What lens would take this kind of photo?

Messages
211
Edit My Images
Yes
This is probably basic as basic gets, but just seen a photo on this website http://www.caldrive.com/primer.html what kind of lens would that be taken with, or isthere no way of knowing? Sorry i cant get the pic on here, im writing this on my phone and cant work out how to do it sorry!

My reason for asking is, i really like that photo and was wondering if there is anything i can buy on a budget for my canon 500D? Thanks!!
 
I would say its a fairly wide angle but not ultra wide. Perhaps about a 15mm on a crop. So a 15-85 would be ok if you wanted a standard zoom that would get it or any of the 10-20 sort of zooms.
 
which image are we talking about? with all of them you could do it with a kit lens by standing back a bit and cropping in. The header pic I wouldn't have said it was taken with an ultrawide on a crop body unless its been very well PP'd on the barelling side.
 
I'll go with Adrian on the longer lens as well. Doesn't look like a shot from a particularly wideangle.
 
My initial guess was something that was wide but not too wide (the suggestion of a kit lens above probably closest to what I was thinking).

Can anyone explain the reason why they thought a particular type of lens was used?
 
I could be way off but I would edge towards something a little longer than your average kit lens range.

There's something about the perspective of the curve in the road, the closely grouped telegraph poles and the feel of the hills beyond that vast expanse of flat ground that makes me think that there's a certain degree of compression going on.

Edit

Now I'm looking at it again and I'm not too sure.

Light must be really bright - how fast would that truck be moving... LOL
 
Last edited:
If it isn't a crop and really was taken in that mode (16:9?) it could have been taken with an LX5 at 6mm :)
 
I'm not sure why you would want to take it anyway, I think the picture itself doesnt work too well. Its better with most of the sky cropped out but even then the eye struggles to find a resting place and certainly isnt lead anywhere.
 
I'm not sure why you would want to take it anyway, I think the picture itself doesnt work too well. Its better with most of the sky cropped out but even then the eye struggles to find a resting place and certainly isnt lead anywhere.

I think it manages to convey open space very well. If you take the sky away it becomes very claustrophobic. By not having a single focal point the restlessness of the image further exagerates the open expanse. If there was one point that the gaze alighted on, the feel of the wide open space would be lost or diluted.

I'm thinking it's a longer lens due to a combination of the perspective (there's a degree of foreshortening you wouldn't get with a wide angle) and the depth of field.
 
Thanks for the info guys, It might not be to everyones taste, it just caught my eye lol.

with the only lens i have at the moment being the 18-55 for my canon 500D, i was worried that I wont get anything like the above with it. I've got a week before I go on holiday, and was debating if to buy another lens?
 
Arent we only supposed to link to images link i the first post and not steal the photographers bandwith by embedding his image on here, its a common courtesy guys.
 
Arent we only supposed to link to images link i the first post and not steal the photographers bandwith by embedding his image on here, its a common courtesy guys.

Correct Gary, that's why I've just broken it to a link :)
 
you can tell straight away it's a long 'un by how clear the mountains are at the farthest point in the background. If it was a wide angle they would be barely visible.

My guess is that it's about 85-135mm on full frame or equivalent.
 
Last edited:
Could be absolutely any lens on any body...
 
I emailed the photographer, who is just going on his vacation so didn't have time to sign up but has given me an answer:

that's a very old image, dating from the early 1990's, maybe mid-1990's, and it was taken with a Sinar 4x5 and a 180mm (i.e. "normal") lens, IIRC (which I might not); in any case, at the time I only had three lenses -- 90mm, 180mm, and 360mm -- so it was one of those :-). The scan was done years ago and wasn't very good, hence the image doesn't look as good as it probably should. Nowadays, of course, I use Nikon DSLRs (and mostly shoot video, but that's another story...). I briefly browsed through the forum thread a few minutes ago but am on my way to work and then vacation so I don't have time to respond, so if you want to post this as a response, please do....


Cheers,


Hamish
 
Aww that was going to be my guess on camera/lens combination ;-)
 
Back
Top