easier to be more specific and say its a phone with a built in camera.
You can't call a product a camera when its primary purpose is something else.
Slightly pedantic I know.
Ricardodaforce said:In my opinion it's very pedantic, but that's your view. In my opinion I own two cameras, a Nikon D7000 and an iPhone 4S. The latter is not some silly toy only good enough for "snaps" as some here maintain.
I agree that the iPhone has a great phone which produces good quality calls but at the end of the day it is a small functionality of what is otherwise a camera/ipod/mobile internet device.
brianwar said:Fixed that for you.
You forgot the GPS part too lol
True, I definitely use the maps on the iphone more than I use it as a phone.
Should not be long before Brian goes and buys a proper camera then........
Phone is a phone and might do ok holiday snaps........
Simon photo said:Its all about standing in front of the interesting things at the right time. And capturing that moment with whatever tool you have at your disposal is the photography.
But would anyone with a d3 or a 1d mount their camera inside an old bellows camera to give it that "nostalgic" look? Probably not, so what sort of person puts an iphone in something that makes it look like an old 35mm camera? I would like to say but wouldn't want to offend anyone.
If the case was cheap at say, £10 then i would pass it off a bit of a gimmick and fun but have you seen the price on it!
No, like i said. Go out and buy the real deal and a roll of film and learn something.
Phil V said:That first bit is the wrong way round:
Photography Is all about standing in front of the interesting things at the right time and capturing them. That's where the skill of photography lies. Otherwise just buying great gear would make you a great photographer, which is patently untrue.
Hehehehe, In our day it was start out with a cheap Pentax or Russian slr now it's start off with a naff old Apple phone...
from these little acorns many move on to proper real cameras

Hehehehe, In our day it was start out with a cheap Pentax or Russian slr now it's start off with a naff old Apple phone... from these little acorns many move on to proper real cameras to push the bonderies and explore New Frontiers... Too boldly go where most get confused....
Evolution.... it's natural
Next week Badgers with spoons.....