What is your interpretation of the term "HDR" - MUST it involve layering?

A point well made Steve. I think people can get caught up in how their images are post processed and forget that post processing isn't the most important part of an image. The best post processing in the world isn't going to save a duff image!
 
A point well made Steve. I think people can get caught up in how their images are post processed and forget that post processing isn't the most important part of an image. The best post processing in the world isn't going to save a duff image!

Ansel Adams? One of the all time greats, and he spent countless hours manipulating tone and dynamic range. His pictures wouldn't look anything like as good if he just knocked them out without any enhancement.
 
That's not quite right. Yes, you can capture an image with a large dynamic range without using HDR but that image is not HDR...

HDR stands for High Dynamic Range - but the term itself does not imply a way of capturing or operating the HDR scenes. It came to be that it is closely associated and often substituted or confused with one of the methods of capturing HDR scene but they are not the same. A method is just that - a way of capturing HDR scene that may or may not resort to capture and/or separately process two or more images. But it's not the only method and thus cannot be used as a definition of what HDR is.

...it's just an image that has a large dynamic range. The high end Fuji D-SLR's are renowned for their large dynamic range in their images but the images are not HDR.

I was not referring to what your RAW converter is doing because this is what you are describing. The sensor produces the RAW files that capture details of a scene with large DR (larger than ordinary camera sensor would permit capturing in one go). Then RAW converter compresses it down to "just an image that has a large dynamic range" or rather to a file that has HDR scene compressed down to ordinary DR range (i.e. what JPEG can record). Nothing prevents you to write a converter that will take small and large sensors into account and produce pure EXR or floating point TIFF (HDR formats) output from Fuji RAW files (Fuji sensor is effectively two sensors in one with some simplification) .

HDR is a described method of creating images with an extended dynamic range by combining images with different exposures in order to capture more detail than you would otherwise. So by its very definition HDR has to involve combining images of different exposure.

HDR is not limited to a single capture method (where you capture multiple images and separately process them and merge them into ordinary image to get a large DR) - never was and never will be despite what Wikipedia might say on a subject ;)

HDR is referring to a way to capture, storing and manipulating images with high dynamic range where ordinary image processing does not work. This is partly the reason why you would need to "capture many frames" having just an ordinary camera and sensor.

Take a look at this and this - those do not need multiple capture and special merging software - they capture EXR files (HDR format) right from the camera.
 
I wouldn't worry about.

Just about all of the best images of the last 100 years were made with just one exposure!

I'm not worried ;)

Although what your saying here is true and it does sound cool and all that jazz, the OP's questions are HDR related.

If you one to be offended or aggravated by post production techniques and their applications, then this thread has little to offer you. :)
 
Ansel Adams? One of the all time greats, and he spent countless hours manipulating tone and dynamic range. His pictures wouldn't look anything like as good if he just knocked them out without any enhancement.
No, of course they wouldn't, but that's not what I was saying.

HDR stands for High Dynamic Range - but the term itself does not imply a way of capturing or operating the HDR scenes. It came to be that it is closely associated and oftenly substituted or confused with one of the methods of capturing HDR scene but they are not the same. A method is just that - a way of capturing HDR scene that may or may not resort to capture and separately process two or more images. But it's not the only method and thus cannot be used as a definition of what HDR is.
I know what HDR stands for and what it refers to. I disagree with your statement that it does not imply a way of capturing images with a large dynamic range though. I know a high dynamic range image does not have to be created by any particular method but the term HDR is synonimous with images created in the way that we are discussing.

I was not referring to what your RAW converter is doing because this is what you are describing. The sensor produces the RAW files that capture details of a scene with large DR. Then RAW converter compresses it down to "just an image that has a large dynamic range". Nothing prevents you to write a converter that will take small and large sensors into account and produce pure EXR output from Fuji RAW files.
Not really sure what you're on about here. I wasn't describing anything to do with a RAW converter. As I said before I know there are images with a large dynamic range that are not created by the method we are discussing here (which I call HDR) but I do not class them as HDR because they were not created using the method that I call HDR. If you choose to call all high dynamic range images HDR then that's up to you. I have found that the vast majority of photographers I've talked to think of the method we're discussing when HDR is mentioned.

HDR is not limited to a single capture method (where you capture multiple images and merge them to get a large DR) - never was and never will despite what Wikipedia might say ona subject.

HDR is referring to a way to capture, storing and manipulating images with high dynamic range where ordinary image processing does not work. This is partly the reason why you would need to "capture many frames" having just an ordinary camera and sensor.
I guess me and Wikipedia will have to agree to disagree with you. :)

Take a look at this and this - those do not need multiple capture and special merging software - they capture EXR files (HDR format) right from the camera.
Those cameras capture images with a higher dynamic range than normal cameras and are capitalising on the popularity of 'HDR' to market them. Can't fault them for that but the 'HDR' that is so popular is not what those cameras are producing, it's the method of producing high dynamic range images (which I call HDR) that we have been discussing that is so popular. ;)
 
Ansel Adams? One of the all time greats, and he spent countless hours manipulating tone and dynamic range. His pictures wouldn't look anything like as good if he just knocked them out without any enhancement.

But he still only took one exposure.


Steve.
 
But he still only took one exposure.

And your point seems to be that all 'good' photography should only be taken with a single exposure.

Look, with all due respect Steve, if your into a more single exposure only approach then I really can't see what you expect to gain here. :shrug:

A reminder of the thread topic feels necessary:

'What is your interpretation of the term "HDR" - MUST it involve layering?'
 
As I said before I know there are images with a large dynamic range that are not created by the method we are discussing here (which I call HDR) but I do not class them as HDR because they were not created using the method that I call HDR.

Well I agree with that and it actually explains all the confusion. A lot of people only knowing HDR from that angle would equate it with one of the methods of capturing HDR scene.

But FYI, the term HDR itself didn't came from the method you are referring to. The term itself came from the first graphic file format that aimed at storing the scene in a file in such a way that it is contrast ratio (that defines scene DR) would be unlimited. Conventional file formats store pixel data as integer numbers (8, 16, 24 and so on bits) so you are always limited as to what amount of brightness levels you can store (hence you maximum scene contrast and DR will be limited). Firts HDR format was using floating point numbers for the pixel data and hence gave an ability to store scenes with truly unlimited contrast (and hence DR). It was initially used purely by CG systems and any photo applications came later.

So from historical prospective you are wrong I'm afraid because when HDR was conceived there were no image capturing involved - just the HDR files and tone mapping to smaller limited numerical spaces (integer based image formats).

I accept that you may not agree, but that is what I know and used to work with back in the late 80s early 90s when there were no digital SLRs yet ;)
 
Back
Top