Watchdog presenters mum hassled over pictures of Grandchildren.

As a mother of a 7 year old daughter and a keen Photographer I have mixed views on this subject.

It seems there are many others out there who have views and feel strongly about it. There was a thread on here in May (11-5-2009) Titled 'Scowling Parents' I think. It ended up getting 317 hits in the end and from memory I think it had to be taken off as some people were getting so annoyed it turned into a real heated debate.

I have read the article in The mail and as ridiculous as it seems most people know that you are not allowed to snap away at a public pool/leisure centre. The signs saying 'Photography Prohibited' in bold red lettering usually says it all to be honest.

I have been taking my daughter to a local leisure centre swimming since she was little. It has an indoor and outdoor pool, water slide, wave pool and we always have a great time and lots of fun. However as much as it disappoints me that I cannot capture these images I have never taken a camera with me as it is the centres rules.

On a different issue it also disappoints me that I am told at every School Play/Assembly that I cannot take any photos or take video :( BUT then I take my camera(s) to every Sports Day, Summer Fetes, Christmas Fayres, Last day of term etc and not a word is said to me!:shrug:

The end of the article mentioned a school that had upset parents as they were told they could not take pictures of their own children at sports day. A village school in Devon, cited changes for the ban on cameras. Also one of the last paragraghs in the article stated 'Relatives wanting to take pictures at nativity plays,sports days or other public events are often told that doing so would breach the Data Protection Act'.

Sorry if it sounds like im going on but 'Has the world gone mad'!!

Parents can take photos of their children at sports days, the schools have been told they are wrong to ban it. This has been made clear by the office of the DP registrar, and a statement has been issued to clarify the matter.

Feel free to take photos of your kids at sports days.

On top of this... My wife and I are members of a local health club / gym, and we went there with our daughter last week - she wanted me to take some shots of her in the pool. I asked at reception, and was told... "of course you can sir, no problem, thanks for asking".

When I was in the pool area with my camera, out of courtesy I made effort to speak with each parent who was in the pool at that time (not that many... 3 or 4), and each of them were absolutely fine with what I said to them I was doing - even offering to help and asking if their shots could be taken too!!

It seems those who are most over protective are council officials and politicians who only want to protect themselves from being sued by ridiculously over zealous parents who have nothing better to do.
 
I swear I saw one persone LOOKING with their EYES at children once. What can we do?

Actually, that was reported in a paper a couple of weeks ago (The Mail I think). They showed a photograph of a known paedophile walking past some children and the text pointed out how he was actually looking at the children he passed.

I'm afraid I saw the humourous side of it.


Steve.
 
The problem really is that no matter how innocent the purpose the images were taken for in the first place, those images can and will be used for 'dubious' purposes by others...
One man's innocent Birthday-Party images are another man's porn, unfortunately...

Understandably, many parents are concerned about what happens to photos in which their children may appear by accident, such as those taken at a swimming pool or on the beach...
I don't think anyone was suggesting that 'Granny' was setting out to disseminate Kiddie-Porn, but as you all know, after they go up on FB, Flickr or PhotoBucket, all control of them is lost.

In the days of Kodak Instamatics and Olympus Trips, no-one cared because you collected the prints from Boots and they remained in your posession - now they're 'published' online for anyone to see and download...

The other problem is that I believe the issue with paedophiles is exacerbated by the Press and the internet...individuals who may in the past have repressed those feelings now have a ready source of material with which to experiment and have realised that they are not alone in having those feelings thanks to all the publicity...it take a few moments online to contact others of a similar persuasion and compare notes and images...

You cannot undo technology, therefore you have to prevent images falling into the wrong hands - and the only way to do that is not to take them in the first place.
It's horrible, but it's a fact of life...

To paraphrase the Cardinal in 'The Mission':
"The World is not thus...thus have we made the World..."
 
Well if someone gets their jollies by looking at a picture of a clothed child, theyre gonna get the same jollies from looking at a child in the street. So where do you draw the line? Ban children from the public incase someone has impure thoughts about them?

That's thought police territory IMO.

I disagree with the notion that just because a paedophile can now see clothed images of children online in the privacy of their own home, this means they will then go on to seek out hard child porn.
 
Well if someone gets their jollies by looking at a picture of a clothed child, theyre gonna get the same jollies from looking at a child in the street. So where do you draw the line? Ban children from the public incase someone has impure thoughts about them?

That's thought police territory IMO.

I disagree with the notion that just because a paedophile can now see clothed images of children online in the privacy of their own home, this means they will then go on to seek out hard child porn.

That wasn't quite what I meant - I'm saying that in some cases it could lead to stronger images being sought - and kids in swimming costumes isn't exactly 'clothed' but i know what you mean...
 
The other problem is that I believe the issue with paedophiles is exacerbated by the Press and the internet...individuals who may in the past have repressed those feelings now have a ready source of material with which to experiment and have realised that they are not alone in having those feelings thanks to all the publicity...it take a few moments online to contact others of a similar persuasion and compare notes and images...

You cannot undo technology, therefore you have to prevent images falling into the wrong hands - and the only way to do that is not to take them in the first place.
It's horrible, but it's a fact of life...

To paraphrase the Cardinal in 'The Mission':
"The World is not thus...thus have we made the World..."

I disagree with this. I don't think paedophiles are any more common now because of easier access to child photography via media or internet. I also don't think there is a greater release of repressed feelings now then in the past on this issue. There will always of been and continue to be those individuals who manage to repress those feelings but the internet won't of changed basic human nature, and the reallity is that most people find such activities sick and disturbing, the proportion who do so won't of decreased because of the invention of new technology.

Even with new technology, the vast majority of paedophiles know there victims, and would do so without technologys help.

I agree about losing control of images, but I don't agree thats a reason not to take them in the first place. It is the world we've made, and there's lotas of things not to like about it, but I for one am not going to let fear keep me from doing perfectly normal things

Hugh
 
I didn't say that there are more paedophiles now than in the past, just that they have better access to material.
in the past it would be a lone guy in the park keeping to himself (maybe with a bag of sweeties) but mostly that was a s far as it went...
Nowadays with all the publicity, individuals who in the past would have repressed those urges have ready access to imagery which could feed those urges and encourage them to act, rather than remain passive - I think the Press has to a degree contributed to that, though it's a fine line - if we fail to inform the public we fail in our duty to protect our children, but in doing so do we also contribute to the problem by raising awareness in individuals who would otherwise keep to themselves?
 
I understand...it could lead to it, you're right. Is it likely to? I have no idea, and tbh wouldn't trust any government 'think tank' that gave an answer either way.

They say burglaries are on the increase. Sure...with more houses being built and the population increasing what do you expect?
There are more cars stolen today than there were 100 years ago too :D

We do have a duty to protect our children, I do agree. And if I'm completely honest, the thought of someone getting at tingling in their giblets looking at pictures of my clothed children online does make me feel very uneasy.

However, if I look at it logically...what harm is it causing. Sure I would prefer it if it didn't happen, but what can I do about it? I could never put the pictures there. I could keep them locked away on my hard drive.
However, is that the answer? To hide away because of what someone is thinking? What damage are they causing to my child? Are they likely to actually *do* anything? I would say not.

The problem that the internet has caused is that everything is readily accessible at the click of a button.

15 years ago, I wouldn't know how to make a bomb. As a kid, I would have loved to have read up on how to make one.
I could go and find out how to make one now with household stuff. I would find reading about it fascinating, but even so Im not likely to go and make one.
Its a silly analogy I know, but the principle is there.

I think what's needed is more common sense by the majority, and a much harsher punishment for those who do act upon their urges.
 
Actually, that was reported in a paper a couple of weeks ago (The Mail I think). They showed a photograph of a known paedophile walking past some children and the text pointed out how he was actually looking at the children he passed.

I'm afraid I saw the humourous side of it.


Steve.


that is fantastic :)

the sad thing is upon reading that, the vast majority of their readers would angrly spit out their coffee and demand the banning of eyes without a second thought (while muttering something about 'immigants'and rip off britain presumably..).. or they'd request all paedophiles have their eyes removed..

but we live in a world where the most popular newspapers flip flop between stories like 'kill all paedos' and 'shes nearly legal lads!' (in reference to famous folk turning 16 for example) without anyone thinking much of it.
 
Its an interesting argument but I'm still not 100% swayed by it. If you look historically then most child abuse cases have been performed by those in positions to access children, be it Catholic priests, family members or school caretakers. Even in the horrific case in Plymouth this year the images taken were secondary to the act. I'm not convinced that even with the more ready access to images of children nowdays then this drives paedophile urges, anymore than a photo of a group of actresses on the way to a movie premier would would drive men to rape.

I'd never thought about the press actions in that way before., and one thing I think missing from the fine line is the difference between informing the public and encouiraging a culture of fear where we go to far in protecting children to both their and our detriment

Hugh
 
This reminds me of what happened to me when my daughter had her first time in a swimming pool.

My wife was in the pool with her and I was filming with a video camera and after about five minutes one of the lifeguards came waltzing over and told me to stop filming as it was against the law, this was 8 years ago and I knew that it was not against the law then and I still don't think it is now.

Anyway, I politely told him to go away after telling him that there were no signs to say that it was prohibited to film and that I was not going to stop.

You will have to bear in mind that the particular swimming pool was basically in the centre of my town and was glass from pavement level to the roof, so perverts really did not need to actually enter the building, they could stand outside with their nose pressed up against the glass.

Also my daughters school have banned all parents from filming or photography at any plays or award ceremonies because they say that it infringes on the other childrens rights and that they are afraid of thing appearing on youtube. The funny thing is though, the school films and photographs these events and then you can buy either the photo or DVD, a nice little money maker given the fearful climate..... ;)
 
that is fantastic :)

the sad thing is upon reading that, the vast majority of their readers would angrly spit out their coffee and demand the banning of eyes without a second thought (while muttering something about 'immigants'and rip off britain presumably..).. or they'd request all paedophiles have their eyes removed..

but we live in a world where the most popular newspapers flip flop between stories like 'kill all paedos' and 'shes nearly legal lads!' (in reference to famous folk turning 16 for example) without anyone thinking much of it.

The hypocrisy it breathtaking isn't it. Reminds me of the outrage at the brasseye special, from the Daily Star:

http://chilled.cream.org/graphics/charlotte.jpg
 
The method by which people do anything is relevant. A person who openly displays their activity and shows what thay are doing is far less of a risk, security or child than a person who undertakes that ativity in a secretive manner. How else is covert activity undertaken. It is obvious when you see a police officer in uniform, can you pick out the one in plain clothes?

The point I was trying to make, which you seem to want to associate with the banning of phones, is that if I were wishing to take an illegal image of whatever it was I certainly would not be open up front and honest and use a piece of equipment that would draw attention. Unfortunately the photo police seem only able to recognise photographers who do not pose a threat and fail to look for the real problem that may or not exist.
Sorry, I do get what you mean now, but what I mean is that taking actual logic to the people who make these decisions is pointless, and they would just follow through with 'right, we need to ban mobile, cameras, eyes, etc'

L
 
Back
Top