Whats the general opinion of HDR.

Messages
987
Name
Phil
Edit My Images
No
I`ve recently been using a method called Pseudo HDR, now reading through a load of threads on the forum there is a very mixed view of HDR and alot of people dont like it or totally against it, now is it only because there are some extreme HDRs that people dont like or is it HDR full stop, i`m not sure if i`m making any sense to you but i use `pseudo hdr` to bring out some colours and a bit of punch to my images but for some strange reason i feel guilty doing it because so many people `diss` HDR but i can`t help but use it.

For example i can understand why HDR haters will be against images like this because its really extreme and unnatural:
3240456675_1616fe9ed4.jpg


But what do you think of images like these which have been `pseudo HDR`d` but think still keep their original natural look but with little punch and life to the image?
3248419070_05feca8e03.jpg


3248529830_fa95168dc2.jpg


3229290703_7d64a00320.jpg


3225395305_9f3338bbef.jpg


3213018433_9613c7ec53.jpg
 
Are you using photomatix for your psuedo's?

My personal opinion is that it is just another processing technique that has its place and if done well can look great. In your case I think it works really well, I'd be interested to hear your personal technique :thumbs:
 
Would perchance I be recognizing Porhtleven in number 1, and perhaps Portreath in 4 and 5?
 
Are you using photomatix for your psuedo's?

My personal opinion is that it is just another processing technique that has its place and if done well can look great. In your case I think it works really well, I'd be interested to hear your personal technique :thumbs:

Yes using Photomatix, Simple technique really, Always shoot in raw, using adobe camera raw (cs4), adjust exposure to either 1 or 1/3 -/+, open in photomatix and then apply the changes whether i fancy extreme or some subtle, i find taking pictures in the middle of the day which is shocking for a nice blend of light can be salvaged using the technique see the photos above all shot on truly shocking days where the weather was very very bland.

Would perchance I be recognizing Porhtleven in number 1, and perhaps Portreath in 4 and 5?

You would indeed, Porthleven my gorgeous home!!!:)
 
I quite like HDR when done well but it's a fine line before it becomes absolutely gross.
 
I like them, and enjoy seeing those taken to extreme's alongside those with only subtle enhancements.

Never tried one myself yet though... should probably get on with it and give it a go really!
 
I like them, and enjoy seeing those taken to extreme's alongside those with only subtle enhancements.

Never tried one myself yet though... should probably get on with it and give it a go really!

I like HDR, and can appreciate both camps. Some of the more extreme ones work if the subject matter is right, in the same way that abstract art sometimes works. The ones you have posted are very good in a subtle way, and I like that too. They don't look like HDR's as such. It's just another technique, and something I'm yet to have a go at.
 
Thank you very much for your comments i really appreciate it, suddenly i dont feel so `guilty` for using hdr now, i guess its no different to using Photoshop, dodging, burning, cloning, curves etc etc although everyone does have their own taste and style.
 
I've never tried HDR and perhaps I should as I can see clear benefits for using it! But I would have thought that if someone looks at a shot and says something like "mmmmm nice HDR shot" or "That's HDR" then surely the processing has over stepped it's purpose :thinking: I believe that processing should enhance the subject and NOT become the subject :D

Just my opinion and I don't know much anyway :lol:

Nice shots by the way..
 
HDR is all good. It doesnt matter what others think - if you like the final image then thats fine. Its no different to using any other image editing techniques. Sure the results sometimes look wierd but its all art. Some of my photo 52s are HDR - one very obvious and the other less so - and I am enjoying the arty aspect of making them - I could care less what others think so long as I like it. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder etc etc.
 
It's just another way to make average pictures look even worse, I'm yet to see a really good image made better by HDR.
Yes it has it's place, but I suspect it will eventually go the same way as keyhole masks, tobacco grads and other techniques I can't remember from the 70's and 80's.
 
but I suspect it will eventually go the same way as keyhole masks, tobacco grads and other techniques I can't remember from the 70's and 80's...............

................loons, big hair, Brut, Dancing round your handbag, curly perms, Blue Nun and Paul Daniels perhaps :)
 
It's just another way to make average pictures look even worse, I'm yet to see a really good image made better by HDR.
Yes it has it's place, but I suspect it will eventually go the same way as keyhole masks, tobacco grads and other techniques I can't remember from the 70's and 80's.

You know HDR has been around since the 50's yer? Tone mapping since about 1993. Its not going away.
 
but I suspect it will eventually go the same way as keyhole masks, tobacco grads and other techniques I can't remember from the 70's and 80's.

................loons, big hair, Brut, Dancing round your handbag, curly perms, Blue Nun and Paul Daniels perhaps :)

ooohhhhhhhhhhhh, you mean all those things that have made a come back then, in the current 'retro' fashions :D


It's just another way to make average pictures look even worse, I'm yet to see a really good image made better by HDR.


How can you be sure, when you look at an image that it hasn't been HDR'd? Very subtle use of the technique leaves little if any discernable trace, when used to simply balance tone, detail and exposure. Unless the photograher tells you the technique has been used, you wouldn't know.

I am a fan of hdr, when done well, whether its very obvious or totally subtle. Very obvious doesn't have to mean very bad, though all too often it can do unfortunately. However sweeping statements about not liking it strike be as being a bit odd, as ultimately, like any post processing, its just another technique that changes the original data the camera captured and like all those techniques can be 'in yer face' or totally unnoticable.
 
I'm yet to see a really good image made better by HDR. QUOTE]

So are you saying that my pictures ALL look HDR`d and they dont look all that great?? i can understand the top one but that is an example of an extreme HDR, but surely you must think the others look great and not HDR`d at all.
 
As long as the final image holds the attention and is pleasing to look at, who cares what went into creating it, except to try and replicate the technique.

It's the final image that matters :)
 
I like the OP's pics.

There's lots of photographers who don't like HDR, ime though I've come across few of the picture buying public who don't like them.
 
No my statement was a very general one.
Photographers have always looked to increase the tonal range of pictures, wether it be in the darkroom or on the computer. I wonder how Ansel Adams would have adapted his zone theory for Photoshop.

I'm not commenting on any one image or set of images but I see lots of images which should have been deleted, put through Photomatrix or whatever hoping to slavage the poor composition and exposure.

It is a very personal thing and I agree that it isn't to everyones taste, I guess in 5 years time there will another latest and greatest filter/plugin which does something similar ;)

But please, start with a good image.......
 
The problem with HDR is that it tends to stand for ...

Hardly ever Done Right

I'm not pointing the finger at anyone, it's just that many HDR images that are posted come across as overprocessed mutants.



I like to be surprised to find that the shot I've been admiring was infact processed using HDR techniques :)
 
I agree. Just look at the most interesting on Flickr. I found a stealth plane the other week because the tone mapping was so extreme you couldn't tell the plane from the sky. Insane. It also creates highly dramatic rants ;)
 
if someone looks at a shot and says something like "mmmmm nice HDR shot" or "That's HDR" then surely the processing has over stepped it's purpose :thinking: I believe that processing should enhance the subject and NOT become the subject :D

Agreed, its the overprocessed look of many HDR shots I dislike, not the process itself. Philx's are pretty subtle.

If I had the time and ability I'd have a go myself.
 
Won't need to P&P for HDR ....as it'll be built into the Camera. Not sure why it ain't done now must be possible with all the HDR software available ...... will allow the camera to produce a closer rendition of what the tog is seeing...... although taking it one step further why don't we just have a SD card socket built in....blink to take the pic, we get perfect pics every time then..... and no heavy gadget bag and tripod to carry....
 
This was 1 exposure tonemapped on Photomatix. I thought this worked quite well with the textures and colours in the image. What do you guys think?

2860782844_8867dbf574.jpg
 
My viewpoint on HDR is very black and white in that I personally hate the very obviuous ones with a passion and unlike a previous poster can see no artistic merit in any of the ones I have seen,however when done with subtlety so that it does not look like HDR I have seen some really good shots with a bit of added sparkle
 
This was 1 exposure tonemapped on Photomatix. I thought this worked quite well with the textures and colours in the image. What do you guys think?

2860782844_8867dbf574.jpg

Looks like a band photo and if that is so, a bit of extra oomf is a good thing, you want something that is going to reflect the larger than life nature of stage presence. Black + white conversions are sometimes used for similar reasons which, depending on your perception, are not exactly accurate portrayals of what was in front of the lens!

If we are taking art, it's no holds barred. Unless it's a covers band in which case people want to hear a realistic representation. Context is a useful tool.
 
Can't see what all the fuss is about. Your pictures, do what ya like. I shall continue to apply the bare minimum of post processing to my photos because a) I prefer the natural look and b) I am too stupid to work out what the hell to do in Photoshop. Either option is valid in my book. And if HDR or any other technique produces the result you are happy with then use it. Some people will like it and some people won't. Such is the way of things.
 
Back
Top