Whats the general opinion of HDR.

Am i right in thinking HDR is taking a shot with 3different Exposure compensations and combining them in a program later?
What is ment by Pseudo HDR?
 
Do you mean like taking 1 shot in raw, and changing the Exp Comp in editing?
 
Do you mean like taking 1 shot in raw, and changing the Exp Comp in editing?

Just use one exposure and put it through the HDR process, some programs allow you to do this, some will ask that you create 3 images from the one RAW file, just call them img1254, img1254a and img1254b, you don`t even have to change the exposure, photomatix will do that for you.

WARNING< WARNING, WARNING.

Using this procedure does tend to upset people. :lol:
 
From the earliest days of photography, images have been manipulated, it's a fundamental part of the practice. Be it HDR, colour popping, Digital capture or whatever else, it's just another aspect of photography which some will like, others will not..well executed shots regardless of the technique are still good shots.
 
I think HDR photos look absolutely great when they've been composed in a decent enough way. I have come across poorly taken shots where people are astounded that someone can criticise their HDR masterpiece, simply because of the detail. You do see it used where you'd prefer a normal and well-composed photo in its place.

I think that's it.. HDR, there's a time and a place :)
 
Hate to say this but its looking like HDR is here to stay. Dolby are working on HDR displays.

# Contrast ratio (full on/full off): Infinite (over 1000000:1)

:thumbs: Hate to say i told you so.(not you in particular) It's a bit like when guitars went electric, loads of traditionalists hated it but the electric and effected sounds are now more popular than the original. Not to say it's 'better' of course.

Cant wait to se some big screen HDR movies.
 
I never thought HDR itself was never in any doubt, tonemapping on the other hand I think will see some dramatic changes. Tonemapping is the true cause of those highly saturated catastrophes you see all over the interweb. Photomatix has a lot to answer for :p.
 
No such thing as bad tonemapping IMHO - although we might not like someones image, it doesnt mean that its not 'art' or that other people wont like it. Let them have their fun (fun is what its all about right?)! Having said that, I prefer the less obvious approach - having tried a few HDRs myself I am quickly finding that the over processed look isnt for me! Many 'photographers' on here probably have a more discerning sense of what makes a nice image, so are bound to be critical of cartoony results. Each to their own - this debate will never go away!
 
There is such a thing as bad tone mappping. Just like theres such a thing as bad photography.
 
Its all subjective is what I'm saying. Dont get me wrong - the kind of images you produce are inspiring to me, but if people want to screw up their images by tonemapping them to hell, then thats all well and good. We dont have to like it. If it brings them pleasure then it cant be bad :). For example - I HATE a lot of pop art, but lots of people seem to like it so I wont argue with that (I'll just mutter under my breath instead ;) )
 
I'm very well aware that its all subjective. There is no bad art its just art. When writing about HDR you have to be very careful not to say "Don't do this" because its too commanding. You have to say "If you do this it'll look like this and it can be bad because..." If people still wanna do it well they're silly. The majority of "good" HDRs on Flickr are technically bad imho. But there definitely are issues that can arrise from "bad" tone mapping.
 
Hmmmm - OK - I will bow to your superior knowledge on the subject as you seem to know what you are talking about ;)

So - do you (and anyone else) think that the poor examples of HDR come about because people simply 'play' with the buttons until they like the image? Do you think that having a better underlying understanding of what the software is actually doing when you change parameters would lead to fewer 'bad' examples? I for one would really like more technical information about what everything does. The vanilladays tutorial is great for example, but I find I want to know even more about what the software is actually doing when you press the buttons (i.e. what algorithms, what this means in terms of changing pixel values over space etc.). I'm really interested in the technical side because I come from a background of raster processing of spatial imagery (satellite images, computer models etc.) and so its really fun to figure out what the software is doing behind the scenes...

Anyway - didnt want to start an argument - sorry about that! I m well aware that my HDRs are lacking, but I want to learn how to make technically better images. To do that, I need more info from people like you :)
 
What gets me is the implication you often find by people who don't like it that they are somehow superior for not using it or that HDR is inferior.

It's not, it's just a different approach.
 
I love loads of HDR and hate loads of HDR. When I don't like it I find it more offensive somehow than just a badly taken image, particularly when it is followed by a load of praise on Flickr. I have tried it a few times and have yet to produce anything that isn't complete pants.

I&#8217;d love to sit down with an expert and watch them through the process and try to replicate it. Pete, fancy visiting Kent?
 
So - do you (and anyone else) think that the poor examples of HDR come about because people simply 'play' with the buttons until they like the image?

I do. There is certainly a lot of people around who simply want their photos to look "arty" like they've been edited by a professional but the thing is they really don't look that way. You find a lot of people think that Dave Hill's work is simply HDR and its not. They'll tone map anything going for the "Dave Hill look". The difference is that Dave Hill knows light and is brilliant with strobes and post production.

Do you think that having a better underlying understanding of what the software is actually doing when you change parameters would lead to fewer 'bad' examples?

Maybe, maybe not. There are people who know how to use the software very well but use it to produce the cliched ott HDR shots. I think its simply that there is a market for it.

I for one would really like more technical information about what everything does. The vanilladays tutorial is great for example, but I find I want to know even more about what the software is actually doing when you press the buttons (i.e. what algorithms, what this means in terms of changing pixel values over space etc.). I'm really interested in the technical side because I come from a background of raster processing of spatial imagery (satellite images, computer models etc.) and so its really fun to figure out what the software is doing behind the scenes...

TBH I don't really care what the program does when I push a button, at least not on a code point of view. I care how it affects my images so I know what does what and how to apply it to a new shot.
 
My opinion reflects what a few others have said. There are three types of HDR:

Extreme done bad (Most common, and the reason HDR has such a bad name)
Extreme done good (Pete Carr proves it can be done)
HDR done Subtle (HDR that improves the photo a lot, without shouting "I'm HDR, I'm HDR."

I do not mind the latter two HDR types. The first has a LOT to answer for.

Gary.
 
I'm yet to see a really good image made better by HDR. QUOTE]

So are you saying that my pictures ALL look HDR`d and they dont look all that great?? i can understand the top one but that is an example of an extreme HDR, but surely you must think the others look great and not HDR`d at all.

I am not so sure if I like the HDR on any of these shots. I will reply in more detail shortly, just reading the thread first.

Gary.
 
This was 1 exposure tonemapped on Photomatix. I thought this worked quite well with the textures and colours in the image. What do you guys think?

2860782844_8867dbf574.jpg

I think the detail is fantastic, but so fantastic it detracts from the faces. I keep looking at the jeans. Therefore, bad choice for HDR in my opinion.

Gary.
 
Hate to say this but its looking like HDR is here to stay. Dolby are working on HDR displays.

# Contrast ratio (full on/full off): Infinite (over 1000000:1)

I spoke to someone with knowledge in all things physics, claims that HDR displays are hype and will not actually be much different to current top end displays, due to what the human eye can see. Don't shoot the messenger!

Gary.
 
All of the images below, in my opinion, have some strange things going on. Weird greens and subtle but definitely glowing oranges. Where my brain says there should be blacks in the rocks, I see a wash of grays. The last image I feel works best, but the greens and oranges almost make me thing of those awful 3D images, which require the use of those funny specs.

It's so subtle, its insane. But it's still very obvious and off putting to me.

Cracking HDR is not easy, and I am not sure these work as HDR photos. Still better than most attempts though! :)

Gary.

But what do you think of images like these which have been `pseudo HDR`d` but think still keep their original natural look but with little punch and life to the image?

3248419070_05feca8e03.jpg


3248529830_fa95168dc2.jpg


3229290703_7d64a00320.jpg


3225395305_9f3338bbef.jpg


3213018433_9613c7ec53.jpg
 
I think HDR can be good if used correctly. I've never done it myself, but I really like some of the pictures I see. It seems so easy to over do it though, and you end up creating a weird (I would call grotesque) thing that looks like someones dropped some acid and taken photos with their eyes... or something :).

Can be good, can also be very very bad. just learn how to use it properly i guess. Personally though I don't enjoy must post processing on my pictures, but I don't need to sell them to people so I get that luxury.
 
HDR and tonemapping like EdGary said can be both good and bad, there is unfortunatly a lot more bad out there than there is good. The fact that a lot of the good stuff people don't realise it's HDR doesn't really help the people who think that all HDR sucks because they in reality most likely like some HDR shots without realising it.

#1
2610902196_996b4483be.jpg


#2
2343902084_82276c47a8.jpg


#3
2123131342_d9638347f1.jpg


#4
3237495751_b9f1d4313f.jpg


#5
2610571179_219ed5edbf.jpg


How many of these are HDR?
 
I'm going to say 5, 4 (not 100% about this one) and 1 are HDR but I wouldn't be surprised if they all as seeing as this is an HDR topic. 2 could probably be done with a circular polarizer, 3 looks about right for long exposure at night time although it could be HDR to stop the sky blowing out.
 
All of the images below, in my opinion, have some strange things going on. Weird greens and subtle but definitely glowing oranges. Where my brain says there should be blacks in the rocks, I see a wash of grays. The last image I feel works best, but the greens and oranges almost make me thing of those awful 3D images, which require the use of those funny specs.

It's so subtle, its insane. But it's still very obvious and off putting to me.

Cracking HDR is not easy, and I am not sure these work as HDR photos. Still better than most attempts though! :)

Gary.


Ok thank you very much for your advice/input.


I didnt think i done to bad, never mind back to the drawing board or to the field should i say. lol
 
Ok thank you very much for your advice/input.


I didnt think i done to bad, never mind back to the drawing board or to the field should i say. lol

They are better than most for sure, but I just think HDR needs to be well controlled in order for it not to impact on a photo in a negative way. The lack of blacks and the sometimes bizarre oranges / greens are for me anyway, tell tale signs of not quite right HDR, and they get on my goat :D

Gary.
 
HDR and tonemapping like EdGary said can be both good and bad, there is unfortunatly a lot more bad out there than there is good. The fact that a lot of the good stuff people don't realise it's HDR doesn't really help the people who think that all HDR sucks because they in reality most likely like some HDR shots without realising it.



How many of these are HDR?

For me taking a wild guess, i would say 5 is showing the most tell tale signs of hdr and possibly 3 but agree that all could be hdr................or possibly none of them are.

I just think alot of people think the worst of hdr because like it has already been said there are so many over done pictures like my first pic of the topic.
But i still think its a great method to use to boost your sometimes dull pictures.

But at the end of the day you never ever gonna get a picture that EVERYONE is going to like, it takes all sorts, for instance i have a picture of mine in the local art gallery, now looking at it i wouldn`t say it is my best picture i have done however it is selling in the gallery very well and selling more than the shots that i think are far far better.
 
They are better than most for sure, but I just think HDR needs to be well controlled in order for it not to impact on a photo in a negative way. The lack of blacks and the sometimes bizarre oranges / greens are for me anyway, tell tale signs of not quite right HDR, and they get on my goat :D

Gary.


Thats cool, thanks for the info, i`m off to learn some more now lol.
 
Now for the answer!
#2 was hdr'd, #5 is a single raw exposure blended in photoshop to give a slight dynamic range boost.

HDR has unfortunately gotten bad press for being a good way to polish turds, a lot of people forget that it can be used to produce fantastic shots as well as overprocessed shots. Any technique can be used OTT it's just most people seem to use HDR'ing more to get that effect than any other.
 
but I suspect it will eventually go the same way as keyhole masks, tobacco grads and other techniques I can't remember from the 70's and 80's.

Where Top Gear??.


Personally I like the HDR effect, it just that an effect, like black and white, or any of the many other effects we add, if it works for you great!
Wayne
 
Now for the answer!
#2 was hdr'd, #5 is a single raw exposure blended in photoshop to give a slight dynamic range boost.

HDR has unfortunately gotten bad press for being a good way to polish turds, a lot of people forget that it can be used to produce fantastic shots as well as overprocessed shots. Any technique can be used OTT it's just most people seem to use HDR'ing more to get that effect than any other.

Excellent.
 
Back
Top