Was this photo done with an ND filter

Riz

Messages
388
Edit My Images
Yes
I like the way the clouds are little elongated?

a> is courtesy of TripAdvisor
 
Last edited:
Last edited by a moderator:
It was most likely shot with an ultra wide lens (10mm +), an ND grad will bring out the contrast in the clouds but won't make them appear 'elongated'.
 
It was most likely shot with an ultra wide lens (10mm +), an ND grad will bring out the contrast in the clouds but won't make them appear 'elongated'.

yeah that as well - though i assumed the use of an ND (not a grad) had made the clouds elongated through movement during long exposure - The mirror still ness of the water when the clouds suggest wind also indicates a long exp to me
 
Ah yes hadn't thought of the ND rather than ND grad, should have read it properly! Looking at it I still think it's just a UWA but as you say, may have been a longish exposure.

I wouldn't imagine an ND would have been needed though as the evening light looks pretty low.
 
welding glass - but mind your hands because the edges are sharp (if you search on here there's a thread)

that aside the cokin square filter system (id suggest P rather than A ) has a variety of NDs and ND grads available - or if you want to spend more money you can get the lere filters version.

there are other ways though - for a start turn your ISO down as low as it'll go, select a relatively narrow apperture (though not stupidly narrow or it'll record all the grot on your sensor) - also if you have a polariser that reduces by about 2 stops. Plus of course you can shoot in low light.

(Nb: you need a decent tripod to even contemplate doing these shots succesfully)
 
welding glass - but mind your hands because the edges are sharp (if you search on here there's a thread)

that aside the cokin square filter system (id suggest P rather than A ) has a variety of NDs and ND grads available - or if you want to spend more money you can get the lere filters version.

there are other ways though - for a start turn your ISO down as low as it'll go, select a relatively narrow apperture (though not stupidly narrow or it'll record all the grot on your sensor) - also if you have a polariser that reduces by about 2 stops. Plus of course you can shoot in low light.

(Nb: you need a decent tripod to even contemplate doing these shots succesfully)

Oh i have a redsnapper tripod. Im goin on hols in a few weeks and wanted to try something like that. I have a polariser ill start there. Thanks
 
ideally id suggest one that holds square/rectangular filters instead of a screw on

like this http://www.cokin.co.uk/pages/cokinP.htm

the reason being that if you have screw ons you can only use them on lenses with that filter thread - if you go with cokin or lee you can get a bunch of adaptors and use the filter mount on all your lenses

I wouldnt use a filter for better portraits when very bright tho - basically you either need to put yoursubject in the shade or use a flash gun/reflectors to fill the shadow areas
 
Last edited:
oh ok ill look into that. sometimes with my 35mm on shallow depth portraits I tend to overexposed the background a little, I guess I could speed up the shutter, but I read that an nd4 could help.
 
oh ok ill look into that. sometimes with my 35mm on shallow depth portraits I tend to overexposed the background a little, I guess I could speed up the shutter, but I read that an nd4 could help.

you could be right - i'm not really a portrait tog but imo - if the back ground is brighter than the subject if you correctly expose the background the subject will be under exposed - what you need to do is reduce the bckground without reducing the subject - you used to be able to get (and maybe still can) filters that were graduated ND arround the edge and clear in the middle but i never liked them.

personally i'd say if its important the background isnt blown and you dont want to use flash to balance the subject, take two shots one exposed for the subject and one for the background and merge them in PP - though note if the subject has a lot of complicated edging (like a womans hair) this will take a lot of 400% view editing to get 100%
 
Riz said:
surely there is an easier way?

Yes, by using a diffused flash!
 
Last edited:
surely there is an easier way?

course the easiest way is to position your subject out of harsh sunlight in the first place !

Yes, by using a diffused flash!

This - I did speciffically say that if you didnt want to use flash or reflectors the next best way was PP

the trouble with the centre grads is that they control where you can put your subject in the frame, and also the max size of the subject.
 
Last edited:
course the easiest way is to position your subject out of harsh sunlight in the first place !



This - I did speciffically say that if you didnt want to use flash or reflectors the next best way was PP

the trouble with the centre grads is that they control where you can put your subject in the frame, and also the max size of the subject.

I think ill try and just speed up the shutter. My concern isnt the subject being over exposed , they are fine ite more the background! But thanks anyway, ill try some fill inflash aswell
 
I think ill try and just speed up the shutter. My concern isnt the subject being over exposed , they are fine ite more the background! But thanks anyway, ill try some fill inflash aswell

i dont think you're understanding the principles here - if the subject is exposed correctly but the background is blown and you speed up the shutter for the same apperture you will wind up with the subject under exposed but the background exposed correctly

if you compensate for the shutter speed with the appertuire you will have the same exposure (roughly) as before - ie subject still exposed correctly and background still blown

the only ways to get the whole lot exposed correctly (apart from PP) are

a) to get more light on the subject - ie fill flash or reflectors

b) to darken the background with a centre grad (not good for the reasons explained above)

or c) to shoot the subject against a less bright background in the firstplace

(there is also the option of going high key and just accepting the blown background)

In PP you also have the options of

d) shooting with the background exposed correctly and the subject dark and using the selection brush and them levels tool to lighten the subject (not a good idea if there is a big exposure diffeence on account of noise)

e) shooting two exposures and combining them as discussed above

f) shooting a range of exposures and combining them in a HDR effect

No offence but IMO you are trying to run before you can walk - you'll get a lot more out of your photography in the long run if you spend some time learning the basic principals of exposure etc rather than looking for a quick fix
 
Last edited:
Thanks Moose, i guess i just said shutter speed without thinking. Im just thinking as next week i am going on holiday and im not going to take a reflector or have white paper on hand to fill in.

I dont really like using the selection brush and dodg/burning etc, its too fiddly for me.

Ill try some fill in flash and slightly lighter backgrounds.

Cheers
 
Thanks Moose, i guess i just said shutter speed without thinking. Im just thinking as next week i am going on holiday and im not going to take a reflector or have white paper on hand to fill in.

I dont really like using the selection brush and dodg/burning etc, its too fiddly for me.

Ill try some fill in flash and slightly lighter backgrounds.

Cheers

darker backgrounds - if the background is lighter it will be more over exposed not less

:bang:

ouch that hurt

by the way you can get reflectors that fold up and are silver one side and gold the other - they hardly weigh anything and will go in a suitcase of clothes no problem

lastolite are the brand most pros use - but they are about 80 quid , but knock off copies are about 15 squid
 
darker backgrounds - if the background is lighter it will be more over exposed not less

:bang:

ouch that hurt

by the way you can get reflectors that fold up and are silver one side and gold the other - they hardly weigh anything and will go in a suitcase of clothes no problem

lastolite are the brand most pros use - but they are about 80 quid , but knock off copies are about 15 squid

Lol i meant darker hoenstly!!

I have a reflector, but its not practical on our holiday with all the other baby crap im taking!!
 
Riz said:
Lol i meant darker hoenstly!!

I have a reflector, but its not practical on our holiday with all the other baby crap im taking!!

Just use a fill flash, worst case scenario just use the on board flash, it's easy to use as a fill flash, it could t be simpler!
 
Back
Top